Different paths towards Flexibility, Deregulated employment protection or temporary employment?

Chung, Heejung (2005): Different paths towards Flexibility, Deregulated employment protection or temporary employment?

Abstract

There are numerous debates on the need to increase flexibility through deregulation of employment protection. Many believe it is essential in generating employment but it is also believed to generate �socially unacceptable� flexible jobs. However, recent studies point to strict regulations on firing permanent workers as the cause of increase in the shares of temporary employment. In other words, stringent protective regulations are not only a source of rigidity, but also force employers to increase flexibility in the labour market through other means. This study explores this hypothesis by examining various aspects of employment protection legislation in concomitance with other competing factors, including structural changes and labour market institutional factors, to explain the cross-national variance of temporary employment across 19 OECD countries using quantitative data. The results show that high cost of firing workers on permanent contracts is the most important factor that explains the high shares of temporary employment. This implies that there are two different ways in which flexibility has been introduced. Either introducing flexibility throughout the labour market using relaxed regulations on firing regular workers, or securing the core workers with high firing cost for regular workers while allowing for flexibility through the use of temporary employment.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: University of Edinburgh
• Language: English
• Keywords: labour market flexibility; temporary employment; EPL (employment protection legislation); OECD countries; cross-national comparative studies; employment regimes
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General > J08 - Labor Economics Policies; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General > J00 - General; P - Economic Systems > P5 - Comparative Economic Systems

References

Andersen, J. G. & Halvorsen, K. (2002) “Changing labour markets, unemployment and unemployment policies in a citizenship prospective.” In Andersen, J. G. et al (eds) (2002) Europe’s New State of Welfare: Unemployment, employment policies and citizenship. Policy Press, Bristol, UK Atkinson, A. B. & Micklewright, J., (1991) "Unemployment Compensation and Labour Market Transitions: A Critical Review". Journal of Economic Literature. 29:4 pp. 1679-1727. Atkinson, J. (1984) Flexibility, Uncertainty and Manpower Management, IMS Report No.89, Institute of Manpower Studies, Brighton. Auer, P. & Cazes, S. (2003a) “Introduction” in Auer, P. & Cazes, S. (eds.) (2003) Employment Stability in an Age of Flexibility: Evidence from industrialized countries. ILO, Geneva. pp.1~21. Auer, P. & Cazes, S. (2003b) “The Resilience of the Long-Term Employment Relationship” in Auer, P. & Cazes, S. (eds.) (2003) Employment Stability in an Age of Flexibility: Evidence from industrialized countries. ILO, Geneva. pp. 22~58. Beck, N. (2001) ‘Time Series-Cross-Section Data: What have we learned in the past few years’. Annual Review of Political Science, 4:271~293. Bentolila, S. & Dolado, J. J. (1994) “Labour Flexibility and Wages: Lessons from Spain”, Economic Policy, 14. pp.53~99. Bertola, G., Blau, F. D., Kahn, L. M. (2002) Labour Market Institutions and Demographic Employment Patterns, NBER Working Paper 9043, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge. http://www.nber.org/papers/w9043 Blanchard, O. & Landier, A. (2001) “The Perverse Effect of Partial Labour Market Reform: Fixed Duration Contracts in France”, National Bureau for Economic Research, Working Paper No.8219. Bonoli, G. & Safarti, H. (2002) “Conclusions: the Policy Implications of a Changing Labour Market- Social Protection Relationship” in Bonoli, G & Safarti, H. (eds) Labour Market and Social Protection Reforms in International Perspective: Parallel or converging tracks? Ashgate Publishing Limited, Aldershot. pp.451~486. Booth, A.L., Dolado, J.J. & Frank, J. (2002) “Symposium on temporary work: Introduction”. The Economic Journal, Vol.112(June) F181~F188 Royal Economic Society Oxford. Burtless, G., (1990) "Unemployment Insurance and Labour Supply: A Survey". in Hansen, L., & Byers, J. (eds.) Unemployment Insurance, The University of Wisconsin Press, Madison. Buti, M., Pench, L. R., & Sestito, P., (1998) "European Unemployment: Contending Theories and Institutional Complexities". Economic and Financial Report. BEI/EIB Report 98/01. European Investment Bank. Calandrino, M. & Gagliarducci, S. “Labour market transitions and advancement: temporary employment and low-pay in Europe” paper for TLM.Net Conference: Quality in Labour Market Transitions: A European Challenge. 2004 Nov.24~26. Amsterdam. Campbell, I. (2004) “Trade Unions and Temporary Employment: New Initiatives in Regulation and Representation” paper for the 25th Conference of the International Working Party on Labour Market Segmentation, Brisbane, 22nd ~24th July, 2004. Castles, F. (2004) The Future of the Welfare State: Crisis Myths and Crisis Realities, Oxford University Press, New York. ______ (1998) Comparative Public Policy: Patterns of Post-war Transformation, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK. Cahuc, P. & Postel-Vinay, F. (2001) “Temporary Jobs, Employment Protection and Labour Market Performance” IZA Discussion Paper No. 260. Chung, H. (2003) 노동시장정책과 사회보장제도의 관계: OECD 17개국 고용보호와 실업급여의 상관관계 중심으로, MSW dissertation, Yonsei University, Seoul. Summarized in Chung (2005) “Social Security and Labour Market Reform, Friends or Foes? Unemployment Benefit and Employment Protection Legislation of 17 OECD countries in the late 1990s”, unpublished manuscript. Corson, W., & Nicholson, W., (1988) "An Examination of Declining UI Claims During the 1980s". Washington D.C.: US Department of Labour, Employment and Training Administration. Danziger, S., Haveman, R. H., & Plotnick, R., (1981) " How Income Transfer Program affect Work, Savings, and Income Distribution: A Critical Review," Journal of Economic Literature. 19. Dasgupta, S. (2001) “Employment Security: Conceptual and Statistical Issues”, International Labour Orgainization, Geneva. Debels, A. (2004) “Temporary Jobs: Segmented security through the labour and welfare system” paper presented at TLM.Net Conference: Quality in Labour Market Transitions: A European Challenge. 2004 Nov.24~26. Amsterdam. Delsen, L. (1995) Atypical Employment an International Perspective: Causes, Consequences and Policy. WoltersgroepGroningen bv, Netherlands. Dolado, J.J, Garcia-Serrano, C., Jimeno-Serrano, J.F. (2001) “Drawing Lessons From The Boom of Temporary Jobs in Spain” Discussion Paper No.2884, Centre for Economic Policy Research. London, UK. EIRO (2002) “Non-permanent employment, quality of work and industrial relations” http://www.eiro.eurofound.eu.int/2002/02/study/index.html (Searched June, 2005) Esping-Andersen, G. (2001) “Who is Harmed by Labour Market Regulations?” in Esping-Andersen, G. & Regini, M. (eds.) Why Deregulate Labour Markets? Oxford University Press, Oxford. ______ (1999) The Social Foundations of Post-industrial Economies, Oxford University Press, Oxford. European Commission (2004) “Key Determinants of Labour Market Performance” in Employment in Europe 2004. EC. Brussels. http://europa.eu.int/comm/employment_social/employment_analysis/eie/eie2004_chap2_en.pdf ______ (2003) “European Employment Guidelines”. European Union, Brussels. http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/pri/en/oj/dat/2003/l_197/l_19720030805en00130021.pdf ______ (2002) Employment in Europe 2002. Recent trends and prospects. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities. Forde C. & Slater G. (2001) “Just a Temporary Phenomenon? The Rise and Fall of Temporary Work in the UK”, Paper Presented at the Eastern Economic Association Conference, New York, 23rd-25th February. Garrett, G. (1998) Partisan Politics in the Global Economy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Grubbs, D. & Wells, W. (1993) “Employment Regulation and Patterns of Work in EC countries”, OECD Economic Studies, No.21 Winter pp.7~58. Güell, M. (2003) “Fixed-Term Contracts and the Duration Distribution of Unemployment” IZA Discussion Paper No.791, Institute for the Study of Labor. Güell, M. & Petrongolo, B. (1998) “The Transition of Workers from Temporary to Permanent Employment: the Spanish Case”, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Working Paper No,.98~81. Ham, J., & Rea, S. A., (1987) "Unemployment Insurance and Male Unemployment Duration in Canada". Journal of Labour Economics. 5. pp.325-353. Holumlund, B., (1998) "Unemployment Insurance in Theory and Practice". Scandinavian Journal of Economics. 100:1. pp. 113-141. Holmlund, B., & Storrie, D. (2002) “Temporary Work in Turbulent Times: The Swedish Experience”, The Economic Journal 112(June) F245~F269, Royal Economic Society, Oxford. Kahn, L. M. (2005) “The Impact of Employment Protection Mandates on Demographic Temporary Employment Patterns: International Microeconomic Evidence”, IZA Discussion Paper No. 1548. Katz, L., & Meyer, B., (1990) "The Impact of the Potential Duration of Unemployment Benefits on the Duration of Unemployment". Journal of Public Economic. 41. pp. 45-72 Katzenstein, P. (1985) Small States in World Markets. Cornell University Press; Ithaca, NY Kittel, B. (2000) ‘Sense and Sensitivity in the Pooled Analysis of Political Data’ European Journal of Political Research, 35:225~253. Landman, T. (2000) Issues and Methods in Comparative Politics. London: Routledge. Lechner, M., Pfeiffer, F., Spengler, H., & Almus, M. (2000) “The Impact of Non-profit Temping Agencies on Individual Labour Market Success in the West Germany State of Rhineland-Palatinate”, Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW), Discussion Paper No.00-02. Madsen, P. K. (2003) (2004) “The Danish Model of ‘Flexicurity’: Experiences and Lessons”, Transfer-European Review of Labour and Research. Vol.10 No.2: 187~207. ______ ““Flexicurity” through labour market policies and institutions in Denmark” in Auer, P. & Cazes, S. (eds.) Employment Stability in an Age of Flexibility, International Labour Organization, Geneva. pp.59 ~ 105. Mishra, R. (1999) Globalization and the Welfare State, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham. Moffit, R., (1985) "Unemployment Insurance and The Distribution of Unemployment Spells". Journal of Econometrics. 28. pp. 85-101. Moffit, R., & Nicolson, W., (1982) "The Effect of Unemployment Insurance on Unemployment: The Case of Federal Supplemental Benefits". Review of Economic and Statistics. 64. pp. 1-11 Monastiriotis, V. (2003) “A Panel of Regional Indicators of Labour Market Flexibility”, Discussion Paper 2003-01, Royal Holloway, University of London. http://www.rhul.ac.uk/economics/Research/WorkingPapers/pdf/dpe0301.pdf Morishima, M. (2001) “Contingent Workers in Japan: New Developments and Unexpected Consequences”, Japan Labor Bulletin, Special Topic, Vol. 40, No. 3, March 1. Nickell, S. (2003a) “Labour Market Institutions and Unemployment in OECD Countries” http://www.dse.unibo.it/rovelli/EIE/Eie-Refs/Nickell-INSTITandUNEMPL-dicereport2-2003.pdf ______ (2003b) “Employment and Taxes” CESIFO Working Paper No. 1109. http://www.cesifo.de/~DocCIDL/1109.pdf (Searched July, 2005) ______ (1997) “Unemployment and Labour Market Rigidities: Europe versus North America” Journal of Economic Perspectives Vol.11 Number 3, Summer 1997: pp. 55 ~ 74 Nickell, S., Nunziata, L., & Ochel, W. (2005) “Unemployment in the OECD since the 1960s. What do we know?” The Economic Journal, 115 (January) p. 1~27. Royal Economic Society, Oxford. Nunziata, L. & Staffolani, S. (2005) “Short Term Contracts Regulations and Dynamic Labour Demand: Theory and Evidence” Paper presented at the CEPR Workshop, January 27-28, 2005, British Embassy, Berlin Germany. http://www.wiwi.hu-berlin.de/wpol/schumpeter/workshop_agency-work/papers/ Nunziata_Staffolani.pdf (Searched June, 2005) Nunziata, L. & Staffolani, S. (2001) “On Short-Term Contracts Regulations” Nuffield College economics working paper 2001-W7, University of Oxford. http://www.nuff.ox.ac.uk/economics/papers/2001/w7/onshorttermcontracts.pdf (searched June, 2005) OECD (2005) OECD Economic Outlook No.77, Paris. ______ (2004a) “Employment Protection Regulation and Labour Market Performance” OECD Employment Outlook, Paris. pp.61~125 ______ (2004b) “Wage-setting Institutions and Outcomes” OECD Employment Outlook, Paris. pp.127~181. ______ (2004c) Taxing Wages 2002-2003, Paris. ______ (2004d) Labour Force Statistics 1983-2003, Paris. ______ (2004e) OECD Economic Outlook, No.76, Paris. ______ (2004f) Benefits and Wages, Paris. ______ (2004g) OECD Employment Outlook, Paris. ______ (2002a) “Taking the measure of temporary employment” OECD Employment Outlook, Paris. pp. 127~185. ______ (2002b) “Recent labour market developments and prospects: Special Focus on: A Better Start for Youths?” OECD Employment Outlook. pp.13~60. ______ (1999) “Employment protection and labour market performance” OECD Employment Outlook, Paris. pp. 48~132. ______ (1997a) “Economic performance and the structure of collective bargaining”, OECD Employment Outlook, Paris. pp.63~92. ______ (1997b) The OECD Job Strategy: Making work pay. Taxation, benefit, employment and unemployment, Paris. ______ (1994) The OECD Job Study. Evidence and Explanations. Part I: Labour market trends and underlying forces of change; Part II: The adjustment potential of the labour market, Paris. Pissarides, C. A. (2001) “Employment Protection” Labour Economics (8), pp.131~159. Pot, F., Koene, B. & Paauwe, J. (2000) “Contingent Employment in the Netherlands”, Erasmus Research Institute of Management, Working Paper No. ERS-2001-4ORG, Rotterdam University. Ragin, C. (1994) ‘Introduction to Qualitative Comparative Analysis,’ in Janoski, P. and Hicks, A. (eds) Comparative Political Economy of the Welfare State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 299~320. Robinson, P. (1999) “Explaining the Relationship between Flexible Employment and Labour Market Regulation” in Felstead, A. and Jewson, N. (eds) Global Trends in Flexible Labour, Macmillan Press LTD, London. Rodrik, D. (1997) Has Globalization Gone Too Far? Institute for International Economics, Washington, DC. Saint-Paul, G. (1996) Dual Labour Markets, The MIT Press, Cambridge. ______ (2002) “The Political Economy of Employment Protection” Journal of Political Economy, 110(3): pp.672~701. University of Chicago Press, Chicago. Sapir, A. (2000) “Who Is Afraid of Globalization? The Challenge of Domestic Adjustment in Europe and America” Paper prepared for the Conference on Efficiency, Equity and Legitimacy: The Multilateral Trading System at the Millennium, the Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, June 1-2, 2000. Scarpetta, S. (1996) “Assessing the Role of Labour Market Policies and Institutional Settings on Unemployment: A Cross-Country Study”, OECD Economic Studies, No. 26. pp.43~98. Paris. Standing, G. (1999) Global Labour Flexibility: Seeking Distributive Justice. Macmillan Press LTD, London. Sigel, N. A. (2003) ‘Worlds of Comparative Welfare State Analysis: Some Suggestions for Potential Bridge-Over Strategies’. Paper presented at the ESPAnet Annual Conference, Kopenhagen: Eigtveds Pakhus, 13~15 Nov. 2003. Villeval, M. C. (1990) “Labour market restructuring and deprivation processes” paper presented at the 1990 EALE Conference, University of Lund, September, 20th ~23rd. Visser, J. & Hemerijk, A. (1997) A Dutch Miracle: Job Growth, Welfare Reform and Corporatism in the Netherlands, Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam. Wilthagen, T. & Rogowski, R. (2002) “Legal Regulation of Transitional Labour Markets” in Schmid, G. & Gazier, B. (eds) The Dynamics of Full Employment: Social Integration through Transitional Labour Markets, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham: 233~273. Wilthagen, T. & Tros, F. (2004) “The concept of ‘flexicurity’: a new approach to regulating employment in the labour market.” Transfer-European Review of Labour and Research. Vol.10 No.2: 166~186. World Bank (2005) “Special Topic: Labour Taxes and Employment in the EU8” World Bank EU-8 Quarterly Economic Report April, 2004 Part II. http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTSLOVAKIA/Resources/QERQ105SpecialTopic.doc (Searched July, 2005) Yoo, G.S., Kim,B.S., Sung, J.M. (2003) 실업급여 수급자의 특성과 재취업 행태, Study report 2003-02. Korea Labour Institute, Seoul.