You Can’t Put Old Wine in New Bottles: The Effect of Newcomers on Coordination in Groups

McCarter, Matthew and Sheremeta, Roman (2013): You Can’t Put Old Wine in New Bottles: The Effect of Newcomers on Coordination in Groups. Forthcoming in: PLOS ONE

Abstract

A common finding in social sciences is that member change hinders group functioning and performance. However, questions remain as to why member change negatively affects group performance and what are some ways to alleviate the negative effects of member change on performance? To answer these questions we conduct an experiment in which we investigate the effect of newcomers on a group’s ability to coordinate efficiently. Participants play a coordination game in a four-person group for the first part of the experiment, and then two members of the group are replaced with new participants, and the newly formed group plays the game for the second part of the experiment. Our results show that the arrival of newcomers decreases trust among group members and this decrease in trust negatively affects group performance. Knowing the performance history of the arriving newcomers mitigates the negative effect of their arrival, but only when newcomers also know the oldtimers performance history. Surprisingly, in groups that performed poorly prior to the newcomers’ arrival, the distrust generated by newcomers is mainly between oldtimers about each other rather than about the newcomers.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: coordination, group performance, oldtimers, newcomers, trust, experiments
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory > C72 - Noncooperative Games; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C91 - Laboratory, Individual Behavior

References

Arrow H, McGrath JE (1995) Membership dynamics in groups at work: A theoretical framework. In: Cummings LL, Staw BM, editors. Research in Organizational Behavior. Greenwich, Connecticut: JAI Press. pp. 373-412.

Zald MN, Ash R (1966) Social movement organizations: Growth, decay and change. Social Forces 44: 327-341.

Kane AA, Argote L, Levine JM (2005) Knowledge transfer between groups via personnel rotation: Effects of social identity and knowledge quality. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes 96: 56-71.

Choi H-S, Thompson L (2005) Old wine in a new bottle: Impact of membership change on group creativity. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 98: 121-132.

Moreland RL, Levine JM (1989) Newcomers and oldtimers in small groups. In: Paulis PB, editor. Psychology of Group Influence. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. pp. 143-186.

Edmondson AC, Nembhard IM (2009) Product development and learning in project teams: The challenges are the benefits. Journal of Product Innovation Management 26: 123-138.

Goodman PS, Garber S (1988) Absenteeism and accidents in a dangerous environment: Empirical analysis of underground coal mines. Journal of Applied Psychology 73: 81-86.

Huckman RS, Staats BR, Upton DM (2009) Team familiarity, role eperience, and performance: Evidence from Indian software services. Management Science 55: 85-100.

Ostrom E, Burger J, Field C, Norgaard R, Policansky D (1999) Revisiting the commons: Local lessons, global challenges. Science 284: 278-282.

Speck FG, Hadlock WS (1946) A report on tribal boundaries and hunting areas of the Malecite Indian of New Brunswick. American Anthropologist 48: 355-374.

Akgün AE, Lynn GS (2002) Antecedents and consequences of team stability on new product development performance. Journal of Engineering and Technology Management 19: 263-286.

Moreland RL, Levine JM (2002) Socialization and trust in work groups. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 5: 185-201.

Dineen BR, Noe RA (2003) The Impact of team fluidity and its implications for human resource management research and practice. . In: Martocchio JJ, Ferris GR, editors. Research in personnel and human resources management. Oxford, UK: JAI Press. pp. 1-37.

Marks MA, Mathieu JE, Zaccaro SJ (2001) A temporally based framework and taxonomy of team processes. Academy of Management Review 26: 356-376.

Cason TN, Sheremeta RM, Zhang J (2012) Communication and efficiency in competitive coordination games. Games & Economic Behavior 76: 26-43.

van der Vegt GS, Bunderson S, Kuipers B (2010) Why turnover matters in self-managing work teams: Learning, social integration, and task flexibility. Journal of Management 36: 1168-1191.

Hornsey MJ, Grice T, Jetten J, Paulsen N, Callan V (2007) Group-directed criticisms and recommendations for change: Why newcomers arouse more resistance than old-timers. Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin 33: 1036-1048.

Kiffin-Petersen S (2004) Trust: A neglected variable in team effectiveness research. Journal of Management & Organization 10: 38-53.

Robinson SL (1996) Trust and breach of the psychological contract. Administrative Science Quarterly 41: 574-599.

Weber RA (2006) Managing growth to achieve efficient coordination in large groups. American Economic Review 96: 114-126.

Franzen A (1995) Group size and one-shot collective action. Rationality & Society 7: 183-200.

Olson M (1995) The logic of the collective action. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Dirks KT (1999) The effects of interpersonal trust on work group performance. Journal of Applied Psychology 84: 445-455.

Brodbeck FC, Greitemeyer T (2000) Effects of individual versus mixed individual and group experience in rule induction on group member learning and group performance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 36: 621-648.

Cason TN, Savikhin AC, Sheremeta RM (2012) Behavioral spillovers in coordination games. European Economic Review 56: 233-245.

Finkel EJ, Cambell WK, Brunell AB, Dalton AN, Scarbeck SJ, et al. (2006) High-maintenance interaction: Inefficient social coordination impairs self-regulation. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology 91: 456-475.

Knez M, Camerer C (2000) Increasing cooperation in prisoner's dilemmas by establishing a precedent of efficiency in coordination games. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes 82: 194-216.

Zellmer-Bruhn ME (2003) Interruptive events and team knowledge acquisition. Management Science 49: 514-528.

Camerer C, Knez M (1997) Coordination in organizations: A game-theoretic perspective. In: Shapira Z, editor. Organizational decision making. New York: Cambridge University Press. pp. 158-191.

Schnake ME (1991) Equity in effort: The 'sucker effect' in co-acting groups. Journal of Management 17: 41-54.

Lewicki RJ, Tomlinson EC, Gillespie N (2006) Models of interpersonal trust development: Theoretical approaches, empirical evidence, and future directions. Journal of Management 32: 991-1022.

Sniezek JA, May DR, Sawyer JE (1990) Social uncertainty and interdependence: A study of resource allocation decisions in groups. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes 46: 155-180.

Bottom WP (1998) Negotiator Risk: Sources of Uncertainty and the Impact of Reference Points on Negotiated Agreements. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes 76: 89-112.

Gulati R (1995) Does familiarity breed trust? The implications of repeated ties for contractual choice in alliances. Academy of Management Journal 38: 85-112.

Jones GR, George JM (1998) The experience and evolution of trust: Implications for cooperation and teamwork. Academy of Management Review 23: 531-546.

Kollock P (1994) The emergence of exchange structures: An experimental study of uncertainty, commitment, and trust. American Journal of Sociology 100: 313-345.

McCarter MW, Mahoney JT, Northcraft GB (2011) Testing the waters: Using collective real options to managed the social dilemma of strategic alliances. Academy of Management Review 36: 621-640.

Jarvenpaa SL, Leidner DE (1999) Communication and trust in global virtual teams. Organization Science 10: 791-815.

Crawford V (1998) A survey of experiments on communication via cheap talk. Journal of Economic Theory 78: 286-298.

Kramer RM, Wei J (1999) Social uncertainty and the problem of trust in social groups: The social self in doubt. In: Tyler TR, Kramer RM, John OP, editors. The psychology of the social self. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. pp. 145-168.

Ho T-H, Weigelt K (2005) Trust building among strangers. Management Science 51: 519-530.

Madsen TL, Mosakowski E, Zaheer S (2003) Knowledge retention and personnel mobility: The nondisruptive effects of inflows of experience. Organization Science 14: 173-191.

Kollock P (1998) Social dilemmas: The anatomy of cooperation. Annual Review of Sociology 24: 183-214.

Poppo L, Zhou KZ, Sungmin R (2008) Alternative Origins to Interorganizational Trust: An Interdependence Perspective on the Shadow of the Past and the Shadow of the Future. Organization Science 19: 39-55.

Bechky BA, Okhuysen GA (2009) Coordination in organizations: An integrative perspective. Academy of Management Annals 3: 463-502.

Colquitt JA (2008) From the editors: Publishing laboratory research in AMJ: A question of when, not if. Academy of Management Journal 51: 616-620.

Creswell JW (2003) Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Huyck JBV, Battalio RC, Beil RO (1990) Tacit coordination games, Strategic uncertainty, and coordination failure. American Economic Review 80: 234-248.

Skyrms B (2004) The stag hunt and evolution of social structure. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

McCarter MW, Bonner BL (2013) Glad tidings and grave warnings: The role of advice on cooperation in public goods dilemmas with value uncertainty. Organization Management Journal: in press.

Knez M, Camerer C (1994) Creating expectational assets in the laboratory: Coordination in 'weakest- link' games. Strategic Management Journal 15: 101-119.

Weber R, Camerer C, Rottenstreich Y, Knez M (2001) The illusion of leadership: Misattribution of cause in coordination games. Organization Science 12: 582-598.

McCarter MW, Northcraft GB (2007) Happy together?: Insights and implications of viewing managed supply chains as a social dilemma. Journal of Operations Management 25: 498-511.

Fawcett SE, Magnan G, McCarter MW (2008) Supply chain alliances and social dilemmas: Bridging the barriers that impede collaboration. International Journal of Procurement Management 1: 318–342.

Fischbacher U (2007) Z-tree: Zurich toolbox for ready-made economic experiments. Experimental Economics 10: 171-178.

Friedman D, Sunder S (1994) Experimental methods: A primer for economics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Sally DF (1995) Conversation and cooperation in social dilemmas: Experimental evidence from 1958 to 1992. Rationality & Society 7: 58-92.

Frank RH, Gilovich T, Regan DT (1993) Does studying economics inhibit cooperation? The Journal of Economic Perspectives 7: 159-171.

Bettenhausen KL, Murnighan JK (1991) The development of an intragroup norm and the effects of interpersonal and structural challenges. Administrative Science Quarterly 36: 20-35.

Choi H-S, Levine JM (2004) Minority influence in work teams: The impact of newcomers. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 40: 273-280.

Kenny DA, Kashy DA, Bolger N (1998) Data analysis in social psychology. In: Gilbert DT, Fiske ST, Lindzey G, editors. Handbook of Social Psychology. 4th ed. Boston: McGraw-Hill. pp. 233-265.

Winer BJ (1962) Statistical principles in experimental design. New York: NY: McGraw-Hill.

Campion MA, Papper EM, Medsker GJ (1996) Relations between work team characteristics and effectiveness: A replication and extension. Personnel Psychology 49: 429-452.

Ballinger GA (2004) Using generalized estimating equations for longitudinal data analysis. Organizational Research Methods 7: 127–150.

Marques JM, Yzerbyt VY (1988) The black sheep effect: Judgmental extremity towards ingroup members in inter- and intra-group situations. European Journal of Social Psychology 18: 287-292.

Marques JM, Paez D (1994) The "black sheep effect": Social categorization, rejection of ingroup deviates, and perception of group variability. In: Stroebe W, Hewstone M, editors. European review of social psychology. Chichester, UK: Wiley. pp. 38-68.

Hogg M, Fielding KS, Darley J (2005) Fringe dwellers: Processes of deviance and marginalization in groups. In: Abrams D, Hogg M, Marques JM, editors. The social psychology of inclusion and exclusion. New York: Psychology Press. pp. 191-211.

Gratton L, Erickson TJ (2007) Eight ways to build collaborative teams. Harvard Business Review 85: 100-109.

Taylor M, Ward H (1982) Chickens, whales, and lumpy goods: Alternative models of public-goods provision. Political Studies 30: 350-370.

Krishnamurthy S (2001) The effect of provision points on generic advertising funding. Marketing Letters 12: 315-325.

McCarter MW, Rockmann KW, Northcraft GB (2010) Is it even worth it? The effect of loss prospects in the outcome distribution of a public goods dilemma. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes 111: 1-11.

Lomborg B (1996) Nucleus and shield: The evolution of social structure in the iterated prisoner's dilemma. American Sociological Review 61: 278-307.

Bottom WP, Gibson K, Daniels SE, Murnighan JK (2002) When talk is not cheap: Substantive penance and expressions of intent in rebuilding cooperation. Organization Science 13: 497-513.

Brandts J, Charness G (2003) Truth or consequences: An experiment. Management Science 49: 116-130.

Schniter E, Sheremeta RM, Sznycer D (2013) Building and rebuilding trust with promises and apologies. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization: in press.