The Fallacy of Fiscal Discipline

Canofari, Paolo and Piergallini, Alessandro and Piersanti, Giovanni (2018): The Fallacy of Fiscal Discipline.

Abstract

Fiscal discipline is commonly evaluated on the basis of the debt-GDP ratio, which exhibits a stock variable measured relative to a flow variable. This way of monitoring debt solvency is arguably not consistent with transversality conditions obtained from optimizing macroeconomic frameworks. In this paper we consider a wealth-based sustainability index of government debt policy derived from a baseline endogenous growth model. We calculate the index from 1999 onwards for countries in which the after-growth real interest rate is positive, consistently with the theoretical setup. Results are radically different from common wisdom. We show that the fiscal position is sustainable for both Germany and Italy, and strongly unsustainable for both Japan and France. Policy implications of our findings are discussed.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Fiscal Discipline, Financial Wealth, Sustainability Indicators.
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E60 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy; H - Public Economics > H6 - National Budget, Deficit, and Debt > H60 - General

References

Aizenman, J., and Y. Jinjarak (2010). “De facto Fiscal Space and Fiscalm Stimulus: Definition and Assessment”. NBER Working Paper, No. 16539, November.

Arrow, K., P. Dasgupta, L. Goulder, G. Daily, P. Ehrlich, G. Heal, S. Lewis, K. G. M¨aller, S. Schneider, D. Starrett, and B. Wlaker (2004). “Are We Consuming Too Much?”. Journal of Economic Perspectives 18 (3), 147-172.

Azzimonti, M., E. De Francisco, and V. Quadrini (2014). “Financial Globalization, Inequality, and the Rising Public Debt”. American Economic Review, 104 (8), 2267-2302.

Balassone, F., and D. Franco (2000). “Assessing Fiscal Sustainability: A Review of Methods with a View to EMU”. In Banca d’Italia, Fiscal Sustainability Conference, 21-60, Rome.

Baldacci, E., I. Petrova, N. Belhocine, G. Dobrescu, and S. Mazraani (2011). “Assessing Fiscal Stress”. IMF Working Paper, 11/100, May.

Barro, R. J. (1990). “Government Spending in a Simple Model of Endogenous Growth”. Journal of Political Economy, 98 (5), S103-S125.

Bi, H., and E. M. Leeper (2013). “Analysing Fiscal Sustainability”. Bank of Canada Working Paper, 2013-27, August.

Blanchard, O.J. (1990). “Suggestions for a New Set of Fiscal Indicators”. OECD Economics Department Working Paper, No. 79, April.

Bohn, H. (1998). “The Behavior of U.S. Public Debt and Deficits”. Quarterly Journal of Economics. 113 (3), 949-963.

Bohn, H. (2008). “The Sustainability of Fiscal Policy in the United States”. In R. Neck and J. Sturm. Sustainability of Public Debt. MIT Press, Cambridge, 15-49.

Bruce, N., and S. Turnovsky (1999). “Budget Balance, Welfare, and the Growth Rate: Dynamic Scoring of the Long-run Government Budget”. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 31 (2), 162-186.

Buffie, E. E., A. Berg, C. Pattillo, R. Portillo, and L. F. Zanna (2012). “Public Investment, Growth, and Debt Sustainability: Putting Together the Pieces”. IMF Working Paper, No. 12/144, June.

Buiter, W. H. (1983). “Measurement of the Public Sector Deficit and Its Implications for Policy Evaluation and Design”. IMF Staff Papers, 30 (2), 306-49.

Buiter, W. H. (1985). “A Guide to Public Sector Debt and Deficits”. Economic Policy, 1 (1), 13-79.

Buiter, W. H. (1987). “The Current Global Economic Situation, Outlook and Policy Options, with Special Emphasis on Fiscal Policy Issues”. CEPR Discussion Paper, No. 210, November.

Buiter, W. H., G. Corsetti, and N. Rubini (1993). “Excessive Deficits: Sense and Nonsense in the Treaty of Maastricht”. Economic Policy, 8 (16), 57-100.

Cafiso, G., and R. Cellini (2014). “Fiscal Consolidations and Public Debt in Europe”. International Tax and Public Finance, 21 (4), 614-644.

Canofari, P., G. Marini and G. Piersanti (2015). “Expectations and Systemic Risk in EMU Government Bond Spreads”. Quantitative Finance, 15 (4), 711-724.

Cordella, T., L.A. Ricci, and M. Ruiz-Arranz (2010). “Debt Overhang or Debt Irrelevance?”. IMF Staff Papers, 57 (1), 1-24.

Croce, M. E., and M. V. H. Juan-Ramon (2003). “Assessing Fiscal Sustainability: A Cross Country Comparison”. IMF Working Paper, No. 03/145, July.

Chudik, A., K. Mohaddes, M. H. Pesaran, and M. Raissi (2017). “Is there a Debt Threshold Effect on Output Growth?”. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 99 (1), 135-150.

De Grauwe, P., and Y. Ji (2012). “Self-fulfilling Crises in the Eurozone: An Empirical Test”. Journal of International Money and Finance, 34, April, 15-36.

DeLong, J. B., and L. H. Summers (2012). “Fiscal Policy in a Depressed Economy”. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 43 (1), 233-297.

Egert, B. (2015). “Public Debt, Economic Growth and Nonlinear Effects: Myth or Reality?”. Journal of Macroeconomics, 43 (C), 226-238.

Fournier, J.M., and F. Fall (2015). “Limits to Government Debt Sustainability”. OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 1229, June.

Ghosh, A., J. Kim, E. Mendoza, J. Ostry, and M. Qureshi (2013). “Fiscal Fatigue, Fiscal Space, and Debt Sustainability in Advanced Economies”. The Economic Journal, 123 (566), F4-F30.

Hamilton, J.D., andM. A. Flavin (1986). “On the Limitations of Government Borrowing: A Framework for Empirical Testing”. American Economic Review, 76 (4), 808-819.

Heller P. (2005). “Understanding Fiscal Space”. IMF Working Paper, 05/4, March.

Horne, J. (1991). “Indicators of Fiscal Sustainability”. IMF Working Paper, No. 91/5, January.

House, C. L., C. Proebsting and L. L. Tesar (2017). “Austerity in the aftermath of the Great Recession”. NBER Working Paper, No. 23147, February.

IMF andWorld Bank (2012). “Revisiting the Debt Sustainability Framework for Low-Income Countries”. January.

IMF (2014). “Is it Time for an Infrastructure Push? The Macroeconomic Effects of Public Investment”. World Economic Outlook, October.

IMF (2016). “Assessing Fiscal Space: An Initial Consistent Set of Considerations”. IMF Policy Papers, November.

Ireland, P. (1994). “Supply-side Economics and Endogenous Growth”. Journal of Monetary Economics, 33 (3), 559-571.

Ize, A. (1991). “Measurement of Fiscal Performance in IMF-Supported Programs: Some Methodological Issues”. In Blejer, M. I. and A. Cheasty (eds.). How to Measure the Fiscal Deficit. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund, 52-84.

Jones, L. E. and R. E. Manuelli (1990). “A Convex Model of Equilibrium Growth: Theory and Policy Implications”. Journal of Political Economy, 98 (5), 1008-1038.

Jones, L. E., R. E. Manuelli, and P. E. Rossi (1993). “Optimal Taxation in Models of Endogenous Growth”. Journal of Political Economy, 101(3), 485-517.

Larch, M., and J. Nogueira Martins (2007). “Fiscal Indicators”. European Economy – Economic Papers, No. 297 (Proceedings from the Directorate-General for Economic and Financial AffairsWorkshop Brussels, September 22, 2006).

Marini, G., and A. Piergallini (2008). “Indicators and Tests of Fiscal Sustainability: An Integrated Approach”. CEIS Research Paper, No. 111, February.

Miller, M. (1983). “Inflation Adjusting the Public Sector Financial Deficit”. In Kay, J. (ed.). The 1982 Budget. Basil Blackwell, London.

Ostry, J.D., A.R. Ghosh, J.I. Kim, and M.S. Qureshi (2010). “Fiscal Space”. IMF Staff Position Note 10/11, September.

Ostry, J.D., A.R. Ghosh, and R. Espinoza (2015). “When Should Public Debt Be Reduced?”. IMF Staff Dicussion Note, 15/10, June.

Panizza, U., and A. F. Presbitero (2014). “Public Debt and Economic Growth: Is There a Causal Effect?”. Journal of Macroeconomics, 41 (C), 21-41.

Pecorino, P. (1993). “Tax Structure and Growth in a Model with Human Capital”. Journal of Public Economics, 52 (2), 251-271.

Pescatori, A., D. Sandri, and J. Simon (2014). “Debt and Growth: Is There a Magic Threshold?”. IMF Working Paper, 14/34, Washington, DC, February.

Rebelo, S. (1991). “Long-run Policy Analysis and Long-run Growth.” Journal of Political Economy, 99 (3), 500-521.

Schadler, S. (2016). “Does the Level of Public Debt Matter?”. Centre for International Governance Innovation, Policy Brief No. 76, April.

Trehan, B., and C. Walsh (1988). “Common Trends, The Government Budget Constraint, and Revenue Smoothing”. Journal of Economics Dynamics and Control, 12 (2-3), 425-444.

Turnovsky, S. J. (1996). “Optimal Tax, Debt, and Expenditure Policies in a Growing Economy”. Journal of Public Economics, 60 (1), 21-44.

Turnovsky, S. J. (2000). “Fiscal Policy, Elastic Labor Supply, and Endogenous Growth”. Journal of Monetary Economics, 45 (1), 185-210.

Wyplosz, C. (2011). “Debt Sustainability Assessment: Mission Impossible”. Review of Economics and Istitutions, 2 (3), 1-37.