Competitive Strategy of the Japanese Integrated Steel Firms in Mature Stage

Kawabata, Nozomu (2003): Competitive Strategy of the Japanese Integrated Steel Firms in Mature Stage.

Abstract

Around the turn of the century from the 20th to the 21st, the inter-firm relations in the Japanese steel industry changed greatly. Within the country, NKK and Kawasaki Steel consolidated all their businesses and chartered JFE Holdings. Nippon Steel, Sumitomo Metals, and Kobe Steel formed alliances. Abroad, all integrated producers formed alliances with foreign steel firms. Did those changes mean a new step forward in prosperity? Did they mean a desperate counterattack to arrest the decline of the industry? What did they reinforce . cooperation or competition? This paper explains the reasons for those strategic choices of the Japanese integrated steel firms as a consequence of the environmental change and market competition in the 1990s and the early 2000s. The changing pattern of competition is considered, as integrated firms sought the best competitive strategy in the mature stage of the industry. In conclusion, the Japanese integrated steel firms have maintained competitiveness since the collapse of the Bubble Economy. However, they have not made stable profits. In other words, they have not reversed the move towards maturity, although they have not reached a stage of decline. After the collapse of the domestic system of cooperative oligopoly and homogeneous competition, inter-firm relations were reorganized through consolidations and alliances at home and abroad. The future of the integrated firms depends on whether they can take advantage of their competitive capabilities in the new inter-firm relations.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Japan; steel industry; competitive strategy; inter firm relation
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L6 - Industry Studies: Manufacturing > L61 - Metals and Metal Products ; Cement ; Glass ; Ceramics

References

Abernathy, William J., Kim B. Clark, and Alan M. Kantrow (1983), Industrial Renaissance, New York: Basic Books.

Adams, Walter (1995), ‘Steel’, in Walter Adams and James Brock eds., The Structure of American Industry 9th edition, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall: 93-118.

Baba, Yasunori and Shinji Takai (1997) (originally published in 1994 in Japan), ‘Metallic Materials Industry’, in Japan Commission on Industrial Performance [JCIP], Made in Japan: Revitalizing Japanese Manufacturing for Economic Growth, Cambridge, Mass: The MIT Press: 97-121.

Baldwin, Carliss Y. and Kim B. Clark (1994), ‘Capital-Budgeting Systems and Capabilities Investments in U.S. Companies after the Second World War’, Business History Review, 68/1: 73-109.

Chiba, Yuji (2003), ‘Tekko gyo ni okeru kigyo bunka to ishi kettei’ [‘Corporate Culture and Decision- Making in the Steel Industry’], in Masao Toyama ed., Keisu ni manabu kigyo no bunka [Case Studies of Corporate Culture], Tokyo: Hakuto Syobo: 25-61.

Facility for Research on Industrial Education Plan, School of Education, The University of Hokkaido (1995), Tekko gyo no risutorakutyaringu to juso teki rodoryoku no saihensei [Restructuring of the Steel Industry and Reorganization of the Multi-tiered Labor Forces], Sapporo: School of Education, The University of Hokkaido.

Ghosn, Carlos with Miguel Rivas- Micoud and Kermit Carvell (2001), Runessansu: saisei eno chosen [Renaissance: The Challenge for Survival], Tokyo: Diamond Inc.

Hashimoto, Juro (1991), Nihon keizai ron [The Japanese Economy], Kyoto: Minerva Shobo.

Itami, Hiroyuki and Itami Laboratory (1997), Nihon no tekko gyo: naze ima mo sekaiichi nanoka [Japanese Steel Industry: Why is It still No. 1 in the World?], Tokyo: NTT Publishing. Japan Economic Research Institute [JERI] (2002), 21 seiki no Ajia to Nippon [Asia and Japan in the 21st Century], Tokyo: JERI.

Japan Iron and Steel Exporters’ Association[JISEA], Market Research Committee (1999), ‘Roshia Ukraina no tekko yushutsu no genjo to mitoshi’ [‘Current States and Future Outlook of the Steel Exportation from Russia and Ukraine’], Geppo [Monthly Review], JISEA, November, 2-8.

The Japan Iron and Steel Federation [JISF] (1996), ‘DIOS no kyodo kenkyu wo oete’ [‘Joint Research of DIOS has Finished’], Tekkokai [Steel World], June: 30-6.

JISF, (1999), Tekko junen shi 1988-1997 [A 10-Year History of the Iron and Steel Industry 1988-1997], Tokyo: JISF.

JISF, International Section (2002), ‘Roshia Ukraina no tekko yushutsu no genjo to sono haikei’ [‘Current States and Background of the Steel Exports from Russia and Ukraine’], Tekkokai, July-August: 28-33.

JISF, Standard Section (1996), ‘Jidosha kohan no nihon tekko renmei kikaku no seitei’ [‘Constitution of the JISF Standard of Steel Sheets for Motor Vehicles’], Tekkokai, June: 46-50.

The Japan Research and Development Center For Metals [JRCM] [Sponsored by New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization(NEDO)] (2001), Tekko sangyo no gijutsu kaihatsu doko ni kansuru chosa kenkyu seika hokoku syo[Report of the Investigation of Research and Development Activities and Some Other Issues in the Iron and Steel Industry], Tokyo: NEDO.

Kawabata Nozomu (1995a), ‘Technology, Management, and Industrial Relations of U.S. Integrated Steel Companies: The Process of Restructuring’, Osaka City University Economic Review, 30/1-2, January: 53-79.

Kawabata, Nozomu (1995b), ‘Nihon koro meka ni okeru seihin kaihatsu’ [‘Product Development at the Japanese Integrated Steel Firms’], in Yoshihiko Akashi and Hirofumi Ueda eds., Nihon kigyo no kenkyu kaihatsu sisutemu [Systems of Innovation in Japanese Firms], Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press: 113-45.

Kawabata, Nozomu (1998), ‘Koro meka no seisan sisutemu to kyoso senryaku’ [‘Production System and Competitive Strategy of the Integrated Steel Firms’], in Kiyoshi Sakamoto ed., Nihon Kigyo no Seisan Sisutemu [Production Systems of Japanese Firms], Tokyo: Chuokeizai Sha: 69-111.

Kawabata, Nozomu (2003), ‘Ajia tsuka kiki go no Thai tekko gyo: kigyo saiken, kigyo kan bungyo, boeki mondai’ [‘The Thai Steel Industry After the Asian Currency Crisis: Corporate Reconstruction, Inter-firm Division of Labor and Trade Problem’], NEU-JICA Discussion Paper, July 2003.

Lynn, Leonard H. (1982), How Japan Innovates: A Comparison with the U.S. in the Case of Oxygen Steelmaking, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Miura, Takatoshi (1999), ‘Jisedai Kokusuro Gijutsu to Kankyo Hozen’ [‘Environmental Protection in Cokemaking Process towards 21st Century’], Ferrum [Bulletin of The Iron and Steel Institute of Japan], 4/6, June: 25-9.

Nagai, Toru (1992), ‘Shisan koritsu kara mita tekko gyo’ [‘Efficiency of Asset Utilization of the Steel Industry’], Daiwa toushi siryo [Information for Investment by Daiwa Institute of Research], 689, November, 24-45.

Nippon Steel Corporation Nagoya Works (1995), Nanatsu no umi kara nanatsu no umi he: Nagoya seitetsusyo senko ikkan 30 nenshi [From Seven Seas to Seven Seas: A 30-Year History of Integrated Steel Production of Nagoya Works], Nagoya, Nippon Steel Corporation Nagoya Works.

Ohashi, Shuji (1979), ‘Nihon tekko gyo ni okeru kakaku keisei’ [‘Price Setting in the Japanese Steel Industry’], in Noriyoshi Imai et al., Gendai Keizai to Kokka, Jo [Modern Economy and State Vol.1], Tokyo: Nippon- Hyoron- Sha: 133-164.

Okamoto, Hirokimi (1984), Gendai tekko kigyo no ruikei bunseki [Typological Analysis of Modern Iron and Steel Firms], Kyoto: Minerva Shobo.

Scheuerman, William (1986), The Steel Crisis: The Economics and Politics of a Declining Industry, New York: Praeger.

Sozai Sangyo Kozo Mondai Kenkyu Kai (1999), Isogareru sozai sangyo no kozo kaikaku [Structural Reform of the Basic Materials Industries Should be Accelerated], Tokyo: Ministry of Economics, Trade and Industry [METI].

Suzuki, Yoshitaka (1991), ‘The Rise and Decline of Steel Industries’, in Etsuo Abe and Yoshitaka Suzuki eds., Changing Patterns of International Rivalry: Some Lessons from the Steel Industry, Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 1-17.

Suzuki, Yoshitaka and Etsuo Abe (1991), ‘Concluding Remarks’, in Abe and Suzuki eds., Changing Patterns of International Rivalry, 299-307.

Tekko gyo no kyoso ryoku kyoka to shorai tenbo ni kansuru kenkyukai (2001), Chukan hokoku [Interim Report], Tokyo: METI.

Tona, Naoki (1996a), Nihon Gata Tekko Shisutemu [The Japanese-Style Steel Industry], Tokyo: Dobunkan Shuppan.

Tona, Naoki (1996b), Tekko Seisan Shisutemu [The Steel Production System], Tokyo: Dobunkan Shuppan.

U.S. Department of Commerce, International Trade Administration (2000), Report to the President, Global Steel Trade, Washington DC: U.S. Department of Commerce .

Vernon, Raymond (1966), ‘International Investment and International Trade in the Product Cycle’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 80/2: 190-207.

Yonekura, Seiichiro (1986), ‘Tekko gyo ni okeru inobeishon donyu prosesu’ [‘Adoption Process of Innovation in the Iron and Steel Industry’], in Kenichi Imai ed., Inobeishon to soshiki [Innovation and Organization], Tokyo: Toyo Keizai Inc.: 177-206.

Yonekura, Seiichiro (1993), ‘Fukyo karuteru to auto saida’ [‘Anti-recession Cartel and Outsider’], Nenpo Kindai Nihon Kenkyu [Yearbook of Studies on Modern Japanese History], 15, Tokyo: Yamakawa Shuppansha: 195-221.

Yonekura, Seiichiro (1994), The Japanese Iron and Steel Industry, 1850-1990: Continuity and Discontinuity, New York: St. Martin’s Press.

Yonekura, Seiichiro and Francoise Guelle (1998), ‘The Japanese Steel Industry in the 1990s’, in Ruggero Ranieri and Enrico Gibellieri eds., The Steel Industry in the New Millennium, Vol. 2, London: IOM Communications.

Yoshikawa, Hiroshi (1991), ‘Nihon kigyo no toshi kodo’ [‘Investment Behaviour of the Japanese Firms’], in Hirofumi Uzawa ed., Nihon kigyo no dainamizumu [Dynamism of the Japanese Firms], Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press.