Recent findings regarding the shift from direct to indirect taxation in the EA-17

Bernardi, LUIGI (2013): Recent findings regarding the shift from direct to indirect taxation in the EA-17. Forthcoming in: Rivista di diritto finanziario e scienza delle finanze No. 2013/2

Abstract

The relative merits of direct vs. indirect taxes have been largely debated since the advent of public finance theory. The current phase of the discussion concerns the relative ability of these two kinds of taxes to creating a more growth-friendly environment. The prevailing view favours indirect taxation, and suggests a shift of the fiscal burden towards indirect taxes, especially those on consumption. We shall be looking only briefly at this last question, as this paper has two other principal aims. The first aim is to evaluate the entity of the said tax shift over the last decade across Euro Area (EA-17) member countries. Our conclusion is that a “true” tax shift has not been as widespread and large as the EU Commission believes. Secondly, among the most widely-debated issues concerning the tax shift, we are going to examine the contrasting short-term impacts on the economy resulting from it, and we shall outline the possible risk that, in the short term, this tax shift may exacerbate the economic slump spreading across the European Union, particularly as an effect of the general adoption of restrictive fiscal policies by almost all member countries

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Direct taxes, indirect taxes, Euro Area
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue

References

ALBI, E., AND MARTINEZ, J.M., The Elgar guide to taxation, Northampton, Edwar Elgar.

BERNARDI, L., 2004, “Rationale and open issues of more radical reforms”, in BERNARDI, L., AND PROFETA, P., Tax Systems and Reforms in Europe, London and New York, Routledge: 30 -54.

BERNARDI, L., 2011, “Economic crisis and taxation in Europe”, Rivista di Diritto Finanziario e Scienza delle Finanze, Vol. LXX (2): 175-211.

BERNARDI, L., 2012, “Heterogeneity of taxation in EA member countries and some implications for EA fiscal governance”, Rivista di Diritto Finanziario e Scienza delle Finanze, Vol. LXXI (2): 212-236.

BOADWAY, R., 2012, The From optimal tax theory to tax policy. Retrospective and perspective, views, London: The MIT Press.

BOCCONI UNIVERSITY - ECONPUBBLICA, 2011, The role and impacts of labour taxation policies, Milano, Bocconi University.

BLANCHARD, O. AND LEIGH, D., 2013, Growth forecast error and fiscal multipliers, IMF WP/13/1, Washington, D.C.: The IMF.

CAPRIOLI, F. AND MOMIGLIANO, S., 2012, The effects of fiscal shocks with debt-stabilizing budgetary policies in Italy, Rome: Department of Treasury, Ministry of Economy and Finance.

CNOSSEN, S., 2002, “Tax policy in the European Union: A review of issues and options” FinanzArchiv, (4): 1-93.

COENEN, G. ET AL., 2012, “Effects of fiscal stimulus in structural models”, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 4 (1): 22-68.

ECB, 2004, The short term impact of government budgets on prices. Evidences from macroeconomic models, WP n. 396, Frankfurt: The European Central Bank.

EU COMMISSION, 2010, “The impact of fiscal consolidation on European economic outlook”, European Economic Forecast, Autumn 2010, Brussels, The European Commission: 32-47.

EU COMMISSION, 2011, Taxation papers. Tax reforms in EU member states, WP n. 28, Brussels: The EU Commission.

EU COMMISSION, 2012a, Taxation trends in the European Union, Brussels: The EU Commission.

EU COMMISSION, 2012b, Ameco data bank. Data 1995-2014, Brussels: The EU Commission.

FAIR, R.C., 2011, “Possible macroeconomics consequences of large future federal government deficits”, in J.R. Brown (ED.), Tax policy and the economy, 25, The University of Chicago Press for the NBER: 89-108.

GRAVELLE, J.C. AND HUNGERFORD, T.L., 2011, Can contractionary fiscal policy be expansionary?, Washington: Congressional Research Service.

HEPPKE-FALK, K., ET AL., 2006, The macroeconomic effects of exogenous fiscal policy in Germany: A disaggregated SVAR analysis, Discussion Paper n. 41/2006, Frankfurt: The Bundesbank.

IMF, 2010, “Will it hurt? Macroeconomic effects of fiscal consolidations”, Word Economic Outlook, Washington: The IMF, October.

JOHANSSON, A. ET AL, 2008, Taxes and economic growth, OECD Economic Dept. Working Papers n. 620, Paris: The OECD.

JOHNSON, P. AND MYLES, G. (EDS), 2011, “Special issue on the Mirrlees review”, Fiscal Studies, 32 (3): 319-452.

KAPLOW, L., 2011, The theory of taxation and public economics, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

MUSGRAVE, R.A, 1969, Fiscal systems, New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

MYLES, G.D., 2009, Economic growth and the role of taxation, OECD Economic Department, WP n. 714, Paris: The OECD.

OECD, 2010a, Tax policy reform and economic growth, OECD tax policy studies n. 20, Paris: The OECD.

OECD, 2010b, Taxing wages: 2008-2009, Paris: The OECD.

PISAURO, G., 2012, “I conti pubblici sull’altalena dello spread”, in A. ZANARDI (ED), La finanza pubblica italiana. Rapporto 2012, Bologna, ilMulino: 17-46.

SALANIÉ, B., 2011, The economics of taxation, 2nd ed, London: The MIT Press.

STEVE, S., 1976, Lezioni di scienza delle finanze, 6a ed, Padova: CEDAM.

TANZI, V., 2011,”Tax systems in the OECD: recent evolution, competition and convergence”, in E. ALBI AND J. MARTINEZ-VAZQUEZ, 2011: 11-36.

VVAA, 2011, “Forum: What is the size of the multiplier?” Journal of Economic Literature, XLIX (3): 673-751.