Long-run performance of IPOs and the role of financial analysts: some French evidence

Boissin, Romain and Sentis, Patrick (2012): Long-run performance of IPOs and the role of financial analysts: some French evidence. Forthcoming in: The European Journal of Finance

Abstract

This paper examines the long-run performance of French initial public offerings (IPOs) carried out between 1991 and 2005. Using various methodologies, we found that IPOs in our sample performed poorly relative to the comparison portfolios over the 1991–2005 horizon in contrast to that reported by prior studies of the French market. This abnormal long-run performance is more severe for orphan IPOs (those without financial analysts’ recommendations) than for non-orphan IPOs the first year following the offerings (a statistically significant difference). In contrast to the widely held belief, this evidence suggests that analyst coverage is indeed not important to the issuing firm. Investors pay more attention to non-orphan IPOs when they are not book built, venture capital backed, underwritten by a large syndicate and less underpriced. Over the 1991–2005 period, an analyst’s affiliation does not appear to matter. This result is inconsistent with the conflict of interest hypothesis. During the first year of issuance, analysts’ recommendations are associated with the success of a newly public firm. However, once we extend the horizon to 3 or 5 years after the issuance, we can find that analysts’ recommendations are not significantly related to the long-run performance of IPOs.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: initial public offerings; financial analyst; long-run performance
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G14 - Information and Market Efficiency ; Event Studies ; Insider Trading

References

Aggarwal, R., R. Leal, and L. Hernandez, 1993, “The aftermarket performance of initial public offerings in Latin America”, Financial Management 22, 42-53.

Aggarwal, R., L. Krigman, and K. Womack, 2002, “Strategic IPO underpricing, information momentum, and lockup expiration selling”, Journal of Financial Economics 66, 106-137.

Asquith, P., M. Mikhail, and A. Au, 2005, “Information Content of Equity Analyst Reports.” Journal of Financial Economics75, 245-282.

Bagchee, D., 2003, “Investor response to sell-side analyst revisions in IPO recommendations: Do they correct expectations?”, Working paper.

Barber, B., R. Lehavy, M. McNichols and B. Trueman, 2001, “Can Investors Profit from the Prophets? Security Analyst Recommendations and Stock Returns” Journal of Finance 56, 531-563.

Barry, C., C. Muscarella, J. Peavy, and M. Vetsuypens, 1990, “The role of venture capital in the creation of public companies: Evidence from the going-public process”, Journal of Financial Economics 27, 447-476.

Barth, M., R. Kasznik and M. McNichols, 2001, “Analyst coverage and intangible assets” Journal of Accounting Research 39, 1-34.

Bhabra, H., and R. Pettway, 2003, “IPO prospectus information and subsequent performance”, The Financial Review 38, 369-397.

Bhushan, R., 1989, “Firm characteristics and analyst following”, Journal of Accounting and Economics 11, 255-274.

Bradley, D., B. Jordan, and J. Ritter, 2008a, “Analyst behavior following IPOs: the ‘bubble period’ evidence”, Review of financial studies 21, 101-133.

Bradley, D., K.Chan, J. Kim, and A. Singh, 2008b, “Are there long-run implications of analysts’ coverage for IPOs?”, Journal of Banking and Finance 32, 1120-1132.

Bradley, D., K.Chan, J. Kim, and A. Singh, 2004, “Investment bankers, their analysts and orphaned IPOs”, working paper.

Bradley, D., B. Jordan, and J. Ritter, 2003, “The quiet period goes out with a bang”, Journal of Finance 58, 1-36.

Brav, A. and P. Gompers, 1997, “Myth or reality? The long-run performance of initial public offerings: evidence from venture and nonventure capital-backed companies”, Journal of Finance 52, 1791-1821.

Brav, A., C. Geczy and P. Gompers, 2000, “Is the abnormal return following equity issuances anomalous?, Journal of Financial Economics 56, 209-249.

Brav, A., and R. Lehavy, 2003, “An empirical analysis of analysts’ target prices: short-term informativeness and long-term dynamics” Journal of Finance 58, 1933-1967.

Carter, R., F. Dark, and A. Singh, 1998, “Underwriter reputation, initial returns, and the long run performance of IPO stocks”, Journal of Finance 53, 285-311.

Chen, X., 2004, “Analysts’ affiliation, ranking, and the market reaction to stock recommendations for IPOs”, working paper, University of British Columbia.

Chen, H., and J. Ritter, 2000, “The seven percent solution”, Journal of Finance 55, 1105-1131.

Cliff, M. And D. Denis, 2004, “Do initial public offering firms purchase analysts’ coverage with underpricing?”, Journal of Finance 59, 2871-2901.

Cliff, M. and V. Tech, 2006. “Do Affiliated Analysts Mean What They Say?” Financial Management, Forthcoming.

Cooper, R., T.Day, and C. Lewis, 2001, “Following the leader: a study of individual analysts’ earnings forecasts”, Journal of financial economics 61, 383-416.

Corwin, S., and P. Schultz, 2005, “The role of IPO underwriting syndicates: pricing, information production, and underwriter competition”, The Journal of Finance 60, 443-486.

Das, S., R. Guo, and H. Zhang, 2006, “Analysts’ selective coverage and subsequent performance of newly public firms”, Journal of Finance 61, 1159-1185.

Das, S., C.Levine, and K. Sivaramakrishnan, 1998, “Earnings predictability and bias in analysts’ earnings forecasts”, The Accounting Review 73, 277-294.

Dechow, P., A. Hutton, and R. Sloan, 2000, “The relation between analysts’ forecasts of long-term earnings growth and stock price performance following equity offerings”, Contemporary accounting research17, 1-32.

Degeorge, F., F. Derrien, and K. Womack, 2007, “Analyst hype in IPOs: explaining the popularity of bookbuilding”, Review of Financial Studies 20, 1021-1058.

Degeorge, F., and F. Derrien, 2001, “IPO performance and earnings expectations : some French evidence”, working paper, HEC School of Management.

Derrien, F., 2006. "Currying Favor to Win IPO Mandates." Working paper, Université de Toronto.

Fama, E., and K. French, 1996, “Multifactor explanations of asset pricing anomalies”, The Journal of Finance 51, 55-84.

Francis, J., and Philbrick, D., 1993, “Analysts decisions as products of multi-task environment”, Journal of Accounting Research 31, 216-230.

Gompers, P. and J. Lerner, 2003, “The really long-run performance of initial public offerings: the pre-nasdaq evidence”, Journal of Finance 58, 1355-1392.

Hayes, R., 1998, “The impact of trading commission incentives on analysts’ stock coverage decisions and earnings forecasts”, Journal of Accounting Research 36, 299-320.

Houston, J., C. James, and J. Karceski, 2006, “What a difference a month makes: stock analyst valuations following initial public offerings”, Journal of financial and quantitative analysis 41, 85-109.

Irvine, P., 2003, “The incremental impact of analyst initiation of coverage”, Journal of Corporate Finance 9, 431-451.

Irvine P., 2004, “Analysts’ forecasts and brokerage-firm trading”, The Accounting Review 79, 125-149.

Iskoz, S., 2003, “Bias in underwriter analyst recommendations: does it matter?”, unpublished MIT dissertation.

Jain, B., and O.Kini, 2000, “Does the presence of venture capitalists improve the survival profile of IPO firms?”, Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 27, 1139-1176.

Jain, B., and O.Kini, 1994, “The post-issue operating performance of IPO firms”, Journal of Finance 49, 1699-1726.

James, C., and J. Karceski, 2006, “Strength of analysts’ coverage following IPOs”, Journal of Financial Economics 82, 1-34.

Jegadeesh, N., J. Kim, 2006, “Value of analyst recommendations: international evidence”, Journal of financial markets 9, 274-309.

Jegadeesh, N., J. Kim, S. Krische, and C. Lee, 2004, “Analysing the analysts: when do recommendations add value?”, Journal of Finance 59, 1083-1124.

Kadan, O., L. Madureira, R. Wang, T. Zach, 2009. "Conflicts of Interest and Stock Recommendations-The Effects of the Global Settlement and Related Regulations.", Review of Financial Studies 22, 4189-4217.

Kooli, M., and J-M. Suret, 2004, “The aftermarket performance of initial public offerings in Canada”, Journal of Multinational Financial Management 14, 47-66.

Krigman, L., W. Shaw, and K. Womack, 2001, “Why do firms switch underwriters?”, Journal of Financial Economics 60, 245-284.

Levis, M., 1993, “The long run performance of initial public offerings: the UK experience 1980-1988”Financial Management 22, 28-41.

Lin, H., and Mc Nichols M., 1998, “Underwriting relationships, analysts’ earnings forecasts and investment recommendations”, Journal of Accounting and Economics 25, 101-127.

Ljungqvist, A., and W. Wilhelm, 2003, “IPO pricing in the dot-com bubble”, Journal of Finance 58, 723-752.

Loughran, T., and J. Ritter, 2004, Why has IPO underpricing changed over time?”, Financial Management 33, 5-37.

Loughran, T., and J. Ritter, 1995, “The new issues puzzle”, Journal of Finance 50, 23-51.

Megginson, W., and K. Weiss, 1991, “Venture capitalist certification in initial public Offerings”, Journal of Finance 46, 879-903.

Michaely, R., and K. Womack, 1999, “Conflict of interest and the credibility of underwriter analyst recommendations”, Review of financial studies 12, 653-686.

Miller, E., 1977, “Risk, uncertainty, and divergence of opinion”, Journal of Finance 32, 1151-1168.

O’Brien, P. and R. Bhushan, 1990, “Analyst following and institutional ownership”, Journal of Accounting Research 28, 55-76.

Rajan, R., and H. Servaes, 1997, “Analyst following of initial public offerings”, Journal of Finance 52, 507-529.

Ritter, J., 1991, “The long-run performance of Initial Public Offerings”, Journal of Finance 46, 3-27.

Sayrak, A. and N. Dhiensiri, 2004, “The Value Effects of Analysts’ Coverage Initiations” Working paper, University of Pittsburgh.

Teoh,S., I. Welch, and T. Wong, 1998, “Earnings management and the long-run market performance of initial public offerings”, Journal of Finance 53, 1935-1974.