Benefits of U.S. organic agriculture

Lohr, Luanne (2002): Benefits of U.S. organic agriculture.

Abstract

This case study reviews the economic, social, and environmental benefits associated with organic agriculture in the U.S. These benefits include measurable impacts and unmeasurable impacts that affect both agricultural and consumer systems in fundamental ways. Both are discussed in this study. Measurable impacts are quantified in two ways – by comparing characteristics of organic and conventional farmers and by comparing indicators of benefits in counties with organic farms and counties without. Statistical differences in counties with and without organic farms are strong evidence that organic farms need not be numerous to generate benefits. There were 1,208 counties containing 4,868 organic farms in the U.S. in 1997, the last year for which location data are available. Findings of measurable impacts include: • Organic farmers are more likely to be female, hold a college degree, and be full-time farmers. The average organic farmer is 7 years younger than the average U.S. farmer. • Retail price premiums for organic foods average 10% to 30% higher than conventional. Farm price premiums are 70% to 250% more than what conventional farmers receive. • Counties with organic farms have stronger farm economies and contribute more to local economies through total sales, net revenue, farm value, taxes paid, payroll, and purchases of fertilizer, seed, and repair and maintenance services. • Counties with organic farms have more committed farmers and give more support to rural development with higher percentages of resident full-time farmers, greater direct to consumer sales, more workers hired, and higher worker pay. • Counties with organic farms provide more bird and wildlife habitat and have lower insecticide and nematicide use. • Watersheds with organic farms and have reduced agricultural impact and lower runoff risk from nitrogen and sediment. Findings of unmeasurable impacts include: • Organic farming under current standards avoids social and economic costs such as pesticide poisonings and costs of testing for genetically engineered foods. • The market in organic foods is more efficient than for conventional foods, because prices reflect more of the cost of producing socially desirable outputs, such as clean water, as a byproduct of food production activities. This reduces the need for government intervention through taxes or subsidies to obtain these benefits. • Innovation and openness to new ideas are necessary for growth in knowledge-based organic systems, and result in rapid development and dissemination of information on nonchemical production methods that benefit all farmers. Overall, the findings of this study are surprising in the strength of support for the hypothesis that organic farming produces more benefits than conventional farming. Nearly every indicator tested across the range of economic, social, and environmental benefits favors organic systems. Even though organic farmers are not a large percentage of the total number of U.S. farmers, their influence is felt through their innovation of management techniques and leadership in meeting the organic standards.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: organic farming; water quality; employment; tax base; farm value; input purchase; t-test
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q0 - General

References

Bertramsen, S.K., and T. L. Dobbs, Comparison of prices for ‘organic’ and ‘conventional’ grains and soybeans in the northern Great Plains and upper Midwest: 1995 to 2000, Economics pamphlet 2001-1, South Dakota State University, Brookings, SD.

Colla, G., J.P. Mitchell, D.D. Poudel, and S.R. Temple, Changes in tomato yield and fruit elemental composition in conventional, low input, and organic systems, Journal of Sustainable Agriculture, 20(2002):53-67.

Cook, R.L. Marketing organic commodities in California: structure and obstacles to expansion, staff paper, Department of Agricultural Economics, University of California, Davis, CA, 1988.

Dmitri, C., and C. Greene, Recent Growth Patterns in the U.S. Organic Food Market, ERS AIB 777, USDA Economic Research Service, Washington, DC, September 2002.

Duram, L.A., Factors in organic farmers’ decisionmaking: diversity, challenge, and obstacles, American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 14(1999):2-10.

Estes, E.A., T. Kleese, L. Lauffer, D. Treadwell, and R. Burton, An overview of the North Carolina organic industry, ARE Report No. 17, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC, 1999.

Egri, C.P. Attitudes, backgrounds and information preferences of Canadian organic farmers and conventional farmers: implications for organic farming advocacy and extension. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture, 13(1999):45-72.

Fjelkner-Modig, S., H. Bengtsson, R. Stegmark, and S. Nystr`m, The influence of organic and integrated production on nuritional, sensory and agricultural aspects of vegetable raw materials for food production, Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Sect. B Soil and Plant Sciences 50(2000):102-113.

General Accounting Office, Pesticides on Farms: Limited Capability Exists to Monitor Occupational Illness and Injuries. Report to the Chairman, Agriculture, Forestry and Nutrition, U.S. Senate. Washington, DC, 1993.

Greene, C. U.S. Organic Farming Emerges in the 1990s: Adoption of Certified Systems, ERS AIB 770, USDA Economic Research Service, Washington, DC, June 2001.

HealthFocus, Inc., What Do Consumers Want From Organics? Des Moines, IA, 1999.

Hoppe, R.A., J. Johnson, J.E. Perry, P. Korb, J.E. Sommer, J.T. Ryan, R.C. Green, R. Durst, and J. Monke, Structural and Financial Characteristics of U.S. Farms: 2001 Family Farm Report, ERS AIB 768, USDA Economic Research Service, Washington, DC, May 2001.

Johnson, D.H., Grassland bird use of Conservation Reserve Program fFields in the northern Great Plains, In: A Comprehensive Review of Farm Bill Contributions to Wildlife Conservation 1985-2000, W.L. Hohman and D. J. Halloum (eds.), Technical Report USDA/NRCS/WHMI-2000, Washington, DC, 2000.

Kevan, P.G., E.A. Clark, and V. G. Thomas, Insect pollinators and sustainable agriculture, American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 5(1990):13-23.

Lasley, P., E. Hoiberg, and G. Bultena, Is sustainable agriculture an elixir for rural communities? American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 8(1993):133-139.

Lohr, L. Factors affecting international demand and trade in organic food products, In: Changing Structure of Global Food Consumption and Trade, ERS WRS No. 01-1, A. Regmi (ed.), USDA Economic Research Service, Washington, DC, May 2001, 67-79.

Lohr, L., and A. Semali, Reconciling attitudes and behavior in organic food retailing, FS 00-08, University of Georgia, Agricultural and Applied Economics, Athens, GA, 2000.

Lohr, L. Consumer welfare effects of ecolabel proliferation: too much of a good thing? Proceedings of 1999 Food and Agricultural Marketing Consortium, Alexandria, VA, January 1999, unpaged.

Lohr, L., Y. Gonzalez-Alvarez, A. Graf, Predicting organic market development with spatial analysis of existing industry information, FS 01-15, University of Georgia, Agricultural and Applied Economics, Athens, GA, October 2001.

Lokemoen, J.T., and J. A. Beiser, Bird use and nesting in conventional, minimum-tillage, and organic cropland, Journal of Wildlife Management, 61(1997):644-655.

Mahoney, P.R., K.D. Olson, P.M. Porter, D.R. Huggins, C.A. Perrilo, and K. Crookston, Risk analysis of organic cropping systems in Minnesota, Dept. of Applied Economics, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN, 2001.

Norman, D., L. Bloomquist, R. Janke, S. Freyenberger, J. Jost, B. Schurle, and H. Kok, The meaning of sustainable agriculture: reflections of some Kansas practitioners, American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 15(2000):129-136.

Reganold, J.P., J.D. Glover, P.K. Andrews, and H.R. Hinman, Sustainability of three apple production systems, Nature 410(2001):926-930.

Reigart, J.R., and J.R. Roberts, Recognition and Management of Pesticide Poisonings, EPA #735-R-98-003, Office of Pesticide Programs, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, 1999.

Rigby, R. P. Woodhouse, T. Young, and M. Burton, Constructing a farm level indicator of sustainable agriculture practice, Ecological Economics, 39(2001):463-478.

Reynolds, R.E. Waterfowl responses to the Conservation Reserve Program in the northern Great Plains, In: A Comprehensive Review of Farm Bill Contributions to Wildlife Conservation 1985-2000, W.L. Hohman and D. J. Halloum (eds.), Technical Report USDA/NRCS/WHMI-2000, Washington, DC, 2000, 35-44.

Roper ASW, Taking Control and Taking Care – The Role of Organic Food and Beverages in the Lifestyles of American. Roper Number: C205-007497. Prepared for Walnut Acres and PT and Co., 2002.

Stolze, M., A. Piorr, A. Haring, S. Dabbert, The Environmental Impacts of Organic Farming in Europe, Organic Farming in Europe: Economics and Policy, Volume 6, Stuttgart, Germany, University of Hohenheim, 2000.

The Packer, Fresh Trends 2000, Vance Publishing Corp., Lenaxa, KS, 2000.

U.S. Department of Agriculture, Report and Recommendations on Organic Farming, Washington, DC, 1980.

U.S. Department of Agriculture, Ag97 Census of Agriculture CD-ROM, Version 1.1.24, National Agricultural Statistics Service, Washington, DC, 1997.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Index of Agricultural Runoff Potential (Based Upon Nitrogen, Sediment and Pesticide) (1990-1995), IWI Version 1.2, Entry ID 1754, Washington, DC, August 2002.

Vogtmann, H., M. Zehr, K.-H. Simon, Agriculture and climate, In: New Research in Organic Agriculture – Down to Earth and Further Afield, Volume 2, N. H. Kristensen and H Hrgh-Jensen (eds.), IFOAM, Tholey-Theley, Germany, 1996, 200-207.

Walz, E., Final Results of the Third Biennial National Organic Farmers’ Survey, Santa Cruz, CA, Organic Farming Research Foundation, 1999.

Welsh, R. The Economics of Organic Grain and Soybean Production in the Midwestern United States, Policy Studies Report 13, Henry A. Wallace Institute for Alternative Agriculture, Greenbelt, MD, May 1999.

Werner, M.R., and D.L. Dindal, Effects of conversion to organic agricultural practices on soil biota, American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 5(1990):24-32.

Woese, K., D. Lange, C. Boess, and K.W. B`gl, A comparison of organically and conventionally grown foods – results of a review of the relevant literature, Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 74(1997):281-293.

Worthington, V., Nutritional quality of organic versus conventional fruits, vegetables, and grains, Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 7(2001):161-174.