A reconstructive critique of IPE and GPE from a critical scientific realist perspective: An alternative Keynesian-Kaleckian approach

Khan, Haider and Patomäki, Heikki (2013): A reconstructive critique of IPE and GPE from a critical scientific realist perspective: An alternative Keynesian-Kaleckian approach.

Abstract

This paper offers, first, a critique of the relative lack of economic theory in ‘British’ Global Political Economy and then use of neoclassical rational choice theory in American mainstream IPE from the perspective of critical scientific realism. Keynesian economic theories provide perhaps the most obvious alternative. Keynes’ General Theory has been followed by many, forming also the basis of Minsky’s long ignored but now, after the 2008-9 crisis, all of a sudden famous explorations on the mechanisms of financial markets. While a major leap forward, we argue that these theories are historically and conceptually limited. Keynes’ critique of neoclassical economic theory and his alternative theories of particularly the effective demand and of money and credit can be strengthened by following also a neo-Kaleckian approach which avoids some of the inconsistencies of neo-Keynesianism. We indicate where further conceptual work is required and provide several illustrations from the neo-Kaleckian and neo-Keynesian theory to suggest a partial agenda of further scientific work including the explanation of unnecessary and undesired global fluctuations, tendencies and crises and possible collective responses to them. We also suggest the possibility of going beyond Keynes and Kalecki in terms of a general field theory of global political economy that can accommodate the deep normative and institutional underpinnings of the historically evolving planetary political economy.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Financial Crisis; Policy Space; Keynes; Kalecki; Minsky
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance; F - International Economics > F6 - Economic Impacts of Globalization

References

Arestis, P. and Driver, C. 1987. “The Effects of Income Distribution on Consumer Imports”. Journal of Macroeconomics 9 (1): 83-94.

Arestis, P. and Eichner, A.S. 1988. “The Post-Keynesian and Institutionalist Theory of Money and Credit”. Journal of Economic Issues 22 (4): 1003-1033. Arrow, Kenneth and Frank Hahn. 1971. General Competitive Analysis. Amsterdam, North Holland.

Asimakopulos, A. 1975. “A Kaleckian Theory of Income Distribution”. Canadian Journal of Economics 8(3): 313-333. Asimakopulos, A. 1989. “Kalecki and Robinson”. In M. Sebastiani,ed. Kalecki’s Relevance Today. London: St. Martin’s Press: 10-24.

Ball, R.J. 1964. Inflation and the Theory of Money. London: Allen and Unwin.

Baran, P. 1957. The Political Economy of Growth. New York: Monthly Review

Basile, L. and Salvadori, N. 1984-85. “Kalecki’s Pricing Theory”. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 7 (2): 249-262. Best, Jacqueline. 2008. Ambiguity, Uncertainty, and Risk: Rethinking Indeterminacy, International Political Sociology, 2 (4): 355-74.

Bhaduri, A. and Marglin, S. 1990. “Unemployment and the Real Wage: The Economic Basis for Contesting Political Ideologies”. Cambridge Journal of Economics 14 (4): 375-393.

Bhaskar, Roy. 1997. A Realist Theory of Science. London: Verso, originally published in 1975.

Bohm, David. 2002. Wholeness and the Implicate Order. London: Routledge (Classics), originally published in 1980.

Bourdieu, Pierre. 1968. “Intellectual Field and Creative Project”. Social Science Information 8 (2): 89-119.

Bourdieu, Pierre. 1977. Outline of a Theory of Practice. Translated by R. Nice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Bourdieu, Pierre. 1993. Sociology in Question. Translated by R. Nice. London: Sage.

Bourdieu, Pierre. 1998. Practical Reason. On the Theory of Action. Translated by R. Nice, Gisele Shapiro et.al. Cambridge: Polity.

Bourdieu, P. and L.J.D. Wacquant. 1992. An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press

Bowles, Samuel. 2008. “Policies Designed for Self-Interested Citizens May Undermine ‘The Moral Sentiments’: Evidence from Economic Experiments”. Science, (320): 1605-9.

Bowles, Samuel & Gintis, Herbert. 1993. “A Political and Economic Case for the Democratic Enterprise”. Economics & Philosophy, 9 (1): 75-100.

Boyd, R. 1984, “The Current Status of Scientific Realism”, in J. Leplin edition. Scientific Realism, Berkeley: University of California Press.

Carson, J. 1994. ‘Existence and Uniqueness of Solution to Kalecki’s Pricing Equations’. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 16 (3): 411-434.

Chang, Ha-Joon. 2008. Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capitalism. New York: Bloomsbury Press.

-------2002. Kicking away the Ladder: Development Strategy in Historical Perspective. London, UK; Anthem Press, 1st ed.

Cohen, Benjamin J. 2008a. “The Transatlantic Divide: A Rejoinder”. Review of International Political Economy, 15 (1): 30-34.

Cohen, Benjamin J. 2008b. International Political Economy. An Intellectual History. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Cowling, K. 1982. Monopoly Capitalism. London: Macmillan

Cowling, K. 1985. ‘Economic Obstacles to Democracy’. In R.C.O. Matthews (ed.). Economy and Democracy. London: Macmillan.

Cowling. K. and Waterson, M. 1976. “Price-cost Margins and Market Structure”. Economica 43 (171): 267-274.

Cox, Robert W. 1981. “Social Forces, States and World Orders: Beyond International Relations Theory”. Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 10 (2): 126-155.

Cox, Robert W. 1983. “Gramsci, Hegemony and International Relations”. Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 12 (2): 397-401.

Cox, Robert W. 1987. Production, Power and World Order: Social Forces in the Making of History. New York: Columbia University Press.

Cox, Robert W. 1996. Approaches to World Order. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Crocco, Marco. 2002. “The Concept of Degrees of Uncertainty in Keynes, Shackle, and Davidson”. Nova Economia Belo Horizonte, 12 (2): 11-27.

Davidson, Paul. 1992. “The Asimakopulos View of Keynes’s General Theory”. Paper read at the conference on Employment, Distribution and Markets. Levy Institute, Bard College, New York: 24-26.

Davidson, Paul. 1992-93. “Reforming the World’s Money”. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 15 (2): 153-179.

Dymski, Gary A.1996 “Kalecki’s Monetary Economics”, pp. 115-140 in J. E. King ed. An Alternative Macroeconomic Theory: The Kaleckian Model and Post-Keynesian Economics, Doedrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

FitzGerald, E.V.K. 1979. The Political Economy of Peru 1956-78. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Eichner, A.S. 1976. The Megacorp and Oligopoly: Micro Foundations of Macro Dynamics. Cambridge: Cambridge University press.

Flassbeck, Heiner. 2004. “Saving, Investment and Government Deficits: A Modern Kaleckian Approach”, pp. 125-142 in Z. Sadowski and A. Szeworski, eds. Kalecki’s Economics Today, London: Routledge.

Gill, Stephen. 1990. American Hegemony and the Trilateral Commission. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Gill, Stephen. 1991. “Reflections on Global Order and Sociohistorical Time”. Alternatives, 16 (3): 275-314.

Gill, Stephen ed. 1993. Gramsci, Historical Materialism and International Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Gill, Stephen. 2008. Power and Resistance in the New World Order. 2nd edition, fully revised and updated. Houndmills, Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.

Gill, Stephen and David Law. 1988. Global Political Economy. Perspectives, Problems and Policies. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Gillies, Donald. 2006. “Keynes and Probability”, pp.199-216 in R. Backhouse and B. Bateman (eds): The Cambridge Companion to Keynes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Harcourt, G.C. 1965. “A Two-sector Model of the Distribution of Income and the Level of Employment in the Short Run”. Economic Record 41 (93): 103-117.

Harcourt, G.C. 1991. “Review of Collected Works of Michal Kalecki, Volume I: Capitalism, Business Cycles and Full Employment”, ed. by Jerzy Osiatynski. Economic Journal, 101 (409): 1608-1610.

Harré, Rom, and E.H. Madden. 1975. Causal Powers. Oxford: Blackwell.

Hull, David L.1988. Science as a Process. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Hull, David L. 1999 The Use and Abuse of Sir Karl Popper. Biology and Philosophy, 14: 481-504.

Jameson , K. P. 1980 “An intermediate regime in historical context: the case of Guyana”. Development and Change 11 (??): 77–95.

Kaldor, Nicholas. 1980. Essays on Economic Stability and Growth, London: Duckworth.

Kalecki, Michał. 1938. “The Determinants of Distribution of National Income”, CW II: 3-20, 479-516.

Kalecki, Michał. 1939a. Essays in the Theory of Economic Fluctuations, London: Allen & Unwin, CW I: 233-318, 510-57.

Kalecki, Michał. 1939b. ‘‘Money and Real Wages’, CW II: 21-50, 516-21

Kalecki, Michał. 1940. “Wage Bill and Cash Circulation”, CW VII: 38-44, 509.

Kalecki, Michał. 1943. “Political Aspects of Full Employment”. Political Quarterly, 14 (4): 322-31.

Kalecki, Michał. 1944a. ‘Professor Pigou on “The Classical Stationary State”: A Comment’. Economic Journal 54 (1): 131-2.

Kalecki, Michał. 1946. “Multilateralism and Full Employment”. Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 12(3), August: 322-327.

Kalecki, Michał. 1954. Theory of Economic Dynamics: An Essay on Cyclical and Long-run Changes in Capitalist Economy. London: Allen and Unwin.

Kalecki, Michał. 1954a. Theory of Economic Dynamics: An Essay on Cyclical and Long-Run Changes in Capitalist Economy, London: Allen & Unwin, CW II: 205-348, 550-77.

Kalecki, Michał. 1954b. “The Problem of Financing of Economic Development”, CW V: 23-44, 206-8.

Kalecki, Michał. 1966. ‘Money and Real Wages’. In M. Kalecki, Studies in the Theory of Business Cycles. Oxford: Blackwell: 40-71.

Kalecki, Michał. 1969 Introduction to the theory of growth in a socialist economy. Oxford: Blackwell .

Kalecki, Michał. 1970. “Theories of Growth in Different Social Systems”. Scientia 105: 311-16.

Kalecki, Michał. 1971. “Class Struggle and Distribution of National Income”. Kyklos 24 (1): 1-9.

Kalecki, Michał. 1972 Selected Essays on the Economic Growth of the Socialist and the Mixed Economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kalecki, Michał and Schumacher, E.F. 1943. ‘International Clearing and Long-Term Lending’. Bulletin of the Oxford Institute of Statistics 5, Supplement, August: 29-33.

Keen, Steve. 2001. Debunking Economics. The Naked Emperor of the Social Sciences. London: Zed Books.

Keene, Ian. 2004. Aboriginal Economy and Society: Australia at the threshold of Colonisation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Keynes, J.M. 1936. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money. London: Macmillan.

Keynes, John Maynard. 1961. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money. London: MacMillan, originally published in 1936.

Keynes, John Maynard. 1980. “Proposals for an International Currency Union,” pp. in J.M.Keynes, The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes vol.XXV. London, MacMillan, originally 1941

Khan Haider A.1982. “Modeling Energy, Technology and Income Distribution”, in A. Hamza ed. Applied Simulation and Modeling, Calgary, Canada: ACTA Press.

Khan Haider A.1983. Technology, Energy, Distribution and Balance of Payments, unpublished Dissertation, Cornell University

Khan Haider A. 1997. Technology, Energy and Development: The South Korean Transition. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

Khan Haider A. 1998. Technology, Development and Democracy: Limits to National Innovation Systems in the Age of Postmodernism. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

Khan Haider A. 2002a. “Innovation and Growth in a Schumpeterian Model”. Oxford Development Studies 30 (3): 289-306.

Khan, Haider A. 2002b. “The Extended Panda's Thumb and a New Global Financial Architecture”, August 2002. University of Tokyo CIRJE, Graduate School of Economics Discussion Paper, available at http://www.e.utokyo.ac.jp/cirje/index.htm. Khan, Haider A. 2002c. “On Paradigms, Theories and Models”. IDEAS Paper, available at http://ideas.repec.org/e/pkh22.html.

Khan Haider A. 2004a. Innovation and Growth in East Asia: The Future of Miracles. Houndsmills and New York: Macmillan/Palgrave.

Khan Haider A. 2004b. Global Markets and Financial Crisis in Asia: Towards a Theory for the Twenty First Century. Houndsmills and New York: Macmillan/Palgrave.

Khan, H.A.2006 “Trade Liberalization and Poverty Reduction in CGE Models: The Dual-Dual Approach”, pp.?? in J. Weiss and H. Khan, eds., Poverty Strategies in Asia, E.Elgar, 2006.

Khan Haider A. 2008a. “Building an Innovative Economy through Managed Creative Destruction: A Theory with Applications to South Korea”. Accessed April 2008 at http://econpapers.repec.org/paper/pramprapa/7713.htm

Khan Haider A. 2008b. “Making Globalization Work: Towards Global Economic Justice”. Cosmopolis, May 2008, available at http://ideas.repec.org/p/pra/mprapa/7864.html

Khan , Haider A. 2008c. “Causal Depth contra Humean Empiricism: Aspects of a Scientific Realist Approach to Explanation”. On line Paper in IDEAS and MPRA, available at ??.

Khan , Haider A. 2009. “Towards A Kaleckian Approach to IPE and GPE: A Short Preliminary Note”, unpublished paper, JKSIS, University of Denver.

Khan , Haider A. and M. Irafn. 2010. “A Critical Look at the Use of International Trade Theory in IPE”. A paper presented at the ISA conference, New Orleans, La. USA, Feb. 17, 2010.

Kitcher, Philip. 2001. Science, Truth and Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kriesler, P. 1987. Kalecki’s Microanalysis: The Development of Kalecki’s Analysis of Pricing and Distribution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kurki, Milja. 2006. “The Causes of a Dividing Discipline”. Review of International Studies, 32 (2): 189-216.

Kurki, Milja. 2008. Causation in International Relations: Reclaiming Causal Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lawson, Tony. 2003. “Keynes’ Realist Orientation”, pp. 159-69 in The Philosophy of Keynes’s Economics. Probability, Uncertainty and Convention, ed. by Jochen Runde and Sohei Mizuhara. London: Routledge.

Levine, D.P. 1982. “Determinants of Capitalist Expansion”, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 30 (2): 299-320.

Levine, D.P. .1986. “A Note on Wage Determination and capital accumulation”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 8 (3) :463-477.

Lin, C.-S., H.A. Khan, R.-Y. Chang and Y.-C. Wang. 2008. A New Approach to Modeling Early Warning Systems for Financial Crises, Journal of International Money and Finance, ?? (??) Oct.: 1098-1121.

Lipietz, Alain. 1996. “Social Europe: The Post-Maastrichtian Challenge”. Review of International Political Economy, 3 (3): 369-379.

Lizardo, Omar. 2004. “The Cognitive Origins of Bourdieu’s Habitus”. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 34 (4): 375-401.

Marx, Karl. 1973. Grundrisse. Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy (Rough Draft). Translated by Martin Nicolaus. London: Penguin Books (in association with New Left Review), first published 1939.

Marx, Karl. 1991. Capital Vol. III. Translated by David Fernbach. London: Penguin Classics, first published in 1894. McCartney, Matthew and Barbara Harriss-White. 2000. “Intermediate Regime and Intermediate Classes Revisited: A Critical Political Economy of Indian Economic Development from 1980 to Hindutva” Queen Elizabeth House Working Paper No. 34 Oxford: Queen Elizabeth House http://www3.qeh.ox.ac.uk/RePEc/qeh/qehwps/qehwps34.pdf McCloskey, Donald. 1986. The Rhetoric of Economics. Brighton: Wheatsheaf.

Miller, R.1987. Fact and Method, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Minsky, Hyman. 1982. Can “It” Happen Again? Essays on Instability and Finance. Armonk, NY: M.E.Sharpe.

Minsky, Hyman. 2008. Stabilizing and Unstable Economy. 2nd edition. New York: McGraw Hill.

Moore, B.J. 1988. Horizontalists and Verticalists: The Macroeconomics of Credit Money. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Morgan, Jamie. 2003. “The Global Power of Orthodox Economics”. Journal of Critical Realism, 1 (2): 7-34.

Mott, Tracy. 2004. “Kalecki’s principle of increasing risk, the distribution of income, and consequences for macroeconomic performance”, pp. 79-86 in Z. Sadowski and A. Szeworski, eds. Kalecki’s Economics Today, London: Routledge.

Myrdal, Gunnar. 1939. Monetary Equilibrium. London: Hodge

Nayyar, Deepak. 2006. “Globalization, history and development”, Cambridge Journal of Economics , 30, 137–159

Nuti, D. Mario. 2004. “Kalecki and Keynes Revisited: Two original approaches to demand-determined income and much more besides”, pp.3-9 in Z. Sadowski and A. Szeworski, eds. Kalecki’s Economics Today, London: Routledge.

O’Hara, Philip. 2006. Growth and Development in the Global Political Economy. Social Structures of Accumulation and Modes of Regulation. London: Routledge.

Pasinetti, L.L. 1974. Growth and Income Distribution: Essays in Economic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Patomäki, Heikki. 2002. After International Relations. Critical Realism and the (Re)Construction of World Politics, London: Routledge.

Patomäki, Heikki. 2003. ”A Critical Realist Approach to Global Political Economy”, pp.197-220 in J.Cruickshank (ed.): Critical Realism: The Difference It Makes, London: Routledge.

Patomäki, Heikki. 2005. “The Long Downward Wave of the World Economy and the Future of Global Conflict”. Globalizations, 2 (1): 61-78.

Patomäki, Heikki. 2008. The Political Economy of Global Security. War, Future Crises and Changes in Global Governance. London: Routledge.

Patomäki, Heikki. 2009. “How to Tell Better Stories about the History and Future of Global Political Economy”, Review of International Political Economy, 16 (2): pp.309-320.

Patomäki, Heikki. 2010. “The Three Fields of Global Political Economy”. A manuscript in progress.

Phillips, Nicola. 2009. “The Slow Death of Pluralism”. Review of International Political Economy, 16 (1): 85-94.

Raj, K. N. 1973. “The Politics and Economics of ‘Intermediate Regimes’”. Economic and Political Weekly, 8 (27): 1189 and 1191-98.

Rescher, Nicholas. 1966. Distributive Justice. A Constructive Critique of the Utilitarian Theory of Distribution. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.

Reynolds, P.J. 1989. “Kaleckian and Post-Keynesian Theories of Pricing: Some Extensions and Implications”. In Arestis and Kitromilides 1990: 229-69.

Robinson, J. 1962. Essays in the Theory of Economic Growth. London: Macmillan.

Robinson, J. 1966. “Kalecki and Keynes”. In Problems of Economic Dynamics and Planning: Essays in Honour of Michal Kalecki. Oxford: Pergamon: 335-41.

Robinson, J. 1977. “Michal Kalecki on the Economics of Capitalism”. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 39 (1): 7-18.

Rowthorn R. 1981. “Demand, Real Wages, and Economic Growth”. Thames Papers in Political Economy. ??? Autumn: 1-39.

Rupert, Mark. 1995. Producing Hegemony. The Politics of Mass Production and American Global Power. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ryner, Magnus. 2002. Capitalist Restructuring, Globalization and the Third Way: Lessons from the Swedish Model. London: Routledge.

Sachs, I. 2004. “Kalecki’s Political Economy of Development of Mixed Economies”, pp. 105-177 in Z. Sadowski and A. Szeworski, eds. Kalecki’s Economics Today, London: Routledge.

Sayer, Andrew. 2003. “(De)commodification, Consumer Culture and Moral Economy”, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 21 (3): 341-57.

Sawyer, M.C. 1985. The Economics of Michal Kalecki. London: Macmillan.

Schumpeter, Joseph. 1939. Business Cycles. Volume 1. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Shaikh, Anwar. 2007. Globalization and the Myth of Free Trade,. London: Routledge

Sloman, John. 1994. Economics. Updated 2nd edition. Prentice Hall: Harvester Wheatsheaf

Steindl, J. 1952. Maturity and Stagnation in American Capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Steindl, J. 1979. “Stagnation Theory and Stagnation Policy”. Cambridge Journal of Economics. 3 (1): 1-14.

Strange, Susan. 2000. “World Order, Non-State Actors, and the Global Casino: The Retreat of the State”, pp.82-90 in Richard Stubbs and Geoffrey R.D.Underhill (eds.): Political Economy and the Changing Global Order. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Swedberg, Richard. 1986. “The Doctrine of Economic Neutrality of the IMF and the World Bank, Journal of Peace Research, 23 (4): ??.

Targetti, F. and Kinda-Hass, B. 1982. “Kalecki’s Review of Keynes’s General Theory”. Australian Economic Papers. 21 (39): 244-260.

Teivainen Teivo. 2002. Enter Economism, Exit Politics. Experts, Economic Policy and the Damage to Democracy. London: Zed Books.

Thirlwall, A.P. 1979. “The Balance of Payments Constraint as an Explanation of International Growth Rate Differences”. Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review. 32 (128): 45-53.

Wade, Robert. 2009. “Beware What You Wish For: Lessons for International Political Economy from the Transformation of Economics”. Review of International Political Economy, 16 (1): 106-21.

Wood, A. 1975. A Theory of Profits. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.