Renewable Natural Gas as a Solution to Climate Goals: Response to California's Low Carbon Fuel Standard

Scheitrum, Daniel (2017): Renewable Natural Gas as a Solution to Climate Goals: Response to California's Low Carbon Fuel Standard.

Abstract

Natural gas is a growing portion of transportation fuel consumed in California. While natural gas has a slight environmental benefit relative to the use of conventional liquid fuels, such as gasoline and diesel, the environmental performance of natural gas can be greatly improved by procurement from renewable sources. Yet renewable natural gas (RNG) production is too expensive to compete with fossil natural gas in the absence of policy intervention. I consider the impacts of the LCFS policy on four pathways of RNG production: (1) dairy manure, (2) municipal solid waste, (3) wastewater treatment plants, and (4) landfill gas. Using a novel dataset of California RNG supply estimates, I construct a static, multi-market, partial equilibrium model of the California fuels markets to evaluate the supply response of RNG to existing California fuel policy, the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS). I also evaluate policy response of natural gas from fossil sources, gasoline, ethanol, diesel, and biodiesel fuels. Additionally, I apply a method of modeling consumer fuel switching to accurately reflect the extent to which fuel substitution is possible in the short term. I assess the economic surplus, climate, and RNG response to the LCFS policy and compare the policy efficiency of the LCFS to a hypothetical carbon tax. My findings indicate that the LCFS policy is sufficient to incentivize substantial quantities of RNG production; enough to supply the entire market for vehicular natural gas. Further, the LCFS is less efficient than a carbon tax, but when combined with a price ceiling, the policy approaches the efficiency of a carbon tax as the LCFS policy become more stringent.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: renewable natural gas, methane abatement, fuel standards, multi-market partial equilibrium
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q18 - Agricultural Policy ; Food Policy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q42 - Alternative Energy Sources; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics

References

Anderson, Soren T. 2010. “The Demand for Ethanol as a Gasoline Substitute.” National Bureau of Economic Research.

Arora, Vipin. 2014. “Estimates of the price elasticities of natural gas supply and demand in the United States.” University Library of Munich, Germany.

Borenstein, Severin, James Bushnell, Frank A Wolak, and Matthew Zaragoza-Watkins. 2015. “Expecting the Unexpected: Emissions Uncertainty and Environmental Market Design.” National Bureau of Economic Research.

Bourbon, E. 2016. “Clean Cities Alternative Fuel Price Report: January 2016.” US Department of Energy, Washington, DC.

Brennan, Michael J. 1958. “The supply of storage.” The American Economic Review, 50–72.

Brown, Daryl R, James E Cabe, and Tyson E Stout. 2011. “National lab uses OGJ data to develop cost equations.” Oil and Gas Journal, 109(PNNL-SA-74993).

California Air Resources Board. 2016. “Low Carbon Fuel Standard, Media Request July 28, 2016.” https://www.arb.ca.gov/fuels/lcfs/dashboard/media_request_072816.xlsx.

California Board of Equalization. 2016. “NetTReport Gasoline Gallons.” https://www.boe.ca.gov/sptaxprog/reports/mvf_10_year_report.pdf.

California Code of Regulations. 2015. Title 17. §95488.

California Energy Commission. 2016a. “Fuel and Transportation Division.” http://www.energy.ca.gov/transportation/.

California Energy Commission. 2016b. “Supply and Demand of Natural Gas in California.” http://www.energy.ca.gov/almanac/naturalgas_data/overview.html.

California State Bill 1383. 2016. “An act to add Sections 39730.5, 39730.6, 39730.7, and 39730.8 to the Health and Safety Code, and to add Chapter 13.1 (commencing with Section 42652) to Part 3 of Division 30 of the Public Resources Code, relating to methane emissions.” https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201520160SB1383.

CalRecycle. 2015. “Landfill Tipping Fees in California.” , (Publication #DRRR-2015-1520).

Carter, Colin A, Gordon C Rausser, and Aaron Smith. 2016. “Commodity storage and the market effects of biofuel policies.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Forthcoming.

Coyle, David, Jason DeBacker, and Richard Prisinzano. 2012. “Estimating the supply and demand of gasoline using tax data.” Energy Economics, 34(1): 195–200.

Dahl, Carol A. 2012. “Measuring global gasoline and diesel price and income elasticities.” Energy Policy, 41: 2–13.

Dahl, Carol, and Thomas Sterner. 1991. “Analysing gasoline demand elasticities: a survey.” Energy economics, 13(3): 203–210.

Davis, Stacy C, Susan W Diegel, and Robert G Boundy. 2016. “Transportation Energy Data Book 34.” Oak Ridge National Laboratory.

Dumas, Carl Ryan. 2016. “California dairy industry fights ‘unacheivable’ methane mandate.” http://www.capitalpress.com/California/20160830/california-dairyindustry-fights-unachievable-methane-mandate.

E85Prices. 2016. “State Average Fuel Price.” https://e85prices.com/california.html.

Elam, R, Will Faulkner, C LaPlante, and P Chase. 2015. “2016 California Success Story.” Propel Fuels White Paper.

Electrigaz. 2011. “Economic Study on Renewable Natural Gas Production and Injection Costs in the Natural Gas Distribution Grid in Ontario.”

Energy Information Administration. 2016a. “Almost all U.S. gasoline is blended with 10% ethanol.” https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=26092.

Energy Information Administration. 2016b. “Biofuels: Ethanol and Biodiesel Explained.” https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/index.cfm?page=biofuel_ethanol_use.

Energy Information Administration. 2016c. “Natural Gas Prices.” https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_pri_sum_dcu_SCA_m.htm.

Energy Information Administration. 2016d. “Vehicular Natural Gas Consumption.” https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_sum_lsum_a_EPG0_vdv_mmcf_a.htm.

Energy Information Administration. 2016e. “Weekly Retail Gasoline and Diesel Prices.” https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/pet_pri_gnd_dcus_sca_a.htm.

EPA AgSTAR. 2009. “AGSTAR Database of Livestock Digesters.”

Espey, Molly. 1996. “Explaining the variation in elasticity estimates of gasoline demand in the United States: a meta-analysis.” The Energy Journal, 49–60.

Farrell, Alexander, and Dan Sperling. 2007a. “A low-carbon fuel standard for California, Part 1: Technical analysis.” Institute of Transportation Studies.

Farrell, Alexander, and Dan Sperling. 2007b. “A Low-Carbon Fuel Standard for California, Part 2: Policy Analysis.” Institute of Transportation Studies.

Faulhaber, Carol Rose, D Raj Raman, and RT Burns. 2012. “An engineering-economic model for analyzing dairy plug-flow anaerobic digesters: Cost structures and policy implications.” Transactions of the ASABE, 55(1): 201–209.

Graham, Daniel J, and Stephen Glaister. 2004. “Road traffic demand elasticity estimates: a review.” Transport reviews, 24(3): 261–274.

Holland, Stephen P, Jonathan E Hughes, and Christopher R Knittel. 2009. “Greenhouse gas reductions under low carbon fuel standards?” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 1(1): 106–146.

Hughes, Jonathan E, Christopher R Knittel, and Daniel Sperling. 2006. “Evidence of a shift in the short-run price elasticity of gasoline demand.” National Bureau of Economic Research.

ICF International. 2013. “Californias Low Carbon Fuel Standard: Compliance Outlook for 2020.” Prepared for California Electric Transportation Coalition.

Jaffe, Amy Myers, Rosa Dominguez-Faus, Allen Lee, Kenneth Medlock, Nathan Parker, Daniel Scheitrum, Andrew Burke, Hengbing Zhao, and Yueyue Fan. 2015. “Exploring the Role of Natural Gas in US Transportation.” UC Davis Institute of Transporta- tion Studies NextSTEPS White Paper.

Jaffe, Amy Myers, Rosa Dominguez-Faus, Nathan Parker, Daniel Scheitrum, Justin Wilcock, and Marshall Miller. 2016. “The Feasibility of Renewable Natural Gas as a Large- Scale, Low Carbon Substitute.” California Air Resources Board Final Draft Report Contract No. 13-307.

Johansson, Olof, and Lee Schipper. 1997. “Measuring the long-run fuel demand of cars: sepa- rate estimations of vehicle stock, mean fuel intensity, and mean annual driving distance.” Journal of Transport Economics and policy, 277–292.

Knittel, Christopher R. 2012. “Reducing petroleum consumption from transportation.” The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 26(1): 93–118.

Krugman, Paul. 2010. “Building a green economy.” The New York Times Magazine, 5: 2–16.

Krupnick, Alan J. 2011. “Will Natural Gas Vehicles Be in Our Future?” Resources For the Future, May.

Lade, Gabriel E, and C-Y Cynthia Lin Lawell. 2015a. “The design and economics of low carbon fuel standards.” Research in Transportation Economics, 52: 91–99.

Lade, Gabriel E, and C-Y Cynthia Lin Lawell. 2015b. “Mandating green: On the design of renewable fuel policies and cost containment mechanisms.” University of California, Davis Working Paper.

Lin, C-Y Cynthia, and Lea Prince. 2013. “Gasoline price volatility and the elasticity of demand for gasoline.” Energy Economics, 38: 111–117.

LMOP, EPA. 2015. “United States Environmental Protection Agency Landfill Methane Outreach Program.”

Luchansky, Matthew S., and James Monks. 2009. “Supply and demand elasticities in the U.S. ethanol fuel market.” Energy Economics, 31(3): 403–410.

Metcalf, Gilbert E. 2009. “Market-based policy options to control US greenhouse gas emissions.” The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 23(2): 5–27.

Morse, Edward L, A Yuen, SM Kleinman, Christian Wetherbee, T Thein, I Michaeli, G Cunningham, and RP Smith. 2013. “Energy 2020: Trucks Trains & Automobiles.” Citigroup.

Pachauri, Rajendra K, Myles R Allen, VR Barros, J Broome, W Cramer, R Christ, JA Church, L Clarke, Q Dahe, and P Dasgupta. 2014. Climate change 2014: synthesis Report. Contribution of working groups I, II and III to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. IPCC.

Parker, Nathan. 2016. “Economic Potential for Renewable Natural Gas in California.” Working paper.

Parker, Nathan, Peter Tittmann, Quinn Hart, Richard Nelson, Ken Skog, Anneliese Schmidt, Edward Gray, and Bryan Jenkins. 2010. “Development of a biorefinery optimized biofuel supply curve for the Western United States.” Biomass and Bioenergy, 34(11): 1597-1607.

Rapport, Joshua, Ruihong Zhang, Bryan M. Jenkins, and Robert B. Williams. 2008. “Current Anaerobic Digestion Technologies Used for Treatment of Municipal Organic Solid Waste.” Contractors Report to California Integrated Waste Management Board.

Rubin, Jonathan, and Paul N Leiby. 2013. “Tradable credits system design and cost savings for a national low carbon fuel standard for road transport.” Energy policy, 56: 16–28.

Sandmo, Agnar. 1971. “On the theory of the competitive firm under price uncertainty.” The American Economic Review, 61(1): 65–73.

Schnepf, Randy, and Brent D Yacobucci. 2010. “Renewable fuel standard (RFS): overview and issues.”

Summers, Matthew, and Doug Williams. 2013. “An Economic Analysis of Six Dairy Digester Systems in California.” , (California Energy Commission. Publication number: CEC-500-2014- 001-V1).

Tittmann, PW, NC Parker, QJ Hart, and BM Jenkins. 2010. “A spatially explicit techno- economic model of bioenergy and biofuels production in California.” Journal of Transport Geog- raphy, 18(6): 715–728.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 2016. “Program Overview for Renewable Fuel Standard Program.” https://www.epa.gov/renewable-fuel-standard-program/program-overview-renewable-fuel-standard-program.

Wang, Wei-Guang, Donald W Lyons, Nigel N Clark, M Gautam, and PM Norton. 2000. “Emissions from nine heavy trucks fueled by diesel and biodiesel blend without engine modification.” Environmental Science & Technology, 34(6): 933–939.

Williams, Robert B., Bryan M. Jenkins, and Steve Kaffka. 2015. “An Assessment of Biomass Resources in California.”