Нестабильность демократии в странах, богатых ресурсами

Polterovich, Victor and Popov, Vladimir and Tonis, Alexander (2008): Нестабильность демократии в странах, богатых ресурсами. Published in: HSE Economic Journal , Vol. 12, No. 2 (2008): pp. 176-200.

Abstract

We analyze data on sustainability of democratic regimes in resource rich countries and suggest a two-period model to explain why resource abundance may lead to instability of democracy in some countries, but does not create any difficulties for democratic system in other ones. Our central idea is as follows. If a country is abundant by point resources, this creates a prerequisite for resource owners to have dominant economic power. If institutions are weak under democracy, the economic power may be converted into political one. Resource owners («oligarchs») can thrust their preferred decisions on a parliament, bribing politicians. This creates a base for a potential Autocrat's strategy to get power. Rate of resource rent tax is considered as the only policy instrument in our simple model. The tax affects the income of a representative voter. Choosing a tax rate, Autocrat competes with conventional Politician (a representative political party) for the office. Our model takes into account the fact that the actual Autocrat's policy may be different from the announced one. If the difference between the two policies is big, then the public may rise up and throw the Autocrat down. Our main conclusions from the model exploration are as follows. The probability of democracy preservation is decreasing in the amount of resources, if the institutional quality is low enough. It is independent of resources and is determined only by cultural characteristics of the society, if the institutional quality is higher than the threshold. The level of the threshold, however, is positively dependent on the resource amount. These effects are consequences of the optimal Autocrat policy: the larger is the amount of resources, the stronger are Oligarch's incentives (inspired by Autocrat's policy) to bribe politicians.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• English Title: Instability of Democracy in Resource Abundant Countries
• Language: Russian
• Keywords: resource abundance; resource curse; democracy; autocracy; elections; political stability
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P16 - Political Economy

References

Гевелинг Л.В. Клептократия. М.: Гуманитарий, 2001.

Acemoglu D., Johnson S., Robinson J., Yared P. Income and Democracy: MIT Working Paper. 2005. N 05-05.

Acemoglu D., Robinson J.A., Verdier T. Kleptocracy and Divide-and Rule: A Model of Personal Rule: NBER Working Series. Working Paper. 2003. N 10136.

Akhmedov A., Zhuravskaya E. Opportunistic Political Cycles: Test in a Young Democracy Setting // Quarterly Journal of Economics. 2004. November. P. 1301–1338.

Alexeev M., Conrad R. The Elusive Curse of Oil: Working Papers Series. 2005. N SAN05-07.

Auty R.M. (ed.) Resource Abundance and Economic Development. Oxford University Press, 2001.

Barro R.J. Democracy and Growth // Journal of Economic Growth. 1996. Vol. 1. P. 3–27.

Barro R.J. Determinants of Democracy // The Journal of Political Economy. 1999. Vol. 107. N 6. Part. 2.

Brunnschweiler C.N. Cursing the Blessings? Natural Resource Abundance, Institutions, and Economic Growth: Economics Working Paper Series. 2006. N 06/51. ETH Zurich.

Bulte E.H., Damania R., Deacon R.T. Resource Abundance, Poverty and Development: Working Paper, Department of Economics, University of California, Santa Barbara. 2003.

Carothers T. The End of the Transition Paradigm // Journal of Democracy. 2002. January. P. 5–21.

Chistyakov E. Natural Resources, Corruption, and Manufacturing in Small Open Economy: Master's Thesis. M.: New Economic School, 2006. Manuscript.

Clague Ch., Keefer Ph., Knack St., Olson M. Property and Contract Rights in Autocracies and Democracies // Journal of Economic Growth. 1996. Vol. 1. June. P. 243–276.

Diamond L.J. Thinking About Hybrid Regimes // Journal of Democracy. 2002. Vol. 13. N 2. P. 21–35.

Egorov G., Guriev S., Sonin K. Media Freedom, Bureaucratic Incentives, and the Resource Curse: CEDI Working Paper. 2006. N 06-10.

Kartashov G. Economic Growth and Institutional Quality in Resource Oriented Countries: Master's Thesis. M.: New Economic School, 2006. Manuscript.

Leite C., Weidmann J. Does Mother Nature Corrupt? Natural Resources, Corruption, and Economic Growth: IMF Working Paper. 1999. N 99/85.

Llosa A.V. The Rise of Hugo Chavez. 2007.

Mehlum H., Moene K.O., Torvik R. Institutions and the Resource Curse // Economic Journal, Royal Economic Society. 2005. N 116(508). P. 1–20.

Polterovich V., Popov V. Democratization, Quality of Institutions and Economic Growth: Working Paper. 2006. N 056.

Robinson J.A., Torvik R., Verdier T. Political Foundations of the Resource Curse // Journal of Development Economics. 2006. N 79. P. 447–468.

Rodriguez F., Sachs J.D. Why do Resource Abundant Economies Grow More Slowly? A New Explanation and an Application to Venezuela // Journal of Economic Growth. 1999. N 4. P. 277–303.

Ross M.L. Does Oil Hinder Democracy? // World Politics. 2001. N 53. P. 325–361.

Sachs J.D., Warner A.M. The Big Push, Natural Resource Booms and Growth // Journal of Development Economics. 1999. Vol. 59. P. 43–76.

Sachs J.D., Warner A.M. The Curse of Natural Resources // European Economic Review. 2001. N 45. P. 827–838.

Stiglitz J.E. The Resource Curse Revisited, Project Syndicate. 2004.

Stijns P.C. Natural Resource Abundance and Economic Growth Revisited. UC Berkeley: Department of Economics, 2005. Mimeo.

Tornell A., Lane P.R. The Voracity Effect // American Economic Review. 1999. N 89. P. 22–46.

Torvik R. Natural Resources, Rent Seeking and Welfare // Journal of Development Economics. 2002. N 67. P. 455–470.

Wantchekon L. Why do Resource Dependent Countries Have Authoritarian Governments? Yale University, 1999.

Wantchekon L., Yehoue E. Crime in New Democracies. 2002.

Wintrobe R. Dictatorship: Analytical Approaches // Boix C., Stokes S. Oxford Handbook of Comparative Politics. Oxford University Press, 2007.

Zhukova N. Institutions and Optimal Level of Resources in Resource Abundant Countries: Master's Thesis. M.: New Economic School, 2006. Manuscript.