The need for revaluation of the model structure for electricity liberalization

Szablewski, Andrzej T. (2011): The need for revaluation of the model structure for electricity liberalization. Published in: Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies , Vol. 2011 V, (2011): pp. 201-223.

Abstract

The question about an appropriate structure for the electricity industry has been extensively discussed in scientific literature and experts studies. Since the beginning of electricity liberalization, it was apparent for its promoters that such a structure (in this paper referred to as the model structure or ideal structural model) for the electricity sector should involve a separation of its four sub-sectors, i.e., generation, transmission, distribution, and supply. With the exception of transmission, each sub-sector should consist of many stand-alone type companies. Given the high degree of vertical and horizontal integration of the electricity sectors, their procompetitive restructuring (i.e., de-integration) became a standard component of electricity sector reform packages. This paper provides a concise review of the origins and justification of the initial model structure for electricity liberalization, as well as an overview of the restructuring developments in the early years of electricity liberalization. Some attention is also devoted to the EU’s unbundling initiatives. The core part of this paper discusses the first signs indicating the crisis of the initial structural canon. The paper concludes with some comments referring to the modified form for a model structure that is emerging. It involves vertical integration of generation and supply and allows a higher degree of horizontal concentration of the electricity competitive markets.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: electricity liberalization, model structure, unbundling, internal electricity market, EU restructuring developments
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K21 - Antitrust Law

References

Adib P., J. Zarnikau, ‘Texas: The Most Robust Competitive market in North America’ [in:] F.P. Sioshansi, W. Pfaffenberger (eds), Electricity Market Reform. An International Perspective, Elsvier, 2006.

Blumsack S.A, J. Apt, L.B. Lave, ‘Lessons from the Failure of U.S. Electricity Restructuring’ (2006) 19(2) The Electricity Journal.

Bobińska K., ‘The Defense of Monopoly as a Determinant of the Process of Transformation of State-owned Infrastructure Sectors in Poland’ (2008) 1(1) Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies.

Bunn D.W., ‘Institutional Intent and Strategic Evolution in Electricity Markets’ [in:] Complex Electricity Markets (W. Mielczarski, ed.), Series: The European Power Supply Industry, Wyd. Instytut Elektroenergetyki Politechniki Łódzkiej i Stowarzyszenie Elektryków Polskich, Oddział Łódzki, Łódź 2006.

Chao H-P., S. Oren, R. Wilson, ‘Revaluation of Vertical Integration and Unbundling in Restructured Electricity Markets’ [in:] Sioshansi F.,P., (ed), Competitive Electricity Markets: Design, Implementation, Performance, Elsvier, 2008.

Editorial Board, ‘Enron’s Sins’, (2002) Wall Street Journal, January 12. Giuletti M., R. Sicca, ‘The liberalization of the internal market for electricity: what choices for Italy’ (1999) 8 Utilities Policy.

Haas R., J.-M. Glachant, N. Keseric, Y. Perez, ‘Competition in the Continental European Electricity Market; Despair or Work in Progress’ [in:] F.P. Sioshansi, W. Pfaffenberger (eds), Electricity Market Reform. An International Perspective, Elsvier, 2006.

Hancher L., ‘Slow and not so sure: Europe’s long march to electricity liberalization’ (1997) 10(9) The Electricity Journal.

Helm D., Energy, the State, and the Market. British Energy Policy since 1979, Revised Edition, Oxford University Press 2003.

Helm D., T. Jenkinson (eds.) Competition in Regulated Industries, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1994.

Impact Assessment, Accompanying Report, European Commission, Brussels, 2007.

Joskow P.L. ‘California’s Electricity Crisis’, 17(3) Oxford Review of Economic Policy.

Kahn A.E., The Economics of Regulation. Principles and Institution, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass. 1990.

Kunneke R., T. Fens, ‘Ownership unbundling in electricity distribution: The case of the Netherlands (2007) 35(3) Energy Policy.

Lenard T.M., ‘Electricity “Restructuring”: What Went Wrong’ (2005) 18(6) The Electricity Journal.

Mitchels R.J., ‘Vertical Integration: The economics that Electricity Forgot’ (2004) 17 The Electricity Journal 10.

Newbery D., Problems of liberalizing the electricity industry, (2002) European Economic Review 46.

Newbery D., Regulatory Challenges to European Electricity Liberalization, DAE Working Paper WP 0230, 2002.

Newbery D., The Relationship Between Regulation and Competition Policy for Network Industries, CWPE 0631 and EPRG 0611, March 2006.

Nillesen P., M. Pollitt, Ownership unbundling in electricity distribution: empirical evidence from New Zealand, EPRG Working Paper in Economics 0836, 2008, paper available on the web.

Pollitt M., ‘The arguments for and against ownership unbundling of energy transmission networks’ (2008) 36 Energy Policy.

Pollitt M., The Future of Electricity (and gas) Regulation, CWPE 0811 and EPRG 0819, May, 2008.

Ralph E., Cross-subsidy: A Novice’s Guide to the Arcane, Duke University, Durham NC 27706 USA, 1992, paper available on the web.

Rosenzweig M.B., C. Pabon-Agueldo, ‘Power Sector Reform: Is there a Road Forward?’ (2006) 19(6) The Electricity Journal.

Sioshansi F.P., ‘California’s dysfunctional electricity market: policy lessons on market restructuring’ (2001) 29 Energy Policy.

Sobel J., ‘A Reexamination of yardstick competition’ (1998) 8(1) Journal of Economics and Management Strategy.

Stiglitz J., The Roaring Nineties: A New History of the World’s Most Prosperous Decade, 2003.

Szablewski A.T., ‘Koncepcja i programy wdrażania reform w energetyce polskiej’ [Concepts and Programmes of the Reforms of the Polish Energy Industry], [in:] P. Jasiński, A.T. Szablewski, G. Yarrow, Konkurencja i regulacja w przemyśle energetycznym. Brytyjskie doświadczenia a polskie problemy [Competition and Regulation in the Polish Energy Industry. British Experiences and Polish Problems], Polska Akademia Nauk, Instytut Nauk Ekonomicznych, Wyd. Elipsa, Warszawa, 1995.

Szablewski A., T., ‘Konsolidacja a konkurencja na polskim rynku energii elektrycznej’ [Consolidation and Competition on the Polish Electricity Market] (2002) 2–3 Gospodarka Narodowa.

Szablewski A.T., ‘Liberalizacja sektora elektroenergetycznego a bezpieczeństwo dostaw. Wnioski dla polityki energetycznej i regulacyjnej’ [Liberalization of the Electricity Sector and Supply Security. Conclusions for Energy and Regulation Policies], forthcoming.

Szablewski A.T., Zarys teorii i praktyki reform regulacyjnych na przykładzie energetyki [Theory and Practice of Regulatory Reforms. The Case of the Energy Sector] Monografie Nr. 12 Instytut Nauk Ekonomicznych PAN, DiG Łódź-Warszawa 2003.

The Unbundling Regime. Note Of DG Energy &Transport On Directives 2003/54 and 2003/55/EC On The Internal Market In Electricity and Natural Gas.

Unbundling as a crucial factor in the completion of European Electricity and Gas Market liberalization, Position Paper, EFET, September 2000.

Vickers J., and G. Yarrow, Privatization: An Economic Analysis, The MIT Press Cambridge, London, 1988.

Weaver J.L., ‘Can Energy Markets Be Trusted? The Effect of the Rise and Fall of Enron on Energy Markets’ (2004) Houston Business and Tax Law Journal.

Wolak F.A., ‘Diagnosing the California Electricity Crisis’ (2003) 16(7) The Electricity Journal.

Zakary M., British government saves British Energy from bankruptcy, available at: http://www.bellona.org/english_import_area/energy/nuclear/26199.