The impact of the Bosman ruling on the market for native soccer players

Marcén, Miriam (2014): The impact of the Bosman ruling on the market for native soccer players.

Abstract

This paper examines whether the Bosman ruling plays an important role in the market for native soccer players. Through the abolition of transfer fees after the expiration of contracts, as well as the liberalization of the migration of professional soccer players within the European Union, the Bosman ruling could negatively impact the number of national players participating in their national leagues. To explore this issue, we use data on the First Division of the Spanish League for the seasons 1980/1981 to 2011/2012. Results point to a decline in the number of native Spanish players after the Bosman ruling, although the impact does not appear to be permanent. This finding is consistent with the use of different subsamples, and to the introduction of controls for unobserved characteristics varying at the team level or over time, and to observed characteristics such as GDP per capita, population, the age of players, and potential TV revenues. This work also explores the impact of other, similar legislative changes, such as the Kolpak case and the Cotonou agreement, which appeared in the post-Bosman period. In addition, we incorporate empirical evidence of the potential impact that the Bosman ruling may have on the performance of the Spanish players. Our findings indicate that the Bosman case has had a negative impact on the number of minutes played and on the participation of national players in the first team, suggesting that an average Spanish player is less important to his team.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Bosman ruling, Spanish League, National Labor Market, Kolpak-Nihat-Simutenkov cases, Cotonou agreement, TV rights.
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F22 - International Migration; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J22 - Time Allocation and Labor Supply; K - Law and Economics > K1 - Basic Areas of Law > K19 - Other; L - Industrial Organization > L8 - Industry Studies: Services > L83 - Sports ; Gambling ; Restaurants ; Recreation ; Tourism

References

Álvarez, J., Forrest, D., Sanz, I., and J:D. Tena (2011) Impact of importing foreign talent on performance levels of local co-workers. Labour Economics, 18 (3), 287–296.

Andreff W. (2006) International Labour Migration, Chapter 32, Handbook on the Economics of Sport, ed. Wladimir Andreff y Stefan Szymanski, Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, Great Britain.

Andreff W. and Szymanski S. (2006) Introduction: sport and economics, Handbook on the Economics of Sport, ed. Wladimir Andreff y Stefan Szymanski, Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, Great Britain.

Antonioni, P., and J. Cubbin (2000) The Bosman Ruling and the emergence of a single market in soccer talent. European Journal of Law and Economics, 9 (2), 157–173.

Barros, C. P., del Corral, J. and P. Garcia-del-Barrio (2008) Identification of Segments of Soccer Clubs in the Spanish League first Division with a Latent Class model, Journal of Sports Economics, 9 (5), 451-468.

Berlinschi, R., Schokkaert, J. and J. Swinnen (2013) When drains and gains coincide: Migration and international football performance, Labour Economics, 21, 1-14.

Binder J.J. and M. Findlay (2012) The effects of the Bosman Ruling on National and Club Teams in Europe, Journal of Sports Economics, 13, 107-129.

Cies Football Observatory Big-5 Weekly post, New Record High for Expatriate Presence in the Big-5,, 11/11/2005.

Case C-265/03, Igor Simutenkov v. Ministerio de Educación y Cultura ,Real Federación Española de Fútbol, [2005] ECR I-2579.

Court of Justice of the European Communities (1995) Union Royale Belge des Societes de Football Association vs Jean Marc Bosman. Case c-415/93.

Darby, P. (2007) African football labour migration to Portugal: colonial and neocolonial resource. Soccer & Society, 8 (4), 495–509.

Darby, P., Akindes, G., and M. Kirwin (2007). Football academies and the migration of African football labor to Europe. Journal of Sport & Social Issues, 31 (2), 143–161.

Ericson, T. (2000) The Bosman Case Effects of the Abolition of the Transfer Fee, Journal of Sports Economics, 1 (3), 203-218.

Flores, R., Forrest, D., and J. D. Tena (2010) Impact on Competitive Balance from Allowing Foreign Players in a Sports League: Evidence from European Soccer, Kyklos, 63(4), 546–557.

Frick B. (2009) Globalization and Factor Mobility: The impact of the “Bosman-Ruling” on Player Migration in Professional Soccer, Journal of Sports Economics, 10, 88-106.

García, J. and P. Rodríguez (2006) The economics of soccer in Spain, Chapter 51, Handbook on the Economics of Sport, ed. Wladimir Andreff y Stefan Szymanski, Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, Great Britain.

Hendrickx, F. (2005) The Simutenkov Case: Russian players are equal to European Union players, The International Sports Law Journal (ISLJ) 2005/3.

Kahn, L.M. (2000) The sports business as a labor market laboratory. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 14 (3), 75–94.

Karaca, O. (2008) The impact of foreign players on international performance. Working Paper No. 11064. Munich Personal RePEc Archive, Munich.

Kesenne, S. (2007) The peculiar international economics of professional football in Europe. Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 54 (3), 388–399.

Milanovic, B. (2005) Globalization and goals: does soccer show the way? Review of International Political Economy, 12 (5), 829–850.

Penn, D.W. (2006) From Bosman to Simutenkov: the application of non-discrimination principles to non-EU nationals in European sports. Suffolk Transnational Law Review, 30 (1), 203–231.

Quirk, J. and R. Fort (1992), Pay dirt: the business of professional team sports (Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ).

The Telegraph,http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/2369701/Uefa-say-Bosman-ruined-footballs-values.html

Vrooman, J. (2007) Theory of the Beautiful Game: The unification of European Football, Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 54 (3), 314-354.

Wolfers, J. (2006) Did unilateral divorce laws raise divorce rates? A reconciliation and new results, American Economic Review, 96, 1802-1820