Corporate governance, competition, the new international financial architecture and large corporations in emerging markets

Singh, Ajit and Singh, Alaka and Weisse, Bruce (2002): Corporate governance, competition, the new international financial architecture and large corporations in emerging markets. Published in: Management of Capital Flows: comparative experiences and implications for Africa No. UNCTAD (ed.) (1 April 2003): pp. 1-70.

Abstract

Abstract

This paper examines from the developing countries perspective important analytical and policy issues arising from: a) the current international discussions about corporate governance in relation to the New International Financial Architecture; b) changes in the international competitive environment being caused by the enormous international merger movement in advanced countries.

The background to a) above is the emergence of corporate governance as a key issue in the current G7 proposals for the New International Financial Architecture. The G7 emphasis on corporate governance can be traced back to the thesis that the ‘deeper’ reasons for the Asian crisis lay in the microeconomic behaviour of corporations and businesses in the affected countries. The failings of the corporate governance mechanisms and distortions in the competitive process have received special scrutiny in such analyses.

With respect to b) above, the context is that the largest corporations in advanced countries are currently in the process of potentially cartelising the world market place through a spate of cross-border mergers and take-overs. This huge merger movement raises serious policy concerns for developing countries.

The paper's main conclusions are:

1.The thesis that the deeper causes of the Asian crisis were the flawed systems of corporate governance and a poor competitive environment in the affected countries is not supported by evidence.

2.The Anglo-Saxon model of widely held corporations with dispersed share ownership is by far the exception in developing countries and in much of continental Europe. Empirical evidence suggests that emerging markets, as well as European countries such as Italy, Sweden or Germany have successful records of fast long-term growth with different governance systems, indeed superior to those of Anglo-Saxon countries.

3.Empirical evidence does not support the view that the Asian crisis 1997 to 1999 was caused by crony capitalism.

4.Corporate financing patterns in emerging markets in the 1990s were broadly similar to those observed in the 1980s. Unlike their counterparts in advanced countries, large developing countries firms continued to rely overwhelmingly on external sources to finance their growth of total assets.

5.The analysis of this paper does not support the claim that developing country conglomerates are inefficient, financially precarious and necessarily create moral hazard. It also indicates that contrary to widely held beliefs, product market competition in emerging countries is no less intense than in advanced economies.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Corporate governance, competition, emerging markets
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E0 - General; F - International Economics > F0 - General; F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance; F - International Economics > F4 - Macroeconomic Aspects of International Trade and Finance; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance

References

References

Aichian, AA and Kessel RA (1962) “Competition, monopoly and the pursuit of pecuniary gain”, Aspects of Labor Economics, Conference of the Universities National Bureau Committee for Economic Research, Princeton

Amjad R (1982) Private Industrial Investment in Pakistan: 1960-1970, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Amsden A (1989) Asia’s Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialization, New York: Oxford University Press

Amsden A (2000) The rise of “the rest”: Challenges to the West from late-industrializing economies, Oxford: Oxford University Press

Amsden A and Hikino T (1994) “Project executive capability, organisational know-how and conglomerate corporate growth in late-industrialisation”, Industry and Corporate Change, Vol. 3, No. 1, 111-147

Amsden A and Singh A (1994) “The optimal degree of competition and dynamic efficiency in Japan and Korea” European Economic Review, Vol. 38, No.3/4, 941-951

Aoki M, Kim H-K and Okuno-Fujiwara (eds) (1997) The Role of Government in East Asian Economic Development, Clarendon Press, Oxford

Balasubramanian N (1993) Corporate Financial Policies and Shareholder returns: the Indian Experience, New Delhi: Himalaya Publishing House

Baumol W. et al. (1982) Contestable Markets and the Theory of Industry Structure, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich London and San Diego

Berglof E. and von Thadden L (1999) The Changing Corporate Governance Paradigm: Implications for Transition and Developing Countries, Unpublished Working Paper, Stockholm Institute of Transition Economics, Stockholm, Sweden

Berle A and Means G (1933) The Modern Corporation and Private Capital, New York: Macmillan

Bhinde A (1994) “The hidden cost of stock market liquidity” Journal of Financial Economics, 31-51

Camdessus M (1998) Speech to Transparency International reported in the IMF Survey, 9 February 1988

Chandler AD (1977) The visible hand: The managerial revolution in American business, Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press

Chang, H-J and Park, H-J (2000) 'An Alternative Perspective on Government Policy towards the Chaebol in Korea: Industrial Policy, Financial Regulations, and Political Democracy' in S-H. Jwa & I. Lee (eds.), Korean Chaebol in Transition: Road Ahead and Agenda, Seoul, Korea Economic Research Institute

Claessens S, Djankov S and Lang L (2000) “The separation of ownership and control in East Asian Corporations”, Journal of Financial Economics, vol 58 81-112

Confederation of Indian Industry (1998) Desirable corporate governance: A code, New Delhi: CII

Corbett J and Jenkinson T (1994) The financing of industry, 1970-89: An international comparison, Discussion Paper No. 948, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research

Correa C (1999) "Competition Law and Development Policies", paper presented at the Zurich seminar on issues of international competition

Cosh A, Hughes A and Singh A (1990) “Take-overs and short-termism in the United Kingdom: Analytical and Policy Issues in the U.K. Economy,” Institute for Public Policy Research London

Connolly R and Schwartz S (1985) “The Inter-temporal Behavior of Economic Profits” International Journal of Industrial Organization, 3, 379-400

Feldstein M (1998) “Trying to do too much,” Financial Times, March 3, 1998

Frankel JA (1998) “The Asian Model, The Miracle, The Crisis and The Fund”, Paper delivered at the U.S. International Trade Commission, April 16, 1998

Friedman M (1953) Essays in Positive Economics, University of Chicago Press

Geroski P (1990) Modeling Persistent Profitability, in Mueller 1990

Geroski P and Cubbin J (1987) “The Convergence of Profits in the Long-Run: Inter-Firm and Inter-Industry Comparisons,” Journal of Industrial Economics, Vol. XXXV, 427-442

Geroski P and Jacquemin A (1988) “The Persistence of Profits: A European comparison,” Economic Journal, Vol. 98, 375-389

Glen J, Lee K and Singh A (2000) Competition, corporate governance and financing of corporate growth in emerging markets, Cambridge Discussion Paper in Accounting and Finance No. AF46, Department of Applied Economics, University of Cambridge

Goddard, J A and Wilson J O S (1999) "The persistence of profit: a new empirical interpretation" International Journal of Industrial Organisation, 17 (5) 663-687

Greenspan A (1998) Testimony before the Committee on Banking and Financial Services, US House of Representatives, January 30, 1998

Hughes A (1989) “The Impact of Mergers: A Survey of Empirical Evidence for the UK" 1950-1990” in J. Fairburn and J.A. Kay (eds), Mergers and Merger Policy, 2nd edition, Oxford, 1989

Iskander MR and Chamlou N (2000) Corporate governance: A framework for implementation, The World Bank, Washington DC

Jensen MC (1988) “Take-overs: their causes and consequences,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 2, No. 1 (Winter), 21-48

Jensen M and Meckeling W (1976) “Theory of the firm: Managerial behaviour, agency costs and ownership structure”, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 3, No. 4, 305-60

Johnson S, Boone P, Breach A and Friedman E (2000) “Corporate governance in the Asian financial crisis”, Journal of Financial Economics, vol.58, 141-186

Khanna T (2000) “Business groups and social welfare in emerging markets: Existing evidence and unanswered questions”, European Economic Review 44, 748-761

Khanna T and Palepu K (1997) “Why focused strategies may be wrong for emerging markets” , Harvard Business Review, July-August, Vol 75 (4) 41 - 51

Khanna T and Palepu K (1999) “The right was to restructure conglomerates in emerging markets”, Harvard Business Review, July-August, Vol 8, 271 - 310

Khanna T and Yafeh Y (2000) Business groups and risk sharing around the world, Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Working Paper Series (http://papers.ssrn.com), January 25, 2001

Krause L (2000) “The aftermath of the Asian financial crisis for South Korea”, The Journal of the Korean Economy, Vol. 1, No. 1 (Spring), 1-22

Krugman P (1999) The Return of Depression Economics, Harmondsworth: Penguin

Laffont J (1999) “Competition, Information, and Development”, Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics, 1998, pp. 237-257

La Porta R, Lopez-de-Silanes F and Shleifer A (1999) “Corporate Ownership around the World,” Journal of Finance", 54, pp. 471-517

La Porta R, Lopez-de-Silanes F, Shleifer A and Vishny RW (1997) “Legal Determinants of External Finance,” Journal of Finance, 52, pp. 1131-1150

La Porta R, Lopez-de-Silanes F, Shleifer A and Vishny RW (1998) “Law and Finance”, Journal of Political Economy, 106, pp. 1113-55

La Porta R, Lopez-de-Silanes F, Shleifer A and Vishny RW (1999) “Investor Protection: Origins, Consequences, Reform,” Harvard University, manuscript

La Porta R, Lopez-de-Silanes F, Shleifer A and Vishny RW (2000) “Agency Problems and Dividend Policies Around the World,” Journal of Finance, Vol 58 pp.3-27

Leff N (1979) “Entrepreneurship and Economic Development: The Problem Revisited”, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol.17 (17), pp. 46-64

Leff N (1978) “Industrial Organization and Entrepreneurship in Developing Countries: The Economic Groups”, Economic Development and Cultural Change, vol.4 (26), pp. 661-675

Maddison A (1991) Dynamic forces in capital development: A long-run perspective, Oxford: Oxford University Press

Manne HG (1965) “Mergers and the market for corporate control”, Journal of Political Economy, 73, pp. 693-706

Mayer C (1990) “Financial systems, corporate finance and economic development” in R. Glen Hubbard ed. Asymmetric information, corporate finance and investment, Chicago: University of Chicago Press

Mayya MR (1995) Reflections on the Changing Scenario of the Indian Stock Markets, Bombay: A.D.Shroff Memorial Trust

Mueller D ed. (1990) The Dynamics of Company Profits: An International Comparison, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Mueller D (1986) Profits in the Long Run, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Mueller D and Geroski P (1990) "The Persistence of Profits in Perspective, " in D Mueller ed., The Dynamics of Company Profits: An International Comparison, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.187-204

Myers S and Majluf N (1984) “Corporate Financing and Investment Decisions When Firms Have Information that Investors Do Not Have”, Journal of Financial Economics, 13, (2), pp. 187-221

Odagiri H (1994) Growth Through Competition, Competition Through Growth: Strategic Management and the Economy in Japan, Oxford: Clarendon Press

Peacock A and Bannock G (1991) Corporate take-overs and the public interest, Aberdeen: Aberdeen University press for the David Hume Institute

Phelps ES (1999) “The Global Crisis of Corporatism”, in Wall Street Journal, 25 March, 1999

Pistor K (1999) “Law as a Determinant of Equity Market Development”, Unpublished Working Paper Harvard University, Cambridge, MA

Porter ME (1990) “The Competitive Advantage of Nations”, The Macmillan Press Ltd New York, 1990

Porter ME (1992) “Capital disadvantage: America’s falling capital investment system”, Harvard Business Review, September-October, Vol 70 No. 5, pp. 65-82

Rajan R and Zingales L (1998) “Finance Dependence and Growth,” American Economic Review, June, 88(3), pp. 559-629

Ravenscraft DJ and Scherer FM (1987) Mergers, sell-offs and economic efficiency, Washington DC: Brookings Institution

Scherer FM (1998) “Corporate take-overs: The efficiency argument”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 2, No. 1 (Winter) pp.69 - 82

Shleifer A and Summers L. (1988) “Breach of trust in hostile take-overs” in Alan Auerbach ed. Corporate take-overs: Causes and consequences, Chicago: University of Chicago pp. 33-61

Shleifer A and Vishny RW (1997) “A survey of corporate governance”, Journal of Finance, 52, pp.737-783

Singh A (1971) Take-overs, Their Relevance to the Stock Market and the Theory of the Firm, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Singh A (1975) “Take-overs, Economic Natural Selection and the Theory of the Firm”, Economic Journal, September Vol 85 pp.497 - 515

Singh A (1992) “Corporate Takeovers”, in J. Eatwell, M. Milgate and P. Newman (eds), The New Palgrave Dictionary of Money and Finance, London: Macmillan, pp.480-486

Singh A (1993) “Regulation of Mergers: A New Agenda”, in Roger Sugden (ed.) Industrial Economic Regulation: A Framework and Exploration, London: Routledge, pp.141-58

Singh A (1995a) Corporate Financial Patterns in Industrializing Economies: A Comparative International Study. IFC Technical Paper, Washington, DC: IFC

Singh A (1995b) “The causes of fast economic growth in East Asia”, UNCTAD Review, pp.91-127

Singh A (1997) “Financial liberalisation, stock markets and economic development”, Economic Journal, May Vol 107 (442), pp.771-782

Singh A (1998a) “Liberalisation, the stock market and the market for corporate control: a bridge too far for the Indian economy?” In Ahluwalia, IJ and Little IMD (eds) India’s Economic Reforms and Development: Essays for Manmohan Singh, Oxford, pp. 169-196

Singh A (1998b) “Savings, Investment and the Corporation in the East Asian Miracle”, The Journal of Development Studies, Volume 34, no. 6, pp.112 - 137

Singh A (1998c) “Financial crisis in East Asia: The end of the Asian Model?”, Issues in Development, Discussion Paper 24, ILO, Geneva

Singh A (1999) “’Asian capitalism’ and the financial crisis” in Michie J and Grieve Smith J(eds), Global Instability: The political economy of world economic governance, London: Routledge, pp. 9-36

Singh A (2000) “The Anglo-Saxon market for corporate control: The financial system and international competitiveness” in Candice Howes and Ajit Singh ed. Competitiveness matters: Industry and economic performance in the US, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press pp.89 - 105

Singh A (2001) Corporate governance, evolution of corporate laws and Asian economic development into the 21st century Faculty of Economics Cambridge (Processed)

Singh A and Dhumale R (1999) Competition policy, development and developing countries, T.R.A.D.E. Working Paper 7, South Centre, Geneva

Singh A and Hamid J (1992) Corporate financial structures in developing countries, Technical Paper 1, IFC, Washington DC

Singh A Singh A and Weisse B (2000) Information technology, venture capital and the stock market, Cambridge Discussion Paper in Accounting and Finance No. AF47, Department of Applied Economics, University of Cambridge

Singh A and Weisse B (1998) “Emerging stock markets, portfolio capital flows and long-term economic growth: Micro and Macro Perspectives”, World Development, Vol. 26, No. 4, pp.607-622

Singh A and Weisse B (1999) “The Asian model: A crisis foretold?” International Social Science Journal, No. 160

Singh A and Zammit A (2000) “International capital flows: Identifying the gender dimension”, World Development, Vol. 28, No. 7., pp.1249-1268

Summers L H (1998) Quoted in an article by Gerard Baker "US looks to G7 backing on Asia crisis" Financial Times, February 19, 1998

Stein JC (1989) “Efficient stock markets, inefficient firms: A model of myopic corporate behaviour”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, November

Stiglitz J (1999) “Reforming the Global Financial Architecture: Lessons from Recent Crises”, Journal of Finance 54(4), pp.1508-22

Summers LH (1998) “Opportunities Out of Crises: Lessons From Asia”, Remarks to the Overseas Development Council, From the Office of Public Affairs, March 19, 1998

The Economist (2001) Special insert from p 76. Survey of corporate finance, January 22 - February 2

Tybout J (2000) “Manufacturing firms in developing countries: How well do they do and why?”, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 38, No. 1 (March), pp.11-44

Waring G (1996) "Industry Differences in the Persistence of Firm-Specific Returns", American Economic Review, Vol.86 (4), December, pp.1253-1265

Whittington G, Saporta V and Singh A (1997) The Effects of Hyper-Inflation on Accounting Ratios: Financing of Corporate Growth in Industrialising Economies, Technical Paper 3, IFC, Washington

Williamson OE (1975) Markets and hierarchies: Analysis and antitrust implications, New: York: The Free Press

Winters SG Jr (1964) “Economic ‘natural selection’ and the theory of the firm”, Yale Economic Essays, Vol Spring IV (1) pp. 225-272

World Bank (1993) The East Asian Miracle: Economic Growth and Public Policy, New York: Oxford University Press