Firms’ disclosure compliance with IASB’s Management Commentary framework:an empirical investigation

Riccardo, Macchioni and Giuseppe, Sannino and Gianluca, Ginesti and Carlo, Drago (2013): Firms’ disclosure compliance with IASB’s Management Commentary framework:an empirical investigation. Published in: Rivista Italiana di Ragioneria ed Economia Aziendale (RIREA) No. Vol. July-August-September 2013 (2013)

Abstract

The continuous demand for enhanced financial reporting has highlighted the decline of the usefulness of traditional financial statements in satisfying the informational needs and requirements of users. Despite there being several points of view, many proposals revolve around the increase of narrative disclosure accompanying financial statements. It is apparent that the regulatory attention regarding narrative reporting has mainly focused on the Management Commentary (MC) report. As a result, the accounting standard setters have promoted different approaches to improve the comparability and usefulness of the MC among the firms. In December 2010, the IASB completed the project on the MC disclosure framework, through the publishing of a non-binding IFRS practice statement (IFRSps). The aim of this study is to analyze the information conveyed by the MC report for a sample of firms listed on the Italian Stock Exchange at the end of 2010. More specifically, we investigate the determinants affecting the extent of firms disclosure compliance with the IASB’s MC voluntary guidelines, reported in the IFRSps, soon after its implementation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first empirical study which examines the explanatory factors affecting the extent of voluntary disclosure convergence in relation to IFRSps, with reference to Italy. To analyze the informational content of each MC report, we create an index of disclosure compliance using a self-constructed checklist designed on the IASB’s MC guidelines. To assess the relationship between the index of disclosure compliance and the firm characteristics, we use a regression model. Consistent with previous accounting studies, our results suggest that firm size and ownership diffusion are positively related to the extent of disclosure compliance with IASB’s MC guidelines. On the other hand, the leverage and profitability were found to be unrelated to the index of disclosure compliance. The results also show that the level of disclosure compliance to the IASB’s MC guidance is low, ranging from 10% to 76%, averaging 39%. This means that despite the continued demand for better comparability in financial reporting practices, in Italy a large number of firms do not seem to converge towards a single set of standards for both the narrative and numerical-financial disclosure.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: management commentary, Narrative Disclosure, IAS/IFRS, financial reporting
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M48 - Government Policy and Regulation

References

ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD (2009), Rising to the challenge, A review of narrative reporting by UK listed companies.

AHMED K., COURTIS J. K. (1999), “Associations between corporate characteristics and disclosure levels in annual reports: a meta-analysis”, in British Accounting Review, vol. 31, pp. 35-61.

AJINKYA B., BHOJRAJ S., SENGUPTA P. (2005), “The Association between Outside Directors, Institutional Investors and the Properties of Management Earnings Forecasts”, in Journal of accounting research, vol. 43, pp. 343-376.

ALJIFRI K. (2008), “Annual report disclosure in a developing country: The case of the UAE”, in Advances in Accounting, incorporating Advances in International Accounting, vol. 24, pp. 93-100.

AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANTS (1994), “Improving business reporting. A customer focus”, New York. 714

BAGNOLI C., VEDOVATO M. (2004) “Le determinanti del gap informativo tra imprese quotate ed analisti finanziari: i contenuti della relazione sulla gestione”, in Rivista Italiana di Ragioneria e di Economia Aziendale.

BARRON O. E., KILE, C. O. (1999) “MD&A quality as measured by the SEC and analysts’ earnings forecasts”, in Contemporary Accounting Research, vol. 16, pp. 75-109.

BEATTIE V., MCINNES W., FEARNLEY S. (2004), “A methodology for analysing and evaluating narratives in annual reports: a comprehensive descriptive profile and metrics for disclosure quality attributes”, in Accounting Forum, vol. 28, pp. 205-236.

BEATTIE V., MCINNES B., PIERPOINT J. (2008), “The management commentary: comparing narrative outcomes from alternative regulatory regimes”, in Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, London.

BERETTA S., BOZZOLAN S. (2004), “A framework for the analysis of firm risk communication, in The International Journal of Accounting, vol. 39, pp. 265-288.

BERETTA S., BOZZOLAN S. (2008), “Quantity vs Quality: the case of Forward Looking Disclosure”, in Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance, vol. 3, pp. 333-375.

BOTOSAN C. A. (1997),“Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital”, in The Accounting Review, vol. 72, pp. 323-350.

BRYAN S. H. (1997), “Incremental information content of required disclosures contained in management discussion and analysis”, in The Accounting Review, vol. 72, pp. 285-301.

BROWN S., TUCKER J. (2010), “Large-sample evidence of firms’ year-over-year MD&A modifications”, in Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 49, pp. 309-346.

BRUNI G. (2007), “Le informazioni complementari al bilancio. Quale reporting revolution?”, in Rivista Italiana di Ragioneria e di Economia Aziendale, 1-2.

BUZBY S. L. (1975), “Company size, listed versus unlisted stocks, and the extent of financial disclosure”, in Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 13, pp. 16-37.

CALDARELLI A. (2010), “La disclosure integrativa e suppletiva nel financial reporting”, in AA. VV. ( a cura di L. Potito), Il bilancio secondo i principi contabili internazionali IAS/IFRS. Regole e applicazioni, seconda edizione riveduta e ampliata, Giappichelli, Torino.

CANADIAN INSTITUTE OF CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS (2009), Management Discussion and Analysis: guidance on Preparation and Disclosure, Canada.

COLE C. J., JONES C. L. (2004), “The usefulness of MD&A disclosures in the retail industry”, in Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance, vol. 19, pp. 361-388.

COOKE T. E. (1989), “Disclosure in the corporate annual reports of Swedish companies”, in Accounting and Business Research, vol. 19, pp. 113-124.

COOKE T. E. (1992), “The Impact of Size, Stock Market Listing and Industry Type on Disclosure in the Annual Reports of Japanese Listed Companies”, in Accounting and Business Research, vol. 22, pp. 229-237.

CONSIGLIO NAZIONALE DEI DOTTORI COMMERCIALISTI E DEGLI ESPERTI CONTABILI (CNDCEC) (2009), “La relazione sulla gestione art. 2428 codice civile”, January.

DAVIS A. K., TAMA-SWEET I. (2012), “Managers’ Use of Language Across Alternative Disclosure Outlets: Earnings Press Releases Versus MD&A”, in Contemporary Accounting Research, vol. 29, pp. 804-837.

DEPOERS F. (2000), “A cost-benefit study of voluntary disclosure: some empirical evidence from French listed companies”, in The European Accounting Review, vol. 9, pp. 245-263.

DIAMOND D., VERRECCHIA R. (1991), “Disclosure, liquidity, and the cost of capital”, in Journal of Finance, vol. 46, pp. 1325-1359.

DIETER R., SANDEFUR K. (1989), “Spotlight on management discussion and analysis: What the SEC expect this year?”, in Journal of Accountancy, vol. 6, pp. 4-70.

DONOHER W.J., REED S.F., STORRUD-BARNES (2007), “Incentive alignment, control, and the issue of misleading financial disclosures”, in Journal of Management, vol. 33, pp. 547-569.

FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD (2001), “Improving business reporting: insights into enhancing voluntary disclosures”, USA.

FIRTH M. (1980),“Raising finance and firms’ corporate reporting policies”, in Abacus, vol. 16, pp. 100-115.

FITÒ A., GOMEZ F., MOYA S. (2012), “Choice in IFRS adoption in Spain, Determinants and Consequences”, in Accounting in Europe, vol. 9, pp.61-84.

FRANCIS J.R., KHURANA I.K., MARTIN X., PERREIRA R. (2008), “The Role of Firm-Specific Incentives and CountryFactors in Explaining Voluntary IAS Adoptions: Evidence from Private Firms”, in The European Accounting Review, vol. 17, pp. 331-360.

GARCIA-MECA E., SANCHEZ-BALLESTA (2010), “The Association of Board Independence and Ownership Concentration with Voluntary Disclosure: A Meta-analysis”, in the European Accounting Review, vol. 19, pp. 603-627.

GINER B. (1997), “The influence of company characteristics and accounting regulation on information disclosed by Spanish firms”, in The European Accounting Review, vol. 6, pp. 45-68.

GINESTI G., MACCHIONI R., SANNINO G., SPANO M. (2013), “The Impact of International Accounting Standards Board (IASB)’s Guidelines for Preparing Management Commentary (MC): Evidence From Italian Listed Firms”, in Journal of Modern Accounting and Auditing, vol. 9, pp. 305-320.

GIUNTA F., PISANI M. (2006), Il bilancio, Apogeo, 2006.

HANIFFA R.M., COOKE T.E. (2002), “Culture, corporate governance and disclosure in Malasyan corporations”, in Abacus, vol. 38, pp. 317-349.

HEALY P., HUTTON A., PALEPU, K. (1999), “Stock performance and intermediation changes surrounding sustained increases in disclosure”, in Contemporary Accounting Research, vol. 16, pp. 485-520.

HEALY P.M., PALEPU K.G. (2001), “Information asymmetry, corporate disclosure, and the capital markets: A review of the empirical literature.”, in Journal of Accounting & Economics, vol. 31, pp. 405-440.

HOOKS K.L., MOON J.E. (1993), “A classification scheme to examine management discussion and analysis compliance”, in Accounting Horizons, vol. 7, pp. 41-59.

HOLDER-WEBB L. (2007), “The question of disclosure: providing a tool for evaluating management’s discussion and analysis”, in Advances in accounting behavioral research, vol. 10, pp. 183-223.

HOSSAIN M., TAN L. M., ADAMS M. (1994), “Voluntary disclosure in an emerging capital market: Some empirical evidence from companies listed on the Kuala Lumpur stock exchange”, in International Journal of Accounting, vol. 29, pp. 334-351..

INCHAUSTI B. G. (1997), “The influence of Company Characteristics and Accounting Regulation on Information Disclosed by Spanish Firms”, in The European Accounting Review, vol. 6, pp. 45-68.

INSTITUTE OF CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS IN ENGLAND AND WALES (1999), “Inside out: reporting on shareholders value”.

INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD (2010), “IFRS practice statement Management Commentary - A framework for presentation”

KOTHARI S., LI X., SHORT J. (2009), “The effect of disclosures by management, analysts, and financial press on cost of capital,return volatility, and analyst forecasts: A study using content analysis.”, in The Accounting Review, vol. 84, pp. 1639-1670.

KRIPPENDORF K. (1980), Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology, Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.

LANG M., LUNDHOLM R. (1993),“Cross-sectional determinants of analyst ratings of corporate disclosures”, in Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 31, pp. 246-271.

LEHAVY R., LI F., MERKLEY K. (2011), “The Effect of Annual Report Readability on Analyst Following and the Properties of Their Earnings Forecasts”, in The Accounting Review, vol. 86, pp. 1087-1115.

LEV B., ZAROWIN P. (1999), “The boundaries of financial reporting and how to extend them”, in Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 37, pp. 353-386.

LEUZ C. (1999), “Proprietary versus non-proprietary disclosures: voluntary cash flow statements and business segment reports in Germany”, in Working Paper, Department of Business and Economics, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universita, Frankfurt.

LI, F. (2008), “Annual Report Readability, Current Earnings, and Earnings Persistence”, in Journal of Accounting and Economics, vol. 45, pp. 221-47.

LI F. (2010), “Textual Analysis of Corporate Disclosures: A. Survey of the Literature”, in Journal of Accounting Literature, vol. 29, pp. 143-165.

MACCHIONI R. (2010), “Informazione di bilancio e principi contabili internazionali”, in AA. VV., Il bilancio secondo i principi contabili internazionali IAS/IFRS. Regole e applicazioni, seconda edizione riveduta e ampliata, Giappichelli, Torino.

MALONE D., FRIES C., JONES T. (1993), “An empirical investigation of the extent of corporate financial disclosure in the oil and gas industry”, in Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance, vol. 8, pp. 251-273.

MARSTON C. L., SHRIVES, P. J. (1991), “The use of disclosure indices in accounting research: a review article”, in British Accounting Review, vol. 23, pp. 195-210.

MEEK G. K., ROBERTS C. B.,GRAY S. J., (1995), “Factors Influencing Voluntary Annual Disclosures By U.S., U.K., and Continental European Multinational Corporations”, in Journal of International Business Studies, vol. 26, pp. 555-57.

MERKL-DAVIES, D. M., BRENNAN, N. M. (2007), “Discretionary Disclosure Strategies in Corporate Narratives: Incremental Information or Impression Management?”, in Journal of Accounting Literature, vol. 26, pp. 116-196.

MCKINNON J., DALIMUNTHE J. (1993), “Voluntary disclosure of segment information by Australian diversified companies”, in Accounting and Finance, vol. 33, pp. 33-50.

NOBES C., PARKER R. (2010), Comparative International Accounting, FT Prentice Hall. 11th ed.

POTITO L., TARTAGLIA-POLCINI P. (2010), “I principi contabili internazionali: riflessioni critiche, in Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti”, n. 2, 2010.

PRENCIPE A. (2004), “Proprietary costs and determinants of voluntary segment disclosure: evidence from Italian listed companies”, in The European Accounting Review, vol.13, pp. 319-340.

QUAGLI A. (2004), Comunicare il futuro. L’informativa economico-finanziaria di tipo previsionale delle società quotate italiane, Franco Angeli, Milano (Italy).

RAFFOURNIER B. (1995), “The determinants of voluntary financial disclosure by Swiss listed companies”, in the European Accounting Review, vol. 4, pp. 261-280.

ROBB S.W.G., SINGLE L.E., ZARZESKI M.T. (2001), “Non-financial disclosures across Anglo-American countries”, in the Journal of International Accounting, vol. 10, pp. 71-83.

ROBBINS W. A., AUSTIN K. R., (1986), “Disclosure Quality in Governmental Financial Reports: An Assessment of the Appropriateness of a Compound Measure”, in Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 24, pp. 412-421

SANNINO G. (1999), Il percorso di formazione dei principi contabili nordamericani. Aspetti teorici ed operativi, Cedam, Padova.

SCHIPPER K. (1981), “Discussion of Voluntary Corporate Disclosure: The Case of Interim Reporting, in Journal of Accounting Research, vol. 19 supplement, pp. 85-88.

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION (2003), Interpretation: Commission Guidance Regarding Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, Release Nos. 33-8350; 34-48960; FR- 72.

SHI YUN SEAH S., TARCA A. (2006), “The impact of regulatory framework on management commentary reports” Working Paper, University of Western Australia.

SINGHVI S., DESAI H. B. (1971), “An Empirical Analysis of the Quality of Corporate Financial Disclosure”, in The Accounting Review, vol. 46, pp. 621-632.

SILVI R., BARTOLINI M. (2011), “The role of performance indicators in management commentary”, in Financial Reporting, vol. 3, supplement, pp. 61-80.

SINGHVI S. S., DESAI, H. B. (1971), “An empirical analysis of the quality of corporate financial disclosure”, in The Accounting Review, vol. 46, pp. 129-138.

SUBRAMANIAN R., INSLEY R.G., BLACKWELL R.D. (1993), “Performance and readability: a comparison of annual reports of profitable and unprofitable corporations”, in Journal of Business Communication, vol. 30, pp. 49-61.

WALLACE R.S.O., NASER, K., MORA, A. (1994), “The relationship between the comprehensiveness of corporate annual reports and firm characteristics in Spain”, in Accounting and Business Research, vol. 25, pp. 41-53.

WALLACE R.S.O., NASER, K. (1995), “Firm-specific determinants of the comprehensiveness of mandatory disclosure in the corporate annual reports of firms listed on the stock exchange of Hong Kong” in Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, vol. 14, pp. 311-368.

WEBER R.P. (1985), Basic Content Analysis, Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, Beverly Hills, No. 49, Sage Publications.

VERBEEK (2008), A guide to modern econometrics, Wiley Edition.

VERRECCHIA R. (2001), “Essays on disclosure”, in Journal of Accounting & Economics, vol. 32, pp. 97-180.

VIGANÒ E. (2008), Contenuto e finalità del bilancio, Cedam, Padova.