Cooperative Agricultural Farms in Bulgaria (1890 -1989)

Marinova, Tsvetelina and Nenovsky, Nikolay (2020): Cooperative Agricultural Farms in Bulgaria (1890 -1989).

Abstract

In this paper we have proposed an institutional reconstruction of the Bulgarian agricultural cooperatives’ history. The aim was to find the theoretical explanation of the complete deprivation of individuality of the agricultural cooperatives in the years of communism and their rejection respectively during the post-communist period. We consider that a relevant explanation was the accumulation of two institutional processes which were related to the nationalization of the cooperative sector and the cooperative idea. The first one may be referred to as being inertial and related to the specificities of the Bulgarian lagging behind and peripheral capitalism from the beginning of 20th century. That capitalism had a state character. The second institutional process occurred mainly in the wake of WWII. It was related to the large scale and actually mechanical application (despite some nominal specificities) of the Soviet model of agriculture and of the communist ideas of the place of that sector in the planned and all people’s economy. It must be underscored that the ideas of the agricultural cooperatives and the organization of agriculture coming from Russia and later from the USSR also played a definite role for shaping up the general understanding of cooperatives in Bulgaria.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: agricultural cooperatives, communism, Soviet agrarian model, Bulgaria, institutional reconstruction
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N5 - Agriculture, Natural Resources, Environment, and Extractive Industries > N53 - Europe: Pre-1913; P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P13 - Cooperative Enterprises

References

Aldcroft, Derek. 2006. Europe’s Third World. The European Periphery in the Interwar Years. Aldershot: Ashgate. Allisson, François. 2015. Value and Prices in Russian Economic Thought. A Journey inside the Russian Synthesis 1890–1920. Routledge. Allisson, François. 2014. Tugan-Baranovsky on Socialism: From Utopia to the Economic Plan. Œconomia, 4-1: p. 35-53 Arroyo, Jacques. 1983. Political Economy of Socialism. Questions and Answers. Sofia: Partizdat. (in Bulgarian) Arroyo, Jacques. 1986. Law of Value under Socialism. Sofia:Partizdat. (in Bulgarian) Atanasov, Hristiyan. 2017. Rural Credit Development in the Danube Vilayet: "Credit Funds of Public Utility" in the 60s and 70s of the 19th Century". Veliko Tarnovo: Faber. (in Bulgarian) Avramov, Roumen. 2007. Communal Capitalism, Sofia: Bulgarian Science and Art Foundation (in Bulgarian) Bakurdjieva, Teodora. 2009. One Step ahead of Time. Statesman and Reformer Midhat Pasha (1822-1884). Rouse: Avangard Print. (in Bulgarian) Barnett, Vincent, Joachim Zweynert. 2008. Economics in Russia. Studies in Intellectual History (Modern economic and social history): Routledge. Batyrev, Viktor. 1961. On Commodity-Money Relations during the Period of Accelerated Building of Communism, in: Kronrod, I. (Ed). Problems of Political Economy of Socialism, Moscow: Edition Politicheskoi Literaturi (In Russian) Bukharin, Nikolai. [1920] 1979. The Politics and Economics of the Transition Period. London: Routledge. Bukharin, Nikolai, Evgenii Preobrazhensky. [1922] 1969. The ABC of Communism. Penguin Books. Bell, John. 1977. Peasants in Power: Alexander Stamboliiski and the Bulgarian Agrarian National Union: 1899-1923. Princeton: N.J.: Princeton University Press. Berov, Lyuben. 1989. Economy of Bulgaria until the Socialist Revolution, Sofia: Nauka i izkustvo Publisher (in Bulgarian). Bogomazov, Georgi. 1988. Studies on the Commodity-Money Relations under Socialism, In: Bogomazov, G. (Ed.). History of Political Economy in USSR during 1930-1950, Leningrad: Leningrad University Edition, 35-36 (in Russian) Bücher, Karl. [1893] 1901. Industrial Revolution. New York, H. Hold and Company. Central Cooperative Union. 1986. History of the Cooperative Movement in Bulgaria. First volume. Sofia: Otechestven Front Publisher. (in Bulgarian) Central Cooperative Union. 1986. History of the Cooperative Movement in Bulgaria. Second volume. Sofia: Otechestven Front Publisher. (in Bulgarian) Daskalov, Roumen, Diana Mishkova (Eds.). 2014. Entangled histories of the Balkans. Volume two: Transfers of political ideologies and institutions. Sofia: New Bulgarian University. (in Bulgarian) Deyanova, Мariya. 1935. Agrarian Issues of the Balkan Countries. Archives of Economic and Social Policy. Book one. Sofia. (in Bulgarian) Dimitrov, Mitko. 2014. The State and the Economy in Bulgaria during the Interwar Period 1919-1939. Sofia: Publishing Complex-UNWE (in Bulgarian). EIAS, Economics Institute of the Academy of Sciences of the U.S.S.R. 1954. Political economy. Manual. Moscow: Edition Politicheskoi Literaturii. Gruev, Mihail. 2009. Re-ploughed Landmarks: Collectivization and Social Change in the Bulgarian Northwest, 1940s1950s. Sofia: Ciela (in Bulgarian) Halévy, Élie. 1974. Histoire du socialisme européen. Gallimard. Iorga, Nicolae. 1929. Le caractère commun des institutions du Sud-Est de l'Europe. Paris. Ivanov, Мartin. 2012. Gross Domestic Product of Bulgaria 1870-1945. Sofia: Ciela. (in Bulgarian) Kan, Pavel 1988. On Commodity-Money Relations inside the Government Sector, in: Bogomazov, G. (Ed.). History of Political Economy in USSR during 1930-1950, Leningrad: Leningrad University Edition, 57-66 (in Russian) Kojima, Shuichi. 2014. Russian Liberal Visions of Agricultural Development at the Beginning of the Twentieth Century - Litoshenko and Brutzkus, Œconomia 4-1: p. 55-76. Kopsidis, Michael, Martin Ivanov. 2015. Was Gerschenkron Right? Bulgarian Agricultural Growth during the Interwar period in Light of Modern Development Economics. EHES Working papers in economic history №82. Korelin, Avenir. 2009. Cooperation and Cooperative Movements in Russia, 1860-1917. Moscow: Rosspen. Kostov, I. 2018. Testimonies on Transition, 1989 – 1999, Sofia : Ciela Edition Kunin, Petko. 1977. The Process of Building the Socialist Order in the Bulgarian Village. Character and Regularities. Solution of the Agrarian-rural Issue. Sofia: Partizdat. (in Bulgarian) Kurklisiiski, Nikola. 1941. Findings on Lending Activities of Banking Institutions Considering Their Impact on Important Sectors of the Bulgarian National Economy, Varna: Bulgarian Agricultural and Cooperative Bank. (in Bulgarian) Lampe, John. 1986. The Bulgarian Economy in the Twentieth Century. London: Croom Helm. Lavaleye, Émile. 1888. La péninsule des Balkans : Vienne, Croatie, Bosnie, Serbie, Bulgarie, Roumélie, Turquie, Roumanie. Paris:BnF Gallica. Lenin, Vladimir. [1923], 1950. On Cooperation. Selected Works. Vol. II. Moscow. Lutsov, Ivan. 1976. Planning of the National Agrarian-industrial Complex. Theoretical and Methodological Aspects. Sofia: Partizdat. (in Bulgarian) Magnin, Eric, Nikolay Nenovsky. 2016. Dependent Capitalism and Monetary Regimes in the Balkans, in: Trajectoires de transformation et d‘intégration dans l‘Europe du Sud-Est. Défis pour les élargissements futurs, V. Delteil and R. Ivan, Eds., Editura Universităţii din Bucureşti, 173-196. Marinova, Tsvetelina, Nikolay Nenovsky. 2017. Histoire et transformation institutionnelle des banques coopératives bulgares: de l’Empire ottoman à la Première Guerre mondiale. Recma, n° 343, 2017: 131-146. Marinova, Tsvetelina, Nikolay Nenovsky. 2017a. L'apport des banques populaires au progrès économique et social en Bulgarie entre les deux guerres (1919-1938). Recma n° 344 :104-119. Meshcheryakov, Nikolai. 1920. Cooperation and Socialism. Moscow. (in Russian) Migev, Vladimir. 1995. The Collectivization of the Bulgarian Village (1948-1958). Sofia: Stopanstvo Publisher (in Bulgarian). Migev, Vladimir. 1998. Problems of the Agrarian Development of Bulgaria (1944-1960). Sofia: К&M. (in Bulgarian) Nenovsky, Nikolay. 2006. Exchange Rates and Inflation: France and Bulgaria in the Interwar Period and the contribution of Albert Aftalion (1874-1856), Sofia: Bulgarian National Bank. Nenovsky, Nikolay. 2009. Place of Labour and Labour Theory in Tugan Baranovsky’s Theoretical System. The Kyoto Economic Review, 78(1): 53-77. Nenovsky, Nikolay. 2012. Theoretical Debates in Bulgaria during the Great Depression Confronting Sombart, Marx and Keynes. OEconomia, (1): 67 - 101 Nenovsky, Nikolay, Gergana Mihailova – Borissova. 2015. Debts, Ideas and Interests in the Balkans. Chronology of the Post-communist Transformation, 1990-2013, Economie et institutions, 23(2): 121-145 Novakovitch, Dragolioub. 1905. La zadrouga. Les communautés familières chez les Serbes. Paris: A. Pedone. Palazov, Iliya. [1935] 2005. Theory and Practice of the Cooperation. Sofia: Filvest. (in Bulgarian) Pamuk, Sevket. 2016. Economic Growth in Southeastern Europe and Eastern Mediterranean, 1820-1914, Economic alternatives n°3, 2016. Pavlov, Ivan, (Ed.). 1970. 80 Years Anniversary of the First Bulgarian Cooperative in the Village of Mirkovo. Sofia: Profizdat (in Bulgarian) Penchev, Pencho. 2014. Boris Brutzkus and the Theoretical Debate on Socialism, Economic and social alternatives, n°2, 2014. (in Bulgarian) Penchev, Pencho. 2017. Theoretical Analyses of the Dirigisme and Economic Planning among the Bulgarian Economists during the 1930s, MRC Working Papers No 14/2017. (in Bulgarian) Popov, Nikola, (Ed.). 1978. 100 Years of Bulgarian Economy. Sofia: Nauka i izkustvo. (in Bulgarian) Popov, Nikola. 1990. Agrarian Relations under Socialism. Sofia: Publishing house "Kliment Ohridski". (in Bulgarian) Rogalina, Nina. 1998. Boris Brutzkus. A Historian of Russian National Economy. Moscow. (in Russsian) Sazdov, Dimitar (Ed). 2005. The Collectivization and Development of the Bulgarian Agriculture. In: History of the National Economy. Sofia: Stopanstvo, 479-488 (in Bulgarian) Stamboliiski, Aleksander, [1909], 1990. Political Parties or Estate Organizations, Sofia: Bulgarski zemedelski naroden sauz Publisher (in Bulgarian). State Gazette, issue, 282, 1 December 1948. (in Bulgarian) State Gazette, issue, 13, 13 February 1953. (in Bulgarian) Syulemezov, Stoyan. 1975. Cooperative Movement Development in Bulgaria. Sofia: Partizdat. (in Bulgarian) Syulemezov, Stoyan. 1967. Furrows of the Future. Sofia: Narodna mladej. (in Bulgarian) Tambovtzev, Vitalyi. [2014], 2017. Economic Theory of Informal Institutions, Ed. Prospect, Moscow State University, Moscow (in Russian) Todorova, Мariya. 2010 Bulgaria, the Balkans, the World: Ideas, Processes, Events. Sofia: Prosveta. (in Bulgarian) Totomianz, Vahan. 1922. The Cooperative in Russia. Prague. (in Russian) Totomianz, Vahan. 1929. Cooperative Chrestomathy. Prague. (in Russian) Totomianz, Vahan. 1961. The Cooperative (History, Principles, Forms, Importance). Frankfurt am Main. (in Russian) Tugan-Baranovsky, Mikhail. 1916. The Social Foundations of Cooperatives. Moscow: Kušnerev. (in Russian) Tugan-Baranovsky, Mikhail. [1891] 2000. P. Proudhon. His Life and Social Activities, Krasand, Moscow. (in Russian) Tsankov, Аlexander. 1942. The Three Economic Systems: Capitalism, Communism, National Socialism. Sofia. (in Bulgarian) Velikov, Nikola. 1977. Contemporary Issues of the Political Economy of Socialism, part one. Department of post-graduate learning, Sofia. (in Bulgarian) Zagoroff, Slavcho. 1955. Agriculture and Food in Bulgaria before and during World War II. in:Zagoroff, Slavcho, Végh Jeno and Alexander Bilimovich: The Agricultural Economy of the Danubian Countries 1935-45. Stanford:Stanford University Press.