Mixed Feelings: Theories of and Evidence on Giving

Konow, James (2009): Mixed Feelings: Theories of and Evidence on Giving. Published in: Journal of Public Economics , Vol. 94, No. 3-4 (April 2010): pp. 279-297.

Abstract

This paper examines possible motives and institutional factors that impact giving. Specifically, I consider alternative theories parallel to dictator experiments that generate evidence on both allocation decisions and their effect on feelings. A number of new empirical findings as well as new interpretations for previously reported findings result. A novel test distinguishes warm glow from impure altruism and rules out the former as the sole motive for giving. Very generous donations to charities that aid the needy (with modal gifts of the entire dictator’s stakes) cannot be attributed to familiarity with the charities. A charity that offers a matching grant increases its revenues by drawing donors and donations away from one that does not, although aggregate charitable donations do not rise. Additional results on emotions paint a picture of “mixed feelings:” generosity creates good feelings when the recipients are charities and bad feelings when they are fellow students. No group of dictators, however, feels better, on average, than a control group that is given no opportunity to donate. I propose a simple model that accounts for these results on allocation behavior and feelings by incorporating elements of two approaches, unconditional altruism and social preference theories, that to date have mostly evolved independently. A critical feature of this model is the social norm, and the results of the experiments corroborate the theory in the context of two norms of distributive justice that are important to real world giving: equity and need.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: Loyola Marymount University
• Language: English
• Keywords: Happiness; Equity; Fairness; Justice; Need; Altruism; Warm-Glow; Matching grants
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D63 - Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement; H - Public Economics > H4 - Publicly Provided Goods > H41 - Public Goods; D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D64 - Altruism ; Philanthropy

References

Abrams, B.A., and Schmitz, M.A. (1978). "The Crowding Out Effect of Government Transfers on Private Charitable Contributions," Public Choice 33, 29-39.

Alpizar, Francisco, Carlsson, Fredrik and Johansson-Stenman, Olof (2008). "Does Context Matter More for Hypothetical Than for Actual Contributions? Evidence from a Natural Field Experiment," Experimental Economics, 11(3), September, 299-314.

Andreoni, James (1989). "Giving with Impure Altruism: Applications to Charity and Ricardian Equivalence," Journal of Political Economy, 97(6), 1447-1458.

Andreoni, James (1990). "Impure Altruism and Donations to Public Goods: A Theory of Warm-Glow Giving," Economic Journal, June 1990, 100, 464-477.

Andreoni, James (1993). "An Experimental Test of the Public Goods Crowding-Out Hypothesis," American Economic Review, 83(5), 1317-1327.

Andreoni, James (1995). "Cooperation in Public-Goods Experiments: Kindness or Confusion?" American Economic Review, 85(4), 891-904.

Andreoni, James (2006). "Philanthropy," in the Handbook of the Economics of Giving, Altruism and Reciprocity, edited by Kolm, S-C., and Mercier, J.M., Amsterdam: Elsevier/North Holland, 1201-1269.

Andreoni, James and Bernheim, B. Douglas (2009). "Social Image and the 50-50 Norm: A Theoretical and Experimental Analysis of Audience Effects," Econometrica, 77(5), September, 1607-1636.

Andreoni, James, and Payne, A. Abigail (2003). "Do Government Grants to Private Charities Crowd Out Giving or Fund-raising?" American Economic Review, 93(3), 792-812.

Batson, C. Daniel (1987)."Prosocial Motivation: Is It Ever Truly Altruistic?" Advances in Experimental and Social Psychology, 20, 65-122.

Batson, C. Daniel (1997a). "Self-Other Merging and the Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis: Reply to Neuberg et al. (1997)," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 517-522.

Batson, C. Daniel, et al. (1988). "Five Studies Testing Two New Egoistic Alternatives to the Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 55(1), 52-77.

Batson, C. Daniel, et al. (1997b). "Is Empathy-Induced Helping Due to Self-Other Merging?" Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 495-509.

Becker, Gary S. (1974). "A Theory of Social Interactions," Journal of Political Economy, 82, November/December, 1063-1093.

Ben-Shakhar, Gershon, Bornstein, Gary, Hopfensitz, Astrid and van Winden, Frans (2007). "Reciprocity and Emotions in Bargaining Using Physiological and Self-Report Measures," Journal of Economic Psychology, 28(3), June, 314-323.

Benz, Matthias, and Meier, Stephan (2008). "Do People Behave in Experiments as in the Field? – Evidence from Donations," Experimental Economics, 11 (3), September, 268-281.

Bergstrom, Theodore C., Blume, Lawrence E., and Varian, Hal R. (1986). "On the Private Provision of Public Goods," American Economic Review, 29, 789-793.

Bolton, Gary E. and Katok, Elena (1998). "An Experimental Test of the Crowding Out Hypothesis: The Nature of Beneficent Behavior," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 37(3), 315-331.

Bolton, Gary E., Katok, Elena, and Zwick, Rami (1998). "Dictator Game Giving: Rules of Fairness versus Acts of Kindness," International Journal of Game Theory, 27(2), 269-299.

Bolton, Gary E., and Ockenfels, Axel (2000). "ERC: A Theory of Equity, Reciprocity, and Competition," American Economic Review, 90(1), March, 166-193.

Bosman, Ronald and van Winden, Frans (2002). "Emotional Hazard in a Power to Take Experiment," The Economic Journal, 112(476), January, 147-169.

Brekke, Kjell Arne, Kipperberg, Gorm, and Nyborg, Karine (2007). "Reluctant Recyclers: Social Interaction in Responsibility Ascription," Department of Economics, University of Oslo; The Frisch Centre for Economic Research.

Brekke, Kjell Arne, Kverndokk, Snorre, and Nyborg, Karine (2003). "An Economic Model of Moral Motivation," Journal of Public Economics, vol. 87, nos. 9-10 (September), pp. 1967-1983.

Broberg, Tomas, Ellingsen, Tore, and Johannesson, Magnus (2007)."Is Generosity Involuntary?" Eocnomics Letters, 94, 32-37.

Buchanan, Laurie, Eckel, Catherine C. and Grossman, Philip J. (2000). "To Give or not to Give: Effects of Altruism and Recognition on Philanthropic Gifts," mimeo.

Carpenter, Jeffrey, Connolly, Cristina and Myers, Caitlin Knowles (2008). "Altruistic Behavior in a Representative Dictator Experiment," Experimental Economics, 11(3), September, 282-298.

Carpenter, Jeffrey, Holmes, Jessica and Matthews, Peter Hans (2008). "Charity Auctions: A Field Experiment," The Economic Journal, 118(525), January, 92-113.

Charness, Gary and Grosskopf, Brit (2001). "Relative Payoffs and Happiness: An Experimental Study," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 45(3), 301-328.

Charness, Gary, and Rabin, Matthew (2002). "Understanding Social Preferences with Simple Tests." Quarterly Journal of Economics 117:3, 817-869.

Cialdini, Robert B., et al. (1997). "Reinterpreting the Empathy-Altruism Relationship: When One Into One Equals Oneness," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 481-494.

Crumpler, Heidi and Grossman, Philip J. (2008). "An Experimental Test of Warm Glow Giving," Journal of Public Economics, 92(5-6), June, 1011-1021.

Dana, Jason, Weber, Roberto A., and Kuang, Jason Xi (2007). "Exploiting Moral Wiggle Room: Experiments Demonstrating an Illusory Preference for Fairness," Economic Theory, 33, 67-80.

Di Tella, Rafael, and MacCulloch, Robert (2006). "Some Uses of Happiness Data in Economics," Journal of Economic Perspectives, 20(1), 25-46.

Diener, Ed, Suh, Eunkook M., Lucas, Richard E. and Smith, Heidi L. (1999). "Subjective Well-Being: Three Decades of Progress," Psychological Bulletin, 125(2), March, 276-302.

Dufwenberg, Martin and Kirchsteiger, Georg (2004). "A Theory of Sequential Reciprocity," Games and Economic Behavior, 47(2), May, 268-298.

Eckel, Catherine C. and Grossman, Philip J. (1996). "Altruism in Anonymous Dictator Games," Games and Economic Behavior, 16, 181-191.

Eckel, Catherine C. and Grossman, Philip J.(2008). "Subsidizing Charitable Contributions: A Natural Field Experiment Comparing Matching and Rebate Subsidies," Experimental Economics, 11 (3), September, 234-252.

Eckel, Catherine C., Grossman, Philip J., and Johnston, Rachel M. (2005). "An Experimental Test of the Crowding Out Hypothesis," Journal of Public Economics, 89 (8), August, 1543-1560.

Ellingsen, Tore and Johannesson, Magnus (2008). "Anticipated Verbal Feedback Induces Altruistic Behavior," Evolution and Human Behavior, 29, 100-105.

Fehr, Ernst and Camerer, Colin F. (2007). "Social Neuroeconomics: The Neural Circuitry of Social Preferences," TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences, 11(10), October, 419-427.

Fehr, Ernst, and Schmidt, Klaus M. (1999). "A Theory of Fairness, Competition and Cooperation," Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114(3), 817-868.

Fong, Christina (2007). "Evidence from an Experiment on Charity to Welfare Recipients: Reciprocity, Altruism, and the Empathic Responsiveness Hypothesis," The Economic Journal, vol. 117, no. 522 (July), pp. 1008-1024.

Frey, Bruno and Meier, Stephan (2004). "Social Comparisons and Pro-social Behavior: Testing ‘Conditional Cooperation’ in a Field Experiment," American Economic Review, vol. 94, no. 5 (December), pp. 1717-1722.

Frey, Bruno, and Stutzer, Alois (2002a). Happiness & Economics, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Frey, Bruno, and Stutzer, Alois (2002b). "What Can Economists Learn from Happiness Research?" Journal of Economic Literature, 40(2), 402-435.

Gächter, Simon and Fehr, Ernst (1999). "Collective Action as a Social Exchange," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 39(4), 341-369.

Goeree, Jacob K., Holt, Charles A. and Laury, Susan K. (2002). "Private Costs and Public Benefits: Unraveling the Effects of Altruism and Noisy Behavior," Journal of Public Economics, 83, 255-276.

Graham, Liam and Oswald, Andrew J. (2008). "Hedonic Capital, Adaptation and Resilience," University College London and University of Warwick: Department of Economics, 26/February.

Harbaugh, William (1998). "What Do Donations Buy?: A Model of Philanthropy Based on Prestige and Warm Glow," Journal of Public Economics, 67, 269-284.

Harbaugh, William, Mayr, Ulrich, and Burghart, Daniel R. (2007). "Neural Responses to Taxation and Voluntary Giving Reveal Motives for Charitable Donations," Science, 316 (15/June), 1622-1625.

Holm, Håkan, and Engseld, Peter (2005). "Choosing Bargaining Partners: An Experimental Study on the Impact of Information on Income, Status and Gender," Experimental Economics, 8(3), 183-216.

Karlan, Dean and List, John A. (2007). "Does Price Matter in Charitable Giving? Evidence from a Large-Scale Natural Field Experiment," The American Economic Review, 97(5), December, 1774-1793.

Kingma, Bruce (1989). "An Accurate Measure of the Crowd-Out Effect, Income Effect, and Price Effect for Charitable Contributions," Journal of Political Economy, 97, 1197-1207.

Kirchsteiger, Georg, Rigotti, Luca, and Rustichini, Aldo (2006). "Your Morals Might Be Your Moods," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 59(2), 155-172.

Konow, James (2000a). "Fair Shares: Accountability and Cognitive Dissonance in Allocation Decisions," American Economic Review, vol. 90, no. 4 (September), pp. 1072-1091.

Konow, James(2000b). "Conditional Altruism: Theory and Evidence," manuscript, Loyola Marymount University.

Konow, James(2003). "Which is the Fairest One of All?: A Positive Analysis of Justice Theories," Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 41, no. 4 (December), pp. 1186-1237.

Konow, James, and Earley, Joseph (2008). "The Hedonistic Paradox: Is Homo Economicus Happier?" Journal of Public Economics, vol. 92, nos. 1-2 (February), pp. 1-33.

Korenok, Oleg, Millner, Edward L. and Razzolini, Laura (2008). "Experimental Evidence on Inequality Aversion: Dictators Give to Help the Less Fortunate," Virginia Commonwealth University, 28/August.

Levine, David K. (1998). "Modeling Altruism and Spitefulness in Experiments," Review of Economic Dynamics, 1(3), July, 593-622.

Levitt, Steven D. and List, John A. (2007). "What Do Laboratory Experiments Measuring Social Preferences Reveal About the Real World?" Journal of Economic Perspectives, 21(2), Spring, 153-174.

List, John A. (2007), "On the Interpretation of Giving in Dictator Games," Journal of Political Economy, 115(3), June, 482-493.

Loewenstein, George and Small, Deborah A. (2007). "The Scarecrow and the Tin Man: The Vicissitudes of Human Sympathy and Caring," Review of General Psychology, 11(2), 1-15.

McBride, Michael (2008). "Money, Happiness, and Aspirations: An Experimental Study," University of California, Irvine: Department of Economics, 23/July.

McGranahan, Leslie Moscow (2000). "Charity and the Bequest Motive: Evidence from Seventeenth-Century Wills," Journal of Political Economy, 108(6), December, 1270-1291.

Neuberg, Steven L., et al. (1997). "Does Empathy Lead to Anything More Than Superficial Helping? Comment on Batson et al. (1997)," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 510-516.

Novemsky, Nathan and Kahneman, Daniel (2005). "The Boundaries of Loss Aversion," Journal of Marketing Research, 42(2), 119-128.

Palfrey, Thomas R., and Prisbrey, Jeffrey E. (1996). "Altruism, Reputation and Noise in Linear Public Goods Experiments," Journal of Public Economics, 61(3), 409-427.

Palfrey, Thomas R., and Prisbrey, Jeffrey E. (1997). "Anomalous Behavior in Public Goods Experiments: How Much and Why?" American Economic Review, 87(5), 829-847.

Payne, A. Abigail (1998). "Does the Government Crowd Out Private Donations?: New Evidence from a Sample of Nonprofit Firms," Journal of Public Economics, 69(3), 323-345.

Rabin, Matthew (1993). "Incorporating Fairness into Game Theory and Economics," American Economic Review, 83, 1281-1302.

Rabin, Matthew (1994). "Cognitive Dissonance and Social Change," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 23, 177-194.

Rege, Mari and Telle, Kjetil (2004). "The Impact of Social Approval and Framing on Cooperation in Public Good Situations," Journal of Public Economics, 88(7-8), 1625-1644.

Ribar, David and Wilhelm, Mark O. (2002). “Altruistic and Joy-of-Giving Motivations in Charitable Behavior,” Journal of Political Economy, 110(2), 425-457.

Smith, Adam (1759 [1809]), The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Glasgow: R. Chapman.

Smith, Tom W. (1979). "Happiness: Time Trends, Seasonal Variations, Intersurvey Differences, and Other Mysteries," Social Psychology Quarterly, 42(1), 18-30.

Spichtig, Mathias and Traxler, Christian (2007). "Social Norms and the Evolution of Conditional Cooperation," University of Amsterdam; University of Munich: Institute for Biodiversity and Ecosystem Dynamics (IBED); Seminar for Economic Policy, 15/March.

Thaler, Richard H. (1980). "Toward a Positive Theory of Consumer Choice," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 1, 39-60.

Vesterlund, Lise (2003). "The Informational Value of Sequential Fundraising," Journal of Public Economics, 87(3-4), March, 627-657.

Warr, Peter G. (1983). "The Private Provision of a Public Good Is Independent of the Distribution of Income" Economics Letters, 13, 207-211.

Xiao, Erte and Houser, Daniel (2007). "Emotion Expression and Fairness in Economic Exchange," University of Pennsylvania; George Mason University: Philosophy, Politics and Economics Program and Wharton School; Interdisciplinary Center for Economic Science and Department of Economics, November.

Zizzo, Daniel John, and Oswald, Andrew (2001). “Are People Willing to Pay to Reduce Others' Incomes?,” Annales d'Economie et de Statistique v0, n63-64, July-Dec., 39-65.