Environmentally Related Energy Taxes in Argentina, Bolivia and Uruguay

Navajas, Fernando H. and Panadeiros, Monica and Natale, Oscar (2011): Environmentally Related Energy Taxes in Argentina, Bolivia and Uruguay.

Abstract

We start addressing the performance of environmentally related taxes in Argentina, Bolivia and Uruguay and find differences in level and structure with OECD countries but with the common feature that energy taxes are prime contributors. We then model an energy tax reform process out a status quo and towards environmentally related excises, distinguishing between uniform and non-uniform tax components, positive and normative tax structures, and between non-Ramsey and Ramsey specifications. We implement the model after some effort to estimate local and global environmental costs related to energy consumption. We find a rebalancing of fuel taxes (where gasoline and diesel are main drivers) that is robust to the range of price-demand elasticity and environmental cost parameters. Environmental (almost local) gains of the reform are significant, while fiscal impacts are positive and large but do not allow to claim double dividend effects because of price increases of widespread energy inputs triggered by the reform exercise. In the case of Argentina and Bolivia pre-existing distortions in energy prices imply large increases in end-user prices to accommodate not only tax increases but also corrections of producer prices. The assessment of the distributional impact of tax reforms depends on its type (Non Ramsey vs. Ramsey) and on considering environmental benefits to compensate for negative price effects. A Non-Ramsey tax reform has a positive distributive impact in Uruguay, while large pre-existing price distortions tend to produce negative impacts in Argentina and Bolivia. Overall we recommend non-Ramsey taxes as they are more transparent and easy to implement, avoid inverse-elasticity effects on tax wedges that have nothing to do with environmental costs and have better distributional properties. Moving to multiple instruments is also recommended to integrate other externalities, deal with informality and cope with distributive impacts.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: environmental taxes, energy, tax models
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q40 - General; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q51 - Valuation of Environmental Effects; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies

References

Ahmad, E. and N. Stern (1984) "The Theory of Reform and Indian Indirect Taxes”, Journal of Public Economics, 25, pp. 259-98.

ANCAP (2011), Fichas técnicas, combustibles varios. ARPEL (2005): “Hydrocarbon legal study”, Regional association of oil, gas and biofuels sector companies in Latin America and the Caribbean, Montevideo, Uruguay.

Azqueta D. (1994), Valoración económica de la calidad ambiental, Madrid: Mc Graw-Hill

Barde J.P. and N. Braathen (2005), “Environmentally Related Levies”, Chapter 5 in Cnossen S., Theory and Practice of Excise Taxation: Smoking, Drinking, Gambling, Polluting and Driving. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Baumol W. and W. Oates (1988), The Theory of Environmental Policy, second edition, Cambrige University Press.

Becker G. (1983), “A Theory of Competition Among Pressure Groups for Political Influence”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol.96, pp.371-400

CEPAL (2004): “Políticas de precios de los combustibles en América del Sur y México: implicancias económicas y ambientales” http://www.eclac.org/publicaciones/xml/5/19645/lcl2171eA.pdf

Cesar, H.S.J., et. al. (2000), "Economic valuation of improvement of air quality in the metropolitan area of Mexico City", Working document IVM-W00/28 +W00/28 Appendices.

Cifuentes, Luis A., Alan J. Krupnick, Raúl O’Ryan and Michael Toman, 2005. “Urban Air Quality and Human Health in Latin America and the Caribbean.” Working paper, InterAmerican Development Bank, Washington, DC.

Cont W., P. Hancevic and F. Navajas (2011), “Energy populism and household welfare”, 34th IAEE International Conference, June 20, 2011, Stockholm School of Economics, Sweden. http://www.hhs.se/IAEE-2011/Program/

Cont W., A. Calabria and A. Viglione (2010), “Costos económicos y fiscales de subsidios a los servicios públicos en Argentina”, mimeo, paper for the IDB, (CSC/CAR), December.

Conte Grand M. (2002), “Impacts of GHG Mitigation on Local Air Pollution in the Buenos Aires Metropolitan Area: Valuation of Human Health Effects”, Capítulo 3, Informe Final IES: Integrated Environmental Strategies Program Co-Control Benefits Analysis Project for Argentina (National Renewable Energy Laboratory and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency).

Chisari O. and F. Navajas (1992), “Public inputs, tax collection and fiscal constraints”, 5th NBER Inter-American Seminar on Economics, Buenos Aires, mimeo.

Cremer H., N Gahvari y F. Ladoux (2003), “Environmental taxes with heterogeneous consumers: an application to energy consumption in France”, Journal of Public Economics, vol 87, pp.2791-2815.

Diamond, P. (1973) "Consumption Externalities and Imperfect Corrective Pricing", Bell Journal of Economics, 4, pp. 526-38.

EC (1999), “ExternE: Externalities of Energy, Vol.7: Methodology 1998 Update”, European Commission, Directorate General XII: Science, Research and Development.

EPA (1999), “Final Report to Congress on Benefits and Costs of the Clean Air Act, 1990 to 2010”, EPA 410-R-99-001.

EPA (1999), “Final Report to Congress on Benefits and Costs of the Clean Air Act, 1990 to 2010”, EPA 410-R-99-001.

Eurostat (2001), “Environmental taxes: a statistical guide”, Methods and Nomenclatures.

Fullerton D., I. Hong y G. Metcalf (1999), “A Tax on the Polluting Industry is not a Tax on Pollution: The Importance of Hitting the Target”, NBER Working Paper W7259. En www.nber.org

Fullerton D., A. Leicester and S. Smith (2010) “Environmental Taxes”, Chapter 5 in Institute for Fiscal Studies (2010), The Mirrlees Review. Reforming the tax system for the 21st century. London. http://www.ifs.org.uk/mirrleesReview

Fullerton D. and A. Wolverton (2005), “The two-part instrument in a second-best world”, Journal of Public Economics, 89, pp.1961-75.

Fundación Bariloche (2005), “Inventario de Emisiones de Gases de Efecto Invernadero de la República Argentina. Año 2000”, Tomos II y Tomo IV.

Guesnerie, R. (1977) "On the Direction of Tax Reform", Journal of Public Economics, 7, pp. 179-202.

Hettich W. y S. Winner (1984), “A Positive Model of Tax Structure”, Journal of Public Economics, vol.24, pp.

Kanbur S. Y G. Myles (1992), “Policy Choice and Political Constraints”, European Journal of Political Economy, vol.8, pp.1-29.

Lvovsky, K.; G. Hughes; D. Maddison; B. Ostro; D. Pearce (2000), “Environmental Costs of Fossil Fuels. A Rapid Assessment Method with Application to Six Cities”, World Bank Environment Department.

Ministerio de Desarrollo Sostenible y Planificación (2003), “Inventario Nacional de Emisiones de Gases de Efecto Invernadero de Bolivia para la Década 1990 – 2000 y su Análisis Tendencial”, Bolivia.

MMAyA (2009), “Segunda Comunicación Nacional del Estado Plurinacional de Bolivia ante la Convención Marco de las Naciones Unidas sobre Cambio Climático”.

MVOTMA (2010), “Uruguay: Tercera Comunicación Nacional a la Conferencia de las Partes en la Convención Marco de las Naciones Unidas sobre el Cambio Climático”

Myles G. (1995), Public Economics, Cambridge: University Press.

Navajas F. (1995) ,"Impuestos Ambientales Óptimos y la Tributación Diferencial de las Naftas con o sin plomo", en A. Porto (ed.), Finanzas Públicas y Economía Espacial en honor de Horacio Núñez Miñana, FCE-UNLP.

Navajas F. (2004), “Structural Reforms and the Distributional Effects of Price Changes in Argentina”, Chapter 10 in Bour E., D. Heymann and F. Navajas (eds) (2004), Latin American Macroeconomic Crisis, Trade and Labour, London: MacMillan.

Navajas F. (2009), “Engel Curves, Household Characteristics and Low-User Tariff Schemes in Natural Gas”, Energy Economics, vol.31, 1,pp. 162-168.

Navajas, F. and A. Porto (1994) "Budget Shares, Distributional Characteristics and the Direction of Tax Reform", Economics Letters, 45, 4, August.

Newbery D. (2005), “Why Tax Energy?. Towards a More Rational Energy Policy”, Cambridge Working Papers in Economics CWPE 0508

OECD, www.oecd.org/env/policies/database OECD (1997), Statistical framework on environmental taxes in OECD member countries”, DAFFE/CFA/CT(97)19.

OLADE (2010): “Metodología para la determinación de precios de los principales derivados del petróleo: América del Sur 2009” http://temp2.olade.org/documentos2/not139/METODOLOGIAS.pdf

Parry I. (2011), “Comments on Environmental Taxes in LAC”, mimeo ppt, IDB Seminar on Environmental Taxes in Latin America and the Caribbean, Washington, August 3.

Parry I. and K. Small (2004), “Does Britain or the United States Have the Right Gasoline Tax?”, Disc. Paper 02-12 Rev. Resources for the Future, Washington.

Parry, I. and J. Strand (2010), “International Fuel Tax Assessment: An Application to Chile”, Discussion paper, Resources for the Future, Washington, DC.

Pope, C. A. III, R. T. Burnett, et al. (2004). “Cardiovascular Mortality and Long-Term Exposure to Particulate Air Pollution: Epidemiological Evidence of General Pathophysiological Pathways of Disease.” Circulation 109: 71-77.

Porto A. (1996), “Determinantes Económicos y Políticos de una Estructura Tributaria”, Serie Seminarios 1/1996, Instituto y Universidad Torcuato Di Tella.

Rizzi, L. (2008). “Costos Externos del Transporte Automotor Vial en la Región Metropolitana de Santiago”, Departamento de Ingeniería de Transporte, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile.

Sandmo, A. (1975) "Optimal Taxation in the Presence of Externalities", Swedish Journal of Economics, 77, pp. 86-98.

Sandmo A. (2000), The Public Economics of the Environment, Oxford University Press.

Schwartz, J. (1993), “Air Pollution and Daily Mortality in Birmingham, Alabama”; American Journal of Epidemiology.

SEADS (2008), “Segunda Comunicación Nacional de la República Argentina a la Convención Marco de las Naciones Unidas sobre Cambio Climático”. Secretaría de Energía (2006), Resolución 271/2006, Argentina.

Stavins R. (2007), “Environmental economics”, NBER working paper Nº13575, November.

Viscusi K.W. (1993), "The Value of Risks to Life and Health", Journal of Economic Literature, Vol.31, Issue 4.

World Bank (1994), “Estimating the Health Effects of Air Pollutants: A Method with an Application to Jakarta”, World Bank Policy Research Department, Public Economics Division, Policy Research Working Paper No.1301, May.