Retreat from mandatory pension funds in countries of the Eastern and Central Europe in result of financial and fiscal crisis: Causes, effects and recommendations for fiscal rules

Bielawska, Kamila and Chłoń-Domińczak, Agnieszka and Stańko, Dariusz (2017): Retreat from mandatory pension funds in countries of the Eastern and Central Europe in result of financial and fiscal crisis: Causes, effects and recommendations for fiscal rules. Published in: (2017): pp. 1-107.

Abstract

The aim of this book is to assess in various dimensions the causes and effects of the reduction of mandatory pension funds in selected countries of Central-Eastern Europe and to propose changes to existing fiscal rules so that they could respond to the challenge of population ageing impact on public finances. We review the changes made in 2008-2011 in the multi-pillar pension systems CEE region: Hungary, Poland, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, Bulgaria, Slovakia and Romania. All of these countries in the course of late 1990s and early 2000s introduced multi-pillar pension systems that replaced traditional PAYG ones. All countries are also EU member states and are subject to the European policy with regards to the coordination of economic government including public finance situation. However, as analysis reveals they have different social and economic contexts, relevant from the pension systems’ perspective. We make a comprehensive assessment of consequences of limiting the role of funded pillar in societies’ pension security of selected countries of Central and Eastern Europe from macro perspective (public finance) and micro perspective (pension levels of individuals), also combining the two approaches. This helped to determine the costs and benefits of current developments in the short and long term for various stakeholders. The book comprises of seven chapters. The first chapter presents the design and changes in the multi-pillar pension systems in the CEE countries in the light of their public finance situation and broader socio-economic context. Chapter 2 analyses how the pension fund markets functioned due to the pension changes introduced recently by the governments. Chapter 3 makes an assessment of the short-term effects of reduction of pension funds sectors on the public finance situation and the public pension system in each of the analysed countries. Chapter 4 analyses the impact of changes in pension system on the level of pension wealth of individuals. Chapter 5 provides an assessment of the long-term impact of changes in funded systems for the stability of public finances and pension systems. Chapter 6 presents the recommendations on how to strike the balance between fiscal tensions and the need to maintain the role of pension funds in developing sustainable and adequate pensions in the future. The last chapter summarises the findings of the project with regards to the formulated hypotheses. The authors gratefully acknowledge the financing of this project by the National Science Centre, the decision number DEC-2012/05/B/HS4/04206.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: pension reforms, reversals, funded pensions, pension funds, CEE countries, mandatory pension funds, stability of public finances, stability of pension systems, public finance, performance evaluation
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G23 - Non-bank Financial Institutions ; Financial Instruments ; Institutional Investors; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H53 - Government Expenditures and Welfare Programs; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics

References

Aaron H. J. (1966). The social insurance paradox, Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, Vol. 32, 371-374

Alesina A., Perotti R. (1994), Political economy of budget deficits, Working Paper No 4637, NBER, Cambridge MA

Anderson B., Minarik J.J. (2006), Design choices for fiscal policy rules, „OECD Journal on Budgeting” No 4, vol. 5

Barr N. (2000), Reforming Pensions: myths, truths and policy choices, IMF Working Papers, no 139.

Barr, N., P. Diamond (2010). Pension Reform: A Short Guide, Oxford University Press

Beatie R., McGillivary W. (1995), A risky strategy: reflections on the World Bank Report Averting the Old Age Crisis, International Social Security Review, Vol. 3-4

Bielawska K. (2011a), Zmiany w społecznych systemach emerytalnych jako reakcje państw Europy Środkowo-Wschodniej na wzrost ryzyka destabilizacji finansów publicznych [Changes in social pension systems as a reaction of CEE countries to the increase of the risk of public finance destabilisation], [in:] Makroekonomiczne aspekty zarządzania w warunkach kryzysu [Macroeconomic aspects of management in crisis conditions], Prace i Materiały Wydziału Zarządzania Uniwersytetu Gdańskiego, nr 4/4

Bielawska K. (2011b), Czynniki wzrostu deficytu Funduszu Ubezpieczeń Społecznych po 1998 roku [Factors of Social Insurance Fund deficit growth after 1998], [in:] Ubezpieczenia gospodarcze i społeczne. Wybrane zagadnienia ekonomiczne [Commercial and social insurance. Selected economic issues], Oficyna Wolters Kluwer Business, Warszawa 2011

Bielawska K. (2013), The Impact of the Fiscal Situation on Retreat from Mandatory Pension Funds in the Countries of Central and Eastern Europe: the Case Study of Poland and Hungary in Pension Reforms – Comparison and Evaluation, M. Szczepański (ed.), Publishing House of Poznan University of Technology, Poznań

Bielawska, K., Chłoń-Domińczak, A., & Stańko, D. (n.d.). Policy reversals in Central and Eastern European funded pension systems. What are the reasons for downsizing CEE pension funds?, http://kolegia.sgh.waw.pl/pl/KES/struktura/KUS/publikacje/Documents/Chlon_Stanko_firstdraft_Copy.pdf

Blake D. (2009). NDSC v FDC: Pros, Cons and Replication, Non-Financial Defined Contribution Pension Systems, Pensions Institute, Working Paper 09-13

Bongaarts, J. (2001). “Fertility and reproductive preferences in post-transitional societies”. In. R.A.

Bulatao, J. B. Casterline (eds.) Global fertility transition. Supplement to Population and Development Review 27, New York, Population Council, pp. 260-281 Bongaarts, J. (2002). “The end of the fertility transition in the developed world”. Population and Development Review 28 (3): 419-443

Borowski, J., Ciżkowicz, P., Rzońca, A. Wojciechowski, W. (2013). Kapitałowy filar emerytalny a wzrost gospodarki, Wydawnictwo Beck, Warszawa

Bukowski M., Chłoń-Domińczak, Góra M. (2009), Zmiany w systemie emerytalnym a deficyt i dług publiczny [Changes in the pension system and the deficit and public debt], IBS Policy Paper No.1/2009

Casey B.H. (2014), From Pension Funds to Piggy Banks: (Perverse) Consequences of the Stability and Growth Pact Since the Crisis, International Social Security Review, Vol.67, no 1

Castañeda P., Heinz P. Rudolph (2011). Upgrading Investment Regulations in Second Pillar Pension Systems. A Proposal for Colombia, Policy Research Working Paper No. 5775, World Bank Center for Policy Studies PRAXIS (2008), Transition Costs of Reformed Pension Systems, Project No VT/2007/042, Final Report

Chłoń-Domińczak A, Stańko D. (2011), Mandatory funded systems in Central and Eastern Europe. What is left after the crisis?, conference report, GUSTO Pensions Workshop, University of Warwick, 6-7 January, Warwick, http://kolegia.sgh.waw.pl/pl/KES/struktura/KUS/publikacje/-Documents/Chlon_Stanko_firstdraft_Copy.pdf

Chłoń-Domińczak A. (2002), The Polish Pension Reform of 1999, in E. Fultz (ed.) Pension Reform in Central and Eastern Europe, ILO, Budapest

Chłoń-Domińczak A. (2010), Wpływ sytuacji gospodarczej na system emerytalny [Impact of economic situation on the pension system], [in:] Gospodarka i czynniki demograficzne a system emerytalny [Economy and demographic factors vs pension system], IBnGR, Gdańsk

Chłoń-Domińczak, A. and M. Mora. (2003). Commitment and Consensus in Pension Reform. in: R.Holzmann, M.Orenstein, M.Rutkowski (eds.). Pension Reform in Europe: Process and Progress. World Bank, Washington. pp. 131-156

Chłoń A., Góra M., Rutkowski M. (1999). Shaping the Pension Reform in Poland: Security through Diversity. World Bank Social Protection Discussion Paper No 9905

COUNCIL REGULATION (EC) No 1056/2005 of 27 June 2005 amending Regulation (EC) No 1467/97 on speeding up and clarifying the implementation of the excessive deficit procedure, Official Journal of the European Union L 174/5

COUNCIL REGULATION (EC) No 1055/2005 of 27 June 2005 amending Regulation (EC) No 1466/97 on the strengthening of the surveillance of budgetary positions and the surveillance and coordination of economic policies, Official Journal of the European Union L 174/5

COUNCIL REGULATION (EU) No 1177/2011 of 8 November 2011 amending Regulation (EC) No 1467/97 on speeding up and clarifying the implementation of the excessive deficit procedure, Official Journal of the European Union L 306 DG Employment, & Social Protection Committee. (2012).

Pension Adequacy in the European Union 2010-2050. Brussels Dziemianowicz R., Kargol-Wasiluk A (2015), Fiscal Responsibility Laws in EU Member States and Their Influence on the Stability of Public Finance, International Journal of Business and Information, Volume 10, Number 2

Egert, B. (2012). The impact of changes in the second pension pillars on public finances in Central and Eastern Europe, Economic Department Working Paper no 942, OECD, Paris.

European Commission (2004), Classification of Funded Pension Schemes and Impact on Government Finance

European Commission DG ECFIN. (2009). The 2009 Ageing Report: economic and budgetary projections for the EU-27 Member States (2008-2060). European Economy, 2, 27. doi:10.2765/80301

European Commission (2010), Towards adequate, sustainable and safe European pension system, European Commission, COM(2010) 365

European Commission (2012), Specification on the implementation of the Stability and Growth Pact and Guidelines on the format and content of Stability and Convergence Programmes

European Commission (2012), An agenda for adequate, safe and sustainable pensions, White Paper, European Commission, COM(2012) 55 final

European Commission (2012), Fiscal Sustainability Report 2012, European Economy No 8

European Commission (2015), Fiscal Sustainability Report 2015

European Commission DG ECFIN. (2012). The 2012 Ageing Report. Economic and budgetary projections for the 27 EU Member States (2010-2060) (Vol. 2012), doi:10.2765/19991

European Commission (2014), Identifying fiscal sustainability challenges in the areas of pension, health care and long-term care policies, European Economy, Occasional Papers 201

European Commission DG ECFIN. (2014). The 2015 Ageing Report. Underlying Assumptions and Projection Methodologies. European Economy, (8), doi:10.2765/76255

European Commission DG ECFIN. (2015). The 2015 Ageing Report. Economic and budgetary projections for the 28 EU Member States (2013-2060). European Economy, 3, doi:10.2765/877631

European Commission (2015), Making the best use of the flexibility within the existing rules of Stability and Growth Pact, COM (2015) 12 final provisional

Feher, C. and Holtzer, P. (2012) ‘There and Back Again: A Short Story of the Hungarian Pension Reform’, (mimeo)

FIAP (2012). Biannual Report, International Federation of Pension Fund Administrators (Federation International de Administradoras de Fondos de Pensions)

Fultz E. (ed.) (2002). Pension Reform in Central and Eastern Europe, Vol.1 Restructuring with privatization: case studies of Hungary and Poland, International Labour Office – Subregional Office for Central and Eastern Europe, Budapest

Fultz E. (2012). The retrenchment of second-tier pensions in Hungary and Poland: a precautionary tale, International Social Security Review, Vol. 65, no. 3, p.1 – 25

Ghetu D. (2011), CEE pensions under pressure

Goldstein, J.R., T.Sobotka, A.Jasilioniene. (2009). The End of „Lowest-Low“ Fertility?, MPIDR Working Paper WP 2009-029 Guardiancich, I. (2013). Pension Privatization in CEE : World Bank’s failures and European inconsistencies. The 'new pension orthodoxy', (February), pp. 1–20

Guardiancich., I. (2013). Pension Reforms in Central, Eastern and Southeastern Europe. From post-socialist transition to the global financial crisis. Routledge

Holzmann R., Hinz R. (2005), Old age income support in the 21st Century, World Bank

Holzmann, R., M.Orenstein, M.Rutkowski (ed.) (2003). Pension Reform in Europe: Process and Progress, World Bank

Ionescu L., Robles E.A. (2014). Update of IOPS Work on Fees and Charges, IOPS Working Papers on Effective Pensions Supervision, No.20, International Organisation of Pension Supervisors

Jarrett P. (2011), Pension reforms in Poland and elsewhere: the view from Paris, CASE Network Studies and Analysis, No. 425

Jeko M., Nenovsky N. (2012). Capital Pension Schemes in Bulgaria, Hungary and Slovakia Under the Impact of the Ongoing Financial Ciris, East-West Journal of Economics and Business, Vol. XV – 2012, No 1 & 2 (71-88), page 75, http://www.u-picardie.fr/eastwest/fichiers/art108.pdf

Jērāne, J. (2012). 2nd Pension Pillar, Latvian market 2012, presentation for a conference Reforming Baltic pension funds: sound investment and local finance, Tallinn, http://www.ebrd.com/downloads/news/2nd_pension_pillar,_Latvian_market_2012.pdf

Kawiński M., Stańko D., Rutecka J. (2012). Protection mechanisms in the old-age pension systems of the CEE countries, Journal of Pension Economics and Finance Vol. 11(4): 581-605

KNF (2008). Konkurencja na rynku OFE [in Polish: Competition on OFEs market], Polish Financial Supervision Authority (KNF)

Kopits G. (2001), Fiscal rules: useful policy framework or unnecessary ornament, IMF Working Paper, WP/ 01/145, IMF, Washington

Kopits, G., S. Symansky (1998) Fiscal policy rules, IMF, Washington

Kritzer, B.E. (2001-2002) ‘Social Security Reform in Central and Eastern Europe: Variations on a Latin American Theme’, Social Security Bulletin 64(4)

Kumar M. et al. (2009), Fiscal rules – anchoring expectations for sustainable public finances, Fiscal Affairs Department, IMF, Washington 2009

Lindeman, D. M.Rutkowski, O.Sluchynskyy (2001). The Evolution of Pension Systems in Eastern Europea and Central Asia: Opportunities, Constraints, Dillemas and Emerging Practices, The World Bank

Marchewka-Bartkowiak K. (2012), Nowe ponadnarodowe reguły budżetowe odpowiedzią na kryzys zadłużenia publicznego w strefie euro, Studia ekonomiczne (Economic studies) nr 1 (LXXII)

Milev J., Nenovsky N. (2012). Capital Pension Schemes in Bulgaria, Hungary and Slovakia Under the Impact of the Ongoing Financial Crisis, East-West Journal of Economics and Business, Vol. XV – 2012, No 1 & 2 (71-88)

Milos, M. C., & Milos, L. R. (2013). Pension Funds and the Financial Crisis in the CEE Countries. Resita, Faculty of Economics

Müller K. (2003). Privatising old-age security: Latin America and Eastern Europe Compared, Edward Elgar

OECD (2007). Pensions at a Glance 2007. Public Policies across OECD countries

OECD (2009). Pensions at a Glance 2009. Retirement Income Systems in OECD Countries

OECD (2011). Pensions at a Glance 2011. Retirement-Income Systems in OECD and G20 Countries. OECD Publishing

OECD (2013). Pensions at a Glance 2013: OECD and G20 Indicators

Okólski, M. (2007). Europe in movement: migration from/to Central and Eastern Europe. CMR Working Papers No 22/80. Warsaw University

Oksanen H. (2009), Setting targets for government budgets in the pursuit of intergenerational equity, Economic Papers 358, EC, Brussels

Orenstein M., (2011), Pension privatization in crisis: death or rebirth of a global policy trend? International Social Security Review, Vol. 64. 3/2011

Orenstein, M.A. (2008). Privatising Pensions: The Transnational Campaign for Social Security Reform. Princeton University Press

Orszag P.E, Stiglitz J.E. (1999), Rethinking pension reforms: ten myths about social security systems, World Bank

Pater K. (2011), Fiscal debts associated with the European Union policy [w:] Advancing in the strengthening and consolidation of the individually – funded pension systems, FIAP

Piketty, T. (2013). Capital in the Twenty-First Century, Harvard University Press, ISBN 978-0674430006

Polish Financial Supervision Authority (2008) Konkurencja na rynku OFE [in Polish: Competition on OFEs market], Polish Financial Supervision Authority

Price, W., & Rudolph, H. P. (2013). Reversal and Reduction, Resolution and Reform Lessons from the Financial Crisis in Europe and Central Asia to Improve Outcomes from Mandatory Private Pensions. World Bank Report, (77779), pp. 1–82

Raffelhuschen, Mogg (2014). Honorable States? EU Sustainability Ranking 2014 – Key Results, http://www.stiftung-marktwirtschaft.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Generationenbilanz/Key_Results_Honorable_States_2014.pdf

Regulation (EU) No 1173/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 November 2011 on the effective enforcement of budgetary surveillance in the euro area, Official Journal of the European Union L306

Regulation (EU) No 1175/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 November 2011 amending Council Regulation (EC) No 1466/97 on the strengthening of the surveillance of budgetary positions and the surveillance and coordination of economic policies, Official Journal of the European Union L306

Regulation (EU) No 1177/2011 of 8 November 2011 amending Regulation (EC) No 1467/97 on speeding up and clarifying the implementation of the excessive deficit procedure, Official Journal of the European Union L306

Rocha R., D. Vittas. (2002). The Hungarian pension reform: a preliminary assessment of the first years of implementation in M.Feldstein, H.Siebert (eds.), University of Chicago Press, pp. 365 – 400

Rolfe, H., T. Fic, M. Lalani, M. Roman, M. Prohaska and L. Doudeva. (2013). Potential impacts on the UK of future migration from Bulgaria and Romania. National Institute of Economic and Social Research. London

Šarūnas, R. (2012). Pension fund industry in Lithuania, presentation for a conference Reforming Baltic pension funds: sound investment and local finance, Tallinn

Schwarz, A., & Arias, O. (2014). The Inverting Pyramid. Pension Systems Facing Demographic Challenges in Europe and Central Asia. Washington: World Bank

Security through Diversity (1997). The Programme of Polish Pension Reform

Siegel J. (2008). Stocks for the Long Run. The Definitive Guide to Financial Market Returns & Long Term Financial Strategies, 4th ed., The McGraw Hill

Singh A. (1996), Pension reform, the stock market, capital formation and economic growth: a critical commentary on the World’s Bank proposal, International Social Security Review, Vol.3

Sobotka, T. (2004). Is lowest-low fertility explained by the postponement of childbearing? Population and Development Review 30(2): 195-220

Soto M., Clements B., Eich F. (2011), A fiscal indicator assessing the first and second pillar pension reforms , IMF Staff Discussion Note, SDN/11/09

Stańko D. (2009). Pension funds returns. The case of Central and Eastern Europe, in: Investments and Payouts in Funded Pension Systems, International Federation for Pension Fund Administrators (FIAP), Santiago, Chile

Trainor Jr. J.W. (2005), Within-horizon Exposure to Loss for Dollar Cost Averaging and Lump Sum Investing, Financial Services Review, Vol. 14: 319-330

Velculescu D. (2011), Pension reforms in Emerging Europe: the uncertain road ahead, http://www.ebrd.com/downloads/research/news/4441347_-_Pension_Reforms_in_Emerging_Europe_The_Uncertain_Road_Ahead_(D.Velculescu)_-_1_-_DMSDR1S.pdf

Volskis E. (2012). Challenges and enhancements of funded pension schemes in Baltic States, presentation at the Estonian Ministry of Finance and EBRD workshop: “Reforming Baltic pension funds: sound investment and local finance”, 6-7 December 2012, Tallinn, Estonia, http://www.ebrd.com/downloads/news/Challenges_and_enhancements_of_funded_pension_schemes_in_Baltic_States.pdf

von Hagen J. (2002), Fiscal rules, fiscal institutions and fiscal performance, The Economic and Social Review No 3, Vol. 33

von Hagen J. (2005), Political economy of fiscal institutions, GESY Discussion Paper No 149, Mannheim

World Bank. (1994). Averting the Old-age Crisis. Policies to Protect the Old and Promote Growth. Oxford University Press

World Bank. (2006a). Pension reform and the development of pension systems: An evaluation of World Bank assistance. Independent Evaluation Group. World Bank

World Bank. (2006b). Labour Migration from the New EU Member States, World Bank EU8 Quarterly Report, September 2006