Competition on MARS? A study of broker-dealer competition in the U.S. municipal auction rate securities market

cole, Chip and Edwards, Jeffrey A. (2010): Competition on MARS? A study of broker-dealer competition in the U.S. municipal auction rate securities market.

Abstract

The relationship between competitive bidding in auctions and its impact on price and interest rates has long been of importance for a wide range of market practitioners. Although research has shown that increased competition among broker-dealers and bidders results in lower municipal interest rates, the amount of literature addressing auction rate securities is almost non-existent. The U.S. municipal auction rate securities market (MARS) offers an opportunity to expand the growing but limited empirical analysis of auctions. In particular, researchers can study the impact of market power and competitive search on interest rates using this uniform pricing, multi-unit, frequently repeated dutch auction process. Furthermore, in general, previous cross-sectional models measuring relationships in standard municipal markets are quite static in that they mostly assume some form of dynamic parametric homogeneity. Using a novel empirical approach, i.e., one that doesn't assume the time-constancy of cross-sectional parameters, our research shows that greater underwriter competition and search for potential investors in the form of multiple broker-dealers does indeed lead to lower municipal auction rates. This outcome does not hold for the entire sample life of the security--a result that was captured clearly using our methodology.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: MARS, municipal auctions, securities, parametric heterogeneity
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates

References

Back, Kerry, Jaime F. Zender, 2001, Auctions of divisible goods with endogenous supply, Economic Letters 73,pp29-34.

Benson, Earl D., 1979, The Search for Information by Underwriters and its Impact on Municipal Interest Cost, The Journal of Finance, Vol34,No4, pp 871-885.

Bower, John, Derek Bunn, 2001, Experimental analysis of the efficiency of uniform-price versus discriminatory auctions in the England and Wales electricity market, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 25, pp 561-592.

Brannman, Lance, J. Douglass Klein, Leonard W. Weiss, 1987, The Price Effects of Increased Competition in Auction Markets, The Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol.69,No1,pp.24-32.

Chari, V V, Robert J. Weber, 1992, How the US Treasury Should Auction its Debt, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. Quarterly Review - Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. Vol. 16, Iss. 4; Fall , pg. 3-12.

Edwards, Jeffrey A., Alfred Sams, Benhua Yang. 2006. "A Refinement in the Specification of Empirical Macroeconomic Models as an Extension to the EBA Procedure." Topics in Macroeconomics. Vol. 6, No. 2, Article 13.

Edwards, Jeffrey A. and Krishna Kasibhatla. 2009. "Dynamic Heterogeneity in Cross-Country Growth Relationships," Economic Modelling, Vol. 26: 445-55.

Feroz, Ehsan H., Earl R. Wilson, 1992, Market Segmentation and the Association between Municipal Financial Disclosure and Net Interest rates, The Accounting Review, Vol. 67, No. 3, July, pp 480-495.

Hendershott, Patric H., David S. Kidwell, 1978, The Impact of Relative Security Supplies: A Test with Data from a Regional Tax-Exempt Bond Market, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 10,NO. 3, August, pp 337-347.

Kessel, Reuben, 1971, A Study of the Effects of Competition in the Tax-exempt Bond Market, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol 79,No4,,pp 706-738.

Klemperer, Paul, 2002, What Really Matters in Auction Design, The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 16, No.1, Winter, pp 169-189.

Leonard, Paul A, 1994, Negotiated Versus Competitive Bond Sales: A Review of the Literature, Municipal finance Journal, Vol 15, Summer, pp 12-36.

Leonard, Paul A., 1998, Competitive Bidding for Municipal Bonds: New Tests of the Underwriter Search Hypothesis, Municipal Finance Journal, Vol. 1, No. 1, Spring, pp18-37.

Malvey, Paul F., Christine M. Archibald, Sean T. Flynn, 1995, Uniform-Price Auctions: Evaluation of the Treasury Experience, Office of Market Finance, US Treasury, Washington.

McAleer, M., “Sherlock Holmes and the Search for Truth: a Diagnostic Tale,” Journal of Economic Surveys, Vol. 8, 317-370, 1994.

Robbins, Mark D., Bill Somonsen, Christine Rocco, 2004, Municipal Bond Auctions and Borrowing Costs, Municipal Finance Journal, Vol. 25, No. 1, Spring , pp. 1-16.

Simonsen, William, Mark D. Robbins, 1996, Does It Make Any Difference Anymore? Competitive versus Negotiated Municipal Bond Issuance, Public Administration Review, Vol 56, NO1, Jan-Feb, pp 57-64.

Sorensen, Eric H. 1980, An Analysis of the Relationship Between Underwriter Spread and the Price of Municipal Bonds, The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol. 15,No. 2, June, pp 435-447.

Spanos, Aris, "Statistical Foundations of Econometric Modeling," Cambridge University Press, 1986.

Spanos, Aris, "Probability Theory and Statistical Inference: Econometric Modeling with Observational Data," Cambridge University Press, 1999.

Wilson, Robert B., 1977, A Bidding Model of Perfect Competition. The Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 44, No. 3, Oct., pp. 511-518.