Profiles and Transitions of Groups at Risk of Social Exclusion: Lone Parents

Kapsalis, Constantine and Tourigny, Pierre (2002): Profiles and Transitions of Groups at Risk of Social Exclusion: Lone Parents. Published in: (November 2002)

Abstract

This study attempts to answer the following basic question: why do some lone parents escape low income or never enter spells of low income or social assistance (SA), while others remain in low income or on SA for many years? The analysis relies on the 1993-98 longitudinal panel of the Survey of Labour and Income Dynamics (SLID). The main focus is lone mothers, since they account for 93% of low income lone parents.

The results make somewhat of a case for investing more in education. However, this is not conclusive. Many lone mothers who are in low income or SA recipients have a post-secondary certification. Also, a higher level of education does not seem to have any benefits in terms of shortening SA spells.

The fact that half of new SA recipients exit within the first two years suggest that policies should be well targeted. However, waiting for several years to ascertain who are long term recipients is not the best targeting strategy. Not only is valuable time wasted, but there is evidence that the longer individuals stay on SA, the more difficult it is to exit.

A better strategy is to keep probing the characteristics of SA recipients that are associated with long spells and develop programs that are targeted to those characteristics. And since lack of paid work or limited attachment to paid work are common factors among the low income and SA recipients, the main focus should be on providing employment services (such as referrals and employment counseling), coupled with a more generous treatment of earnings under SA and wage subsidies to those able to work a significant number of paid hours.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: lone mothers; welfare; social assistance
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty

References

Allen, Douglas (1993). "Welfare and the Family: The Canadian Experience." Journal of Labour Economics, 11 (1): S201-223.

Brown, David (1995). "Welfare Caseload Trends in Canada" in Helping the Poor – A Qualified Case for 'Workfare', edited by John Richards and William G. Watson, C. D. Howe Institute, The Social Policy Challenge No. 5, pp. 37-81.

Charette, Michael and Ronald Meng (1994). "The Determinants of Welfare Participation of Female Heads of Household in Canada." Canadian Journal of Economics, Vol. XXVII, No. 2, pp. 290-306.

Corak, Miles and Andrew Heisz (1995). The Duration of Unemployment: A User Guide. Statistics Canada, Business and Labour Market Analysis, Research Paper No. 84.

Dooley, Martin (1994). "Women, Children and Low Income in Canada." Canadian Public Policy, Volume XX, 4, pp. 430-443.

Dooley, Martin (1995). "Lone Mother Families and Social Assistance Policy in Canada" in Family Matters - New Policies for Divorce, Lone Mothers, and Child Low income. C. D. Howe Institute, The Social Policy Challenge, No. 8.

Finnie, Ross (2000). Low Income (Poverty) Dynamics in Canada: Entry, Exit, Spell Durations, and Total Time. Applied Research Branch, Human Resources Development Canada, W-00-7E.

Gascon, Stephane (2000). Potential Market Income and Poverty in Canada, 1986-1996. Applied Research Branch, Human Resources Development Canada, W-00-5E.

Hatfield, Michael (1997): Concentrations of Poverty and Distressed Neighbourhoods in Canada. Applied Research Branch, Human Resources Development Canada, W-97-1E. Hatfield, Michael (2001a): Low income and Exclusion Among the Working-Age Population. Applied Research Branch, Human Resources Development Canada, slide presentation.

Hatfield, Michael (2001b): The Barriers to Social Inclusion: The Lens of Long-Term Low Income. Applied Research Branch, Human Resources Develoment Canada, presented at the "A New Way of Thinking Conference," November 9, 2001.

Kapsalis, Constantine (1997). Social Assistance and the Employment Rate of Lone Mothers: An Analysis of Ontario's Live Experiment. Applied Research Branch, HRDC, W-97-7E.

Kapsalis, Constantine (1998). The Connection Between Literacy and Work: Implications for Social Assistance Recipients. Applied Research Branch, Human Resources Development Canada , W-98-1E.

Kapsalis, Constantine (2001). An Assessment of EI and SA Reporting in SLID. Statistics Canada, Analytical Studies Branch, Research Paper Series, No. 1F0019MPE01166.

Lacroix, Guy (2000a). The Dynamics of Welfare Participation in Newfoundland: 1986-98. Applied Research Branch, Human Resources Development Canada, W-00-6E.

Lacroix, Guy (2000b). "Reforming the Welfare System: In Search of the Optimal Policy Mix." In Adapting Public Policy, edited by Craig Riddell and Frances St-Hilaire, The Institute for Research in Public Policy.

Morisset, Rene and Xuelin Zhang (2001). "Experiencing low income for several years", in Perspectives on Income and Labour, Statistics Canada, Catalogue No. 75-001-X1E (March) Vol 4, no.3.

National Council of Welfare (2000). Poverty Profiles 1998. Volume #113 (Autumn).

OECD (2001). "When money is tight: Poverty dynamics in OECD countries", in Employment Outlook (Chapter 2).

Picot,G, M. Zyblock and W. Pyper (1999) Why Do Children Move Into and Out of Low Income: Changing Labour Market Conditions or Marriage and Divorce? Statistics Canada, Analytical Studies Branch, Research Paper Series, 11F0019MIE, no.132.

Statistics Canada (1999). Low income measures, low income after tax cut-offs and low income after tax measure. Catalogue No. 13F0019XIB.