Lifetime Fairness? Taxes, Subsidies, Age-Based Penalties, and the Price of Health Insurance in Australia

Connelly, Luke B. and Brown III, H. Shelton (2008): Lifetime Fairness? Taxes, Subsidies, Age-Based Penalties, and the Price of Health Insurance in Australia.

Abstract

Abstract Australia has voluntary private health insurance (PHI) markets in which open enrolment and community rated premiums are mandated by government. Historically, adverse selection in these markets led to a substantial decline in coverage, giving voice to fears about the viability of PHI markets in the longer-run. In order to preserve community rating but improve the PHI pool, the Australian Government instituted a novel scheme of age-based penalties (ABPs) for individuals who join a PHI fund later in life. This paper computes the price of health insurance under the so-called Lifetime Cover (LC) scheme and shows that the LC scheme per se is not appropriately calibrated to prevent another adverse selection death spiral (Butler 2002). Based on our results, we recompute age-based penalties that would result in a fair price of PHI for all age groups. The premium multipliers we derive suggest a premium ratio of 10:1 for the oldest and youngest joiners. Our premium multiplier sequence is well-approximated by a linear ABP scheme that is approximately three times that of the present LC scheme for older joiners.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Private Health Insurance; Lifetime Cover; Community Rating; Price; Taxes; Subsidies
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G22 - Insurance ; Insurance Companies ; Actuarial Studies; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health

References

Arrow, Kenneth J. (1963). “Uncertainty and the Welfare Economics of Medical Care”, The American Economic Review, 53: 941-973.

Australian Bureauof Statistics (2006). National Health Survey-Summary of Results 2004-05. Canberra: ABS.

Brown III, H. Shelton. and Connelly, Luke B. (2005). “Lifetime Cover in Private Insurance Markets”, International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics, 5, 75-88.

Butler, James R.G. (1999). “Estimating Elasticities of Demand for Private Health Insurance in Australia”, National Centre for Epidemiology and Population Health (NCEPH) Working Paper No.43. Canberra: NCEPH.

Butler, James R.G (2002). “Policy Change and Private Health Insurance: Did the Cheapest Policy Do the Trick?”, Australia Health Review, 25, 33-41.

Connelly, Luke B. and Brown III, H. Shelton (2006). “Lifetime Subsidies in Australian Private Health Insurance Markets with Community Rating.” Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice, 31, 705-19.

Hall, J., De Abreu Lourenco, R. & Viney, R. (1999). “Carrots and Sticks-the Fall and Fall of Private Health Insurance in Australia”, Health Economics, 8, 653-60.

Herring, Bradley and Pauly, Mark V. (2006a). “Incentive-Compatible Guaranteed Renewable Health Insurance Premiums”, Journal of Health Economics, 25, 395-417.

Herring, Bradley and Pauly, Mark V. (2006b). “The Effect of State Community Rating Regulations on Premiums and Coverage in the Individual Health Insurance Market”, National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) Working Paper. New York: NBER.

Hoffman, Catherine and Wang, Marie (2003). “Health Coverage in America: 2002 Data Update, Technical report, The Kaiser Foundation Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured”, http://www.kff.org/uninsured/4154.cfm, Accessed 17 September 2007. Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation: Washington D.C.

Medibank Private Ltd (2007). “Health Cover Options”, https://secure.medibank.com.au/join/join_result.asp, Accessed 14 February 2007. Medibank Private Ltd: Melbourne.

Private Health Insurance Administration Council (PHIAC) (2007). “Coverage of Hospital Insurance Tables Offered by Registered Health Benefits Organisations By Age Cohort”, http://www.phiac.gov.au/statistics/membershipcoverage/agecohort.htm, Accessed 20 April 2007. Canberra: PHIAC.

Pauly, Mark V. (1970). “The Welfare Economics of Community Rating”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, 37, 407-418.

Pupp, Roger L. (1981). “Community Rate and Cross Subsdies in Health Insurance”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, 48, 610-627.