Indian Fiscal Federalism at the Crossroads: Some reflections

Chakraborty, Lekha S (2019): Indian Fiscal Federalism at the Crossroads: Some reflections.

Abstract

There is a growing recognition that something “fundamental” is happening in Indian fiscal federalism ex-post to the institutional changes like the abolition of the Planning Commission; creation of the NITI Aayog; the Constitutional amendment to introduce GST and the establishment of GST Council; and the historic high tax devolution to the States based on the recommendations of the Fourteenth Finance Commission. Recently the policy makers and experts have raised a few issues, which are (i) to make Finance Commissions permanent or to abolish the Finance Commissions by making the tax devolution share constant through Constitutional Amendment, (ii) the need for an institution to redress spatial inequalities, to fill in the vacuum created by abolishing the Planning Commission, and (iii) arguing the case for Article 282 of the Constitution to be circumscribed. The debates are also focused on whether there is a need establish a link between GST Council and Finance Commissions and should India devise a mechanism of transfer which is predominantly based on sharing of grants for equalization of services rather than tax sharing. What could be a plausible framework for debt-deficit dynamics keeping intact the fiscal autonomy of States and to ensure “output gap” reduction and public investment at the subnational level, without creating bad equilibrium was also another matter of concern. These debates attain significance, especially when for the first time ever a group of States came together to question the Terms of Reference (TOR) of the 15th Finance Commission and there is a growing tension in the Centre-State relations in India.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: : Fiscal federalism, Finance Commission, revenue sharing, fiscal equalization, GST, public debt, fiscal rules
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H6 - National Budget, Deficit, and Debt

References

References

Aguiar Mark and Gita Gopinath, 2007. Emerging Market Business Cycles: Cycles: The Cycle Is the Trend," Journal of Political Economy, University of Chicago Press, vol. 115, pages 69-102.

Ahluwaliah, Montek Singh, 2019. “Comments on Indian Fiscal Federalism”, Panelist to the launch of book “Indian Fiscal Federalism” by Y V Reddy and G R Reddy, at India International Centre, March 28th 2019.

Alesina, Alberto, Guido Tabellini, Francesco Trebbi, 2017, “Is Europe an Optimal Political Area?”, The Brooking Papers on Economic Activity, Spring 2017.

Asian News International (ANI), 2018. “Chidambaram urges states to object 15th Finance Commission” , ANI May 14, 2018. h

Blanchard, Oliver, 2019. Public debt and low interest rate, Presidential Address delivered in American Economic Association meetings , Commentary, Atlanta

Blanchard, Oliver, Pubic Debt and low interest rate, Presidential Address, American Economic Association Meetings, Atlanta, full paper.

Chakraborty, Lekha 2019, “Indian Fiscal Federalism: A Few Empirical Questions” , speech delivered in the panel to the launching of the Book “Indian Fiscal Federalism”, at IIC, new Delhi, March 28th 2019

Chakraborty, Lekha 2018, 15th Finance Commission: What really holds India together?”, The Financial Express.  

Chakraborty, Lekha and Pinaki Chakraborty, 2018. “Federalism, fiscal asymmetries and economic convergence: evidence from Indian States”, Asia-Pacific Journal of Regional Science (2018-04-01) 2: 83-113, Springer.

Chakraborty, Lekha 2016: ‘Fiscal Consolidation, Budget deficits and Macro economy, New Delhi: Sage Publications.

Chakraborty, Pinaki, 2019. Fiscal federalism in India, The India Forum, April 2019.

Chakraborty, Pinaki 2018. “15th Finance Commission: Is it just a South India vs North India debate?”, The Livemint , 10 April 2018.

Chakraborty, Pinaki 2018. “Finance Commission Transfers, The Subramanian formula is flawed?” August 14, 2018. The Financial Express.

Drabu, Haseeb, 2019. “Comments on Indian Fiscal Federalism: Any link between GST Council and Finance Commission?”, Panelist to the launch of book “Indian Fiscal Federalism” by Y V Reddy and G R Reddy, at India International Centre, March 28th 2019.

Hindu, The. 2019. “Fix ratio of tax sharing between Centre and States through a constitutional amendment: Rangarajan”, The Hindu, Chennai

Isaac Thomas, R Mohan and Lekha Chakraborty, 2019. “The Challenges to Indian Fiscal Federalism”, The Leftword Publishers, New Delhi

Isaac Thomas, R Mohan and Lekha Chakraborty, 2019. “Challenges to Indian Fiscal Federalism”, Economic and Political Weekly

Isaac, Thomas 2018. “An open letter to Finance Ministers, The Hindu, May 14th 2018, Chennai.

Kelkar, Vijay 2019. “Towards India’s New Fiscal Federalism, Working paper 252, National Institute of Public Finance and Policy, New Delhi, also published in Journal of Quantitative Economics, 2019, Volume 17, Number 1, Page 237

Marc-Daniel Moessinger, 2014. “Do the personal characteristics of finance ministers affect changes in public debt?”, Public Choice, Volume. 161, No. 1/2 (October 2014), pp. 183-207, Springer

Rao, M Govinda, 2017. “15th Finance Commission: To realise the goals under new India 2022, here is what Centre must remember”, The Financial Express, December 5th 2017.

Reddy Y V , “Indian Fiscal Federalism, “ Speech delivered at Madras School of Economics, Chennai, March 2019

Reddy, G R , 2019. “Unique features of Indian Fiscal Federalism”, talk on the book “Indian Fiscal Federalism” by Y V Reddy and G R Reddy, at the book launch, India International Centre, March 28th 2019.

Reddy, Y V and G R Reddy, 2019. Indian Fiscal Federalism, Oxford University Press.

Reddy, Y V , 2019. Interview to Ira Dugal, Bloomberg Quint, 2019

Reddy Y V 2019. CNBC – TV 18. Indianomics with Former RBI Governor Y V Reddy , by Latha Venkethesh

Reserve Bank of India, 2019., “Some thoughts on Fiscal Federalism, Speech delivered by Shri Shaktikantha Das, Governor, Reserve Bank of India, March 19th 2019, Delivered at the launch of the book “Indian Fiscal Federalism”, Mumbai.

Singh, N K , 2019, “ Speech of Shri N.K. Singh, Chairman, XVFC at the launch of the book ‘Indian Fiscal Federalism’ , PIB, March 28th 2019, Government of India. .

Subramanian Arvind, 2018. Of Counsel: The Challenges of the Modi-Jaitley Economy, 

Vinod Hrishikesh, H Karun and Lekha Chakraborty, 2019. “Encouraging private corporate investment” in Handbook of Statistics, edited by H Vinod and C R Rao, Elsevier 2019