What account for the differences in rent-price ratio and turnover rate? A search-and-matching approach

Huang, Daisy J. and Leung, Charles Ka Yui and Tse, Chung-Yi (2017): What account for the differences in rent-price ratio and turnover rate? A search-and-matching approach.

Abstract

We build an on-the-house-search model and show analytically that the rent-to-price ratio (or rental yield) and turnover rate, which are frequently used metrics for the housing market, are jointly determined in equilibrium. We therefore adopt a simultaneous equation approach on matched sale-rental pairs in our empirical investigation, as a housing unit cannot be owner-occupied and renter-occupied at the same time. Our empirical results confirm a higher turnover rate is associated with a lower rent-to-price ratio, as predicted by the model. Furthermore, our results suggest a form of “dichotomy” in the empirical determinants of rental yield and turnover at the real-estate-development (RED) level: the demographic structure, and past return performance affect its turnover rate, while popularity, human capital environment, mortgage burden, and long run rent growth determine the rental yield. No evidence of “thick market effect” is found. The robustness of our results are established through a series of tests. In addition to these findings, our tractable search-theoretic model, a ranking of more than 130 RED in Hong Kong based on the popularity index we construct, and the estimated brand-premium for different major real estate developers may also carry independent research and practical interests.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: housing rental yield, turnover rate, bootstrap, leave-one-out cross validation (LOOCV), matching estimator, 3 stages least squares (3SLS)
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D10 - General; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G10 - General; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R21 - Housing Demand

References

Albrecht, J., A. Anderson, E. Smith, and S. Vroman, 2007, Opportunistic matching in the housing market, International Economic Review 42, 641-664.

Albrecht, J., P. Gautier and S. Vroman, 2006, Equilibrium directed search with multiple applications, Review of Economic Studies 73, 869-891.

Ambrose, B.W., and H.O. Nourse, 1993, Factors influencing capitalization rates, Journal of Real Estate Research 8, 221-237.

Amihud, Y., H. Mendelson and L.H. Pedersen, 2013, Market Liquidity: Asset Pricing, Risk, and Crises, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

An, X., and Y. Deng, 2009, A structural model for capitalization rate, San Diego State University, mimeo.

Anglin, P., 2006, Value and liquidity under changing market conditions, Journal of Housing Economics 15, 293-304.

Anglin, P., and Y. Gao, 2013, Integrating illiquid assets into the portfolio decision process, Real Estate Economics 39, 277-311.

Banerjee, S., V.A. Gatchev, and P.A. Spindt, 2007, Stock market liquidity and firm dividend policy, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 42, 369-397.

Baum, C.F., Schaffer, M.E., Stillman, S., and V. Wiggins, 2006, Overid: Stata module to calculate tests of overidentifying restrictions after ivreg, ivreg2, ivprobit, ivtobit, reg3. http://ideas.repec.org/c/boc/bocode/s396802.html

Baum, C.F., 2007, Checkreg3: Stata module to check identification status of simultaneous equations system. http://ideas.repec.org/c/boc/bocode/s456877.htm

Bekaert, G., C.R. Harvey, and C. Lundblad, 2007, Liquidity and expected returns: Lessons from emerging markets, Review of Financial Studies 20, 1783-1831.

Blanchard, O.J., and P.A. Diamond, 1990, The cyclical behavior of the gross flows of U.S. workers, Brooking Papers on Economic Activity 2, 85-155.

Brunnermeier, M. and M. Oehmke, 2013, Bubbles, financial crises, and systemic risk, Princeton University, mimeo.

Burdett, K. and D. Mortensen, 1998, Equilibrium wage differentials and employer size, International Economic Review 39, 257-274.

Campbell, S.D., M.A. Davis, J. Gallin, and R.F. Martin, 2009, What moves housing markets: A variance decomposition of the rent-price ratio, Journal of Urban Economics 66, 90-102.

Chambers, M.; C. Garriga and D. Schlagenhauf, 2009, Accounting for changes in the homeownership rate, International Economic Review 50, 677-726.

Chervachidze, S., and W. Wheaton, 2013, What determined the great cap rate compression of 2000-2007, and the dramatic reversal during the 2008-2009 financial crisis? Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 46, 208-231.

Clayton, J., D.C. Ling, and A. Naranjo, 2009, Commercial real estate valuation: Fundamentals versus investor sentiment, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 38, 5-37.

Dhar, P., and S.L. Ross, 2012, School district quality and property values: Examining differences along school district boundaries, Journal of Urban Economics 71, 18-25.

Diamantopoulos, A., and H.M. Winklhofer, 2001, Index construction with formative indicators: An alternative to scale development, Journal of Marketing Research 38, 269-277.

Diamond, P., 1982a, Wage determination and efficiency in search equilibrium, Review of Economic Studies 49, 217-27.

Diamond, P., 1982b, Aggregate demand management in search equilibrium, Journal of Political Economy 90, 881-94.

Diaz, A., and B. Jerez, 2013, House prices, sales, and time on the market: A search-theoretic framework, International Economic Review 54, 837-872.

Diebold, F., 2016, Dynamic econometrics with big data, Society of Financial Econometrics (SoFiE), invited lecture.

Efron, B., and R.J. Tibshirani, 1993, An Introduction to the Bootstrap, New York: Chapman and Hall.

Evans, R.D., 1990, A transfer function analysis of real estate capitalization rates, Journal of Real Estate Research 5, 371-379.

Faig, M., and B. Jerez, 2006, Inflation, prices, and information in competitive search, Advances in Macroeconomics 6, 1-34, ISSN (Online) 1534-6013, DOI: 10.2202/1534-6013.1313.

Figlio, D.N., and M.E. Lucas, 2004, What's in a grade? School report cards and the housing market, American Economic Review 94, 591-604.

Financial Times, 2015, Fears of bubble rise as property investment volumes hit record, available at http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/3439fc8c-99b1-11e4-93c1-00144feabdc0.html#axzz3SjshUzs2

Fisher, J., D. Gatzlaff, D. Geltner and D. Haurin, 2003, Controlling for impact of variable liquidity in commerical real estate price indices, Real Estate Economics 31, 269-303.

Fox, R., and P. Tulip, 2014, Is housing overvalued? Reserve Bank of Australia, mimeo.

Genesove, D., and L. Han, 2012, Search and matching in the housing market, Journal of Urban Economics 72, 31-45.

Gjerstad, S., and V. Smith, 2014, Rethinking Housing Bubbles: The Role of Household and Bank Balance Sheets in Modeling Economic Cycles, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Glaeser, E., and J. Gyourko, 2007. Arbitrage in housing markets, NBER Working Papers 13704.

Global Property Guide, 2010, How to avoid buying into a bubble? available at http://www.globalpropertyguide.com/real-estate-school/How-to-avoid-buying-into-a-bubble

Green, R., 2015, Remarks on the globalization of real estate and its consequences, presented at the 2015 Global Real Estate Submit.

Green, R., and S. Malpezzi, 2003, A Primer on U.S. Housing Markets and Housing Policy, Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute Press.

Greene, W. H., 2008, Econometric Analysis, 6th ed., Boston: Prentice Hall.

Griliches, Z., 1971, Hedonic price indexes revisited, in Z. Griliches, ed., Price Indexes and Quality Change: Studies in New Methods of Measurement, Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univeristy Press.

Guerrieri, V., 2008, Inefficient unemployment dynamics under asymmetric information, Journal of Political Economy 116, 667-708.

Halket, J., and M. Pignatti, 2013, homeownership and the scarcity of rentals, paper presented at HULM-Atlanta Fed conference.

Hanushek, E., Lavy, V. and K. Hitomi, 2008, Do students care about school quality? determinants of dropout behavior in developing countries, Journal of Human Capital 2, 69-105.

Hanushek, E., Rivkin, S. and L. Taylor, 1996, Aggregation and the estimated effects of school resources. Review of Economics and Statistics 78, 611-27.

Hanushek, E., and L. Woessmann, 2012, Do better schools lead to more growth? Cognitive skills, economic outcomes, and causation, Journal of Economic Growth 17, 267-321.

Hanushek, E., and K. Yilmaz, 2007, The complementarity of Tiebout and Alonso, Journal of Housing Economics 16, 243-261.

Hanushek, E., and K. Yilmaz, 2013, Schools and location: Tiebout, Alonso, and governmental finance policy, Journal of Public Economic Theory 15, 829-855.

Hawkins, W., 2013, Competitive search, efficiency, and multiworker firms, International Economic Review 54, 219-251.

Huang, D. J., and C.K.Y. Leung, 2014, Liquidity premium in the housing market: A matching estimator approach, paper presented in AREUEA meeting.

Jarvis, C. B., S.B. MacKenzie, and P.M. Podsakoff, 2003, A critical review of construct indicators and measurement model misspecification in marketing and consumer research, Journal of Consumer Research 30, 199-218.

Jolliffe, I., 2005, Principal Component Analysis, New York: Springer-Verlag.

Jovanovic, B., 1989, Observable implications of models with multiple equilibria, Econometrica 57, 1431-37.

Jovanovic, B. and R. Rosenthal, 1988. Anonymous sequential games, Journal of Mathematical Economics, 17, 77-87.

Jud, D.G., and D.T. Winkler, 1995, The capitalization rate of commercial properties and market returns, Journal of Real Estate Research 10, 509-518.

Kashiwagi, M., 2014, A search-theoretic model of the rental and homeownership markets, Journal of Housing Economics 26, 33-47.

Krainer, J., 2001, A theory of liquidity in residential real estate markets, Journal of Urban Economics 49, 32-53.

Krause, M., D. Lopez-Salido, & Lubik, T., 2008, Do search frictions matter for inflation dynamics? European Economic Review 52, 1464-1479.

Krause, M., and T. Lubik, 2010, Instability and indeterminacy in a simple search and matching model, Economic Quarterly, Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, issue 3Q, 259-272.

Kwok, H., and C.Y. Tse, 2006, Estimating liquidity effects in the housing market, University of Hong Kong, mimeo.

Lam, W.H.K. and C.Y. Cheung, 2000, Pedestrian speed/flow relationships for walking facilities in Hong Kong, Journal of Transportation Engineering 126, 343-349.

Leung, C.K.Y., G.C.K. Lau and Y.C.F. Leong, 2002, Testing alternative theories of the property price-trading volume correlation, Journal of Real Estate Research 23, 253-63.

Leung, C.K.Y., Y.C.F. Leong and I.Y.S. Chan, 2002, TOM: Why isn't price enough? International Real Estate Review 5, 91-115.

Leung, C.K.Y., Y.C.F. Leong and K.S.K. Wong, 2006, Housing price dispersion: An empirical investigation, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 32, 357-385.

Leung, C.K.Y., T.T.C. Leung and B.K.P. Tsang, 2015, Tax-driven bunching of housing market transactions: The case of Hong Kong, International Real Estate Review 18, 473-501.

Leung, C.K.Y., and E.C.H. Tang, 2012, Comparing two financial crises: The case of Hong Kong real estate markets, in A. Bardhan, R. Edelstein and C. Kroll, ed., Global Housing Markets: Crises, Institutions and Policies, New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Leung, C.K.Y., and E.C.H. Tang, 2015, Availability, affordability and volatility: The case of Hong Kong housing market, International Real Estate Review 18, 383-428.

Leung, C.K.Y., and C.Y. Tse, 2016, Flipping in the housing market, forthcoming in Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control.

Leung, C.K.Y., and J. Zhang, 2011, "Fire sales" in housing market: Is the house-search process similar to a theme park visit? International Real Estate Review 14, 311-329.

Levitt, S., and C. Syverson, 2008, Market distortions when agents are better informed: The value of information in real estate transactions, Review of Economics and Statistics 90, 599-611.

Lin, Z., and Y. Liu, 2008, Real estate returns and risk with heterogeneous investors, Real Estate Economics 36, 753-776.

Lin, Z., and K. D. Vandell, 2007, Illiquidity and pricing biases in the real estate market, Real Estate Economics 35, 291-330.

Lo, A. W., and J. Wang, 2009, Stock market trading volume, in Y. Ait-Sahalia and L. P. Hansen, ed., Handbook of Financial Econometrics, New York: Elsevier.

Lubik, T., 2012, Aggregate labour market dynamics in Hong Kong, Pacific Economic Review 17, 257-279.

Luo, G., 2014, Household credit histories: Slow jobless recovery from mortgage crises. Northwestern University, mimeo.

Malpezzi, S., 2008, Hedonic pricing models: A selective and applied review, in T. O'Sullivan and K. Gibb, ed., Housing Economics and Public Policy: Essays in honor of Duncan Maclennan, Oxford: Blackwell Science Ltd.

Malpezzi, S., 2014, On the rental market of the United States, University of Wisconsin, Madison, mimeo.

Mas-Colell, A., M. Whinston and J. Green, 1995, Microeconomic Theory, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Mayer, C.J., 1995, A model of negotiated sales applied to real estate auctions, Journal of Urban Economics 38, 1-22.

McMillen, D.P., 2012, Repeat sales as a matching estimator, Real Estate Economics 40, 745-73.

Moen, E., and A. Rosen, 2004, Does poaching distort training, Review of Economic Studies 71, 1143-1162.

Moore, A., 2016, Cross-validation for detecting and preventing overfitting, Carnegie Mellon University, mimeo.

Mortensen, D., and C. Pissarides, 1994, Job creation and job destruction in the theory of unemployment, Review of Economic Studies 61, 397-415.

Munneke, H., J. Ooi, C. F. Sirmans and G. Turnbull, 2012, Real estate agents, house prices, and liquidity, mimeo.

Ngai, L. R., and S. Tenreyro, 2014, Hot and cold seasons in the housing market, American Economic Review 104, 3991-4026.

Nguyen-Hoang, P., and J. Yinger, 2011, The capitalization of school quality into house values: A review, Journal of Housing Economics 20, 30-48.

Novy-Marx, R., 2009, Hot and cold markets, Real Estate Economics 37, 1-22.

Peng, L., 2013, How Integrated Is the Commercial Real Estate Asset Market? Evidence from Transaction Cap Rates, University of Colorado, mimeo.

Petrongolo, B., and C. Pissardes, 2001, Looking into the black box: A survey of the matching function, Journal of Economic Literature 39, 390-431.

Piazzesi, M., and M. Schneider, 2009, Momentum Traders in the Housing Market: Survey Evidence and a Search Model, American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings 99, 406-411.

Pissarides, C., 1994, Search unemployment with on-the-job search, Review of Economic Studies 61, 457-475.

Pissarides, C., 2000, Equilibrium Unemployment Theory, 2nd ed., Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Plazzi, A., W. Torous, and R. Valkanov, 2010, Expected returns and expected growth in rents of commercial real estate, Review of Financial Studies 23, 3469-3519.

Qian, W., and P. Liu, 2012, Does (and What) Illiquidity Matter for Real Estate Prices? Measure and Evidence, mimeo.

Rubinstein, A., 1990, Bargaining and Markets, New York: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.

Rutherford, R. C., Springer, T. and A. Yavas, 2005, Conflicts between principals and agents: Evidence from real estate brokerage, Journal of Financial Economics 76, 627-665.

Sivitanidou, R., and P. Sivitanides, 1999, Office capitalization rates: Real estate and capital market influences, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 18, 297-322.

Rivkin, S., E. Hanushek and J.F. Kain, 2005, Teachers, schools, and academic achievement, Econometrica 73, 417-458.

Sargent, T., 1979, Macroeconomic Theory, New York: Academic Press.

Sato, Y., and W. Xiao, 2015, Land development, search frictions and city structure, Regional Science and Urban Economics, 50, 63-76.

Shapiro, J. M., 2006, Smart cities: Quality of life, productivity, and the growth effects of human capital, Review of Economics and Statistics 88, 324--335.

Sims, C.A., 1980, Macroeconomics and reality, Econometrica 48, 1-48.

Sims, C.A., 2010, But economics is not an experimental science. Journal of Economic Perspectives 24, 59-68.

Smith, B. A., and W.P. Tesarek, 1991, House prices and regional real estate cycles: Market adjustments in Houston, Real Estate Economics 19, 396-416.

StataCorp, L., 2013, Stata Base Reference Manual, College Station, TX: Stata Press.

Todd, P., 2006, Matching estimators, University of Pennsylvania, mimeo.

Tse, C. Y., 2004, Search frictions, market power, and long-run growth, Journal of Economic Theory 116, 323-346.

Tse, C. Y., 2011, The Spatial origin of commerce, International Economic Review 52, 349-377.

Tse, C. Y., C.K.Y. Leung and W.Y.F. Chan, 2002, Unemployment and Vacancy in the Hong Kong Labour Market, Applied Economics Letters 9, 221-29.

Wheaton, W.C., 1990, Vacancy, search, and prices in a housing market matching model, Journal of Political Economy 98, 1270.

Williams, J.T., 1995, Pricing real assets with costly search, Review of Financial Studies 8, 55-90.

Wong, E., A. Tsang, S. Kong, 2016, How does loan-to-value policy strengthen resilience of banks to property price shocks -- evidence from Hong Kong, International Real Estate Review 19, 120-149.

Wooldridge, J., 2010, Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, 2nd edition, Cambridge: MIT Press.

Wu, J., J. Gyourko and Y. Deng, 2012, Evaluating conditions in major Chinese housing markets, Regional Science and Urban Economics 42, 531-543.

Xiao, W., 2014, Search frictions, unemployment, and housing in cities: Theory and policies, Journal of Regional Science, 54, 422--449.

Yavas, A., 1992a, Marketmakers versus matchmakers, Journal of Financial Intermediation 2, 33-58.

Yavas, A., 1992b, A simple search and bargaining model of real estate markets, Real Estate Economics 20, 533-548.