Learning from physics education research: Lessons for economics education

Simkins, Scott P. and Maier, Mark H. (2008): Learning from physics education research: Lessons for economics education.

Abstract

We believe that economists have much to learn from educational research practices and related pedagogical innovations in other disciplines, in particular physics education. In this paper we identify three key features of physics education research that distinguish it from economics education research - (1) the intentional grounding of physics education research in learning science principles, (2) a shared conceptual research framework focused on how students learn physics concepts, and (3) a cumulative process of knowledge-building in the discipline - and describe their influence on new teaching pedagogies, instructional activities, and curricular design in physics education. In addition, we highlight four specific examples of successful pedagogical innovations drawn from physics education - context-rich problems, concept tests, just-in-time teaching, and interactive lecture demonstrations - and illustrate how these practices can be adapted for economic education.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: economic education; physics education research (PER); research-based teaching; preconceptions; metacognition; transfer; context-rich problems; peer instruction; just-in-time teaching; interactive lecture demonstration
• Subjects: A - General Economics and Teaching > A2 - Economic Education and Teaching of Economics

References

Barkley, Elizabeth F.; Cross, K. Patricia and Major, Claire Howell. Collaborative Learning Techniques: A Handbook for College Faculty. Jossey-Bass, 2005.

Bartlett, Robin L., “The Evolution of Cooperative Learning and Economics Instruction,” W. E. Becker, S. R. Becker and M. W. Watts, Teaching Economics: More Alternatives to Chalk and Talk. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 2006, pp. 39-58.

Becker, W. E. "Teaching Economics to Undergraduates." Journal of Economic Literature, 1997, 35(3), pp. 1347-73.

Becker, William E. "Quantitative Research on Teaching Methods in Tertiary Education," The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education. Indiana University Press, 2004, 265-309.

Becker, William E. and Andrews, Moya L. The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education: Contributions of Research Universities. Indiana University Press, 2004.

Bransford, John; Brown, Ann L.; Cocking, Rodney R. and National Research, Council. How People Learn: Brain, Mind, Experience, and School. National Academy Press, 1999. Online: http://www.nap.edu/html/howpeople1/

Carlson, John A. and Velenchik, Ann D. "Using the Case Method in the Economics Classroom," W. E. Becker, S. R. Becker and M. W. Watts, Teaching Economics: More Alternatives to Chalk and Talk. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 2006, pp. 59-74.

Chizmar, John F. and Ostrosky, Anthony L. "The One-Minute Paper: Some Empirical Findings." The Journal of Economic Education, 1998, 29(1), pp. 3-10. Online: http://www.indiana.edu/~econed/issues/v29_1/1.htm

"Concept Inventory Central," 2008. Online: https://engineering.purdue.edu/SCI/workshop/index.html

Crouch, Catherine H. and Mazur, Eric. "Peer Instruction: Ten Years of Experience and Results." American Journal of Physics, 2001, 69(9), pp. 970-77.

Crouch, Catherine H.; Watkins, Jessica; Fagen, Adam P. and Mazur, Eric. "Peer Instruction: Engaging Students One-on-One, All at Once." Reviews in Physics Education Research, 2007, 1(March). Online: http://www.compadre.org/Repository/document/ServeFile.cfm?DocID=241&ID=4990

Davies, Peter and Mangan, Jean. "Threshold Concepts and the Integration of Understanding in Economics." Studies in Higher Education, 2007, 32(6), pp. 711 - 26.

Elliott, Caroline. "Using a Personal Response System in Economics Teaching." International Review of Economics Education, 2003, 1(1), pp. 80-86. Online: http://www.economicsnetwork.ac.uk/iree/i1/elliott.htm

Halloun, Ibrahim Abou and Hestenes, David. "The Initial Knowledge State of College Physics Students." American Journal of Physics, 1985a, 53(11), pp. 1043-55.

Halloun, Ibrahim Abou and Hestenes, David. "Common Sense Concepts About Motion." American Journal of Physics, 1985b, 53(11), pp. 1056-65.

Hammer, David; Elby, Andrew; Scherr, Rachel E. and Redish, Edward. "Resources, Framing and Transfer," J. P. Mestre, Transfer of Learning from a Modern Multidisciplinary Perspective. Information Age Publishing, 2005, 89-120.

Hansen, W. L.; Salemi, M. K. and Siegfried, J. J. "Use It or Lose It: Teaching Literacy in the Economics Principles Course." American Economic Review, 2002, 92, pp. 463-72.

Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics. "A Private Universe," Annenberg Media, 1997. Online: http://www.learner.org/resources/series28.html

Hazlett, Denise. "Using Classroom Experiments to Teach Economics," W. E. Becker, S. R. Becker and M. W. Watts, Teaching Economics: More Alternatives to Chalk and Talk. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 2006,

Heller, Patricia and Hollabaugh, Mark. "Teaching Problem Solving through Cooperative Grouping. Part 2: Designing Problems and Structuring Groups." American Journal of Physics, 1992, 60(7), pp. 637-44.

Heller, Patricia; Keith, Ronald and Anderson, Scott. "Teaching Problem Solving through Cooperative Grouping. Part 1: Group Versus Individual Problem Solving." American Journal of Physics, 1992, 60(7), pp. 627-36.

Henderson, C. and Rosenthal, A. "Reading Questions: Encouraging Students to Read the Text before Coming to Class." Journal of College Science Teaching, 2006, 35(7), pp. 46-50.

Heron, Paula R. L. and Meltzer, David E. "The Future of Physics Education Research: Intellectual Challenges and Practical Concerns." American Journal of Physics, 2005, 73(5), pp. 390-94.

Hestenes, David; Wells, Malcolm and Swackhamer, Gregg. "Force Concept Inventory." The Physics Teacher, 1992, 30(3), pp. 141-58.

Higher Education Academy Economics Network. "Reflections: Learning Approaches," The Higher Education Academy Economics Network, 2008. Online: http://www.economicsnetwork.ac.uk/showcase/approaches.htm

Kautz, Christian H.; Heron, Paula R. L.; Loverude, Michael E. and McDermott, Lillian C. "Student Understanding of the Ideal Gas Law, Part I: A Macroscopic Perspective." American Journal of Physics, 2005a, 73(11), pp. 1055-63.

Kautz, Christian H.; Heron, Paula R. L.; Shaffer, Peter S. and McDermott, Lillian C. "Student Understanding of the Ideal Gas Law, Part Ii: A Microscopic Perspective." American Journal of Physics, 2005b, 73(11), pp. 1064-71.

Kohl, Patrick B. and Finkelstein, Noah D. "Student Representational Competence and Self-Assessment When Solving Physics Problems." Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research, 2005, 1(1), pp. 010104. Online: http://prst-per.aps.org/abstract/PRSTPER/v1/i1/e010104

Laws, Priscilla W. Workshop Physics Activity Guide. New York: Wiley, 1997.

Mazur, Eric. Peer Instruction: A User's Manual. Upper Saddle River, N.J: Prentice Hall, 1997.

McDermott, Lillian Christie. "Millikan Lecture 1990: What We Teach and What Is Learned---Closing the Gap." American Journal of Physics, 1991, 59(4), pp. 301-15.

McDermott, Lillian C. and Physics Education Group, University of Washington, Physics by Inquiry. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1996.

McDermott, Lillian C. and Redish, Edward F. "Resource Letter: Per-1: Physics Education Research." American Journal of Physics, 1999, 67(9), pp. 755-67.

Millis, Barbara J. and Cottell, Philip G. Cooperative Learning for Higher Education Faculty. Phoenix, Ariz: Oryx Press, 1998.

Meyers, Steven C. “Problem Based Learning in an Applied Econometric Curriculum” Poster Session, Teaching Ideas and Projects, Allied Social Science Association Meetings, New Orleans, January, 2008 Online at: http://gozips.uakron.edu/%7Emyers/scholarship/#2008

Novak, Gregor; Gavrin, Andrew; Christian, Wolfgang and Patterson, Evelyn. Just-in-Time Teaching: Blending Active Learning with Web Technology. Benjamin Cummings, 1999.

Podolefsky, Noah S. and Finkelstein, Noah D. "Analogical Scaffolding and the Learning of Abstract Ideas in Physics: Empirical Studies." Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research, 2007a, 3(2), pp. 020104. Online: http://prst-per.aps.org/abstract/PRSTPER/v3/i2/e020104

Podolefsky, Noah S. and Finkelstein, Noah D. "Salience of Representations and Analogies in Physics," L. McCullough, L. Hsu and C. Henderson, 2007 Physics Education Research Conference (AIP Conference Proceedings). Greensboro, NC: AIP Press, 2007b, 218.

Podolefsky, Noah S. and Finkelstein, Noah D. "Analogical Scaffolding and the Learning of Abstract Ideas in Physics: An Example from Electromagnetic Waves." Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research, 2007c, 3(1), pp. 010109. Online: http://prst-per.aps.org/abstract/PRSTPER/v3/i1/e010109

Pollock, Steven J. and Finkelstein, Noah D. "Sustaining Educational Reforms in Introductory Physics." Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research, 2008, 4(1), pp. 010110. Online: http://prst-per.aps.org/abstract/PRSTPER/v4/i1/e010110

Redish, Edward F. "Millikan Lecture 1998: Building a Science of Teaching Physics." American Journal of Physics, 1999, 67(7), pp. 562-73.

____. Teaching Physics with the Physics Suite. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2003.

REED. "Research in Economic Education Database," 2008, Economic Education Program, Economics Department, University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Online: http://www.cba.unl.edu/outreach/econEd/reed/

Richardson, Jim. "Concept Inventories: Tools for Uncovering Stem Students' Misconceptions," Invention and Impact: Building Excellence in Undergraduate Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Education. Washington, DC: American Association for the Advancement of Science, 2004, 19-25. Online: http://www.aaas.org/publications/books_reports/CCLI/PDFs/02_AER_Richardson.pdf

Salemi, Michael. "Clickenomics: Using a Classroom Response System to Increase Student Engagement in a Large Enrollment Principles of Economics Course," 2008. Online: http://www.unc.edu/~salemi/Papers/Clickenomics%202_20_08.pdf

Saunders, Phillip. "Learning Theory and Instructional Objectives," W. B. Walstad and P. Saunders, Teaching Undergraduate Economics: A Handbook for Instructors. Irwin/McGraw-Hill, 1998, 85-108.

Schwartz, Daniel L.; Bransford, John D. and Sears, David. "Efficiency and Innovation in Transfer," J. P. Mestre, Transfer of Learning from a Modern Multidisciplinary Perspective. Information Age Publishing, 2005, 1-52.

Simkins, Scott and Maier, Mark. "Using Just-in-Time Teaching Techniques in the Principles of Economics Course." Social Science Computer Review, 2004, 22(4), pp. 444-56. Earlier version available online: http://www.ncat.edu/~simkinss/jittecon/jittscholarship/SSCRpaper2004.pdf

Sokoloff, D. R. and Thornton, R. K. "Using Interactive Lecture Demonstrations to Create an Active Learning Environment." Physics Teacher, 1997, 35(6), pp. 340-47.

Sokoloff, David R., Thornton, Ronald K., and Laws, Priscilla W. RealTime Physics: Active Learning Laboratories. Wiley, 2004.

Stokstad, Erik. "Reintroducing the Intro Course." Science, 2001, 293(5535), pp. 1608-10.

Strober, Myra H. and Cook, Allen, “Economics, Lies, and Videotapes,” Journal of Economic Education, 1992, 23(2), pp. 125-151.

Strober, Myra H. "Making and Correcting Errors in Student Economic Analyses: An Examination of Videotapes." Journal of Economic Education, 1997, 28(3), pp. 255-71.

Velenchik, Ann D. "The Case Method as a Strategy for Teaching Policy Analysis to Undergraduates." The Journal of Economic Education, 1995, 26(1), pp. 29-38.

Wieman, Carl. "Why Not Try a Scientific Approach to Science Education?" Change, 2007, 39(5), pp. 9-15.