An empirical analysis of the counterfactual: a merger and divestiture in the Australian cigarette industry

Pham, Vivienne and Prentice, David (2010): An empirical analysis of the counterfactual: a merger and divestiture in the Australian cigarette industry.

Abstract

In this paper we empirically analyse two counterfactual situations facing an anti-trust authority following the merger of two of the largest international cigarette companies. First we estimate a nested logit model of demand for cigarettes. The implied elasticity of demand for smoking and implied marginal costs are both broadly consistent with the limited independent estimates available. We then use the model to simulate the proposed merger and the partial divestiture that was accepted by the Australian anti-trust authority. A comparison of the relative price changes predicted by the divestiture simulation with the actual post-divestiture price changes shows the model successfully anticipated the behaviour of the divested brands. This suggests structural econometric analysis using a nested logit may be usefully utilised by anti-trust authorities to assess the welfare implications of proposed mergers and partial divestitures.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: mergers; divestitures; simulation; cigarettes; anti-trust policy; competition policy
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L13 - Oligopoly and Other Imperfect Markets; L - Industrial Organization > L4 - Antitrust Issues and Policies > L41 - Monopolization ; Horizontal Anticompetitive Practices; L - Industrial Organization > L6 - Industry Studies: Manufacturing > L66 - Food ; Beverages ; Cosmetics ; Tobacco ; Wine and Spirits

References

Ackerberg, Daniel, C. Lanier Benkard, Steven Berry and Ariel Pakes. 2007. "Econometric Tools for Analyzing Market Outcomes." In Handbook of Econometrics, vol. 6 part 1., 4171-4276, edited by James J. Heckman and Edward E. Leamer. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

Ackerberg, Daniel A. and Marc Rysman. 2005. "Unobserved Product Differentiation in Discrete-Choice Models: Estimating Price Elasticities and Welfare Eects." RAND Journal of Economics, 36(4), 771-788.

Aguirregabiria, Victor and Aviv Nevo. 2010. "Recent Developments in Empirical Dynamic Models of Demand and Competition in Oligopoly Markets." Unpublished manuscript. July.

Anderson, Simon P., Andre De Palma and Jacques-Francois Thisse. 1992. Discrete Choice Theory of Product Differentiation. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. 19 September 1996. "Prices surveillance reform welcomed." http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/86817/fromItemId/378002 [accessed on 13 November 2010].

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. 31 March 1999. "ACCC opposes cigarettes merger." http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/322870/fromItemId/378008 [accessed on 29 October 2010].

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. 3 June 1999. "ACCC accepts cigarettes divestiture." http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/322820/fromItemId/378008 [accessed on 29 October 2010].

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. 14 July 1999. "ACCC launches comprehensive GST surveillance." http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/322961/fromItemId/378008 [accessed on 6 November 2010]

Bardsley, Peter and Nilss Olekalns. 1999. "Cigarette and Tobacco Consumption: Have Anti-Smoking Policies Made a Difference?" Economic Record, 75(230), 225-240.

Beriot, M. C. 1993. Tobacco prices, taxes and consumption in Australia. Carlton South: Victorian Smoking and Health Program.

Berry, Steven T. 1994. "Estimating Discrete-Choice Models of Product Differentiation." Rand Journal of Economics, 25(2), 242-262.

Berry, Steven T., James Levinsohn and Ariel Pakes. 1995. "Automobile Prices in Market Equilibrium." Econometrica, 63(4), 841-890.

Brandt, Allan M. 2007. The cigarette century: the rise, fall and deadly persistence of the product that defined America. New York NY: Basic Books.

British American Tobacco Co. 20 October 1999. Overview of Philip Morris' Marketing Strategy. Bates no. 500098281. http://old.tobacco.health.usyd.edu.au/site/gateway/docs/advsearch.htm [accessed on 25 March 2010].

British American Tobacco Australia. 2000. "The new tax system public compliance commitment." http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/6043 [accessed on November 6, 2010].

Budzinski, Oliver and Isabel Ruhmer. 2010. "Merger Simulation in Competition Policy: A Survey." Journal of Competition Law and Economics, 6(2), 277-319.

Cardell, Scott N. 1997. "Variance Components Structures for the Extreme-Value and Logistic Distributions with Application to Models of Heterogeneity." Econometric Theory, 13(2), 185-213.

Chiou, Lesley. 2008. "The timing of movie releases: Evidence from the home video industry." International Journal of Industrial Organization, 26(5), 1059-1073.

Costello, Peter. 1998. "Tax reform, not a new tax, a new tax system." AGPS, November, 1998.

Costello, Peter. 2000. "Excise Tariff Amendment Bill (No. 1), Explanatory Memorandum." http:www.comlaw.gov.au[accessed November 6, 2010].

Dube, Jean-Pierre, Jeremy Fox and Che-Lin Su. 2009. "Improving the Numerical Performance of BLP Static and Dynamic Discrete Choice Random Coefficients Demand Estimation." Working Paper No. 14991. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Mass.

Einav, Liran. 2007. "Seasonality in the U.S. motion picture industry." RAND Journal of Economics, 38(1), 127-145.

Hendel, Igal. 1999. "Estimating Multiple Discrete Choice Models: An Application to Computerization Returns." Review of Economic Studies, 66(2), 423-446.

Hill, David J. and Victoria M. White. 1995. "Australian Adult Smoking Prevalence in 1992." Australian Journal of Public Health, 19(3), 305-308.

Hirji, T. 12 May 1984. Value-for-Money Marketing Brand Development Course, Egham, Surrey, 29th April-12th May 1984 [includes WD & HO Wills (Australia) Limited presentation] Bates no. 102245184/102245197. http://old.tobacco.health.usyd.edu.au/site/gateway/docs/advsearch.htm [accessed on 2 May 2007].

Huang, Dongling, Christian Rojas and Frank Bass. 2008. "What happens when demand is estimated with a misspecified model?" Journal of Industrial Economics, 56(4), 809-839.

Imperial Tobacco Australia. no date. "Public Compliance Commitment." http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/6043 [accessed on 6 November 2010].

Imperial Tobacco Group. 1999. "Australian acquisition." http://imperial-tobacco.com [accessed on 12 December 2009].

Jayaratne, Jith and Carl Shapiro. 2000. "Simulating Partial Asset Divestitures to 'Fix' Mergers." International Journal of the Economics of Business, 7(2), 179-200.

Keane, Michael P. 2010. "Structural vs. atheoretic approaches to econometrics." Journal of Econometrics, 156(1), 3-20.

King, Stephen. 2005. "The use of empirical methods in merger investigations." http://www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/693299/year/2005 [accessed December 29, 2009].

Knittel, Christopher R. and Konstantinos Metaxoglou. 2008. "Estimation of Random Coefficient Demand Models: Challenges, Difficulties and Warnings." Working Paper No. 14080. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Mass.

Mueller, Willard F. and George W. Stocking. 1955. "The Cellophane Case and the New Competition." American Economic Review, 45(1), 29-63.

Nevo, Aviv. 2000. "Mergers with Differentiated Products: the Case of the Ready-to-Eat Cereal Industry." RAND Journal of Economics, 31(3), 395-421.

Nevo, Aviv. 2001. "Measuring Market Power in the Ready-to-Eat Cereal Industry." Econometrica,69(2), 307-342.

Nieuwenhuysen, John P. and Neville R. Norman. 1976. Australian competition and prices policy: trade practices, tariffs, and prices justification. London: Croom Helm.

Peters, Craig. 2006. "Evaluating the Performance of Merger Simulation: Evidence from the U.S. Airline Industry." Journal of Law and Economics, 49(2), 627-649.

Philip Morris. October 3 1990. 1991 original budget: Marketing Presentation October 3, 1990. Bates No. 2504107139A/2504107171. http://old.tobacco.health.usyd.edu.au/site/gateway/docs/advsearch.htm [accessed on 25 March 2010].

Philip Morris USA. March 1990. Value segment synopsis: the Australian market. Bates No. 2048568608/2048568613. http://old.tobacco.health.usyd.edu.au/site/gateway/docs/advsearch.htm [accessed on 25 September 2007].

Poskitt, D. S. and C. L. Skeels. 2009. \Assessing the magnitude of the concentration parameter in a simultaneous equations model." Econometrics Journal 12, 26-44.

Prices Justification Tribunal. 1974-1975. Annual Report. Canberra: Prices Justification Tribunal.

Prices Surveillance Authority. 26 November 1985. Inquiry in Relation to the Supply of Cigarettes, matter number PI/85/2. Canberra: Prices Surveillance Authority.

Prices Surveillance Authority. 5 September 1994. Inquiry into the Cigarettes Declaration. Matter No: PI/94/1, Report No. 52. Canberra: Prices Surveillance Authority.

PriceWaterhouseCoopers. 2005. "Research Report on the Illegal Tobacco Market." PriceWaterhouseCoopers.

Richards, Timothy R. 2007. "A Nested Logit Model of Strategic Promotion." Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 5(1), 63-91.

Scollo, Michelle, Tim Owen and Jason Boulter. 2000. "Price discounting of cigarettes during the National Tobacco Campaign." 155-200 in Australia's National Tobacco Campaign. Evaluation Report Volume Two. Canberra: Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care.

Scollo, M., S. Younie, J. Wakeeld, J. Freeman and F. Iscasiano. 2003. "Impact of tobacco tax reforms on tobacco prices and tobacco use in Australia." Tobacco Control, 12(Suppl II):ii59-ii66.

Scollo, Michelle, Ron Borland and World Health Organization. 2004. Taxation reform as a com- ponent of tobacco control policy in Australia. UC San Francisco: Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education. http://www.escholarship.org/uc/item/95t699r7. Shiffman, Saul. 1989. "Tobaco "chippers" individual differences in tobacco dependence." Psychopharmacology, 97(4), 539-547.

Tauras, John A., Richard M. Peck and Frank J. Chaloupka. 2006. "The Role of Retail Prices and Promotions in Determining Cigarette Brand Market Shares." Review of Industrial Organization, 28(3), 253-284.

Tenn, Steven and John M. Yun. Forthcoming. "The Success of Divestitures in Merger Enforcement: Evidence from the J&J - Pfizer Transaction." International Journal of Industrial Organization.

Walker, Robin. 1984. Under fire: A History of Tobacco Smoking in Australia. Victoria: Melbourne University Press.

WD & HO Wills (Australia) Limited, undated, Value for money marketing in Australia. Bates no. 621707306/621707370. http://old.tobacco.health.usyd.edu.au/site/gateway/docs/advsearch.htm [accessed on 25 March 2010].

WD & HO Wills (Australia) Limited. 1992. Wills Australia: Marketing Strategic Plan Synopsis 1993-1997. Bates no. 500245407/500245418. http://old.tobacco.health.usyd.edu.au/site/gateway/docs/advsearch.htm [accessed on 25 March 2010].

Winstanley, Margaret, Stephen Woodward and Noni Walker. 1995. Tobacco in Australia: Facts and Issues 1995. Victoria: Victorian Smoking and Health Program. Second Edition.