Immigration and the Welfare State Revisited: Fiscal Transfers to Immigrants in Canada in 2014

Grady, Patrick and Grubel, Herbert (2015): Immigration and the Welfare State Revisited: Fiscal Transfers to Immigrants in Canada in 2014. Published in: (10 November 2015)

Abstract

This paper provides an updated estimate for 2010 for the net fiscal transfer to the recent immigrants who came to Canada between 1985 and 2009. At $5,329 per capita per year, it is significantly lower than the over $6,000 per capita of our earlier estimates. This reflects the Conservative Federal Government’s ambitious efforts to reform immigration policy since taking office in 2006 to better select immigrants who are more prepared to succeed in Canada’s labour market and to refocus immigration policy more on economic class immigrants. This included the elimination of a backlog of around a million immigrants selected under an old dysfunctional system who were judged to be likely to encounter labour-market difficulties and the introduction of the Canada Experience Class. Nevertheless, it should be of concern that in spite of the improvement in the net fiscal cost of recent immigration the overall fiscal cost of fiscal transfers to recent immigrants has continued to grow to $20 to 28 billion as of 2010, up from our earlier estimate of $16 to 24 billion in 2005.

The fiscal cost of immigration will probably continue to grow in the future as high levels of immigrants are admitted unless the new Express Entry Program for economic class immigrants is more successful at eliminating the income gap between new immigrants and other Canadians than the measures introduced so far and the mix of immigrants is shifted towards more economic class. At an estimated per-capita net fiscal cost of $5,329, the fiscal cost of immigration can be estimated to have risen to the $27 to $35 billion range in 2014. And the 260,000 to 285,000 planned immigrant admissions recently announced by the Immigration Minister for 2015 should add another $1.4 billion to $1.5 billion to the cost with a similar increment coming every year thereafter as long as the high targeted level of immigration is maintained and achieved.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: taxes, benefits, fiscal cost of immigration, recent immigrants to Canada
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H24 - Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers

References

Friedman, Milton (1999). Quotation from an interview at the 18th Annual Institute for Liberty and Policy Analysis (ISIL) World Libertarian Conference, San Jose, Costa Rica (August 20–22, 1999).

Government of Canada (2015). “Express Entry.” <http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/express/express-entry.asp>

Grady, Patrick (2015a) “Time to Face the Fact that the National Household Survey Is Just the Compulsory Long-Form Census Made Voluntary February 6 <http://www.global-economics.ca/NHS_comments.htm>

Grady, Patrick (2015b) “An Assessment of the Impact of Conservative Immigration Reform on the Labour Market Performance of Immigrants,” Global Economics Policy Paper 2015-2 <http://www.global-economics.ca/immigration_conservative_policies_2012.pdf>

Grubel, Herbert (2005). Immigration and the Welfare State in Canada: Growing Conflicts, Constructive Solutions. Public Policy Sources 84. Fraser Institute. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13108>

Grubel, Herbert and Patrick Grady (2011). “Immigration and the Welfare State 2011.” Fraser Institute, Study in Immigration and Refugee Policy, May.

Grubel, Herbert and Patrick Grady (2012). “Fiscal Transfers to Immigrants in Canada: Responding to Critics and a Revised Estimate.” Fraser Institute, Study in Immigration and Refugee Policy, March.

Hawthorne, Lesleyanne (2011). Competing for Skills: Migration Policies and Trends in New Zealand and Australia, prepared for the New Zealand Department of Labour with funding from the Australian Government/Department of Immigration and Citizenship. <http://www.immi.gov.au/media/publications/research/_pdf/migration-policies-trends-fullreport.pdf>

Jacobson, Paul (2014). “Policy making suffering in Canada without the long-form census.” Globe and Mail, November 5.

Javdani, Mohen and Krishna Pendakur (2011). “Fiscal Transfers to Immigrants in Canada.” Metropolis British Columbia Working Paper No. 11-08. <http://mbc.metropolis.net/assets/uploads/files/wp/2011/WP11-08.pdf>

Kenney, Jason, (2014) “Speaking Points for the Minister of Employment and Social Development at the Toronto Region Board of Trade,” November 6. http://www.bot.com/newsroom/speeches/PDF/20141106JasonKenney.pdf

Statistics Canada (2009). 2006 Census Public Use Microdata File (PUMF)Individuals File Documentation and User guide. Catalogue no. 95M0028XVB.

Statistics Canada (2014a). 2011 National Household Survey Public Use Microdata File(PUMF) Individuals File. Catalogue no. 95M00081.

Statistics Canada (2014b). NHS User Guide, Catalogue no. 99-001-X2011001.

Statistics Canada (2014c). Income Reference Guide: National Household Survey, 2011, Catalogue no. 99-014-X2011006.