Competitor Orientation: Effects of Objectives and Information on Managerial Decisions and Profitability

Armstrong, J. Scott and Collopy, Fred (1996): Competitor Orientation: Effects of Objectives and Information on Managerial Decisions and Profitability. Published in: Journal of Marketing Research No. 33 (1996): pp. 188-199.

Abstract

Managers are often advised, "beat your competitors," which sometimes contrasts with the advice, "do the best for your firm." This may lead managers to focus on comparative measures such as market share. Drawing on game theory, the authors hypothesize that managers are competitor-oriented under certain conditions, in particular, when they are provided with information about competitors' performance. Empirical studies lead to the additional hypothesis that a competitor orientation is detrimental to performance. To examine these hypotheses, the authors conduct two studies. The first is a laboratory study in which 1016 subjects made pricing decisions. When information about the competitor's profits was provided, over 40% of the subjects were willing to sacrifice part of their company's profits to beat or harm the competitor. Such competitor-oriented behavior occurred across a variety of treatments. The second is a field study used to examine the performance over a half-century of 20 large U.S. firms with differing objectives. Firms with competitor-oriented (market share) objectives were less profitable and less likely to survive than those whose objectives were directly oriented to profits.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: competition, profitability, market share
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design

References

Abegglen, James C. and G. Stalk, Jr. (1985), Kaisha: The Japanese Corporation. New York: Basic Books.

Anterasian, Cathy and J. L. Graham (1989), "When It's Good Management to Sacrifice Market Share," Journal of Business Research, 19 (3), 187-213.

Armstrong, J. Scott and R. J. Brodie (1994), "Effects of Portfolio Planning Methods on Decision Making: Experimental Results," International Journal of Research in Marketing, 11 (1), 73-84.

Ashton, R. H. and S. S. Kramer (1980), "Students as Surrogates in Behavioral Accounting Research: Some Evidence," Journal of Accounting Research, 18 (1), 1-16.

Boynton, Robert D., B. F. Blake, and J. N. Uhl (1983), "Retail Price Reporting Effects in Local Food Markets," American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 65 (1), 20-29.

Brodie, Roderick J. and A. Bonfrer (1996), "Do Managers Overreact to Each Others' Promotional Activity? Further Empirical Results," International Journal of Research in Marketing (forthcoming).

Campbell, Donald J. and D. W. Furrer (1995), "Goal Setting and Competition as Determinants of Task Performance," Journal of Organizational Behavior, 16 (4), 377-89.

Campbell, Donald T. and D. W. Fiske (1959), "Convergent and Discriminant Validation of the Multitrait-Multimethod Matrix," Psychological Bulletin, 56 (2), 81-105.

Capon, N., J.U. Farley, and J. M. Hulbert (1987), Corporate Strategic Planning. New York: Columbia University Press.

Corfman, Kim P. and D. Lehmann (1994), "The Prisoner's Dilemma and the Role of Information in Setting Advertising Budgets," Journal of Advertising, 23 (2), 35-48.

Deutsch, Morton (1958), "Trust and Suspicion," Journal of Conflict Resolution, 2 (4), 265-279.

Gordon, Michael L., Allen Slade, and N. Schmitt (1987), "Student Guinea Pigs: Porcine Predictors and Particularistic Phenomena," Academy of Management Review, 12 (1), 160-63.

Griesinger, Donald W. and J. W. Livingston, Jr. (1973), "Toward a Model of Interpersonal Motivation in Experimental Games," Behavioral Science, 18 (3), 173-88.

Griffin, Ricky and K. M. Kacmar (1991), "Laboratory Research in Management: Misconceptions and Missed Opportunities," Journal of Organizational Behavior, 12 (4), 301-11.

Griffith, David E. and R. T. Rust (1994), "The Price of Competitiveness in Competitive Pricing," working paper avail- able from Roland T. Rust, Owen Graduate School of Management, Vanderbilt University.

Hendon, Donald W. (1986), Battling for Profits: How to Win Big on the Marketing Battlefield. Jonesboro, AR: Business Consultants International.

Jacobson, Robert and D. A. Aaker (1985), "Is Market Share All That It's Cracked Up to Be?" Journal of Marketing, 49 (Fall), 11-21.

Kaplan, A. D. H., J. B. Dirlam, and R. F. Lanzillotti (1958), Pricing in Big Business. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.

Kiechel, Walter (1981), "The Decline of the Experience Curve," Fortune, (October 5), 139-46.

Kohn, Alfie (1986), No Contest: The Case Against Competition.

Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

Kotler, Philip (1988), Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, Implementation and Control, 6th ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Kuhlman, D. Michael and A. F. J. Marshello (1975), "Individual Differences in Game Motivation as Moderators of Preprogrammed Strategy Effects in Prisoner's Dilemma," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32 (5), 922-31.

Lanzillotti, Robert F. (1958), "Pricing Objectives in Large Companies," American Economic Review, 48 (5), 921-40.

Leeflang, Peter S. H. and D. R. Wittink (1996), "Competitive Reaction Versus Competitive Response: Do Managers Overreact?" International Journal of Research in Marketing" (forthcoming).

Lieberman, Marvin B. (1987), "The Learning Curve, Diffusion, and Competitive Strategy," Strategic Management Journal, 8, 441-52.

Liebrand, W. B. G. and G. J. van Run (1985), "The Effects of Social Motives on Behavior in Social Dilemmas in Two Cultures," Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 21 (1), 86-102.

Locke, Edwin A. (1986), Generalizing from Laboratory to Field Settings. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.

and G. P. Latham (1990), A Theory of Goal Setting and Task Performance. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Messick, David M. and C. G. McClintock (1968), "Motivational Bases of Choice in Experimental Games," Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 4 (1), 1-25.

W. B. Thomgate (1967), "Relative Gain Maximization in Experimental Games," Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 3 (1), 85-105.

Montgomery, Cynthia A. and B. Wernerfelt (1991), "Sources of Superior Performance: Market Share Versus Industry Effects in the U.S. Brewing Industry," Management Science, 37 (8), 954-59.

Mueller, Dennis C. (1992), "The Corporation and the Economist," International Journal of Industrial Organization, 10 (1), 147-69.

O'Leary-Kelly, Anne M., J. J. Martocchio, and D. W. Frink (1994), "A Review of the Influence of Group Goals on Group Performance," Academy of Management Journal, 37 (5), 1285-301.

Parks, Bill, S. W. Pharr, and B. D. Lockeman (1994), "A Marketer's Guide to Clausewitz: Lessons for Winning Market Share," Business Horizons, 37 (July-August), 68-73.

Porter, Michael E. (1980), Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. New York: The Free Press.

Prescott, John E., A. K. Kohli, and N. Venkatraman (1986), "The Market Share-Profitability Relationship: An Empirical Assessment of Major Assertions and Contradictions," Strategic Management Journal, 7 (4), 377-94.

Scodel, Alvin, J. S. Minas, P. Ratoosh, and M. Lipetz (1959), "Some Descriptive Aspects of Two-Person Non-Zero-Sum Games," Journal of Conflict Resolution, 3 (2), 114-19.

Shimp, Terence A., E. M. Hyatt, and D. J. Snyder (1991), "A Critical Appraisal of Demand Artifacts in Consumer Research," Journal of Consumer Research, 18 (3), 273-83.

Siegel, Sidney and N. J. Castellan, Jr. (1988), Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences. New York: McGraw Hill.

Sigall, H., E. Aronson, and T. van House (1970), "The Cooperative Subject: Myth or Reality?" Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 6 (1), 1-10.

Slater, Robert (1993), The New GE: How Jack Welch Revived an American Institution. Homewood, IL: Business One Irwin.

Slater, Stanley F. and J. C. Narver (1994), "Does Competitive Environment Moderate the Market Orientation-Performance Relationship?" Journal of Marketing, 58 (January), 46-55.

T. J. Zwirlein (1992), "Shareholder Value and Marketing Strategies for Growth Investment Strategy Using the General Portfolio Model," Journal of Management, 18 (4), 717-32.

Suls, Jerry M. (1977), "Social Comparison Theory and Research: An Overview from 1954," in Social Comparison Processes, Jerry M. Suls and R. L. Miller, eds. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Szymanski, David M., S. G. Bharadwaj, and P. R. Varadarajan (1993), "An Analysis of the Market Share-Profitability Relationship," Journal of Marketing, 57 (July), 1-18.

Teger, Allan I. (1980), Too Much Invested to Quit. New York: Pergamon.

Tschoegl, Adrian E. and C. J. Yu (1990), "Gibrat's Law in Marketing: The Case of Liquor Brand Sales," International Journal of Research in Marketing, 7 (4), 249-6.