Indian Capitalism: A Case that doesn’t Fit?

Mazumdar, Surajit (2010): Indian Capitalism: A Case that doesn’t Fit?

Abstract

Abstract: This paper critically examines the ‘Varieties of Capitalism’ (VoC) School’s approach to constructing typologies of capitalisms with reference to the specific case of Indian capitalism. It emphasizes that two factors related to its origin and initial emergence remain crucial for explaining many of the key and sometimes very specific outcomes being generated by the operation of Indian capitalism in its current stage. These factors are, firstly, that Indian capitalism was born out of the womb of capitalist colonialism, and secondly, that no thoroughgoing agrarian transformation happened in India before or after independence. These have strongly conditioned capitalist development in India after independence, first under a more statist and protectionist regime till 1991 and subsequently under a more open and market‐oriented policy in the era of globalization. The transformational impact of this development has been consequently limited, even in comparison to other late‐industrializing Asian capitalisms, and insufficient to transcend these factors. Yet changes have happened over time, which lie behind the break state economic policy made with the past in 1991. The paper argues that such a combination of continuity and change poses some vexing problems for the characterization of contemporary Indian capitalism as a particular variety.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Varieties of Capitalism; India; Third World
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P17 - Performance and Prospects; F - International Economics > F5 - International Relations, National Security, and International Political Economy > F54 - Colonialism ; Imperialism ; Postcolonialism; P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P16 - Political Economy

References

Alam, Ghayur (1985), ‘India's Technology Policy and Its Influence on Technology Imports and Technology Development’, Economic and Political Weekly 20 (45-47): 2073-80.

Amable, Bruno (2000) ‘Institutional complementarity and diversity of social systems of innovation and production’, Review of International Political Economy 7 (4): 645-687.

Amable, Bruno (2003) The Diversity of Modern Capitalism. New York: Oxford University Press.

Bagchi, A.K. (1980) Private investment in India: 1900-1939, Reprint of 1975 Indian Edition, New Delhi: Orient Longman (in association with Cambridge University Press).

Bagchi, Amiya Kumar and Nirmala Banerjee (ed.) (1981): Change and Choice in Indian Industry, Calcutta and New Delhi: K.P. Bagchi and Co.

Basant, Rakesh (2000) 'Corporate Response to Economic Reforms', Economic and Political Weekly 35(10): 813-22.

Berberoglu, Berch (ed.) (1992) Class, State and Development in India, New Delhi: Sage Publications.

Berger, S. and Dore, R., (eds) (1996) National diversity and global capitalism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Bettelheim, Charles (1977) India Independent (Translated from the French by W.A. Caswell), New Delhi: Khosla and Co.

Blyn, George (1966), Agricultural Trends in India, 1891-1947: Output, Availability, and Productivity, Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Blyth, M. (2003) “Same as it Never Was? Typology and Temporality in the Varieties of Capitalism,” Comparative European Politics 1 (2) Summer 2003 pp. 215-225

Boyer, R. (2000) "Is a Finance-Led Regime Growth a Viable Alternative to Fordism? A Preliminary Analysis." Economy and Society 29:111-145.

Boyer, Robert and Yves Saillard (eds.) (2002), Régulation Theory. The State of the Art, London/New York: Routledge.

Byres, Terence J. (ed.) (1994) The State and Development Planning in India. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Carney, Michael, Eric Gedajlovic and Xiaohua Yang (2009): Varieties of Capitalism: Towards and Institutional Theory of Asian Enterprise , Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 26 (3): 361-380.

Chakravarty, Sukhamoy (1987) Development Planning: The Indian Experience, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Chandrasekhar, C.P. and Jayati Ghosh (2002) The Market That Failed: Neoliberal Economic Reforms in India, Second Edition, New Delhi: Left Word Books.

Chaudhuri, Sudip (2008) ‘Ranbaxy Sell-out: Reversal of Fortunes’, Economic and Political Weekly 43(29): 11-13.

Chibber, Vivek (2004) Locked in Place: State Building and Late Industrialization in India, New Delhi: Tulika Books.

Crouch, C. (2005) Capitalist Diversity and Change. Recombinant Governance and Institutional Entrepreneurs, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

D’Costa, Anthony P. (2004), ‘The Indian Software Industry in the Global Division of Labor,’ in D’Costa, A.P. and Sridharan,E. (eds.) India in the Global Software Industry: Innovation, Firm Strategies and Development, Houndmills, Basingtoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 1-26.

Das, Nabagopal (1938): Industrial Enterprise in India, London: Oxford University Press.

Dore, R. 2000. Stock Market Capitalism: Welfare Capitalism: Japan and Germany versus the Anglo-Saxons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Dore, Ronald, William Lazonick and Mary O'Sullivan (1999) ‘Varieties of Capitalism in the Twentieth Century’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 15 (4): 102-20.

Encarnation, D.J. (1989) Dislodging Multinationals: India's Strategy in Comparative Perspective, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Evans, P. (1995) The Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.

Gourevitch, Peter, Michael Hawes (2001) ‘Political Institutions and National Production Systems in the Globalized Economy’, Paper prepared for the conference Business Interests and the Varieties of Capitalism: Historical Origins and Future Possibilities at The University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, November 2/3, 2001.

Hall, P. and D. Soskice (eds.) (2001) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hall, Peter A. and David Soskice (2003) ‘Varieties of Capitalism and Institutional Change: A Response to Three Critics’, Comparative European Politics 1: 241-250.

Hancké, B., Rhodes, M. and Thatcher, M. (eds.) (2007) Beyond Varieties of Capitalism: Conflict, Contradiction and Complementarities in the European Economy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hazari, R.K. (assisted by A.N. Oza) (1966) The Structure of the Private Corporate Sector, A Study of Concentration, Ownership and Control, Bombay: Asia Publishing House.

Hollingsworth, J.R. and Boyer, R. (eds.) (1997) Contemporary Capitalism: the Embeddedness of Institutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Howell, C. 2003. "Varieties of Capitalism: And Then There Was One?" Comparative Politics, 36:1: 103-124.

Jha, Ravinder (2007) ‘Options for Indian Pharmaceutical Industry in the Changing Environment’, Economic and Political Weekly 42(39): 3958-67

Joshi, P.C. (1975) ‘Agrarian Social Structure and Social Change’, in K. Mathew Kurian (ed.) (1975), India - State and Society: A Marxian Approach, Madras: Orient Longman.

Kang, Nahee (2006) ‘A Critique of the “Varieties of Capitalism” Approach’, No. 45-2006, Research Paper Series, International Centre for Corporate Social Responsibility, Nottingham University Business School

Khadria, Binod (1990) ‘Patents, Brain Drain and Higher Education: International Barriers to the Diffusion of Knowledge, Information and Technology’, Social Scientist, 18 (5): 3-18.

Kitschelt, H., Lange, P., Marks, G. and Stephens, J.D., (eds.) (1999), Continuity and Change in Contemporary Capitalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kochanek, Stanley A. (1974) Business and Politics in India. Berkley: University of California Press.

Kohli, Atul (2009a) 'Politics of Economic Growth in India, 1980-2005, Part I: The 1980s' in Atul Kohli, Democracy and Development in India, From Socialism to Pro-Business. New Delhi: Oxford University Press: 140-63.

Kohli, Atul (2009b). 'Politics of Economic Growth in India, 1980-2005, Part II: The 1990s and Beyond' in Atul Kohli, Democracy and Development in India, From Socialism to Pro-Business. New Delhi: Oxford University Press: 164-185.

Lamb, Helen B. (1955): “The Indian Business Communities and the Evolution of an Industrialist Class”, Pacific Affairs, 28 (2): 101-116.

Lokanathan, P.S. (1935) Industrial Organization in India, London: George Allen and Unwin Ltd.

Mani, Sunil (2009) ‘Is India Becoming More Innovative since 1991? Some Disquieting Features’, Economic and Political Weekly 44(46): 41-51.

Mazumdar, Surajit (2006) ‘Business Groups and Concentration in the Private Corporate Sector in India’, unpublished thesis, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.

Mazumdar, Surajit (2008a) 'The Corporate Sector and Indian Industrialization: A Historical Perspective', in S. R. Hashim, K. S. Chalapati Rao, K. V. K. Ranganathan and M.R. Murthy (eds.), Industrial Development and Globalisation New Delhi: Academic Foundation: 193-236

Mazumdar, Surajit (2008b) 'Investment and Growth in India under Liberalization: Asymmetries and Instabilities', Economic and Political Weekly, 43 (49): 68-77.

Mazumdar, Surajit (2010) ‘Industry and Services in Growth and Structural Change in India’, Working Paper No: 2010/02 New Delhi: Institute for Studies in industrial Development.

Morgan, G., R. Whitely, and E. Moen (eds). (2005) Changing Capitalisms: Internationalism, Institutional Change, and Systems of Economic Performance. New York: Oxford University Press.

Nagaraj, R (2003) 'Foreign Direct investment in India in the 1990s' Economic and Political Weekly 38(17): 1701-12.

Nayyar, Deepak (1994a) Migration, Remittances and Capital Flows: The Indian Experience, Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Nayyar, Deepak (ed.) (1994b) Industrial Growth and Stagnation: The Debate in India, Bombay: Oxford University Press for Sameeksha Trust.

Nayyar, Deepak (1998) ‘Economic Development and Political Democracy: Interaction of Economics and Politics in Independent India’, Economic and Political Weekly, 33 (49): 3121-3131.

Nayyar, Deepak (2008) ‘The Internationalization of Firms From India: Investment, Mergers and Acquisitions’, Oxford Development Studies 36(1): 111 – 31.

Patnaik, Utsa (1986), The Agrarian Question and the Development of Capitalism in India, The First Daniel Thorner Memorial Lecture, Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Patnaik, Utsa (1994), ‘India’s Agricultural Development in the Light of Historical Experience’, in Byres (1994), 265-290.

Patnaik, Utsa (1999), The Long Transition: Essays on Political Economy, New Delhi: Tulika.

Patnaik, Utsa (2003), ‘Food Stocks and Hunger: The Causes of Agrarian Distress’, Social Scientist, 31 (7/8), 15-41.

Patnaik, Utsa (2007), ‘Neoliberalism and Rural Poverty in India’, Economic and Political Weekly, 42 (30), 3132-50.

Peck, Jamie and Nik Theodore (2007) ‘Variegated capitalism’, Progress in Human Geography, 31(6): 731–772.

Pedersen, Jorgen Dige (2007) ‘The transformation of Indian business: from passive resisters to active promoters of globalization’, Paper prepared for Sixth Pan-European Conference on International Relations, University of Turin, Italy, 12.-15. September 2007.

Rao, J. Mohan (1994), ‘Agricultural Development under State Planning’, in Byres (1994), 220-264.

Ray, Rajat K. (1985) Industrialisation in India, Growth and Conflict in the Private Corporate Sector: 1914-47. Paperback Edition, 2nd Impression. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Ray, Rajat K. (ed.) (1994) Entrepreneurship and Industry in India, 1800-1947. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Reddy, D. Narasimha and Srijit Mishra (2008) ‘Crisis in Agriculture and Rural Distress in Post-Reform India’, in R. Radhakrishna (ed) India Development Report 2008, New Delhi, Oxford University Press, 40-53.

Rungta, Radhey Shyam (1970) The Rise of Business Corporations in India, 1851-1900, Cambridge at the University Press, Cambridge

Sandesara, J.C. (1992) Industrial Policy and Planning, 1947-91. New Delhi: Sage

Schneider, Ben Ross (2009) ‘Hierarchical Market Economies and Varieties of Capitalism in Latin America’, Journal of Latin American Studies, 41: 553-575

Sengupta, Arjun, K P Kannan , and G Raveendran (2008), ‘India’s Common People: Who Are They, How Many Are They and How Do They Live?’, Economic and Political Weekly, 43 (11): 49-63.

Sengupta, Nitish K. (1983) Changing Patterns of Corporate Management, Delhi: Vikas.

Simmons, Colin (1985), ‘'De-Industrialization', Industrialization and the Indian Economy, c. 1850-1947’, Modern Asian Studies, 19 (3), 593-622.

Sivasubramonian, S. (2000) The National Income of India in the Twentieth Century, New Delhi: Oxford University Press

Streeck, W. and K. Yamamura (eds.) (2001) The Origins of Nonliberal Capitalism: Germany and Japan in Comparison, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Thorner, Daniel (1956), The Agrarian Prospect in India,: Five Lectures on Land Reform delivered in 1955 at the Delhi School of Economics, Delhi: University Press.

Tripathi, Dwijendra (2004) The Oxford History of Indian Business, Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Tyabji, Nasir (2000) Industrialisation and Innovation: The Indian Experience, New Delhi: Sage Publications.

UNCTAD (2008), Trade and Development Report: Commodity Prices, Capital Flows and the Financing of Investment, New York and Geneva, United Nations.

Vakulabharanam, Vamsi (2010), ‘Does Class Matter? Class Structure and Worsening Inequality in India’, Economic and Political Weekly, 45 (29), 67-76.

Watson, Matthew (2003) ‘Ricardian Political Economy and the ‘Varieties of Capitalism’ Approach: Specialization, Trade and Comparative Institutional Advantage’, Comparative European Politics, 1: 227-240.

Whitely, R. (1998) ‘Internationalization and Varieties of Capitalism: The Limited Effects of Cross-National Coordination of Economic Activities on the Nature of Business Systems’, Review of International Political Economy, 5(3): 445-481.

Whitely, R. (1999) Divergent Capitalisms: The Social Structuring and Change of Business Systems. London: Oxford University Press.

Yamamura, K., and W. Streeck (eds.) (2003) The End of Diversity? Prospects for German and Japanese Capitalism. New York: Cornell University Press.

Zysman, J. (1991) ‘How Institutions Create Historically Rooted Trajectories of Growth’, Industrial and Corporate Change 4:243-283.