Altruistic and selfish motivations of charitable giving: The case of the hometown tax donation system (Furusato nozei) in Japan

Yamamura, Eiji and Tsutsui, Yoshiro and Ohtake, Fumio (2018): Altruistic and selfish motivations of charitable giving: The case of the hometown tax donation system (Furusato nozei) in Japan.

Abstract

This study analyzes the altruistic and selfish motivations of charitable giving in the context of Japan’s hometown tax donation system, whereby people can donate to municipalities where they do not live and receive reciprocal gifts, using local government-level panel data for 2008–2015. We find that the Great East Japan earthquake led to an increase in donations through the system for municipalities with disaster victims, reflecting altruistic motivation. Furthermore, a 1% increase in gift expenditure for donors leads to 0.61% increase in donations, suggesting selfish motivation. Gift provision reduces altruistic donation by nearly 300%, compared with no such provision.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Altruism; Hometown tax donation; Self-interest; Redistribution.
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology > Z18 - Public Policy

References

Ackerman, D., and Auten, G. (2011), Tax Expenditures for Noncash Charitable Contributions, National Tax Journal 64, 651–687.

Allgood, S. (2009), Charity, Impure Altruism, and Marginal Redistributions of Income, National Tax Journal 62, 219–235.

Andreoni, J. (1989), Giving With Impure Altruism: Applications to Charity and Ricardian Equivalence, Journal of Political Economy 97, 1447–1458.

Andreoni, J. (1990), Impure Altruism and Donations to Public Goods: A Theory of ‘Warm Glow’ Giving, Economic Journal 100, 464–477.

Auten, G.E., Sieg, H., and Clotfelter, C.T. (2002), Distribution of Charitable Giving, Income and Taxes: An Analysis of Panel Data, American Economic Review 92, 371–382.

Bakija, J., and Heim, B.T. (2011), How Does Charitable Giving Respond to Incentives and Income? New Estimates From Panel Data, National Tax Journal 64, 615–650.

Becerra, O., Cavallo, E., and Noy, I. (2014), Foreign Aid in the Aftermath of Large Natural Disasters, Review of Development Economics 18, 445–460.

Bessho, S. (2017). How should we improve the gaps of local public finances among local governments? (In Japanese)(Chiho zaisei kakusa wa ikani zesei sareru bekika). Chuo Koron,2017, 3, 76-83.

Blumenthal, M., Kalambokidis, L., and Turk, A. (2012), Subsidizing Charitable Contributions with a Match Instead of a Deduction: What Happens to Donations and Compliance?, National Tax Journal 65, 91–116.

Brooks, A.C. (2002), Charitable Giving in Transition Economies: Evidence from Russia. National Tax Journal 55, 743–753.

Cordes, J.J. (2012), Re-Thinking the Deduction for Charitable Contributions: Evaluating the Effects of Deficit-Reduction Proposals, National Tax Journal 65, 1001–1024.

Costa, D.L., and Kahn, M.E. (2003), Understanding the American Decline in Social Capital, 1952--1998, Kyklos 56,17–46.

Crumpler, H., and Philip J.G. (2008), An Experimental Test of Warm Glow Giving, Journal of Public Economics 92, 1011–1021.

Daily Yomiuri. (2017a). Portal takes action over lavish furustato nozei gift, March 4, 2017, Daily Yomiuri.

Daily Yomiuri. (2017b). Gove to call for limit on hometown tax gift, March 25, 2017, Daily Yomiuri.

Derin-Güre, P., and Uler, N. (2010), Charitable Giving Under Inequality Aversion, Economics Letters 107, 208–210.

Dokko, J.K. (2009), Does the NEA Crowd Out Private Charitable Contributions to the Arts?, National Tax Journal 62, 57–75.

Duquette, C.M. (1999), Charitable Giving by Nonitemizers Responsive to Tax Incentives? New Evidence, National Tax Journal 52, 195–206.

Eckel, C.C., and Philip, J.G. (2003), Rebate Versus Matching: Does How We Subsidize Charitable Contributions Matter?, Journal of Public Economics 87, 681–701.

Eckel, C.C., and Philip, J.G. (2006), Subsidizing Charitable Giving with Rebates or Matching: Further Laboratory Evidence, Southern Economic Journal 72, 794–807.

Fehr, E., and Schmidt, M.K. (1999), A Theory of Fairness, Competition, and Cooperation, Quarterly Journal of Economics 114, 817–868.

Fong, C. (2001), Social Preferences, Self-interest, and the Demand for Redistribution, Journal of Public Economics 82, 225–246.

Gneezy, U., and Rustichini, A. (2000 a), A Fine is a Price, Journal of Legal Studies, 29, 1–17.

Gneezy, U., and Rustichini, A. (2000 b), Pay Enough or Don't Pay at All, Quarterly Journal of Economics 115, 791–810.

Greene, P., and McClelland, R. (2001), Taxes and Charitable Giving, National Tax Journal 54, 433–453.

Greene, W. (2008), Econometric Analysis (sixth ed.), Prentice-Hall, London.

Hagami, T. (2017a), A List of a profit-and-loss account for 1741 local governments all over Japan (In Japanese)( Zenkou 1741 jichitai sontoku kanjo list). Chuo Koron,2017, 3, 40-59.

Hagami, T. (2017b). Competition of the reciprocal gift comes to deteriorate a good sense of municipalities, towns, and villages (In Japanese)(henrei-hin kyoso ga shi-ku-choson no ryoshiki wo ubatte iku). Chuo Koron,2017, 3, 68-75.

Hashimoto, K., and Suzuki, Y. (2017). Reveal the cost for the reciprocal gift voluntarily: Discussing the rights and wrongs of the hometown tax donation system (in Japanese)(Henreihin no keihi muzukara kohyo wo: Keizai Kyoshitsu: Furusato nozei no zehi ), Nikkei News Paper (Nihon Keizai Shimbun), April 6, 2017.

Ishino, T., Ogaki, M., Kamesaka, A., and Murai, S. (2011). Effect of the Great East Japan Disaster on Happiness. Keio/Kyoto Global COE Discussion Paper Series, DP2011–38.

Japan Times (2016). Hometown donations surge, especially after natural disasters. Japan Times, January 17, 2016.

Klor, E.F., and Shayo, M. (2010), Social Identity and Preferences over Redistribution, Journal of Public Economics 94, 269–278.

Luttmer, P. E. (2001), Group Loyalty and the Taste for Redistribution, Journal of Political Economy 109, 500–528.

Luttmer, P. E., and Singhal, M. (2011), Culture, Context, and the Taste for Redistribution. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 3, 157–179.

Nohara, Y. (2017). Rural ‘Furusato nozei’ beer, beef thank-yours costing urban Japan much-needed revenues. Japan Times, January 13, 2017.

Null, C. (2010), Warm Glow, Information, and Inefficient Charitable Giving, Journal of Public Economics 95, 455–465. Osaki, T. (2014). Hometown ‘tax’ donations system catching on. Japan Times, October 20, 2014.

Otake, T. (2016). ‘Hometown donation’ system emerges as effective way to help quake victims. Japan Times, April 21, 2016.

Putnam, R. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community, Simon & Schuster, New York.　

Rey-Biel, P., Sheremeta, R., and Uler, N. (2016). When Income Depends on Performance and Luck: The Effects of Culture and Information on Giving. Working Papers 15-12, Chapman University, Economic Science Institute.

Sato, M. (2016a). The current hometown tax donation system is unacceptable: Donation seeking a favor in return possibly distorts the donation culture of Japan (In Japanese) (Imano Frurusato Nozei wa Okashii: Mikaeri wo motomeru kifu-wa nihon no kifu-bunka wo yugame kanenai). WEBRONZA, Asahi Newspaper, (http://webronza.asahi.com/business/articles/2016042600001.html) (Access Date: 2017-04-02).

Sato, M. (2016b). Is the current hometown tax donation system right ? (In Japanese) (Frurusato Nozei wa konomama de yoika.). Toyokeizai Shimpo, February 13, 9.

Sato, M. (2017). Remove gift in return from the subjects covered by tax deduction (in Japanese)(Henreihin kojo taisho gai ni), Nikkei News Paper (Nihon Keizai Shimbun), April 7, 2017.

Scharf, K., and Smith, S. (2015), The Price Elasticity of Charitable Giving: Does the Form of Tax Relief Matter? International Tax and Public Finance 22, 330–352.

Slemrod, J. (1989), Are Estimated Tax Elasticities Really Just Tax Evasion Elasticities? The Case of Charitable Contributions, Review of Economics and Statistics 71, 517–522.

Slemrod, J. (2010), Old George Orwell Got It Backward: Some Thoughts on Behavioral Tax Economics, FinanzArchiv: Public Finance Analysis 66, 15–33.

Tiehen, L. (2001). Tax Policy and Charitable Contributions of Money, National Tax Journal 54, 707–723.

Yamamura, E. (2010), Effects of Interactions among Social Capital, Income and Learning from Experiences of Natural Disasters: A Case Study from Japan, Regional Studies　44, 1019–1032.

Yamamura, E. (2012), Social Capital, Household Income, and Preferences for Income Redistribution, European Journal of Political Economy 28, 498–511.

Yamamura, E. (2016), Natural Disasters and Social Capital Formation: The Impact of the Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake, Papers in Regional Science 95, 143–164.

Yamamura, E. (2017), Identity, Nostalgia and Happiness among Migrants: The Case of the Kōshien High School Baseball Tournament in Japan. Forthcoming in Pacific Economic Review.

Yamamura, E., Tsutsui, Y., Yamane, C., Yamane, S., and Powdthavee, N. (2015), Trust and Happiness: Comparative Study Before and After the Great East Japan Earthquake, Social Indicators Research 123, 919–935.