Profit maximization or bullshit – where between labour economics and Graeber may employments be?

Mann, Stefan (2020): Profit maximization or bullshit – where between labour economics and Graeber may employments be?

Abstract

The fundamental assumption of labour economics that firms maximize their profits through employment has been challenged through David Graebers “Bullshit Jobs”. We compare the epistemological foundations and empirical grounding of the two concepts. After the methodological paradigms have been explored, the paper looks at the five categories of bullshit jobs that Graeber qualifies and at their contribution to added value on the company and the societal level. Neither the mere assumption of rationality and complete information which labour economists usually pursue nor the complete trust in the narratives of unhappy employees are likely to reveal the full truth. The apparent contradictions can mainly be attributed to the high degree of complexity of the labour world.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: work; labour economics; bullshit jobs
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B59 - Other; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J21 - Labor Force and Employment, Size, and Structure; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J28 - Safety ; Job Satisfaction ; Related Public Policy

References

Abdalkrim, G.M. (2013): The Impact of Strategic Planning Activities on Private Sector Organizations Performance in Sudan: An Empirical Research. International Journal of Business and Management 8 (10) 134-143 Alvesson, M., A. Spicer (2016): The Stupidity Paradox. New York: Profile Books Anand, B.N., R. Shachar (2011): Advertising, the Matchmaker. The RAND Journal of Economics 42 (3) 205-245 Anonymous (2011): Four Jobs That Highlight China’s Inefficiency. https://chinachange.org/2011/05/17/four-jobs-that-highlight-chinas-inefficiency/ (Sept 04, 2019) Arthur, W.B. (2015). Complexity and the Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press Beckerman, W. (2011): Economics as Applied Ethics. Value Judgements in Welfare Economics. New York: Palgrave Beckmann, K.B., L. Reimer (2014): Dynamics of Military Conflict: An Economics Perspective. Review of Economics 65 (2) 193-215 Cahuc, P., A. Zylberberg (2004): Labor Economics. Boston: MIT Press Connelly, B., S.T. Certo, R.D. Ireland, C.R. Reutzel (2011): Signaling Theory: A Review and Assessment. Journal of Management 37 (1) 39-67 Cothren, R. (2002): A Model of Military Spending and Economic Growth. Public Choice 110 (1-2) 121-142 Dewally, M., L. Ederington (2006): Reputation, Certification, Warranties, and Information as Remedies for Seller‐Buyer Information Asymmetries: Lessons from the Online Comic Book Market. The Journal of Business 79 (2) 693-729 Donelson, D.C., R.J. Resutek (2012): The effect of R&D on Future Returns and Earnings Forecasts. Review of Accounting Studies 17 (4) 848-876 Dur, R., M. van Lent (2019): Socially Useless Jobs. Industrial Relations 58 (1) 3-16 Efendioglu, A.M., A.T. Karabulut (2010): Impact of Strategic Planning on Financial Performance of Companies in Turkey. International Journal of Business and Management 5 (4) 3-12 Ehrenberg, R.G., R.S. Smith (2018): Modern Labor Economics – theory and public policy. New York: Routledge Fiedler, I. (2018): Regulation of Online Gambling. Economics and Business Letters 7 (4) 162-168 García-Romero A. (2006): Assessing the Socioeconomic Returns of Biomedical Research (I): How Can We Measure the Relationship between Research and Health Care? Scientometrics 66 249-261. Geroski, P.A. (2003): Competition in Markets and Competition for Markets. Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade 3 (3) 151-166 Glaser, E. (2014): Beyond Bullshit Jobs. Sounding 54 (1) 82-94 Graeber, D. (2013): On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs – A Rant. Strike Graeber, D. (2018): Bullshit Jobs – A Theory. London: Allen Lane Gürtler, J., W. Rupper, K. Vogler-Ludwig (1990): Verdeckte Arbeitslosigkeit in der DDR. Munich: ifo Hafferty, F.W., B. Castellani (2010): The Increasing Complexities of Professionalism. Academic Medicine 85 (2) 288-301 Hall, M.J., S.K. Layson, A.N. Link (2014): The Returns to R&D: Division of Policy Research and Analysis at the National Science Foundation. Science and Public Policy 41 (4) 458-463 Henderson, K.A., H.J. Gibson (2017): An Integrative Review of Women, Gender, and Leisure: Increasing Complexities. Journal of Leisure Research 45 (2) 115-135 Johnson, D.D.P., J.H. Fowler (2011): The Evolution of Overconfidence. Nature 477 317-320 Kahneman, D. (2003): A Psychological Perspective on Economics. American Economic Review 93 (2) 162-168 Kopf, D.A., I.M. Torres, A.P. Ciganek (2012): Advertising and Internet Content Providers: Creating a Market for Information. Journal of Internet Commerce 11 (2) 81-99 Kraus, S., R. Harms, E.J. Schwarz (2006): Strategic Planning in Smaller Enterprises – New Empirical Findings. Management Research News 29 (6) 334-344 Leonard, R.J. (1994): Reading Cournot, Reading Nash: The Creation and Stabilisation of the Nash Equilibrium. The Economic Journal 104 (424) 492-511 Libby, R., K. Rennekamp (2011): Self‐Serving Attribution Bias, Overconfidence, and the Issuance of Management Forecasts. Journal of Accounting Research 50 (1) 197-231 Malmendier, U., T. Taylor (2015): On the Verges of Overconfidence. Journal of Economic Perspectives 29 (4) 3-8 Mann, S. (2006): Merit Goods in a Utilitarian Framework. Review of Political Economy 18 (4) 509-520 Mann, S., M. Reinert, G.K. Botelho Pain, M. Noveli (2019): Children’s Snacks, their Ads and Consumer Sovereignty. Forum for Social Economics 48 (3) 264-280 McCormick, B., I. Stone (2007): Economic Costs of Obesity and the Case for Government Intervention. Obesity Reviews 8 (1) 161-164 McLure, C.E. (1968): Merit Wants – A Normatively Empty Box. Finanzarchiv 27 (3) 474-483 Montiel, I., B.W. Husted, P. Christmann (2011): Using Private Management Standard Certification to Reduce Information Asymmetries in Corrupt Environments. Strategic Management 33 (9) 1103-1113 Nayyar, P.R. (1990): Information Asymmetries: A Source of Competitive Advantage for Diversified Service Firms. Strategic Management 11 (7) 513-519 Ostrom, E. (2010): Organizational Economics: Applications to Metropolitan Governance. Journal of Institutional Economics 6 (1) 109-115 Perks, S. G.D. Austin (2013): Exploring Business Growth Aspirations and Strategic Planning of Hair Dressing Salons in South Africa. Integrative Business and Economics 2 (1) 319-332 Richards, H. (2019): Bullshit Jobs. Journal of Critical Realism 18 (1) 94-97 Schoeffler, S., R.D. Buzzell, D.F. Heany (2013): Impact of Strategic Planning on Profit Performance. In P. McKieman: Historical Evolution of Strategic Management. London: Routledge Spicer, A. (2017): Business Bullshit. London: Routledge Stiglitz J.E. (1989) Principal and Agent. In: Eatwell J., Milgate M., Newman P. (eds) Allocation, Information and Markets. London: Palgrave Macmillan Taiwo, A.S., F.O. Idunnu (2007): Impact of Strategic Planning on Organizational Performance and Survival. Research Journal of Business Management 1 (1) 62-73 Terlaak, A., A.A. King (2006): The Effect of Certification with the ISO 9000 Quality Management Standard: A Signaling Approach. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 60 (4) 579-602 Wakeham, J. (2017): Bullshit as a Problem of Social Epistemology. Sociological Theory 35 (1) 15-38 Wilkinson, R., K. Pickett (2009): The Spirit Level. London: Bloomsbury Wooding, S., S. Anton, J. Grant, S. Hanney, S. Hoorens, A. Lierens, M. Shergold, M. Venema (2004): The Returns from Arthritis Research. https://www.rand.org/pubs/technical_reports/TR176.html (Aug 30, 201