Technological advantage and market loss: Siemens and the X-ray machine business in Japan (1900–1960)

Donze, Pierre-Yves (2010): Technological advantage and market loss: Siemens and the X-ray machine business in Japan (1900–1960).

Abstract

This paper focuses on the involvement of Siemens on the market for radiology equipment in Japan between 1900 and 1960 from a business history perspective. It explores why the German multinational was unable to keep its dominant position on the Japanese market in the interwar years, despite its technological competitiveness. In particular, it examines the strategic choices made by the firm (export, licensing, direct investment) in relation to the changing economic and technological environment, highlighting the importance, for foreign multinationals, of working together with national trading firms involved in the distribution of drugs and products for doctors, as the Japanese medical market was already well structured when the country opened up to the West. Four phases have been identified. At first, before World War I, German manufacturers of X-ray machines, especially Siemens, enjoyed a virtual monopoly in Japan and favored an export strategy. The political and technological shifts that occurred during the war (interruption of trade with Germany, development of the Coolidge X-ray tube by General Electric) led to a more competitive market in Japan. Siemens reorganized its involvement in this business via a contract signed with a domestic medical goods trade company, Goto Fuundo (1926). Yet this proved insufficient to overcome the competition, and Siemens finally decided to relocate some of its production facilities for X-ray machines in Japan by entering into a joint venture with Goto (1932). Relations between Siemens and Goto were severed by the war, and Goto tried until the 1950s to go it alone in this field but failed due to a lack of organizational capability. As for Siemens, it reverted to its export strategy approach, re-entering the market in the 1950s.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Siemens, Goto Fuundo, X-ray machines, medical market
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N8 - Micro-Business History > N85 - Asia including Middle East; F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F23 - Multinational Firms ; International Business

References

20 seiki nihon no keizaijin, Tokyo: Nihon keizai shimbun, 2001.

21 seiki ne no kakehashi, Tokyo: Toshiba Medical, 1998.

Arns, Robert G., “The High-Vacuum X-Ray Tube: Technological Change in Social Context”, Technology and Culture, 38/4 (1997), 852-890.

Blume, Stuart S., Insight and Industry. On the Dynamics of Technological Change in Medicine, London/Cambridge: MIT Press, 1992.

Boch, Rudolf (ed.), Patentschutz und Innovation in Geschichte und Gegenwart, Frankfurt am Main, etc.: Peter Lang, 1999.

Chandler, Alfred D., Scale and Scope: The Dynamics of Industrial Capitalism, Cambridge: Belknap, 1990.

Donzé, Pierre-Yves, « Les systèmes hospitaliers contemporains, entre histoire sociale des techniques et business history », Gesnerus. Swiss Journal of the History of Medicine and Sciences 62 (2005) 273-287.

Donzé, Pierre-Yves, L’ombre de César. Les chirurgiens et la construction du système hospitalier vaudois (1840-1960), Lausanne : BHMS, 2007.

Donzé, Pierre-Yves, “Studies Abroad by Japanese Doctors: A Prosopographic Analysis of the Nameless Practitioners, 1862-1912”, Social history of medicine, (published in advance access on the website http://shm.oxfordjournals.org/, 16 March 2010).

Donzé, Pierre-Yves, “Switzerland and the Industrialization of Japan: Swiss direct investments and technology transfers to Japan during the twentieth century”, Business History, forthcoming in 2010

Fuji denki shashi, Tokyo: Fuji denki seizo K.K., 1957. Gaimusho tokubetsu shiryobu, Nihon ni okeru gaikoku shihon, Tokyo: Kasumigaseikai, 1948.

General Electric, The Story of X-Ray, Milwaukee: General Electric, 1963.

Goto, Goro, Nihon hoshasen igakushiko, Tokyo: Nihon igaku hoshasen gakkai, 1969-1970, 2 volumes.

Goto, Setuzo, Surgical instruments and appliances, Tokyo: Goto Fu-undo, 1906.

Holtzmann Kevles, Bettyann, Naked to the Bone: Medical Imaging in the Twentieth Century, New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1997.

Howell, Joel, Technology in the Hospital. Transforming patient care in the early twentieth century, Baltimore/London: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995.

Ikai, Shuhei, Byoin no seiki no riron, Tokyo: Yuhikaku, 2010.

Imaizumi, Asuka, “Tokyo-fu kikai kanren kogyo shuseki ni okeru kanto taishinsai no eikyo”, in Shakai keizai shi gaku, 74/4 (2008), 23-45.

Imakubo, Sachio, “Ekkyo suru kyodai kigyo – shimensu to AEG”, in Watanabe, Hisashi (ed.), Yoroppa no hakken – chiikishi no naka no kokkyo to shijo, Tokyo: Yuhikaku, 2000, 235-239.

Iseki, Kuro (ed.), Dainihon hakushi roku, Tokyo: Hattensha, 1921-1930, 5 volumes.

Japan Patent Office, Tokkyo bunrui betsu somokuroku, Tokyo: Gihodo, 1958.

Kees, Boersma, “Tensions within an Industrial Research Laboratory: The Philips Laboratory’s X-Ray Department between the Wars”, Enterprise & Society, 4 (March 2003) 65-98.

Kikai tokei nenpo, Tokyo: Ministry of International Trade and Industry, various volumes.

Kudo, Akira, Japanese-German business relations: cooperation and rivalry in the inter-war period, London/New York: Routledge, 1998.

Kudo, Akira, Nobuo, Tajima and Pauer, Erich (ed), Japan and Germany: Two Latecomers to the World Stage, 1890-1945, Kent: Global Oriental, 2009,

Löwy, Ilana (ed.), Medicine and Change : Historical and Sociological Studies of Medical Innovation, Paris/London: INSRM/John Libbey Ltd., 1993.

Mason, Stark, American Multinationals and Japan: The Political Economy of Japanese Capital Controls, 1899-1980, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992.

Momotani, Rokurota, Nihon ni okeru shimensu no jigyo to sono keiken reki, Tokyo: Momotani, 1955.

Nihon gaikoku boeki nenpyo, Tokyo: Ministry of Finances, 1951-1960.

Nihon kogyo yokan, Tokyo: Kogyo no nihonsha, various years.

Nihon tokei kyokai (ed.), Nihon choki tokei soran, Tokyo: Nihon tokei kyokai, 2006, 6 volumes.

Nikan kogyo shimbun, Nihon gijutsuka soran, Tokyo: Nikan kogyo shimbun, 1934.

Pickstone, John, Ways of knowing: A new history of science, technology and medicine, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2000.

Rosner, David, A once charitable enterprise. Hospitals and health care in Brooklyn and New York, 1885-1915, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982.

Shimadzu Seisakujo shi, Kyoto: Shimadzu Seisakujo, 1967.

Shiraimatsu kikai, 130 nen no ayumi – 1872-2002, Osaka: Shiraimatsu, 2002.

Siemens, Georg, History of the House of Siemens, Freiburg/Munich: Karl Alber, 1957.

Siemens K.K., 100 Jahre Siemens in Japan, Tokyo: Siemens K.K., 1987.

Stanton, Jennifer, “Making Sense of Technologies in Medicine” Social History of Medicine 12 (1999) 437-448.

Stanton, Jennifer (ed.), Innovations in Health and Medicine. Diffusion and Resistance in the Twentieth Century, London: Routledge, 2002.

Sugaya, Akira, Nihon no byoin: sono ayumi to mondaiten, Tokyo: Chuko, 1981.

Takenaka, Tooru, Jiimensu to meiji nihon, Tokyo: Tokai University Press, 1991.

Takenaka, Tooru, “Business activities of Siemens in Japan: A Case Study of German-Japanese Economic Relationships before the First World War”, in Kudo, Akira, Nobuo, Tajima and Pauer, Erich (ed.), Japan and Germany: Two Latecomers to the World Stage, 1890-1945, Kent: Global oriental, 2009, vol. 1, 114-149.

Tokyo daigaku igakubu hyakunenshi henshuiinkai, Tokyo daigaku igakubu hyakunenshi, Tokyo: Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 1967.

Tokyo shibaura denki, Tokyo shibaura denki kabushiki kaisha 85 nen shi, Tokyo: Tokyo shibaura denki, 1963.

Udagawa, Katsu, “Senzen Nihon no kigyo keiei to gaishikei kigyo”, Keiei Shirin 24/1-2 (1987) 15-31.

Watanabe, Hisashi, “A History of the Process Leading to the Formation of Fuji Electric”, Japanese Yearbook on Business History 1 (1984) 47-71.

Yamashita Mai, Iyaku wo kindaika shita kenkyu to senryaku, Tokyo : Fuyoshobo, 2010

Yuzawa, Takeshi and Udagawa, Masaru (ed.), Foreign Business in Japan Before World War II. Proceedings of The Fuji Conference, Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 1990.