Understanding the impact of Cotton Subsidies on developing countries

Gillson, I and Poulton, Colin and Balcombe, Kelvin and Page, S (2004): Understanding the impact of Cotton Subsidies on developing countries.

Abstract

Models developed to investigate the impact of cotton subsidies have found that US support, by virtue of its absolute magnitude, is particularly damaging and responsible for most of the reduction in cotton-earning potential in developing countries. This has been used as an argument for reducing or postponing cuts in subsidies to European farmers, as these appear to have less impact on developing countries. Our results, through a careful examination of the nature of the cotton market, agree but suggest that under certain assumptions subsidies by smaller subsidisers (such as the EU) may be disproportionately harmful to some suppliers, notably to West and Central African countries. This is especially damaging to them since they have the potential to increase supply.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Cotton, Subsidies, Development
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations

References

Badiane, O., D. Ghura, et al. (2002), Cotton Sector Strategies in West and Central Africa,Washington DC, World Bank.

Banuri, T. (1998), ‘Cotton and Textiles in Pakistan’, Paper prepared for the United Nations Environment Programme, February.

Bautista, R. and M. Thomas (1999), ‘Agricultural Growth Linkages in Zimbabwe: Income and Equity Effects’ Agrekon 38(Special Issue (May)):pp. 66-75.

Booth, D. and J. Kweka (2004), Priorities for National Trade Policy and the PRSP Review, Dar es Salaam, Economic and Social Research Foundation / Overseas Development Institute.

Brandow, J. and G. Davidonis (2000), ‘Quantification of Fibre Quality and the Cotton Production-Processing Interface’, Journal of Cotton Science, 4; pp. 34-64.

Centre for International Economics (2002), Trade Distortions and Cotton Markets: Implications for Global Cotton Producers, May.

Chakraborty, K., K. Hudson, D. Ethridge, S. Misra and G. Kar (1999), An Overview ofthe Cotton and Textile Industries in India, College of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Texas.

Choudhary, B. and G. Laroia (2001), ‘Technological developments and Cotton Production in India and China’, Current Science, Vol. 80(8), April.

Cotton Outlook (2004), Volume 82, No. 1, January 2.

Cotton Outlook (2003a), Volume 81, No. 51/52, December 19.

Cotton Outlook (2003b), Volume 81, No. 45, November 7.

Cotton Outlook (2003c), Volume 81, No. 43, October 24.

Cotton Outlook (2003d), Volume 81, No. 49, December 5.

Daviron, B. (2002), ‘Small Farm Production and the Standardisation of Tropical Products’, Journal of Agrarian Change, Vol. 2(2); pp. 162-184.

Daviron, B. and P. Gibbon (2002), ‘Global Commodity Chains and African Export Agriculture’, Journal of Agrarian Change, Vol. 2(2); pp. 137-161.

Deininger, K. and J. Okidi (2003), ‘Growth and Poverty Reduction in Uganda 1992-2000: Panel Data Evidence,’ Development Policy Review Vol. 21(4):pp. 481-509.

Delgado, C. and N. Minot (2000). Agriculture in Tanzania Since 1986: Follower or Leader of Growth? Washington DC, World Bank / IFPRI / Government of Tanzania: 167.

Dijkstra, A. and J. van Donge (2001). ‘What Does the 'Show Case' Show? Evidence of and Lessons from Adjustment in Uganda’ World Development Vol. 29 (5): 841-863.

FAPRI (2002), ‘The Doha Round of the World Trade Organisation: Appraising Further Liberalisation of Agricultural Markets’, Working Paper 02-WP 317, Food and Agricultural Policy Research Institute, Iowa State University and University of Missouri-Colombia.

Fok, M. and S. Tazi (2003). Regional Synthesis Report: Monitoring Device of Cotton Sectors in Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Cote d'Ivoire, Ghana and Mali. Montpellier, Resocot CottonNet / CIRAD. 70

Gasanfer, S. (1999), ‘Production and Trade Policies Affecting the Cotton Industry’, Paper presented at the ICAC 58th Plenary Meeting, Charleston, South Carolina, 24-29 October.

Gibbon, P. (1998), King Cotton Under Market Sovereignty: The Private Marketing Chain for Cotton in Western Tanzania, 1997/98. CDR Working Paper, 98.17,Copenhagen.

Govereh, J. and T. Jayne (2003), ‘Cash cropping and food crop productivity: synergies or trade-offs?’ Agricultural Economics 28:pp. 39-50.

Govereh, J., J. Nyoro, et al. (1999), Smallholder Commercialisation, Interlinked Markets and Food Crop Productivity: Cross-Country Evidence in Eastern and Southern Africa, Michigan, Michigan State University.

Guitchounts, A. (2003). The Structure of World Trade. Washington DC, ICAC.

Goreux, L. (2003), ‘Prejudice Caused by Industrialised Countries Subsidies to Cotton Sectors in Western and Central Africa’, Background document to the submission made by Benin, Burkina Faso, Chad and Mali to the WTO (TN/AG/GEN/4), June.

Goreux, L. and J. Macrae (2003), ‘Reforming the Cotton Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa’, World Bank Africa Region Working Paper Series No. 47.

Hanyani-Mlambo, B., C. Poulton and M. Larsen (2003), Zimbabwe Country Report, DFID funded project Competition and Coordination in Liberalised African Cotton Market systems: //www.wye.ac.uk/AgEcon/ADU/research/projects/cottonE/ compcord

Hart, C. and B. Babcock (2002), ‘US Farm Policy and the WTO: How do they match up?’, Working Paper 02-WP294, Iowa State University, February.

Heijbroek, A. and H. Husken (1996), The International Cotton Complex: Changing Competitiveness Between Seed and Consumer, The Rabobank Commodity Studies. HG Utrecht: Rabobank International.

Higgiston, J. (2003), ‘Tajikistan: Cotton and Products’, Foreign Agricultural Service Report, USDA.

Hsu, H. and F. Gale (2001), ‘China’s Cotton Reserves to Meet Shortfall, Avert Price Rise’, China Agricultural Trade Report, US Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service.

Hunter, L. and F. Barkhuysen (1999), Developments in the Instrument Measurement of the Quality of National Fibres, http://www.sympotex.co.za/fab130~3%20Lawrence%20Hunter

ICAC (2000), Cotton: Review of the World Situation, September-October, Vol. 54 (1), International Cotton Advisory Committee.

ICAC (2002). Production and Trade Policies Affecting the Cotton Industry. Washington DC, International Cotton Advisory Committee: 11.

ICAC (2002a), World Cotton Trade 2002/03, International Cotton Advisory Committee, October.

ICAC (2002b), Cotton: Review of the World Situation, September-October, Vol. 56 (1), International Cotton Advisory Committee.

ICAC (2003a), ‘Argentina: Economic Injury to the Cotton Sector as a Result of Low Prices’, Paper prepared for the Working Group on Government Measures of the International Cotton Advisory Committee.71

ICAC (2003b), ‘Production and Trade Policies Affecting the Cotton Industry’, International Cotton Advisory Committee, September.

IFAD (2001), Rural Poverty Report: the challenge of ending rural poverty, Oxford/Rome, Oxford University Press/ IFAD.

IFPRI (2001), Impact des Réformes Agricoles Régionale Agricoles sur les Petits Agriculteurs au Bénin, Report prepared for GTZ, Project 97.7860.6-001.00,International Food Policy Research Institute.

ITMF (2001), Cotton Contamination Survey, International Textile Manufacturers Federation, Zurich.

Jenkins, C. (1997). ‘The Politics of Economic Policy-Making in Zimbabwe’, Journal of Modern African Studies Vol. 35 (4): 575-602.

Larsen, M. (2002). ‘Is Oligopoly a Condition of Successful Privatisation? The Case of Cotton in Zimbabwe’ Journal of Agrarian Change Vol. 2(2): 185-205.

Larsen, M. (2003), ‘Quality Standard-Setting in the Global Cotton Chain and Cotton Sector Reforms in Sub-Saharan Africa’, Institute for International Studies Working Paper No. 03.13, August.

Levin, A. (1999), ‘Developments and Outlook for Cotton in Francophone West Africa’,Paper presented at the Beltwide Cotton Conference, Orlando.

Lundbaek, J. (2002), Privatisation of the Cotton Sub-Sector in Uganda: Market Failures and Institutional Mechanisms to Overcome these, The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Copenhagen.

Maumbe, B. and S. Swinton (2003), ‘Hidden Health Costs of Pesticide Use in Zimbabwe's Smallholder Cotton Growers’, Social Science and Medicine 57: p.1559-1571.

Minnot, N. and L. Daniels (2001), ‘Impact of Global Cotton Markets on Rural Poverty in enin’, MSSD Discussion Paper No. 48, Markets and Structural Studies Division, nternational Food Policy Research Institute, Washington.

Mohanty, S., S. Fang and J. Chaudhary (2003), ‘Assessing the Competitiveness of Indian otton Production: A Policy Analysis Matrix Approach’, Journal of Cotton cience, Vol. 7; pp. 65-74.

Mor, U. (2001), ‘Fibre Testing Machinery Plays a Major Role in Marketing’, Cotton nternational, 68th Edition.

Oxfam International (2002), Cultivating Poverty: The Impact of US Cotton Subsidies on frica, Oxford, Oxfam International: 36.

Poulton, C., R. Al-Hassan, et al. (2000), The Cash Crop vs Food Crop Debate, Chatham, Natural resources International.

Poulton, C., P. Gibbon et al. (2004). ‘Competition and Coordination in Liberalised African Cotton Market Systems’, World Development Vol. 32 (3).

Quirke, D. (2001), Trade Distortions and Cotton Markets: Implications for Australian Cotton Producers, Centre for International Economics, Australia.

République du Benin (1997), Rapport sur l’Etat se l’Economie Nationale –Développements récents et perspectives à Moyen Terme, Cellule Macroéconomique de la Présidence de la République du Bénin. Cotonou, Bénin.

Research Centre for Rural Economy (1999), ‘Quantitative Analysis of WTO Admission and its Implications for Chinese Cotton Industry’, Paper presented by Ministry of 72 Agriculture, People’s Republic of China at the ICAC 58th Plenary Meeting.

Charleston, South Carolina, 24-29 October. Rothschild, J. (2003), ‘Nigeria: Cotton and Products’, Foreign Agricultural Service Report, USDA.

Sicular, T. (1998), ‘Establishing Markets: The Process of Commercialisation in Agriculture’, in Walder, A. (ed.), Zouping in Transition, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.

Shurley, D. (2002), ‘2002 Farm Bill Provisions and Impacts’, University of Georgia, http://www.ces.uga.edu/Agriculture/agecon/bill/billpres.htm.

Suh, M. (2002), ‘The Advantages of US Pima’, Cotton Outlook, Special Feature (The Long Staple Market).

Tokarick, S. (2003), ‘Measuring the Impact of Distortions in Agricultural Trade in Partial and General Equilibrium’, IMF Working Paper, WP/03/110.

Townsend, T. (2000), ‘World Extra-Fine Cotton Outlook’, Paper presented to the 4th US Prima Industry Seminar, 24-25 February, San Diego, California.

USDA (1997), Agricultural Resource Management Study, USDA.

USDA (2001), Fact Sheet, Upland Cotton, Summary of 2000 Commodity Loan and Payment Program, June, Farm Service Agency.

Valderrama, C. (1999), ‘Direct Assistance to Production on the Rise Again’, in World Cotton Trade, International Cotton Advisory Committee, Washington, DC.

Valderrama, C. (2000), ‘The World Cotton Market: Prices and Distortions’, Paper presented at the 10th Australian Cotton Conference, Brisbane, 17 August.

Vieira, R., N. Beltrao and A. Medeiros (2003), ‘Developments in Brazilian Cotton to Attend the Industry Needs’, Paper for the International Cotton Advisory Committee, Washington DC.

Zulu, B. and D. Tschirley (2002), An Overview of the Cotton Sub-Sector in Zambia, DFID funded project Competition and Coordination in Liberalised African Cotton Markey Systems.