Pension reform and income inequality among the elderly in 15 European countries

Van Vliet, Olaf and Been, Jim and Caminada, Koen and Goudswaard, Kees (2011): Pension reform and income inequality among the elderly in 15 European countries.

Abstract

The ageing of populations and hampering economic growth increase pressure on public fi-nances in many advanced capitalist societies. Consequently, governments have adopted pen-sion reforms in order to relieve pressure on public finances. These reforms have contributed to a relative shift from public to private pension schemes. Since private social security plans are generally less redistributive than public social security, it can be hypothesized that the privatization of pension plans has led to higher levels of income inequality among the elderly. Existing empirical literature has mainly focused on cross-country comparisons at one moment in time or on time-series for a single country. This study contributes to the income inequality and pension literature by empirically analysing the distributional effects of shifts from public to private pension provision in 15 European countries for the period 1995-2007, using pooled time series cross-section regression analyses. Remarkably, we do not find empirical evidence that shifts from public to private pension provision lead to higher levels of income inequality or poverty among elderly people. The results appear to be robust for a wide range of econometric specifications.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: income inequality; pension reform; public/private-mix; retirement; welfare state
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H53 - Government Expenditures and Welfare Programs; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I32 - Measurement and Analysis of Poverty

References

Adema, W. (2010) ‘The Welfare State across Selected OECD Countries: How much does it really cost and how good is it in reducing poverty?’, in: B. Reynolds, S. Healy, and M. Collins (eds.), The Future of the Welfare State, Dublin: Social Justice Ireland: 20-50.

Adema, W. and M. Ladaique (2009) How Expensive is the Welfare State? Gross and Net Indi-cators in the OECD Social Expenditure Database. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers No. 92. Paris: OECD.

Arza, C. (2008), ‘Changing European welfare: The new distributional principles of pension policy’, in: C. Arza and M. Kohli (eds.) Pension Reform in Europe: Politics, policies and out-come, New York: Routledge: 109-131.

Barr, N., and P. Diamond (2009), ‘Reforming pensions: Principles, analytical errors, and policy directions’, International Social Security Review 62(2): 5-29.

Beck, N., and J.N. Katz (1995), ‘What to do (and not to do) with time-series-cross-section data’, American Political Science Review 89(3): 634-647.

Brown, R.L., and S.G. Prus (2004), ‘Social Transfers and Income Inequality in Old Age: A Mul-tinational Perspective’ , North American Actuarial Journal 8(4): 30-36.

Burtless, G., (2006), ‘Poverty and inequality’, in: G.L. Clark, A.H. Munnel and J.M. Orszag (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Pensions and Retirement Income, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 740-758.

Caminada, K., and K. Goudswaard (2005), ‘Are Public and Private Social Expenditures Com-plementary?’, International Advances in Economic Research 11(2): 175-189.

Caminada, C.L.J., K.P. Goudswaard and F. Koster (2011), ‘Social Income Transfers and Pov-erty: a cross country analysis for OECD countries, International Journal of Social Welfare, forthcoming.

Casey, B.H., and A. Yamada (2002), ‘The public-private mix of retirement income in nine OECD countries: Some evidence from micro-data and an exploration of its Implications’, Luxembourg Income Study Working Paper Series No. 311.

Clarke, P.M., D.G. Fiebig, and U.G. Gerdtham (2008), ‘Optimal recall length in survey design’, Journal of Health Economics 27(5): 1275-1284.

Eurostat (2005), ‘The continuity of indicators during the transition between ECHP and EU-SILC’, Working Paper and Studies, Brussels: Eurostat.

Eurostat (2011a), SILC-database, Brussels: Eurstat. Website: http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/statistics/search_database

Eurostat (2011b), Population Statistics, Brussels: Eurostat. Website: http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/population/introduction

Esping-Anderson, G., and J. Myles (2006), ‘Sustainable and equitable retirement in a life course perspective’, in: G.L. Clark, A.H. Munnel en J.M. Orszag (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Pensions and Retirement Income, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 839-857.

Ferrarini, T., and K. Nelson, (2003), ‘Taxation of Social Insurance and Redistribution: A Com-parative Analysis of Ten Welfare States’, Journal of European Social Policy 13(1): 21-33.

Fukawa, T. (2006), ‘Sustainable structure of the Japanese public pension system viewed from a Germany-Japan comparison’, The Japanese journal of social Security Policy 6(1): 131-143.

Goudswaard, K., and K. Caminada (2010), ‘The Redistributive Effect of Public and Private So-cial Programmes: A Cross-country Empirical Analysis’, International Social Security Review 63(1): 1-19.

Gustafsson, B., and M. Johansson (1999), ‘In search of smoking guns: What makes income inequality vary over time in different countries?’, American Sociological Review 64(4): 585-605.

Hughes, G., and J. Stewart (2004), Reforming pensions in Europe: Evolution of pension fi-nancing and sources of retirement income, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

International Social Security Administration (2010), Social Security Programs throughout the World, ISSA, Washington.

L’horty, Y. and C. Rault (2003), ‘Why is French unemployment so high?’, Journal of Applied Economics 6(1): 127-156

Luxembourg Income Study (2011), LIS Key Figures Database, Luxemburg. Website: http://www.lisproject.org/key-figures/key-figures.htm

Milligan, K. (2008), ‘The evolution of elderly poverty in Canada’, Canadian public Policy 34(s1): 79-94.

Mundlak, Y. (1978), ‘On the Pooling of Time Series and Cross Section Data’, Econometrica 46(1): 69-85.

Myles, J. (2000), ‘The maturation of Canada’s retirement income system: income levels, in-come inequality and low-income among the elderly’, Research Paper Series Statistics Can-ada No. 147.

Myles, J., and P. Pierson (2001), ‘The comparative political economy of pension reform’, in: P. Pierson (ed.) The new politics of the welfare state, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 305-333.

Nanda, A., and S.L. Ross (2008), ‘The impact of property condition disclosure laws on housing prices: Evidence from an event study using propensity scores’, Department of Economics Working Paper Series University of Connecticut, No. 2008-39R.

Natali, D. and M. Rhodes (2008), ‘The “new politics” of pension reforms in Continental Europe’, in: C. Arza and M. Kohli (eds.) Pension Reform in Europe: Politics, policies and outcome, New York: Routledge: 25-46.

OECD (2008), Income Distribution and Poverty Database mid 1970s – mid 2000s, Paris: OECD. Website: http://www.oecd.org/document/14/0,3746,en_2649_33933_38910286_1_1_1_1,00.html

OECD (2009), Pensions at a Glance: Retirement-Income Systems in OECD countries, Paris: OECD.

OECD (2010), Social Expenditures Database 1980-2007, Paris: OECD. Website: http://www.oecd.org/document/9/0,3343,en_2649_34637_38141385_1_1_1_1,00.html

OECD (2011), National Accounts, Paris: OECD. Website: http://stats.oecd.org/index.aspx?queryid=26646

Orenstein, M.A. (2011), ‘Pension privatization in crisis: Death or rebirth of a global policy trend?’, International Social Security Review, 64(3): 65-80.

Oshio, T., and S. Shimizutani (2005), ‘The impact of public pension benefits on income and poverty of the elderly in Japan’, The Japanese journal of social Security Policy, 4(2): 54-66.

Peeters, H., V. Van Gestel, G. Gieselink, J. Berghman and B. Van Buggenhout (2003) Invisible Pensions in Belgium: On the nature, scope and distribution of second and third pillar pen-sions. Research report SB/2003-12. Leuven: Catholic University of Leuven.

Schirle, T. (2009), ‘Income inequality among seniors in Canada: the role of women’s Labour Market Experience’, CLSRN Working Paper no. 10.

Smeeding, T.M., and J. Williamson (2001), ‘Income maintenance in Old Age: What can be learned from cross-national comparisons’, Luxembourg Income Study Working Paper No. 263.

Stern, D.I. (2005), ‘Reversal in the trend of global anthropogenic sulfur emissions’, Rensse-laer Working Papers in Economics, No. 0504.

Toroj, A. (2008), ‘Estimation of weights for the Monetary Conditions Index in Poland’, De-partment of Applied Econometrics Working Papers Warsaw School of Economics, No. 6.

Vandenbroucke, F., and K. Vleminckx (2011), ‘Disappointing poverty trends: is the social in-vestment state to blame? An exercise in soul-searching for policy-makers’, accepted for publication in Journal of European Social Policy (CBS Working Paper 11/01, available at www.centreforsocialpolicy.eu).

Van Vliet, O. (2010), ‘Divergence within Convergence: Europeanisation of Social and Labour Market Policies’, Journal of European Integration 32(3): 269-290.

Van Vliet, O. (2011), Convergence and Europeanisation: The Political Economy of Social and Labour Market Policies, Leiden: Leiden University Press.

Wang, C., and K. Caminada (2011), ‘Disentangle income inequality and the redistributive ef-fect of social transfers and taxes in 36 LIS countries’, Department of Economics Research Memorandum 2011.02. Leiden: Leiden University.

Weller, C.E. (2004), ‘The future of public pensions in the OECD’, Cambridge Journal of Eco-nomics 28(4): 489-504.

Yoo, K-Y., and A. de Serres (2004), ‘Tax treatment of private pension savings in OECD coun-tries’, OECD Economic Studies, no.39 (2): 73-110.