Delivery in the city: evidence on monopolistic competition from New York restaurants

Cosman, Jacob and Schiff, Nathan (2019): Delivery in the city: evidence on monopolistic competition from New York restaurants.

Abstract

We examine the response to entry in a large market with differentiated products using a novel longitudinal dataset of over 550,000 New York City restaurant menus from 68 consecutive weeks. We compare “treated” restaurants facing a nearby entrant to “control” restaurants with no new competition, matching restaurants using location characteristics and a pairwise distance measure based on menu text. Restaurants frequently adjust prices and product offerings, but we find no evidence that they respond differentially to new competition. However, restaurants in the top entry decile are 5% more likely to exit after a year than restaurants in the lowest entry decile.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: spatial competition, monopolistic competition, product differentiation, entry
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D22 - Firm Behavior: Empirical Analysis; D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D43 - Oligopoly and Other Forms of Market Imperfection; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L13 - Oligopoly and Other Imperfect Markets

References

Aaronson, Daniel and Eric French, “Product market evidence on the employment effects of the minimum wage,” Journal of Labor Economics, 2007, 25 (1), 167–200.

Aaronson, Daniel and Eric French, Isaac Sorkin, and Ted To, “Industry dynamics and the minimum wage: a putty-clay approach,” International Economic Review, 2017.

Abadie, Alberto, Susan Athey, Guido W. Imbens, and Jeffrey Wooldridge, “When Should You Adjust Standard Errors for Clustering?,” NBER WP, 2017.

Anderson, Simon P and Andr´e de Palma, “From local to global competition,” European Economic Review, 2000, 44 (3), 423–448.

Atkin, David, Benjamin Faber, and Marco Gonzalez-Navarro, “Retail globalization and household welfare: Evidence from mexico,” Journal of Political Economy, 2018, 126 (1), 1–73.

Austin, Peter C, “Assessing the performance of the generalized propensity score for estimating the effect of quantitative or continuous exposures on survival or time-to-event outcomes,” Statistical methods in medical research, 2018.

Basker, Emek, “Selling a cheaper mousetrap: Wal-Mart’s effect on retail prices,” Journal of Urban Economics, 2005, 58 (2), 203–229.

Behrens, Kristian and Yasusada Murata, “General equilibrium models of monopolistic competition: a new approach,” Journal of Economic Theory, 2007, 136 (1), 776–787.

Benabou, Roland and Jean Tirole, “Identity, morals, and taboos: Beliefs as assets,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2011, 126 (2), 805–855.

Bertoletti, Paolo and Federico Etro, “Preferences, entry, and market structure,” The RAND Journal of Economics, 2016, 47 (4), 792–821.

Boer, Rob, Yuhui Zheng, Adrian Overton, Gregory K Ridgeway, and Deborah A Cohen, “Neighborhood design and walking trips in ten US metropolitan areas,” American journal of preventive medicine, 2007, 32 (4), 298–304.

Busso, Matias and Sebastian Galiani, “The Causal Effect of Competition on Prices and Quality: Evidence from a Field Experiment,” Technical Report 1 January 2019.

Campbell, Jeffrey R, “Competition in large markets,” Journal of Applied Econometrics, 2011, 26 (7), 1113–1136.

Campbell, Jeffrey R. and Hugo A. Hopenhayn, “Market Size Matters,” Journal of Industrial Economics, 2005, 53.

Cavallo, Alberto, “Scraped data and sticky prices,” Review of Economics and Statistics, 2016, (0). Chabe-Ferret, Sylvain, “Bias of Causal Effect Estimators Using Pre-Policy Outcomes,” Working P, 2014.

Chisholm, Darlene C, Margaret S McMillan, and George Norman, “Product differentiation and film programming choice: do first-run movie theatres show the same films?,” Journal of Cultural Economics, 2010, 34 (2), 131–145.

Cosman, Jacob, “Industry dynamics and the value of variety in nightlife: evidence from Chicago,” 2017. Working paper.

Crump, Richard K, V Joseph Hotz, Guido W Imbens, and Oscar A Mitnik, “Dealing with limited overlap in estimation of average treatment effects,” Biometrika, 2009, 96 (1), 187–199.

Damashek, Marc et al., “Gauging similarity with n-grams: Language-independent categorization of text,” Science, 1995, 267 (5199), 843–848.

Dhingra, Swati and John Morrow, “Monopolistic competition and optimum product diversity under firm heterogeneity,” Journal of Political Economy, forthcoming.

Dixit, Avinash K. and Joseph E. Stiglitz, “Monopolistic Competition and Optimum Product Diversity,” American Economic Review, 1977.

Draca, Mirko, Stephen Machin, and John Van Reenen, “Minimum wages and firm profitability,” American economic journal: applied economics, 2011, 3 (1), 129–151.

Fischer, Jeffrey H and Joseph E Harrington Jr, “Product variety and firm agglomeration,” The RAND Journal of Economics, 1996, pp. 281–309.

Flores, Carlos A, Alfonso Flores-Lagunes, Arturo Gonzalez, and Todd C Neumann, “Estimating the effects of length of exposure to instruction in a training program: the case of job corps,” Review of Economics and Statistics, 2012, 94 (1), 153–171.

Freedman, Matthew L and Renata Kosova, “Agglomeration, product heterogeneity and firm entry,” Journal of Economic Geography, 2012, 12 (3), 601–626.

Gasparro, Annie, “McDonald’s Focus on Low Prices Brings in Customers,” The Wall Street Journal, 2019.

Gibbons, Robert and Rebecca Henderson, “Relational contracts and organizational capabilities,” Organization Science, 2012, 23 (5), 1350–1364.

Grubhub, “Grubhub Reports Record Third Quarter Results,” 2018. Accessed at https://investors.grubhub.com/investors/press-releases/press-release-details/2018/Grubhub-Reports- Record-Third-Quarter-Results/default.aspx on 2019-1-17.

Hart, Oliver D, “Monopolistic competition in the spirit of Chamberlin: A general model,” The Review of Economic Studies, 1985, 52 (4), 529–546.

Heckman, James, Hidehiko Ichimura, Jeffrey Smith, and Petra Todd, “Characterizing Selection Bias Using Experimental Data,” Econometrica, 1998, 66 (5), 1017–1098.

Henderson, Rebecca and Eric Van den Steen, “Why do firms have” purpose”? The firm’s role as a carrier of identity and reputation,” American Economic Review, 2015, 105 (5), 326–30.

Hirano, Keisuke and Guido W Imbens, “The propensity score with continuous treatments,” Applied Bayesian modeling and causal inference from incomplete-data perspectives, 2004, 226164, 73–84.

Hoberg, Gerard and Gordon Phillips, “Text-based network industries and endogenous product differentiation,” Journal of Political Economy, 2016, 124 (5), 1423–1465.

Hottman, Colin, “Retail markups, misallocation, and store variety in the US,” Mimeograph, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 2016.

Imbens, GuidoW., “Matching Methods in Practice: Three Examples,” Journal of Human Resources, 2015, 50 (2), 373–419.

Jaffe, Adam B., “Technological Opportunity and Spillovers of R&D: Evidence from Firms’ Patents, Profits, and Market Value,” The American Economic Review, 1986, 76 (5), 984–1001.

Kalnins, Arturs, “Hamburger prices and spatial econometrics,” Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 2003, 12 (4), 591–616.

Kaplan, Sarah and Rebecca Henderson, “Inertia and incentives: Bridging organizational economics and organizational theory,” Organization Science, 2005, 16 (5), 509–521.

Kleinfield, N.R., “In Manhattan Pizza War, Price of Slice Keeps Dropping,” The New York Times, March 2012.

Konishi, H., “Concentration of competing retail stores,” Journal of Urban economics, 2005, 58 (3), 488– 512.

Krizek, Kevin J, “Operationalizing neighborhood accessibility for land use-travel behavior research and regional modeling,” Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2003, 22 (3), 270–287.

Kugler, Agnes and ChristophWeiss, “Time as a strategic variable: business hours in the gasoline market,” Applied Economics Letters, 2016, 23 (15), 1051–1056.

Lafontaine, Francine, “Pricing decisions in franchised chains: a look at the restaurant and fast-food industry,” Technical Report, National Bureau of Economic Research 1995.

Marcus & Millichap, “Retail ResearchMarket Report: New York City, Third Quarter 2017,” Technical Report, Marcus & Millichap Research Services 2017.

Mas-Colell, Andreu, Michael Dennis Whinston, Jerry R Green et al., Microeconomic theory, Vol. 1, Oxford university press New York, 1995.

Matsa, David A, “Competition and product quality in the supermarket industry,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2011, 126 (3), 1539–1591.

Mazzeo, M.J., “Product choice and oligopoly market structure,” The Rand Journal of Economics, 2002, 33 (2), 221–242.

Netz, J.S. and B.A. Taylor, “Maximum or minimum differentiation? Location patterns of retail outlets,” Review of Economics and Statistics, 2002, 84 (1), 162–175.

NYC Department of Consumer Affairs, “Restaurant permits,” 2019. Accessed at https://www1.nyc.gov/nyc-resources/service/2578/restaurant-permit on 2019-1-17.

Olivares, Marcelo and G´erard P Cachon, “Competing retailers and inventory: An empirical investigation of General Motors’ dealerships in isolated US markets,” Management Science, 2009, 55 (9), 1586– 1604.

Parenti, Mathieu, Philip Ushchev, and Jacques-Francois Thisse, “Toward a theory of monopolistic competition,” Journal of Economic Theory, 2017, 167 (C), 86–115.

Pinkse, Joris and Margaret E Slade, “Mergers, brand competition, and the price of a pint,” European Economic Review, 2004, 48 (3), 617–643.

, , and Craig Brett, “Spatial price competition: a semiparametric approach,” Econometrica, 2002, 70 (3), 1111–1153.

Pollak, Michael, “Knowing the Distance,” New York Times, September 17 2006.

Rubin, Donald B and Neal Thomas, “Combining propensity score matching with additional adjustments for prognostic covariates,” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 2000, 95 (450), 573–585.

Salop, Steven C., “Monopolistic competition with outside goods,” Bell Journal of Economics, 1979, 10.

Smith, Jeffrey A and Petra E Todd, “Does matching overcome LaLonde’s critique of nonexperimental estimators?,” Journal of econometrics, 2005, 125 (1), 305–353.

Sweeting, Andrew, “The effects of mergers on product positioning: evidence from the music radio industry,” The RAND Journal of Economics, 2010, 41 (2), 372–397.

Syverson, Chad, “Market Structure and Productivity: A Concrete Example,” Journal of Political Economy, 2004, 112.

Thisse, Jacques-Franc¸ois and Philip Ushchev, “Monopolistic competition without apology,” in “Handbook of Game Theory and Industrial Organization,” Edward Elgar, 2018.

Thomadsen, Raphael, “Product positioning and competition: The role of location in the fast food industry,” Marketing Science, 2007, 26 (6), 792–804.

Tirole, Jean, The Theory of Industrial Organization, MIT Press, 1988.

Toivanen, Otto and Michael Waterson, “Market structure and entry: Where’s the beef?,” RAND Journal of Economics, 2005, pp. 680–699.

Torkells, Erik, “Why Restaurants Hate GrubHub Seamless,” Tribeca Citizen, March 1 2016.

Wikipedia, “Monopolistic comptition,” 2018. Accessed at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopolistic competition on 2019-1-21.

Wolinsky, Asher, “True monopolistic competition as a result of imperfect information,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1986, 101 (3), 493–511.

Xie, Erhao, “Inference in Games without Nash Equilibrium: An Application to Restaurants Competition in Opening Hours,” January 16 2018. Job market paper.

Zhelobodko, Evgeny, Sergey Kokovin, Mathieu Parenti, and Jacques-Franc¸ois Thisse, “Monopolistic competition: Beyond the constant elasticity of substitution,” Econometrica, 2012, 80 (6), 2765–2784