The Wrong Stuff? Creative Class Theory and Economic Performance in UK Cities

Nathan, Max (2007): The Wrong Stuff? Creative Class Theory and Economic Performance in UK Cities. Published in: Canadian Journal of Regional Science , Vol. 3, No. XXX (1 October 2007): pp. 433-450.

Abstract

Richard Florida’s ‘creative class’ theory suggests that diverse, tolerant, ‘cool’ cities will outperform others. Ethnic minorities, gay people and counter-culturalists attract high-skilled professionals: the presence of this ‘creative class’ ensures cities get the best jobs and most dynamic companies. This paper examines Florida’s ideas, focusing on the evidence in British cities. Drawing on previously published work, it first tests the Florida model on a set of British cities, finding weak support for the creative class hypothesis. It then examines this hypothesis in detail. It finds little evidence of a creative class, and little evidence that ‘creative’ cities do better. The paper concludes that the creative class model is a poor predictor of UK city performance. There is other, stronger evidence that diversity and creativity are linked to urban economic growth.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: cities, economic development, urban economics, creative class, diversity, culture, creativity
• Subjects: R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R5 - Regional Government Analysis > R58 - Regional Development Planning and Policy; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R11 - Regional Economic Activity: Growth, Development, Environmental Issues, and Changes; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights

References

Brooks, D. 2000. Bobos in Paradise: The New Upper Class and How They Got There. New York: Touchstone.

Buck, N., I. Gordon, P. Hall, M. Harloe and M. Kleinman. 2002. Working Capital: Life and Labour in Contemporary London. London: Routledge.

Butler, T. 2004. “The Middle Class and the Future of London”, in M. Boddy and M. Parkinson (eds.). City Matters. Bristol: Policy Press.

Champion, T., and T. Fisher. 2004. “Migration, Residential Preferences and the Changing Environment of Cities”, in M. Boddy and M. Parkinson (eds.). City Matters. Bristol: Policy Press.

Charlot, S., and G. Duranton. 2006. “Cities and Workplace Communication: Some Qualitative French Evidence”. Urban Studies, 43: 1365-1394.

Chatterton, P., B. Byrnes, R. Hollands, and C. Reed. 2003. “Changing Our ‘Toon’: Youth, Nightlife and Urban Change in Newcastle”. Discussion paper. Newcastle: CURDS / Sociology and Social Policy Departments.

Costa, D. and M. Kahn. 2000. “Power Couples: Changes in the Locational Choice of the College Educated, 1940-2000”. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112: 827-872.

Countryside Agency. 2004. GB Leisure Day Trips 2004. London: Countryside Agency.

CWHB (Cushman Wakefield Healey and Baker). 2004. European Cities Monitor 2004, London: CWHB.

Demos. 2003. “The Boho Britain Creativity Index”. London: Demos. www.demos.co.uk/uploadstore/docs/BOHO_pr_index.pdf, last accessed June 21, 2005.

Doward, J. 2004. “If You Want to Talk the Talk, Join the Trendsetters in Swinging Wandsworth”. The Observer, 25 January.

Economist. 2006. “Second Thoughts”, 26 August.

Florida, R. 2005. The Flight of the Creative Class: The New Global Competition for Talent. London: Harper Collins.

Florida, R. 2003. The Rise of the Creative Class: And How It’s Transforming Work, Leisure, Community, and Everyday Life. New York: Basic Books.

Florida, R. 2001. “The Geography of Bohemia”. monograph. Pittsburgh: Carnegie Mellon University.

Gertler, M. 2004. “The Future of Cities and Regions in the 21st Century Knowledge Economy”. Presentation to DTI Conference, December. London.

Gibbon, C. 2005. The Cosmopolitan City: Does Richard Florida’s 2002 Paper ‘Bohemia and Economic Geography’ Provide a Useful Tool for Understanding the Spatial Concentrations of High-Tech Employment in Urban Areas in England and Wales?. Unpublished MSc Thesis. London: London School of Economics.

Glaeser, E. 2004. “Review of Richard Florida’s The Rise of the Creative Class”. Unpublished monograph. Cambridge: Harvard University, post.economics.harvard.edu/faculty/glaeser/papers/Review_Florida.pdf, last accessed June 22, 2005.

Glaeser, E. and J. Gottlieb. 2006. “Urban Resurgence and the Consumer City”. Urban Studies, 43: 1275-1299.

Glaeser, E., J. Kolko and A. Saiz. 2001. “Consumer City”. Journal of Economic Geography, 1: 27-50.

Graham, D. 2005. Wider Economic Benefits of Transport Improvements: Link Between City Size and Productivity. London: DFT.

Green, A.E. 1997. “A Question of Compromise? Case Study Evidence on the Location and Mobility Strategies of Dual Career Households”. Regional Studies, 31: 643-659.

Halfpenny, P., N. Britton, F. Devine and R. Mellor. 2004. “The ‘Good’ Suburb as an Asset in Enhancing a City’s Competitiveness”, in M. Boddy and M. Parkinson (eds.). City Matters. Bristol: Policy Press.

Hall, P. and K. Pain. 2006. The Polcycentric Metropolis. London: Earthscan.

Hannigan, J. 2004. “Boom Towns and Cool Cities: The Perils and Prospects of Developing a Distinctive Urban Brand in a Global Economy”. Paper presented at LSE Symposium on The Resurgent City. London, April 19-21.

Hoover, E. 1948. The Location of Economic Activity. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Jacobs, J. 1969. The Economy of Cities. New York: Vintage.

Jarvis, H., A. Pratt and P. Cheng-Chong Wu. 2001. The Secret Life of Cities. London: Prentice Hall.

Kelly, A. 2005. “Liverpool to Debate Gay Quarter Initiative”. Liverpool Daily Post, September 1.

Kotkin, J. 2005. “Urban Legends”. The New Republic, 23 May

Lewis, M. 2005. Home Alone? Unilever Family Report 2005. London: ippr.

McCarthy, J. 2006. “Promoting Image and Identity in Cultural Quarters: The Case of Dundee”. Local Economy, 20: 280-293.

Machin, S. and A. Vignoles. 2001. “The Economic Benefits of Training to the Individual, the Firm and the Economy: the Key Issues”. Paper for Cabinet Office Performance and Innovation Unit. London: PIU.

Malanga, S. 2004. “The Curse of the Creative Class: A New Age theory of Urban Development Amounts to Economic Snake Oil”. Wall St Journal, January 19.

Markusen, A. 2005. “Urban Development and the Politics of a Creative Class: Evidence from the Study of Artists”. Paper presented to RSA Conference on Regional Growth Agendas. Aalborg: May.

Marshall, A. 1920. Principles of Economics. New York: Macmillan.

Martin, R. and P. Sunley. 2003. “Deconstructing Clusters: Chaotic Concept or Policy Panacea?” Journal of Economic Geography, 3: 5-35.

Moore, B. and I. Begg. 2004. “Urban Growth and Competitiveness in Britain: A Long Run Perspective”, in M. Boddy and M. Parkinson (eds.). City Matters. Bristol: Policy Press.

Nathan, M. 2005. “The Wrong Stuff? Creative Class Theory, Diversity and City Performance”. Discussion Paper 1. London: ippr, Centre for Cities.

Nathan, M. and A. Marshall. 2006. “Them and Us: Britain and the European City”. Centre for Cities Discussion Paper 7. London: ippr Centre for Cities.

Nathan, M. and C. Urwin. 2006. City People: City centre living in the UK. London: ippr Centre for Cities.

Nathan, N. and J. Doyle. 2001. “Employment, Place and Identity: A Study of Hypermobile Professionals”. Paper presented at Work, Employment and Society conference. Nottingham, September.

Nathan, N., A. Westwood and T. Cannon. 2003. Welcome to the Ideopolis. London: The Work Foundation.

O’Connor, J. and M. Banks. 2003. “Cultural Industries and the City”, in M. Parkinson and M. Boddy (eds.). Changing Cities: Lessons from Research. Bristol: Policy Press.

ODPM / DTI / HMT 2006. Devolving Decision Making: 3 - Meeting the Regional Economic Challenge: The Importance of Cities to Regional Growth. London: TSO.

ODPM. 2006. The State of the English Cities Report. London: ODPM.

Ottaviano, G. and G. Peri. 2004. “The Economic Value of Cultural Diversity: Evidence from US Cities”, in P. Wood (ed.). The Intercultural City Reader. London: Comedia.

Peck, J. 2005. “Struggling With the Creative Class”. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 24: 740-770.

Pinelli, D., G. Ottoviano and C. Maignan. 2004. “Development and Growth”, in P. Wood (ed.). The Intercultural City Reader. London: Comedia.

Polese, M. 2005. “Cities and National Economic Growth”. Urban Studies, 42: 1429-1451.

Porter, M. 1995. “The Competitive Advantage of the Inner City”. Harvard Business Review, April-May.

Rice, P. and A. Venables. 2004. “Spatial Determinants of Productivity: Analysis for the Regions of Great Britain”. Report for Evidence-Based Policy Fund project Regional Inequalities in the UK: Productivity, Earnings and Skills. LSE: mimeo.

Rosenthal, S. and W. Strange. 2003. “Evidence on the Nature and Sources of Agglomeration Economies“, in J. Henderson and J.-F.Thisse (eds.). Handbook of Urban and Regional Economics. Amsterdam: Elsevier.

Sassen, S. 2006. “Four Dynamics Shaping the Ongoing Utility of Spatial Agglomeration”. Presentation to Cambridge Econometrics Conference, Greater Cities in a Smaller World. Cambridge, July 4-5.

Simmie, J. 2004. “Innovation Clusters and Competitive Cities in the UK and Europe”, in M. Parkinson and M. Boddy (eds.). City Matters. Bristol: Policy Press.

Sriskandarajah, D., L. Cooley and H. Reed. 2005. Paying Their Way: The Fiscal Contribution of Immigrants in the UK. London: ippr.

Storper, M. and M. Manville. 2006. “Behaviour, Preferences and Cities”. Urban Studies, 43:1275-1300.

Storper, M. and A. Venables. 2004. “Buzz: Face to Face Contact and the Urban Economy”. Paper presented at LSE Resurgent City Symposium, April 19-21.

SURF. 2004. Releasing the National Economic Potential of Provincial City- Regions: The Rationale for and Implications of a Northern Way Growth Strategy. London: Office of the Deputy Prime Minister.

Turok, I. 2004. “The Distinctive City: ‘Quality’ as a Source of Competitive Advantage”. Unpublished paper. Glasgow: University of Glasgow.

Urry, J. 2000. Sociology Beyond Societies: Mobilities for the Twenty-First Century. London: Routledge.

Zukin, S. 2004. Point of Purchase: How Shopping Changed America. London: Routledge.

Zukin, S. 1995. Cultures of Cities. Oxford: Blackwell.