Okun's Law: Copula-based Evidence from G7 Countries

Benos, Nikos and Stavrakoudis, Athanassios (2020): Okun's Law: Copula-based Evidence from G7 Countries.

Abstract

In this paper we present evidence on the association between unemployment and output in the G7 economies, which has direct implications for the validity of Okun's Law. Specifically, we investigate dependence and asymmetry between the residuals of the output and unemployment first difference equations using the copula methodology. We find that dependence between GDP and unemployment disturbances is strong only in USA and France followed by Canada, the UK and Germany. There is no dependence in Italy and Japan. This enhances the validity of Okun's Law in the former countries without invalidating it in Italy and Japan, since there is still a negative relationship given by the systematic part of the output-unemployment difference equations estimates. Also, there is asymmetry in the former five countries. Output disturbances are associated with unemployment ones only during recessions, while they are completely disentangled throughout contractions in the US, France, Canada, the UK and Germany. These findings imply that USA and France, and less so Canada, Great Britain and Germany provide the most favorable environment for counter-cyclical economic policies. In these economies, policy makers should react more than output-unemployment dynamic equations dictate in case of output slumps. However, during recoveries in these countries and in Italy as well as Japan during the whole business cycle, authorities ought to base stabilization policies solely on the systematic part of the relation between output and unemployment changes. Our results provide guidance to policy makers in addition to what is suggested by traditional empirical approaches, which focus on the estimation of the deterministic part of the output-unemployment relationship.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Okun's Law; Dependence; Copula; Asymmetry
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C14 - Semiparametric and Nonparametric Methods: General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E1 - General Aggregative Models > E10 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles

References

Ozer Arabaci and Rabihan Yuksel Arabaci. A flexible nonlinear inference to okuns lawfor turkish economy in the last decade.Panoeconomicus, 65(5):569–586, 2018

Vladimir Arcabic and Eric Olson. Estimates of okun’s law using a new output gap mea-sure.Economics Bulletin, 39(2):929–936, 2019

Jushan Bai and Pierre Perron. Critical values for multiple structural change tests.The Econometrics Journal, 6(1):72–78, 2003

Laurence Ball, Daniel Leigh, and Prakash Loungani. Okun’s law: Fit at 50?Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 49(7):1413–1441, 2017.

Daniel Berg. Copula goodness-of-fit testing: an overview and power comparison.The European Journal of Finance, 15:675–701, 2009

Ioannis Bournakis, Christopher Tsoukis, Dimitris K Christopoulos, and Theodore Palivos.Political Economy Perspectives on the Greek Crisis: Debt, Austerity and Unemployment. Springer, 2017

Fabio Busetti and Andrew Harvey. When is a copula constant? a test for changing rela-tionships.Journal of Financial Econometrics, 15:347–333, 2011

Josep Llu ́ıs Carrion-i Silvestre, Dukpa Kim, and Pierre Perron. Gls-based unit roottests with multiple structural breaks under both the null and the alternative hypothe-ses.Econometric theory, pages 1754–1792, 2009

Semih Emre C ̧ ekin, Ashis Kumar Pradhan, Aviral Kumar Tiwari, and Rangan Gupta.Measuring co-dependencies of economic policy uncertainty in latin american countriesusing vine copulas.The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 2019

Xiaohong Chen and Yanqin Fan. Estimation of copula-based semi parametric time series models.Journal of Econometrics, 130:307–335, 2006

Menzie D Chinn, Laurent Ferrara, and Val ́erie Mignon. Post-recession us employment through the lens of a non-linear Okun’s law. Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research, 2013

K. A. Clarke. A simple distribution-free test for nonnested model selection.PoliticalAnalysis, 15:347–363, 2007

James P. Cover and Sushanta K. Mallick. Identifying sources of macroeconomic andexchange rate fluctuations in the uk.Journal of International Money and Finance, 31:1627–1648, 2012

Jes us Crespo Cuaresma. Okun's law revisited.Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statis-tics, 65(4):439–451, 2003

David O Cushman. A unit root in postwar us real gdp still cannot be rejected, and yes, itmatters.Econ Journal Watch, 13:5–45, 2016

David A Dickey and Wayne A Fuller. Likelihood ratio statistics for autoregressive time series with a unit root. Econometrica, 49:1057–1072, 1981

Robert Dixon, GC Lim, and Jan C van Ours. Revisiting the Okun relationship.AppliedEconomics, 49(28):2749–2765, 2017

Kevin Dowd. Copulas in Macroeconomics.Journal of International and global Economic Studies, 1:1–26, 2008.Graham Elliott, Thomas J. Rothenberg, and James H. Stock. Efficient tests for an autoregressive unit root.Econometrica, 64:813–836, 1996

Yanqin Fan and Andrew J. Patton. Copulas in Econometrics.Annual Review of Eco-nomics, 6:179–200, 2014. doi: 10.1146/annurev-economics-080213-041221

Panos Fousekis, Christos Emmanouilides, and Vasilis Grigoriadis. Price linkages in the international skim milk powder market: empirical evidence from nonparametric and time-varying copulas. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 61(1):135–153, 2017. doi: 10.1111/1467-8489.12147.

Donald G Freeman. Panel tests of Okun’s law for ten industrial countries.Economic Inquiry, 39(4):511–523, 2001

Christian Genest and A. C. Fabre. Everything you always wanted to know about copula modeling but were afraid to ask. Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, 12:347–368,2007.

Christian Genest, Bruno Rmillard, and David Beaudoin. Goodness-of-fit tests for copulas:A review and a power study.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 44:199–213,2009. doi: 10.1016/j.insmatheco.2007.10.005.

Paul Gomme. Shirking, unemployment and aggregate fluctuations.International Eco-nomic Review, 40(1):3–21, 1999

Angelia L Grant. The great recession and Okun’s law.Economic Modelling, 69:291–300,2018.Allan W Gregory and Bruce E Hansen. Residual-based tests for cointegration in model swith regime shifts. Journal of Econometrics, 70:99–126, 1996

Peng Guo, Huiming Zhu, and Wanhai You. Asymmetric dependence between economic policy uncertainty and stock market returns in G7 and bric: A quantile regression ap-proach.Finance Research Letters, 25:251–258, 2018

James Douglas Hamilton.Time series analysis. Princeton University Press, 1994. ISBN0-691-04289-6.Mark J Holmes and Brian Silverstone. Okun’s law, asymmetries and jobless recoveries in the united states: A markov-switching approach.Economics Letters, 92(2):293–299,2006

Ho-Chuan Huang and Chih-Chuan Yeh. Okun’s law in panels of countries and states.Applied Economics, 45(2):191–199, 2013

Ho-Chuan River Huang and Ya-Kai Chang. Investigating Okun’s law by the structural break with threshold approach: Evidence from Canada.The Manchester School, 73(5):599–611, 2005

Wanling Huang, Andre Varella Mollick, and Khoa Huu Nguyen. Us stock markets and the role of real interest rates.The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 59:231–242, 2016

Nir Jaimovich and Henry E. Siu. The Trend is the Cycle: Job Polarization and Jobless Recoveries. http://www.nber.org/papers/w18334, 2012.Harry Joe.Dependence Modeling with Copulas. CRC Press, 2014

Søren Johansen. Estimation and hypothesis testing of cointegration vectors in gaussianvector autoregressive models.Econometrica, 59:1551–1580, 1991

Ivan Kojadinovic, Jun Yan, Mark Holmes, et al. Fast large-sample goodness-of-fit testsfor copulas.Statistica Sinica, 21:841–871, 2011

Denis Kwiatkowski, Peter CB Phillips, Peter Schmidt, and Yongcheol Shin. Testing the null hypothesis of stationarity against the alternative of a unit root.Journal of Econo-metrics, 54:159–178, 1992

Cheng-Feng Lee, Te-Chung Hu, Ping-Cheng Li, and Ching-Chuan Tsong. Asymmetric behavior of unemployment rates: Evidence from the quantile covariate unit root test.Japan and the World Economy, 28:72 – 84, 2013

Jim Lee. The robustness of okun’s law: Evidence from oecd countries.Journal of macroeconomics, 22(2):331–356, 2000

Jun-De Lee, Chien-Chiang Lee, and Chun-Ping Chang. Hysteresis in unemployment revisited: Evidence from panel lm unit root tests with heterogeneous structural breaks.Bulletin of Economic Research, 61:325–334, 2009

Guay C Lim, Robert Dixon, and Jan C van Ours. Beyond okuns law: output growth and labor market flows.Empirical Economics, pages 1–23, 2019

Shu-Chin Lin et al. Smooth-time-varying okun’s coefficients.Economic Modelling, 25(2):363–375, 2008

Jim Malley and Hassan Molana. The relationship between output and unemployment withefficiency wages.German Economic Review, 8(4):561–577, 2007.

Jim Malley and Hassan Molana. Output, unemployment and Okun’s law: Some evidencefrom the g7.Economics Letters, 101(2):113–115, 2008

Hans Manner and Olga Reznikova. A survey on time-varying copulas: Specification,simulations, and application.Econometric Reviews, 31:654–687, 2012

Khaled Mokni and Manel Youssef. Measuring persistence of dependence between crude oil prices and gcc stock markets: A copula approach.The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 72:14–33, 2019.

Imad A. Moosa. A cross-country comparison of okun’s coefficient.Journal of Comparative Economics, 24(3):335–356, 1997

Cesar Nebot, Arielle Beyaert, and Jos ́e Garc ́ıa-Solanes. New insights into the nonlinearityof Okun’s law.Economic Modelling, 82:202–210, 2019

Roger B Nelsen.An introduction to copulas. Springer Series in Statistics. Springer, 2007

A. M. Okun. Potential GNP: Its measurement and significance.American Statistical Association, Proceedings of the Business and Economics Statistics Section, pages 98–104, 1962

Arthur M Okun. The economics of prosperity.Washington, DC: Brookings Institution,1970.Andrew J Patton. A review of copula models for economic time series.Journal of Multi-variate Analysis, 110:4–18, 2012

Roger Perman and Christophe Tavera. Testing for convergence of the Okuns law coefficient in Europe. Empirica, 34(1):45–61, 2007.

Roger Perman, Gaetan Stephan, and Christophe Tav ́era. Okun’s lawa meta-analysis.The Manchester School, 83(1):101–126, 2015.Eric Persson. OECD: Search and Extract Data from the OECD, 2016. URL: http://cran.r-project.org/package=OECD. R package version 0.2.2.2

B. Pfaff.Analysis of Integrated and Cointegrated Time Series with R. Springer, New York, second edition, 2008, ISBN: 0-387-27960-1

B. Pfaff.Package vars, 2015. URL: http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=vars. Rpackage version 1.5-2.P. C. B.

Phllips and Z. Xiao. A primer on unit root testing. Journal of Economic Surveys,12:423–470, 1998

Martin FJ Prachowny. Okun’s law: theoretical foundations and revised estimates.The Review of Economics and Statistics, pages 331–336, 1993

Matiur Rahman and Muhammad Mustafa. Okuns law: evidence of 13 selected developed countries.Journal of Economics and Finance, 41(2):297–310, 2017

Ulf Schepsmeier, Jakob Stoeber, Eike Christian Brechmann, Benedikt Graeler, Thomas Nagler, and Tobias Erhardt.VineCopula: Statistical Inference of Vine Copulas, 2016. URLhttp://CRAN.R-project.org/package=VineCopula. R package version 2.0.4.

Ronald Schettkat. Labor market flows over the business cycle: an asymmetric hiring cost explanation. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics (JITE)/Zeitschrift furdie gesamte Staatswissenschaft, pages 641–653, 1996

Yongcheol Shin, Byungchul Yu, and Matthew Greenwood-Nimmo. Modelling asymmet-ric cointegration and dynamic multipliers in a nonlinear ardl framework. In Festschriftin honor of Peter Schmidt, pages 281–314. Springer, 2014

Paramsothy Silvapulle, Imad A Moosa, and Mervyn J Silvapulle. Asymmetry in okun’slaw.Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d’ ́economique, 37(2):353–374, 2004.

A Sklar. Fonctions de R ́epartition`a N Dimensions Et Leurs Marges.Publications de L’Institut Statistique de L' Universite de Paris, pages 229–231, 1959

Leopold S ̈ogner. Okun’s law does the austrian unemployment-GDP relationship exhibit structural breaks? Empirical Economics, 26(3):553–564, 2001.

James H. Stock and Mark W. Watson. Vector autoregressions. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15:101–115, 2001

James H Stock and Mark W Watson. Disentangling the channels of the 2007-2009 reces-sion. Technical Report 1, Brookings Institution, 2012

Abbas Valadkhani and Russell Smyth. Switching and asymmetric behaviour of the okuncoefficient in the us: Evidence for the 1948–2015 period.Economic Modelling, 50:281–290, 2015

Rob W.J. van den Goorbergh, Christian Genest, and Bas J.M. Werker. Bivariate optionpricing using dynamic copula models.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 37:101–114, 2005. doi: 10.1016/j.insmatheco.2005.01.008

Matti Vir ́en. The okun curve is non-linear.Economics letters, 70(2):253–257, 2001.Quang H. Vuong. Likelihood Ratio Tests for Model Selection and Non-Nested Hypotheses. Econometrica, 57:307–333, 1989

Xiuhua Wang and Ho-Chuan Huang. Okuns law revisited: a threshold in regression quantiles approach.Applied Economics Letters, 24(21):1533–1541, 2017.Luca Zanin and Giampiero Marra. Rolling regression versus time-varying coefficient modelling: An empirical investigation of the Okun’s law in some euro area countries.Bulletin of Economic Research, 64(1):91–108, 2012

Eric Zivot and Donald W. K. Andrews. Further evidence on the great crash, the oil-priceshock, and the unit-root hypothesis.Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 10:251–270, 1992.Syed Zwick, S Syed, et al. Augmented okun’s law within the emu: working-time or employment adjustment? a structural equation model.Economics Bulletin, 36(1):440–448, 2016