The Effect of Migrant Workers on Employment,Real Wages and Inequality The Case of Israel -1995 to 2000

Gottlieb, Daniel (2002): The Effect of Migrant Workers on Employment,Real Wages and Inequality The Case of Israel -1995 to 2000.

Abstract

This paper deals with the impact of migrant workers on the Israeli wage structure, on the chances of being unemployed or out of the labor force and on inequality in gross earnings from work. One of the manifestations of globalization is the movement of migrant workers from low-income to richer countries.The recent increase in living standards in Israel has created significant wage differentials for workers from low-income countries. Paradoxically,an important trigger for this process was also the worsening of Israel’s security situation in 1993,following the Oslo accord between Israel and the Palestinians.Israel responded to the deterioration by closures,which sharply reduced the number of Palestinian workers in Israel,substituting them with migrant workers, mainly from Eastern Europe,South and Central America and the Far East. The rapid inflow of migrant workers,especially since 1995,makes Israel an interesting case study for studying its effects on labor force participation, unemployment,the wage structure and gross earnings inequality.Given the bias in the government’s permit policy in favor of unskilled workers,the paper emphasizes the effects on Israelis with weak economic endowments. The research is based on pooled micro data,combined with data on the number of non-Israeli workers by economic branch.The micro-data is based on the Israeli income survey,including a host of personal characteristics,such as the individual’s education level,labor market status and a model-based calculation of welfare benefits. The research also focuses on government policy issues,such as the effect of the replacement ratio on the rate of labor force participation.For individuals not in the labor force the replacement ratio is defined as the income support payment divided by the potential wage.The inflow of migrant workers affects the potential wage negatively and together with a relatively easy access to income support payments,this policy variable is found to contribute significantly to the explanation of the exclusion from the labor force and the worsening of gross earnings distribution in a statistically significant way.The effect of these variables on unemployment is less clear and the effects on the wage structure are varied,distinguishing between substitutive and complementary effects,depending on the individual’s occupational and educational characteristics as well as on the time perspective. The study also shows that the highly branch-specific Israeli migrant permit policy did not prevent the effects on wages from spreading throughout the economy,thus emphasizing the general-equilibrium nature of these effects.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: Bank of Israel
• Language: English
• Keywords: Migrants; Foreign workers; Israel; Income inequality; Employment
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J19 - Other

References

Amir,Shmuel,2000,“Overseas Foreign Workers in Israel:Policy Aims and Labour Market Outcomes”,Chapter 7 in Irregular Migration:Dynamics,Impact,Policy Options,eds:Dilek Cinar,A.Gaechter and H.Waldrauch,European Centre for Social Welfare Policy and Research,Vienna,Austria.p.95-110. Bar-Tsuri,Roni,1999,“Foreign Workers Without Permit in Israel,1998”,Discussion Paper No.3.99,April,Ministry of Labor and Welfare,Jerusalem,Israel,p.1-51, (in Hebrew). Bean F.D.,Lowell B.L.and L.J.Taylor,1988,“Undocumented Mexican Immigrants and the Earnings of Other Workers in the United States”. Demography 25,p.35-49. Borjas,George J.,1992,National Origin and the Skills of Immigrants,in “Immigration and the Work Force”,eds.G.J.Borjas and R.B.Freeman,The University of Chicago Press,Chicago,USA,p.17-47. Borjas,George J.,R.B.Freeman and L.F.Katz,1992,“On the Labor Market Effects of Immigration and Trade”,in “Immigration and the Work Force”,eds.G.J. Borjas and R.B.Freeman,The University of Chicago Press,Chicago,USA,p. 213-244. Bouhris,Jacob and others,2001,Commission Report on the Investigation of Foreign Workers’Employment in Israel,Ministry of Labor and Welfare,July,p.1-36. Bowen,William G.and T Aldrich Finegan,1969,The Economics of Labor Force Participation,Princeton University Press,Princeton,New Jersey. Brender A.,O.Peled and N.Kassir,2001’“Government Policy and Participation Rates in the Labor force for the Population in the Main Working Age –Israel and the OECD in the 1990s,p.1-68,in Hebrew,Research Department,Bank of Israel,Jerusalem,Israel. Burtless,Gary,1995,“The Case for Randomized Field Trials in Economic and Policy Research”,Journal of Economic Perspectives,Vol.9,2,Spring,p.63-84. Castles,S.and M.J.Miller,1993,“The Age of Migration”,New York,Guilford, USA. Cohen,Yaniv,2002,“The Effect of Non-Israeli Workers’Inflow on Real Wages by Economic Branches in Israel”,forthcoming,Bank of Israel,Jerusalem,Israel. De New,John P.and Klaus F.Zimmermann,“Native Wage Impacts of Foreign Labor:A Random Effects Panel Analysis”,Journal of Population Economics,7, P.177-192. Ezra,Esther,1997,“Immigration Policies and Foreign Workers in Europe:Lessons for Israel”,Working Paper 6/97,The Helmut Kohl Institute for European Studies,The Hebrew University of Jerusalem,October,1-45. Fefferman,Binyamin,2000,“Foreign Workers Employed Illegally in Israel”,Chapter 4 in Irregular Migration:Dynamics,Impact,Policy Options,eds:Dilek Cinar, A.Gaechter and H.Waldrauch,European Centre for Social Welfare Policy and Research,Vienna,Austria.p.61-76. Flug,Karnit and Nitsa Kassir (Kaliner),2001,„On Poverty,Work and What’s In Between”,Discussion Paper Series,Research Department,Bank of Israel, August,p.1-34,(in Hebrew). Frisch,Max,1966,Ueberfremdung 1,Ueberfremdung 2,in “Gesammelte Werke”pp. 374-399,Werkausgabe,Suhrkamp,Germany. Frisch,Ronnie,and Yossi Mealem,1999,“The rise in the yield on education in Israel between 1976 and 1997”,Discussion Paper Series 99.06,Bank of Israel, August,p.1-33,(in Hebrew). Gang,Ira N.And Francisco L.Rivera-Batiz,1994,“Labor Market Effects of Immigration in theUnited States and Europe”,Substitution vs. Complementarity”,Journal of Population Economics,7,P.157-175. Gottlieb,Daniel,2000,“The Compliance to the Minimum Wage Law and its Enforcement in Israel”,The Israeli Tax Quarterly,Vol 28,110,September,p. 65-84,(in Hebrew). ______________,2002,“From Welfare to Work:Income Support for People in the Working Age in Israel –The Present Situation and Policy Recommendations”, Economic Quarterly,2002,1,p.121-158,(in Hebrew). Heckman,James J.,Robert J.LaLonde and Jeffrey A.Smith,Draft of “The Economics and Econometrics of Active Labor Market Programs”,in the Handbook of Labor Economics,Volume III,eds.Orley Ashenfelter and David Card,Sections 1-5,p.1-48. Hosmer,David W.and Stanley Lemeshow,2000,Applied Logistic Regression,2. edition,Wiley &Sons,Inc. Killingsworth Mark R.and James J.Heckman,1986,“Female Labor Supply:A Survey”,eds.Ashenfelter Orley and Richard Layard,Handbook of Labor Economics,Volume 1,3-102. Kondor,Jacob,1997,“Foreign Workers in Israel –The Problem and its Political-Economic Solution”,National Insurance Institute,September,p.1-92,(in Hebrew). Layard,Richard,O.Blanchard,R.Dornbusch and P.Krugman,1992,“East-West Migration,the Alternatives”,MIT Press,Cambridge,Massachusetts,London, UK. Layton-Henry,Z.,1992,“The Politics of Immigration”,Oxford,Blackwell,UK. Pencavel,John,1986,“Labor Supply of Men:A Survey”,eds.Ashenfelter Orley and Richard Layard,Handbook of Labor Economics,Volume 1,103-204. Shaviv Meirav,1999,“From Income Support to Employment Support”,Web Site of the Ministry of Finance,Jerusalem,Israel,(in Hebrew). Taylor L.J.,F.D.Bean,J.B.Rebitzer,S.Gonzalez-Baker and B.Lindsay Lowell, 1988,“Mexican Immigrants and the Wages and Unemployment Experience of Native Workers”,Working Paper PRIP-UI-1,The Urban Institute. Yashiv,Eran,2000,“Palestinian Workers in Israel:Patterns of Employment”,Chapter 10 in Irregular Migration:Dynamics,Impact,Policy Options,eds:Dilek Cinar, A.Gaechter and H.Waldrauch,European Centre for Social Welfare Policy and Research,Vienna,Austria.p.129-140.