Measuring Performance of Exchange Traded Funds

Hassine, Marlène and Roncalli, Thierry (2013): Measuring Performance of Exchange Traded Funds.

Abstract

Fund selection is an important issue for investors. This topic has spawned abundant academic literature. Nonetheless, most of the time, these works concern only active management, whereas many investors, such as institutional investors, prefer to invest in index funds. The tools developed in the case of active management are also not suitable for evaluating the performance of these index funds. This explains why information ratios are usually used to compare the performance of passive funds. However, we show that this measure is not pertinent, especially when the tracking error volatility of the index fund is small. The objective of an exchange traded fund (ETF) is precisely to offer an investment vehicle that presents a very low tracking error compared to its benchmark. In this paper, we propose a performance measure based on the value-at-risk framework, which is perfectly adapted to passive management and ETFs. Depending on three parameters (performance difference, tracking error volatility and liquidity spread), this efficiency measure is easy to compute and may help investors in their fund selection process. We provide some examples, and show how liquidity is more of an issue for institutional investors than retail investors.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Passive management; index fund; ETF; information ratio; tracking error; liquidity; spread; value-at-risk
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G11 - Portfolio Choice ; Investment Decisions

References

Amenc N. and Martellini L. (2002), The Brave New World of Hedge Fund Indices, EDHEC-Risk Working paper.

Barras L., Scaillet O. and Wermers R. (2010), False Discoveries in Mutual Fund Performance: Measuring Luck in Estimated Alphas, Journal of Finance, 65(1), pp. 179-216.

Bawa V.S. (1975), Optimal Rules for Ordering Uncertain Prospects, Journal of Financial Economics, 2(1), pp. 95-121.

Beasley J.E., Meade N. and Chang T.-J. (2003), An Evolutionary Heuristic for the Index Tracking Problem, European Journal of Operational Research, 148(3), pp. 621-643.

Blake C.R., Elton E.J. and Gruber M.J. (1993), The Performance of Bond Mutual Funds, Journal of Business, 66(3), pp. 371-403.

Bernstein P.L. (1992), Capital Ideas: The Improbable Origins of Modern Wall Street, Free Press.

Bernstein P.L. (2007), Capital Ideas Evolving, John Wiley \& Sons.

Carhart M.M. (1997), On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance, Journal of Finance, 52(1), pp. 57-82.

Dieterlen R. and Hereil P. (2012), Index Arbitrage Explained, Journal of Indexes Europe, 2(6), pp. 18-23.

Elton E.J., Gruber M.J., Das S. and Hlavka M. (1993), Efficiency with Costly Information: A Reinterpretation of Evidence from Managed Portfolios, Review of Financial Studies, 6(1), pp. 1-22.

Elton E.J., Gruber M.J. and Busse J.A. (2004), Are Investors Rational? Choices among Index Funds, Journal of Finance, 59(1), pp. 261-288.

Estrada J. (2007), Mean-semivariance Behavior: Downside Risk and Capital Asset Pricing, International Review of Economics and Finance, 16(2), pp. 169-185.

Fishburn P.C. (1977), Mean-Risk Analysis with Risk Associated with Below-Target Returns, American Economic Review, 67(1), pp. 116-126.

Gastineau G.L. (2002), Equity Index Funds Have Lost Their Way, Journal of Portfolio Management, 28(2), pp. 55-64.

Gastineau G.L. (2004), The Benchmark Index ETF Performance Problem, Journal of Portfolio Management, 30(2), pp. 96-103.

Grinblatt M. and Titman S. (1989), Portfolio Performance Evaluation: Old Issues and New Insights, Review of Financial Studies, 2(3), pp. 393-421.

Grinold R.C. and Kahn R.N. (2000), Active Portfolio Management: A Quantitative Approach for Providing Superior Returns and Controlling Risk, Second edition, McGraw-Hill.

Harlow W.V. (1991), Asset Allocation in a Downside-Risk Framework, Financial Analysts Journal, 47(5), pp. 28-40.

Jensen M.C. (1968), The Performance of Mutual Funds in the Period 1945-1964, Journal of Finance, 23(2), pp. 389-416.

Jorion P. (2003), Portfolio Optimization with Tracking-Error Constraints, Financial Analysts Journal, 59(5), pp. 70-82.

Markowitz H. (1952), Portfolio Selection, Journal of Finance, 7(1), pp. 77-91.

Markowitz H. (1959), Portfolio Selection: Efficient Diversification of Investments, John Wiley & Sons.

McNeil A.J. and Frey R. (2000), Estimation of Tail-related Risk Measures for Heteroscedastic Financial Time Series: An Extreme Value Approach, Journal of Empirical Finance, 7(3-4), pp. 271-300.

Nawrocki D.N. (1999), A Brief History of Downside Risk Measures, Journal of Investing, 8(3), pp. 9-25.

Pope P.F. and Yadav P.K. (1994), Discovering Errors in Tracking Error, Journal of Portfolio Management, 20(2), pp. 27-32.

Prigent J.-L. (2007), Portfolio Optimization and Performance Analysis, Chapman \& Hall.

Roll R. (1992), A Mean/Variance Analysis of Tracking Error, Journal of Portfolio Management, 18(4), pp. 13-22.

Sharpe W.F. (1964), Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium under Conditions of Risk, Journal of Finance, 19(3), pp. 425-442.

Tobin J. (1958), Liquidity Preference as Behavior Towards Risk, Review of Economic Studies, 25(2), pp. 65-86.