Consumer price indices and the identification problem

Courtney, Mark (2013): Consumer price indices and the identification problem. Published in: Statistical Journal of the IAOS , Vol. 29, No. 1 (2013): pp. 41-51.

Abstract

Conventionally, consumer price indices are constructed on the assumption that we are observing a stable system of consumer demand, and that all price movements are, therefore, the result of supply-side changes. This often leads to an emphasis on consumer price substitution and to a recommendation that we should allow for it by using the geometric mean for first-stage aggregation. This paper argues, on the basis of economic theory and from observations on the UK clothing sub-index, that demand-side changes are also important in generating price movements. For most items we are unable to solve the resulting identification problem of whether supply-side or demand-side influences predominate: in these circumstances, the appropriate formula to use for first-stage aggregation is one that makes no assumptions about the cause of price changes – i.e. one that uses an arithmetic rather than a geometric average. Allowing for both sources of price movements also affects the way in which elementary aggregates should be defined: this should be on the basis of both demand and supply characteristics, in order to minimise problems that arise when aggregating disparate products.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Consumer price indices, first-stage aggregation, identification problem, demand-side changes, geometric mean, elasticity of substitution
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E31 - Price Level ; Inflation ; Deflation

References

B.M. Balk, On curing the CPI’s substitution and new goods bias, in: proc. Ottawa Group fifth meeting, 1999

Bank of England, Quarterly Inflation Report, February 2011

F.W. Bell, The Pope and the price of fish, American Economic Review 58 (1968), 1346–1350.

S.D. Braithwait, The substitution bias of the Laspeyres Price Index: An analysis using estimated Cost-of-Living Indexes, American Economic Review 70 (1980), 64–77.

W.E. Diewert, The early history of price index research, in: Essays in Index Number Theory, (Vol. 1), W.E. Diewert and A.O. Nakamura, eds, Amsterdam, 1993, Chapter 2, pp. 33–71.

European Commission, Compendium of HICP Reference Documents, 2/2001/B/5, Luxembourg 2001, Table 9, pp. 60–61.

D. Fenwick, The impact of choice of base month and other factors on the relative performance of different formulae used for aggregation of Consumer Price Index data at an elementary aggregate level, in: proc. Ottawa Group fifth meeting, 1999.

J.S. Greenlees and R.McClelland, Superlative and regression-based consumer price indexes for apparel using U.S. scanner data, presented at the Conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, St. Gallen, 2010.

International Labour Office et al, Consumer Price Index Manual, Theory and Practice, International Labour Office, Geneva, 2004, Chapter 16.

International Labour Office et al, Consumer Price Index Manual, Theory and Practice, International Labour Office, Geneva, 2004, Chapters 17,18.

S. Nickell, Two Current Monetary Policy Issues, Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, Winter 2003, pp. 504–517.

OECD Statistics, Main Economic Indicators, Consumer Price Indices: Data and Methods.

Office for National Statistics, CPI and RPI: Increased impact of the formula effect in 2010, Information Note, 2011.

Office for National Statistics, The new inflation target: The statistical perspective, London, 2003

M. Sabag and Y. Finkel, The Israeli Consumer Price Index: Alternative computing methods for an ‘Item Price Index’, Statistical Journal of the United Nations ECE 11 (1994), 95–118.

M.D. Shapiro and D.W.Wilcox, Alternative strategies for aggregating prices in the CPI, Federal Reserve Bank of St Louis Review 79 (1997), 113–125.

I. Song and P.K. Chintagunta, Measuring cross-category price effects with aggregate store data, Management Science 52 (2006), 1594–1609.

United Nations Economic Commission for Europe et al, Practical Guide to Producing Consumer Price Indices, United Nations, New York and Geneva, 2009, Chapters 10 and 13.

U.S. Senate, Committee on Finance, Final Report of the Advisory Commission to Study the Consumer Price Index. Print 104-72, 104 Cong., 2 sess. Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office, 1996.