Using local expert knowledge to measure prices: Evidence from a survey experiment in Vietnam

Gibson, John and Le, Trinh (2019): Using local expert knowledge to measure prices: Evidence from a survey experiment in Vietnam.

Abstract

Many countries lack spatially disaggregated consumer price data. Yet these data are needed to estimate real inequality and spatial patterns of poverty, especially for poor countries where weak infrastructure and high transport costs create big price variation over space. We experimented in Vietnam with a new way of obtaining disaggregated price data, using local expert knowledge to derive the mean and variance for prices of 64 consumer items in over 1000 communities. We used photographs of the specified items to ensure comparability of the reported prices. These prices are used to calculate regional cost-of-living indexes, which provide a good approximation to benchmark multilateral price indexes that are calculated from data obtained from traditional market price surveys. In comparison, two widely used no-price methods, based on using food Engel curves to derive deflators and based on using unit values (survey group expenditures over group quantity) are very poor proxy indicators of prices and of the cost-of-living and would distort estimates of real inequality and the spatial pattern of poverty. Prices from local expert informants also exhibit a basic spatial feature of prices – the Alchian-Allen effect or ‘shipping the good apples out’ – in much the same way as do prices from the traditional survey approach. This effect is one reason why unit values are a bad proxy for prices and this effect should become more important as food systems commercialize. Using expert knowledge to measure local prices is a low-cost and feasible approach that could be adopted more widely in developing countries.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Expert knowledge; Inequality; Prices; Regional Cost-of-Living; Surveys; Vietnam
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration

References

Alchian, A. and W. Allen (1967) University Economics, 2nd Edition, Wadsworth Publishing Company: Belmont, California.

Almås, I., Kjelsrud, A. and Somanathan, R. (2019) A behaviour-based approach to the estimation of poverty in India. Scandinavian Journal of Economics 121(1): 182-224.

Almås, I., & Kjelsrud, A. (2017). Rags and riches: Relative prices, non-homothetic preferences, and inequality in India. World Development 97(1): 102-121.

Borcherding, T. and Silberberg, E. (1978) Shipping the good apples out: the Alchian and Allen theorem reconsidered. The Journal of Political Economy 86(1): 131-138.

Breuer, C. and von der Lippe, P. (2011) Problems of Operationalizing the Concept of a Cost-of-Living Index. MPRA Paper No. 32902.

Deaton, A., Friedman, J., and Alatas, V. (2004) Purchasing Power Parity exchange rates from household survey data: India and Indonesia. Princeton Research Program in Development Studies Working Paper.

Deaton, A. (1988) Quality, quantity, and spatial variation of price. American Economic Review 78(3): 418-430.

Deaton, A. (1989) Household survey data and pricing policies in developing countries. The World Bank Economic Review 3(2): 183-210.

Deaton, A. and Dupriez, O. (2011) Spatial Price Differences Within Large Countries. Mimeo, Princeton University.

Diewert, E. (2005) Weighted Country Product Dummy variable regressions and index number formulae. Review of Income and Wealth 51(4): 561-570.

Dumagan, J. and Mount, T. (1997) Re-examining the Cost-of-Living Index and the Biases of Price Indices. Department of Commerce Working Paper ESA/OPD, 97-5.

Gibson, J. (2016) Poverty measurement: We know less than policy makers realize. Asia and the Pacific Policy Studies 3(3): 430-442.

Gibson, J. and Kim, B. (2013) Quality, quantity, and nutritional impacts of rice price changes in Vietnam. World Development 43(1): 329-340.

Gibson, J. and Kim, B. (2015) Hicksian separability does not hold over space: Implications for the design of household surveys and price questionnaires. Journal of Development Economics 114(1): 34 40.

Gibson, J. and Kim, B. (2018) Economies of scale, bulk discounts, and liquidity constraints: Comparing unit value and transaction level evidence in a poor country. Review of Economics of the Household 16(1): 21-39.

Gibson, J., Le, T., and Kim, B. (2017) Prices, Engel curves, and time-space deflation: Impacts on poverty and inequality in Vietnam. The World Bank Economic Review 31(2): 504 530.

Gibson, J. and Rozelle, S. (2005) Prices and unit values in poverty measurement and tax reform analysis. The World Bank Economic Review 19(1): 69-97.

Gong, H. and Meng, X. (2008) Regional Price Differences in Urban China 1986-2001: Estimation and Implication. Discussion Paper No. 3621, Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA), Bonn.

Hamilton, B. (2001) Using Engel’s Law to estimate CPI bias. American Economic Review 91(3): 619 630.

Prais, S. and Houthakker, H. (1955) The Analysis of Family Budgets, New York: Cambridge University Press.

Rao, P. (2005) On the equivalence of Weighted Country‐Product‐Dummy (CPD) method and the Rao‐system for multilateral price comparisons. Review of Income and Wealth 51(4): 571-580.

Saunders, C, and Grootaert, C. (1980) Reflections on the LSMS group meeting. Living Standards Measurement Study Working Paper No. 10, The World Bank.

Selvanathan, E. (1991) Standard errors for Laspeyres and Paasche index numbers. Economics Letters 35(1): 35-38.

Van Veelen, M., and van der Weide, R. (2008) A note on different approaches to index number theory. American Economic Review 98(4): 1722-1730.

Winters, L. A., McCulloch, N., and McKay, A. (2004) Trade liberalization and poverty: The evidence so far. Journal of Economic Literature 42(1): 72-115.

Wood, D., and Knight, J. (1985) The collection of price data for the measurement of living standards. Living Standards Measurement Study Working Paper No. 21, The World Bank.

World Bank (2012) Well Begun, Not Yet Done: Vietnam’s Remarkable Progress on Poverty Reduction and the Emerging Challenges, World Bank: Hanoi