Multimarket Competition and Profitability: Evidence from Ukrainian banking

Pham, Tho and Talavera, Oleksandr and Yang, Junhong (2016): Multimarket Competition and Profitability: Evidence from Ukrainian banking.

Abstract

This paper examines the impacts of non-price competition on bank performance in the Ukrainian banking industry from 2009 Q1 to 2015 Q4. The competition is proxied by three measures of multimarket contacts. Our data reveal that banks with higher level of multiple market contacts are more likely to be profitable. The findings support the mutual forbearance hypothesis. When banks compete with rivals that are similar in size in multiple markets, they have incentives to cooperate instead of competing aggressively. Moreover, the effect is stronger when multimarket competitors are highly similar in size and interact in more competitive markets. Furthermore, we develop an identification strategy in which military actions are treated as an exogenous shock to banks with branches in those regions. The results suggest that after the conflict, the less affected banks do not have incentives to mutual forbear with more affected banks that experienced a sharper decline in number of branches.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Banking; Multimarket competition; Multimarket contact; Mutual forbearance hypothesis; Profitability; Identification strategy; Exogenous shock; Political conflict
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G21 - Banks ; Depository Institutions ; Micro Finance Institutions ; Mortgages; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L11 - Production, Pricing, and Market Structure ; Size Distribution of Firms; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L25 - Firm Performance: Size, Diversification, and Scope; L - Industrial Organization > L4 - Antitrust Issues and Policies > L40 - General

References

Alexander, D.L., 1985. An empirical test of the mutual forbearance hypothesis: The case of bank holding companies. Southern Economic Journal, 52(1), pp.122-140.

Baum, J.A. and Korn, H.J., 1996. Competitive dynamics of interfirm rivalry. Academy of Management journal, 39(2), pp.255-291.

Baum, J.A. and Korn, H.J., 1999. Dynamics of dyadic competitive interaction. Strategic Management Journal, 20(3), pp.251-278.

Berger, A.N., 1995. The relationship between capital and earnings in banking. Journal of money, credit and Banking, 27(2), pp.432-456.

Berger, A.N., Dick, A.A., Goldberg, L.G. and White, L.J., 2007. Competition from Large, Multimarket Firms and the Performance of Small, Single‐Market Firms: Evidence from the Banking Industry. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 39(2‐3), pp.331-368.

Bonin, J.P., Hasan, I. and Wachtel, P., 2005. Privatization matters: Bank efficiency in transition countries. Journal of Banking & Finance, 29(8), pp.2155-2178.

Boubakri, N., Cosset, J.C., Fischer, K. and Guedhami, O., 2005. Privatization and bank performance in developing countries. Journal of Banking & Finance, 29(8), pp.2015-2041.

Bourke, P., 1989. Concentration and other determinants of bank profitability in Europe, North America and Australia. Journal of Banking & Finance, 13(1), pp.65-79.

Cerqueiro, G., Ongena, S. and Roszbach, K., 2016. Collateralization, bank loan rates, and monitoring. The Journal of Finance, 71(3), pp.1295-2322

Coccorese, P. and Pellecchia, A., 2009. Multimarket contact and profitability in banking: evidence from Italy. Journal of Financial Services Research, 35(3), pp.245-271.

Czech National Bank. (2016). [online] Available at: https://apl.cnb.cz/apljerrsdad/JERRS.WEB24.SUBJECTS_COUNTS_2 [Accessed 06 Jun 2016].

De Bonis, R. and Ferrando, A., 2000. The Italian banking structure in the 1990s: testing the multimarket contact hypothesis. Economic Notes, 29(2), pp.215-241.

Degl’Innocenti, M., Girardone, C. and Torluccio, G., 2014. Diversification, multimarket contacts and profits in the leasing industry. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, 31, pp.231-252.

Dietrich, A. and Wanzenried, G., 2011. Determinants of bank profitability before and during the crisis: Evidence from Switzerland. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, 21(3), pp.307-327.

Edwards, C.D., 1955. Conglomerate bigness as a source of power. In Business concentration and price policy (pp. 331-359). Princeton University Press.

Eichengreen, B. and Gibson, H. D., 2011. Greek Banking at the Dawn of the New Millennium. Center for Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No. 2791. London: CEPR

Evans, W.N. and Kessides, I.N., 1994. Living by the "golden rule": Multimarket contact in the US airline industry. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 109(2), pp.341-366.

Feinberg, R.M., 1984. Mutual forbearance as an extension of oligopoly theory. Journal of Economics and Business, 36(2), pp.243-249.

Fuentelsaz, L. and Gómez, J., 2006. Multipoint competition, strategic similarity and entry into geographic markets. Strategic Management Journal, 27(5), pp.477-499.

García-Herrero, A., Gavilá, S. and Santabárbara, D., 2009. What explains the low profitability of Chinese banks?. Journal of Banking & Finance, 33(11), pp.2080-2092.

Gilje, E.P., Loutskina, E. and Strahan, P.E., 2016. Exporting liquidity: Branch banking and financial integration. The Journal of Finance.

Gimeno, J. and Woo, C.Y., 1996. Hypercompetition in a multimarket environment: The role of strategic similarity and multimarket contact in competitive de-escalation. Organization science, 7(3), pp.322-341.

Hanlon, M., Maydew, E.L. and Thornock, J.R., 2015. Taking the long way home: US tax evasion and offshore investments in US equity and debt markets. The Journal of Finance, 70(1), pp.257-287.

Hannan, T.H. and Prager, R.A., 2004. The competitive implications of multimarket bank branching. Journal of Banking & Finance, 28(8), pp.1889-1914.

Hannan, T.H. and Prager, R.A., 2009. The profitability of small single-market banks in an era of multi-market banking. Journal of Banking & Finance, 33(2), pp.263-271.

Hughes, K. and Oughton, C., 1993. Diversification, multi-market contact and profitability. Economica, 60(238), pp.203-224.

Li, S.X. and Chuang, Y.T., 2001. Racing for market share: Hypercompetition and the performance of multiunit-multimarket firms. Advances in Strategic Management, 18, pp.329-355.

Li, S.X. and Greenwood, R., 2004. The effect of within‐industry diversification on firm performance: synergy creation, multi‐market contact and market structuration. Strategic Management Journal, 25(12), pp.1131-1153.

Matsushima, H., 2001. Multimarket contact, imperfect monitoring, and implicit collusion. Journal of Economic Theory, 98(1), pp.158-178.

Mester, L.J., 1987. Multiple market contact between savings and loans: Note. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 19(4), pp.538-549.

Mester, L.J., 1992. Perpetual signalling with imperfectly correlated costs. The RAND Journal of Economics, 23(4), pp.548-563.

Micco, A., Panizza, U. and Yanez, M., 2007. Bank ownership and performance. Does politics matter?. Journal of Banking & Finance, 31(1), pp.219-241.

Miller, S.M. and Noulas, A.G., 1997. Portfolio mix and large-bank profitability in the USA. Applied Economics, 29(4), pp.505-512.

Mirzaei, A., Moore, T. and Liu, G., 2013. Does market structure matter on banks’ profitability and stability? Emerging vs. advanced economies. Journal of Banking & Finance, 37(8), pp.2920-2937.

Molyneux, P. and Forbes, W., 1995. Market structure and performance in European banking. Applied Economics, 27(2), pp.155-159.

Molyneux, P. and Thornton, J., 1992. Determinants of European bank profitability: A note. Journal of Banking & Finance, 16(6), pp.1173-1178.

National bank of Slovakia. (2016). Development of the Banking Sector in the Slovak Republic since 2013 to 2016 - www.nbs.sk. [online] Available at: http://www.nbs.sk/en/statistics/a-survey-of-financial-sector-development/development-of-the-banking-sector-in-the-sr/roz13_16a [Accessed 06 Jun 2016].

National Bank of Ukraine, 2014. On Recalling and Cancellation of Banking Licenses and General Licenses for Carrying out Foreign Currency Operations of Certain Banks and Closing of Banks’ Branches Located on the Territory of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and the City of Sevastopol. Available at http://www.bank.gov.ua/control/uk/publish/article?art_id=7319429&cat_id=13436768

National Bank of Ukraine, 2016. Key performance indicators of banks. [online] Available at: http://bank.gov.ua/control/en/publish/article?art_id=37942&cat_id=37937 [Accessed 31 May 2016].

Parker, P.M. and Röller, L.H., 1997. Collusive conduct in duopolies: multimarket contact and cross-ownership in the mobile telephone industry. The RAND Journal of Economics, 28(20, pp.304-322.

Pasiouras, F. and Kosmidou, K., 2007. Factors influencing the profitability of domestic and foreign commercial banks in the European Union. Research in International Business and Finance, 21(2), pp.222-237.

Pilloff, S.J., 1999. Multimarket contact in banking. Review of Industrial Organization, 14(2), pp.163-182.

Qian, J.Q., Strahan, P.E. and Yang, Z., 2015. The impact of incentives and communication costs on information production and use: Evidence from bank lending. The Journal of Finance, 70(4), pp.1457-1493.

Rhoades, S.A. and Heggestad, A.A., 1985. Multimarket interdependence and performance in banking: Two tests. Antitrust Bull., 30, p.975.

Sandler, R.D., 1988. Market share instability in commercial airline markets and the impact of deregulation. The Journal of Industrial Economics, 36(3), pp.327-335.

Scott, J.T., 1991. Multimarket contact among diversified oligopolists. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 9(2), pp.225-238.

Singal, V., 1996. Airline mergers and multimarket contact. Managerial and Decision Economics, 17(6), pp.559-574.

Solomon, E.H., 1972. Bank merger policy and problems: a linkage theory of oligopoly. Banking Law Journal, 89(2), pp.116-135.

Sorenson, T.L., 2007. Credible collusion in multimarket oligopoly. Managerial and Decision Economics, 28(2), pp.115-128.

The Banks (2016). List of Banks in Hungary. [online] Available at: https://thebanks.eu/banks-by-country/Hungary [Accessed 06 Jun 2016].

The Polish Bank Association (2016). ZBP: General Information. [online] Available at: https://zbp.pl/eng/first [Accessed 06 Jun 2016].

Whalen, G.W., 1996. Nonlocal concentration, multimarket linkages, and interstate banking. Antitrust Bull., 41, p.365.

Yang, T. and Zhao, S., 2014. CEO duality and firm performance: Evidence from an exogenous shock to the competitive environment. Journal of Banking & Finance, 49, pp.534-552.