Romania, Part of the European Area of Freedom, Security and Justice (Migration, Asylum, Borders)

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2005): Romania, Part of the European Area of Freedom, Security and Justice (Migration, Asylum, Borders).

Abstract

At present, cross-border movement is a top priority issue on government agendas and in intergovernmental discussions. ‘Migration is as old as humanity, and it is a vital part of our future. And while migration policy is made at the national level, it has obvious international impact’ (UN, 2003). Over the past 15 years, the number of people crossing borders in search of a better life has been rising steadily. At the start of the 21st Century, one in every 35 people is an international migrant. If they all lived in the same place, it would be the world’s fifth-largest country (BBC, 2004). In Europe, as elsewhere, international migration has become a topical issue in public, political and academic debates. Most European countries are experiencing increased flows of immigration. Already millions of immigrants have come to stay, first in North-western Europe but increasingly also in other regions, and the odds are that many more immigrants will follow in the coming decades. The immigration flows have been triggered by several causes, including family reunification, political persecution, ecological disasters, or disparities in economic opportunity, and so forth. These flows show a tremendous variation in size and spatial distribution. Whatever the causes of international migration or the kind of selection at the border, old and new immigrations have obviously produced all sorts of social, cultural, political and economic changes, and impacted on general trends in specific ways.

Immigrants have contributed to population growth, filled labour shortages and contributed to growth and competitiveness. In sectors in which foreign and domestic labour can easily be substituted for each other, employment of immigrants has also increased unemployment among native-born workers. Labour rigidities in almost all European countries mean that, paradoxically, new immigrant flows coexist with low force-force participation rates, labour shortages and unemployment. Migration policies need to take into account not only the commonalities but also the differences among European labour markets. Distinct migration regimes in northern and southern Europe require differentiated policy approaches. More importantly, migration policies cannot substitute for required domestic economic and social policies. The complexities involved and the need for coordination across various policy domains require new institutional mechanisms to design policy with the active participation by all stakeholders. In light of European integration and enlargement, migration-migration policies should become an integral component of the EU policy agenda (Katseli, 2003). It is a known fact that economic policies implemented in order to liberalise the new markets are likely to, as a secondary effect, curb the number of migrants. For example, free trade policies pursued by the West are likely to lead to a greater convergence of consumer prices and eventually of factor prices. Also, direct foreign investment is helping to improve the economic climate in Central and East European countries, providing for a higher standard of living (Radeva, 2004).

A “frontier-free” Europe cannot be attained by mere ‘deregulation’, but presupposes a network of other controls. Typically, of course, frontiers controls simply moves to another place, perhaps in the form of more regular and random internal checks of forms of identity, or requirements to register a domicile (Shaw (2000), pag.380). Fears and scepticism in the West and hopefulness and optimism in the East are some of the factors which have prompted research done on the potential outcomes of liberalised migration. Two of the most relevant indicators for determining the quantity of migrants are implementation of the Schengen Acquis and economic support for higher growth. The new EU legislation would inevitably cause conflicts with previous bilateral agreements between accession and non-accession countries. Moreover, the differences between GDPs of old and of new EU member states establish a strong argument in favour of migration. A report by the WTO secretariat said temporary labour liberalisation could generate annual gains of 150 billion to 200 billion dollars. 'Gains are estimated to accrue to both developed and developing countries, and would come mainly from the movement of low-skilled workers rather than high skilled workers,' it added (WTO's 2004 World Trade Report, as quoted in AFP (2004)).

The increased labour migration has economic effects. Labour movements were now ungovernable because of the interdependence of markets and economies. What was needed was an open labour movement. National policies were still designed for an autonomous, closed system. Countries were no longer self-sufficient in capital, trade and labour and while this had never fully been the case, the level of interdependence reached required countries to address migratory flows with greater urgency.

Migrant remittances are a vital factor in development. The sums transferred to developing countries are large – and they are growing fast. And in developed countries, migrant labour is increasingly important, particularly in view of current demographic trends (UN, 2003).

The migratory flows Europe would largely be transitory and circulatory. Immigration implied settlement, but as people became more aware of the potential for short-term labour migration, they would no longer aim at full settlement. Compensation for demographic factors, reduction in life-long work time through extended education and greater overall wealth, leading to an early withdrawal from the workforce through retirement could increasingly come from migratory flows. Many people were retiring earlier, but living longer lives. Nurses and care staff from third countries, which had, to some extent been purposely recruited outside the EU, were currently providing care for many of Europe’s elderly and sick. This sporadic recruitment of workers, despite the high percentage of unemployment in most European countries, was emblematic of current trends in the underutilisation of the labour force. While Member States were building their policies around recruiting the ‘best and brightest’ from third countries, what was really necessary to ease the apparent gap were low- to mid-skilled workers. The European public would have to learn to understand the co-dependence of low-skilled and high-skilled labour.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Europe, Romania, migration, asylum, borders, Area of Freedom
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F22 - International Migration; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies > O52 - Europe; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R23 - Regional Migration ; Regional Labor Markets ; Population ; Neighborhood Characteristics

References

AFP (2004): WTO report argues for more extensive economic migration, Agence France Presse (AFP), September 16

AMAP (2004): Migrant Remittances, Accelerated Microenterprise Advancement Project (AMAP), Vol.1 No.1, USAID and Bannock Consulting, August

Annan, Kofi A. (2004): Why Europe Needs an Immigration Strategy, published in newspapers throughout Europe, United Nations, New York, available at (07.11.2004) http://www.un.org/News/ossg/sg/stories/sg-29jan2004.htm

Apap, Joanna and Carrera, Sergio (2003): Progress and Obstacles in the Area of Justice and Home affairs in an Enlarging Europe, in Romanian Journal of European Affairs, vol.3. no.2, September 2003, European Institute of Romania, Bucharest, pages 65-85

BBC (2004): Factfile: Global migration, BBC News, available at (23.03.2004): http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/spl/hi/world/04/migration/html/migrant_labour.stm

Capel, Jonathan, Dumont, Jean-Christophe and Visco, Ignatio (2001): Trends in Immigration and Economic Consequences, OECD, Economic Department Working Papers no. 284, Paris, June 18

Constantin, Florentina (2004): Migrating or Commuting? The Case of Romanian Workers in Italy: Niches for Labour Commuting to the EU, in (Un)Freedom of Movement: Migration Issues in Europe. Part I., EU Monitoring and Advocacy Program (EUMAP), available at (18.10.2004): http://www.eumap.org/journal/features/2004/migration/commuting

Constantin, Daniela-Luminita et al (2004), The Migration Phenomenon from the Perspective of Romania’s Accession to the European Union, Pre-Accession impact Studies II, Study no.5, The European Institute of Romania, Bucharest

Constantinescu, Monica (2002): Teorii ale migratiei internationale (Theories of International Migration), in Sociologie Romaneasca (Romanian Sociology), No.3-4/2002, Bucharest, pages 93-114

Diminescu, Dana (2003): Visible, mais peu nombreux. Les Circulations migratoires roumaines (ed.), Edition de le Maison des Sciences de l’Homme, Paris

Diminescu, Dana and Lazaroiu, Sebastian (2002): Migratia circulatorie a românilor după 1990 (Circulatory Migration of Romanians After 1990), IOM Mission in Romania, Bucharest, as quoted in Sufaru (2004)

DMS (2004): Departamentul pentru Munca în Strainatate (DMS) (Department for Working Abroad), Romanian Government, Ministry of Labour, Social Solidarity and Family, Bucharest, http://www.mmssf.ro/dms/dms.htm

Florian, Razvan (2004): Migraţia cercetatorilor români (Migration of the Romanian Researchers), in Ad Astra, 3(2) 2004, available at (20.10.2004): http://www.ad-astra.ro

Fotakis, Constantinos (2003): Europe’s Demographic Future: Labor Markets & Immigrants, in Policy Briefs: Greek Presidency Conference on Managing Migration, Policy Brief 9, Athens, May 15

Ghetau, Vasile (2003): Declinul demografic continua (The Demographic Decline Continues), Barometrul Social (Social Barometer), February; available at (18.08.2004): http://www.mediauno.ro/bs-search.php?art=2233, as quoted in Constantin et al (2004), page 23

Ghetau, Vasile (2004): 2050: Will Romania’s Population Fall Below 16 Million Inhabitants?, Romanian Academy, National Institute of Economic Research, Population Research Center ‘Vladimir Trebici’, Bucharest

Government of Romania (2004): Government Decision no.616/21 April 2004 for approving the National Strategy on Migration, published in the Official Journal no.406/6 May 2004, Bucharest

IGPF (2004a): Inspectoratul General al Politiei de Frontiera (IGPF) (General Inspectorate of Border Police), Romanian Government, Ministry of Administration and Interior, Bucharest

IGPF (2004b): Press Dossier, Press Briefing of the General Inspectorate of Border Police, IGPF, October 14, Bucharest

IOM (2004): Return Migration: Policies and Practices in Europe, International Organization for Migration (IOM), Geneva, January

IOM – Romania (2004a): National Migration and Development Policy in Romania, IOM Mission in Romania, Bucharest, January

IOM – Romania (2004b): Remittances and Development in Romania, IOM Mission in Romania, Bucharest, January

Katseli, Louka T. (2003): Immigrants & EU Labour Markets, in Policy Briefs: Greek Presidency Conference on Managing Migration, Policy Brief 12, Athens, May 15; report also found at (12.11.2004): Migration Policy Institute, www.migrationpolicy.org

Kideckel, David A. et al (2000): A New “Cult of Labour”: Stress and Crisis Among Romanian Workers, in Sociologie Romaneasca (Romanian Sociology), I/2000, Bucharest, pages 142-161

Lazaroiu, Sebastian (2002): The circulatory migration of the Romanian work force. Consequences on European integration, Bucharest, http://www.osf.ro/ro/initiative.pdf, as quoted in Constantin, Florentina (2004)

Lazaroiu, Sebastian (2003): The Risks of Irregular Migration to the European Union. Perceptions and Trends, IOM Mission in Romania, Bucharest

Lazaroiu, Sebastian (2004): More ‘Out’ than ‘In’ at the Crossroads between Europe and the Balkans, in Migration Trends in Selected Applicant Countries, Volume IV – Romania, International Organization for Migration, Vienna

Lazea, Valentin, Dumitru, Mihail and Diminescu, Dana (2004): Migraţia în străinătate a forţei de muncă provenită din mediul rural. Aspecte şi recomandări (Migration Abroad of the Labour Forces Originated from Rural Area. Aspects and Recommendations), in Grigore Silasi (ed.): Europa între cei 15 şi cei 25 (Europe between the 15th and the 25th) (2004), Editura Universităţii de Vest, Timişoara

MAI (2004): Cartea Albă a Ministerului Administraţiei şi Internelor 2001-2004 (White Paper of the Ministry of Administration and Interior 2001-2004), Directorate for Information and Public Relations, Bucharest, November

MAI (2005): Evaluarea activităţii Ministerului Administraţiei şi Internelor în anul 2004 (Evaluation of the Activity of the Ministry of Administration and Interior in the Year 2004), Bucharest, January

MIR (2004): Immigration in Spain: Evolution and Perspectives, Government of Spain, Ministry for Employment and Social Affairs, Secretariat of State for immigration and Emigration, http://dgei.mir.es

Van Selm, Joanne and Tsolakis, Eleni (2004): The Enlargement of an “Area of Freedom, Security and Justice”: Managing Migration in a European Union of 25 Members, in Policy Brief, Migration Policy Institute (MPI), No.4, May, available at (15.08.2004): www.migrationpolicy.org/pubs

National Institute of Statistics (2004a): Situaţia demografică a României în 2003 (Demographic Situation of Romania in 2003), Bucharest

National Institute of Statistics (2004b): Proiectarea populaţiei României în profil teritorial până în anul 2025 (The Projection of Romania’s Population on Territorial Section in 2025), Bucharest

Nicolescu, Luminiţa and Constantin, Daniela-Luminţa (2005): Romania’s External Migration in the Context of Accession to the EU: Mechanisms, Institutions and Social-Cultural Issues, draft paper submitted for publishing in Romanian Journal of European Studies, edited by The School of High Comparative European Studies (SISEC), Timisoara. The draft paper represents a part of the author’s contribution to Constantin et al (2004).

OMFM (2004): Oficiul pentru Migraţia Forţei de Muncă (OMFM) (Office for Labour Force Migration), Romanian Government, Ministry of Labour, Social Solidarity and Family, Bucharest, http://www.omfm.ro

ONR (2004): Oficiul Naţional pentru Refugiaţi (ONR) (National Refugees Office), Romanian Government, Ministry of Administration and Interior, Bucharest

Ora Romaniei (2004a): Barometrul Ora României – Supliment (Romania’s Hour Barometer) – Supplement no.1, 18-24 October 2004, Bucharest

Ora Romaniei (2004b): Barometrul Ora României – Supliment (Romania’s Hour Barometer) – Supplement no.2, 25-31 October 2004, Bucharest

Radeva, Mariyana (2004): East-West Migration in the Context of an Enlarging European Union: New Opportunities and New Challenges, in (Un)Freedom of Movement: Migration Issues in Europe. Part I., EU Monitoring and Advocacy Program (EUMAP), available at (18.10.2004): http://www.eumap.org/journal/features/2004/migration/eastwest

RFE/RL (2003): Romania to sanction citizens expelled from EU countries, RFE/RL Newsline, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, September 26; available at (29.09.2003): http://www.rferl.org/newsline/2003/09/ 260903.asp

Rusu, Laurentiu (2004): Migraţia ilegală, segment important al crimei organizate transfrontaliere (Illegal Migration, Important Part of Trans-border Organised Crime), in Frontiera (The Border), no.10/2004, General Inspectorate of Border Police, Bucharest, pages 22-24

Sandu, Dumitru (2001): Migraţie şi mobilitate internaţională (International Migration and Mobility), in Barometrul de Opinie Publică (Public Opinion Barometer), Open Society Foundation, http://www.fsd.ro, Bucharest, October

Saniuta, Marian Florian (2004): Accomplishing the Commitments towards the European Union – Essential Premises for Romanian’s Integration, in Revista Română de Studii Internaţionale (Romanian Review of International Studies), nr.1/2004, Asociaţia de Drept Internaţional şi Relaţii Internaţionale (Association for International Law and International Relations), Bucharest, pages 114-127

Scott-Joynt, Jeremy (2004): The Remittance Lifeline, BBC News Online, available at (23.03.2004): http://www.bbc.co.ul

Shaw, Jo (2000): Law of the European Union, third edition, Palgrave Macmillan, New York

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2002): Romania – Source Country and Transit Country for International Migration, in SISEC Discussion Papers, No.I/1 October 2002, West University of Timisoara, School of High Comparative European Studies (SISEC), Timisoara, October (paper presented at the “UNU/WIDER Conference on Poverty, International Migration and Asylum”, Helsinki, Finland, 27-28 September 2002, available at (20.11.2004):http://www.wider.unu.edu/conference/conference-2002-3/conference2002-3.htm)

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2003a): Migration – Fake or Threat? It Is Romania a Real Risk for the European Space After the Enlargement Process, as Source for European Migration?, în László Lehoczy, László Kalmár (ed.): 4th International Conference of PhD Students (2003), Vol. „Economics 2”, Miskolci Egyetem, Miskolc, pages 439 - 446

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2003b): Romania as Source for International Migration, in: Lazar Cistelecan (ed.): Economia şi societatea românească la începuturile mileniului trei (Romanian Economy and Society at the Beginning of the Third Millennium) (2002), Vol. I, Editura Universităţii “Petru Maior”, Târgu Mureş, pages 444-457

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2004): Inequality and Poverty in EU and the Accession Countries from Central and Eastern Europe. The Implications of Migration. The Case of Romania, in Tadeusz Koźluk (ed.): International Immigration and Naturalization Conference (2003), PWSBiA, Warsaw, pages 249-270

Sufaru, Ionela (2004): Economia migraţiei internaţionale a românilor în perioada postcomunistă (The Economy of International Migration in the Post-communist Age), in Barometrul Social (Social Barometer), no.20, September – October 2004, Bucharest, pages 72-82

UN (2003): Win-Win Outcomes Possible if Approach to Migration Is Rational, Compassionate, United Nations, Press Release SG/SM/9064 SOC/4632 09/12/2003, available at (07.11.2004): http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2003/sgsm9064.doc.htm

UNHCR (2003): Asylum Levels and Trends in Industrialized Countries, January to November 2003, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), Geneva

WTO (2004): 2004 World Trade Report, World Trade Organisation, Geneva, September 16; available at (20.09.2004): http://www.wto.org/english/res_e/booksp_e/anrep_e/world_trade_ report04_e.pdf