Mixed Feelings: Theories and Evidence of Warm Glow and Altruism

Konow, James (2006): Mixed Feelings: Theories and Evidence of Warm Glow and Altruism.

Abstract

This paper presents theoretical and empirical analyses of experiments that test competing theories of altruism, including pure altruism (a preference for the well-being of others), warm glow (a good feeling from giving) and impure altruism (a combination of pure altruism and warm glow). These theories produce different predictions regarding crowding out, i.e., the reduction in private donations due to public spending. Variations on dictator experiments involving both students and charities examine the incidence of crowding out and provide a new direct measure of the effect of giving on feelings. The results indicate that crowding out is incomplete, i.e., less than dollar for dollar. The evidence on warm glow suggests mixed feelings: giving may be associated with good or bad feelings, depending on the context. As a way to resolve apparent inconsistencies and reconcile the evidence on crowding out and feelings, this paper proposes a theory of conditional altruism, which extends previous models to incorporate social norms that arise in the workplace, marketplace and laboratory.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: Loyola Marymount University
• Language: English
• Keywords: Altruism; Warm-Glow; Happiness; Efficiency; Fairness; Justice; Need
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D64 - Altruism ; Philanthropy; D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D63 - Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement

References

Abrams, B.A., and Schmitz, M.A. (1978). "The Crowding Out Effect of Government Transfers on Private Charitable Contributions," Public Choice 33, 29-39. Andreoni, James (1989). "Giving with Impure Altruism: Applications to Charity and Ricardian Equivalence," Journal of Political Economy, 97(6), 1447-1458. ---------- (1990). "Impure Altruism and Donations to Public Goods: A Theory of Warm-Glow Giving," Economic Journal, June 1990, 100, 464-477. ---------- (1993). "An Experimental Test of the Public Goods Crowding-Out Hypothesis," American Economic Review, 83(5), 1317-1327. ---------- (1995). "Cooperation in Public-Goods Experiments: Kindness or Confusion?" American Economic Review, 85(4), 891-904. ---------- (forthcoming). "Philanthropy," in the Handbook on the Economics of Giving, Reciprocity and Altruism, edited by Gerard-Varet, L.-A., Kolm, S-C., and Ythier, J. Mercier, Elsevier/North Holland. ---------- and Miller, John H. (2002). "Giving according to GARP: An Experimental Test of the Consistency of Preferences for Altruism." Econometrica 70:2, 737-753. ----------, and Payne, A. Abigail, "Do Government Grants to Private Charities Crowd Out Giving or Fuind-raising?" American Economic Review, 93(3), 2003, 792-812. Babcock, Linda, George Loewenstein, Samuel Issacharoff, and Colin Camerer (1995)."Biased Judgments of Fairness in Bargaining." American Economic Review 85:5, pp. 1337-43. Batson, C. Daniel (1987)."Prosocial Motivation: Is It Ever Truly Altruistic?" Advances in Experimental and Social Psychology, 20, 65-122. ---------- (1997a). "Self-Other Merging and the Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis: Reply to Neuberg et al. (1997)," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 517-522. ----------, et al. (1988). "Five Studies Testing Two New Egoistic Alternatives to the Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 55(1), 52-77. ----------, et al. (1997b). "Is Empathy-Induced Helping Due to Self-Other Merging?" Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 495-509. Becker, Gary S. (1974). "A Theory of Social Interactions," Journal of Political Economy, 82, November/December, 1063-1093. Bergstrom, Theodore C., Blume, Lawrence E., and Varian, Hal R. (1986). "On the Private Provision of Public Goods," American Economic Review, 29, 789-793. Bolton, Gary E. and Katok, Elena (1998). "An Experimental Test of the Crowding Out Hypothesis: The Nature of Beneficent Behavior," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 37(3), 315-331. Bosman, Ronald and van Winden, Frans (2002). "Emotional Hazard in a Power to Take Experiment," The Economic Journal, 112(476), January, 147-169. Buchanan, Laurie, Eckel, Catherine C. and Grossman, Philip J. (2000). "To Give or not to Give: Effects of Altruism and Recognition on Philanthropic Gifts," mimeo. Charness, Gary and Grosskopf, Brit (2001). "Relative Payoffs and Happiness: An Experimental Study," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 45(3), 301-328. —, and Matthew Rabin (2002). "Understanding Social Preferences with Simple Tests." Quarterly Journal of Economics 117:3, 817-869. Cialdini, Robert B., et al. (1997). "Reinterpreting the Empathy-Altruism Relationship: When One Into One Equals Oneness," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 481-494. Clark, Andrew E. and Oswald, Andrew J. (1994). "Unhappiness and Unemployment," Economic Journal, May, 104, 648-659. Croson, Rachel, and Konow, James (2007)."Double Standards: Social Preferences and Moral Biases," manuscript. Dana, Jason, Weber, Roberto A., and Kuang, Jason Xi (2004). "Exploiting Moral Wiggle Room: Behavior Inconsistent with a Preference for Fair Outcomes" manuscript, Carnegie Mellon University. Di Tella, Rafael, MacCulloch, Robert, and Oswald, Andrew (2001). "Preferences over Inflation and Unemployment: Evidence from Surveys of Happiness," American Economic Review, 91(1), 335-341. Di Tella, Rafael, and MacCulloch, Robert (2006). "Some Uses of Happiness Data in Economics," Journal of Economic Perspectives, 20(1), 25-46. Diener, Ed, Suh, Eunkook M., Lucas, Richard E. and Smith, Heidi L. (1999). "Subjective Well-Being: Three Decades of Progress," Psychological Bulletin, 125(2), March, 276-302. Easterlin, Richard A. (1974). "Does Economic Growth Improve the Human Lot? Some Empirical Evidence," in Paul A. David and Melvin W. Reder, eds., Nations and Households in Economic Growth: Essays in Honor of Moses Abramovitz, New York and London: Academic Press, 89-125. Eckel, Catherine C. and Grossman, Philip J. (1996). "Altruism in Anonymous Dictator Games," Games and Economic Behavior, 16, 181-191. ---------- (2000). "Volunteers and Pseudo-Volunteers: The Effect of Recruitment Method in Dictator Experiments," Experimental Economics, 3 (2), October, 107-120. ---------- and Johnston, Rachel M. (2005). "An Experimental Test of the Crowding Out Hypothesis," Journal of Public Economics, 89 (8), August, 1543-1560. Fehr, Ernst and Gächter, Simon (2000). "Fairness and Retaliation: The Economics of Reciprocity," Journal of Economic Perspectives, 14(3), Summer, 159-181. Fehr, Ernst, and Schmidt, Klaus M. (1999). "A Theory of Fairness, Competition and Cooperation," Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114(3), 817-868. Frey, Bruno and Stutzer, Alois (2002a). Happiness & Economics, Princeton: Princeton University Press. ---------- (2002b). "What Can Economists Learn from Happiness Research?" Journal of Economic Literature, 40(2), 402-435. Frohlich, Norman, and Joe A. Oppenheimer (1992). Choosing Justice: An Experimental Approach to Ethical Theory. Berkeley; Los Angeles: University of California Press. Gächter, Simon and Fehr, Ernst (1999). "Collective Action as a Social Exchange," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 39(4), 341-369. Goeree, Jacob K., Holt, Charles A. and Laury, Susan K. (2002). "Private Costs and Public Benefits: Unraveling the Effects of Altruism and Noisy Behavior," Journal of Public Economics, 83, 255-276. Gruber, Jonathan H., and Mullainathan, Sendhil (2005). “Do Cigarette Taxes Make Smokers Happier?” Advances in Economic Analysis & Policy, 5(1), Article 4. Harbaugh, William (1998). "What Do Donations Buy?: A Model of Philanthropy Based on Prestige and Warm Glow," Journal of Public Economics, 67, 269-284. Hoffman, Elizabeth, and Matthew L. Spitzer (1985). "Entitlements, Rights, and Fairness: An Experimental Examination of Subjects' Concepts of Distributive Justice." Journal of Legal Studies 14, 259-97. Holm, Håkan, and Peter Engseld (2005). "Choosing Bargaining Partners: An Experimental Study on the Impact of Information on Income, Status and Gender," Experimental Economics, 8(3), 183-216. Kingma, Bruce (1989). "An Accurate Measure of the Crowd-Out Effect, Income Effect, and Price Effect for Charitable Contributions," Journal of Political Economy, 97, 1197-1207. Kirchsteiger, Georg, Rigotti, Luca, and Rustichini, Aldo (2006). "Your Morals Might Be Your Moods," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 59(2), 155-172. Konow, James (2000). "Fair Shares: Accountability and Cognitive Dissonance in Allocation Decisions," American Economic Review, vol. 90, no. 4 (September), pp. 1072-1091. ---------- (2003). "Which is the Fairest One of All?: A Positive Analysis of Justice Theories," Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 41, no. 4 (December), pp. 1186-1237. ----------, and Earley, Joseph (2007). "The Hedonistic Paradox: Is Homo Economicus Happier?" revised and resubmitted to the Journal of Public Economics. ----------, Saijo, Tatuyoshi, and Akai, Kenju (2007). "Morals versus Mores: Experimental Evidence from the US and Japan," unpublished results. Kravitz, David A., and Samuel Gunto (1992). "Decisions and Perceptions of Recipients in Ultimatum Bargaining Games." Journal of Socio-Economics 21:1, 65-84. Kritikos, Alexander, and Friedel Bolle (2001). "Distributional Concerns: Equity- or Efficiency-oriented?" Economic Letters 73:3, 333-338. McGranahan, Leslie Moscow (2000). "Charity and the Bequest Motive: Evidence from Seventeenth-Century Wills," Journal of Political Economy, 108(6), December, 1270-1291. Neuberg, Steven L., et al. (1997). "Does Empathy Lead to Anything More Than Superficial Helping? Comment on Batson et al. (1997)," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73(3), 510-516. Novemsky, Nathan and Kahneman, Daniel (2005). "The Boundaries of Loss Aversion," Journal of Marketing Research, 42(2), 119-128. Ng, Yew-Kwang (1978). "Economic Growth and Social Welfare: The Need for a Complete Study of Happiness," Kyklos, 31(4), 575-587. Palfrey, Thomas R., and Prisbrey, Jeffrey E. (1996). "Altruism, Reputation and Noise in Linear Public Goods Experiments," Journal of Public Economics, 61(3), 409-427. ---------- (1997). "Anomalous Behavior in Public Goods Experiments: How Much and Why?" American Economic Review, 87(5), 829-847. Payne, A. Abigail (1998). "Does the Government Crowd Out Private Donations?: New Evidence from a Sample of Nonprofit Firms," Journal of Public Economics, 69(3), 323-345. Rabin, Matthew (1994). "Cognitive Dissonance and Social Change," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 23, 177-194. Rege, Mari and Telle, Kjetil (2004). "The Impact of Social Approval and Framing on Cooperation in Public Good Situations," Journal of Public Economics, 88(7-8), 1625-1644. Ribar, David and Wilhelm, Mark O. (2002). “Altruistic and Joy-of-Giving Motivations in Charitable Behavior,” Journal of Political Economy, 110(2), 425-457. Smith, Tom W. (1979). "Happiness: Time Trends, Seasonal Variations, Intersurvey Differences, and Other Mysteries," Social Psychology Quarterly, 42(1), 18-30. Thaler, Richard H. (1980). "Toward a Positive Theory of Consumer Choice," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 1, 39-60. van Praag, Bernard M.S. and Kapteyn, Arie (1973). "Further Evidence on the Individual Welfare Function of Income: An Empirical Investigation in the Netherlands," European Economic Review, 4, 33-62. Veenhoven, Ruut (1991). "Is Happiness Relative?" Social Indicators Research, 24, 1-34. Warr, Peter G. (1983). "The Private Provision of a Public Good Is Independent of the Distribution of Income" Economics Letters, 13, 207-211. Zizzo, Daniel John, and Oswald, Andrew (2001). “Are People Willing to Pay to Reduce Others' Incomes?,” Annales d'Economie et de Statistique v0, n63-64, July-Dec., 39-65.