Close Encounters of a Heterogeneous Kind: Understanding the Differential Impact of Social Distancing on COVID-19 Infections and Deaths

Gibson, John and Johnson, David and Alexi, Thompson (2020): Close Encounters of a Heterogeneous Kind: Understanding the Differential Impact of Social Distancing on COVID-19 Infections and Deaths.

Abstract

We investigate the relationship between social distancing, as measured by encounter rates using cellphone proximity data, and COVID-19 infections and deaths. Consistent with the existing literature on the effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions, we find a positive and statistically significant relationship between the encounter rate and new infections and deaths. However, the magnitude of this effect is relatively weak. One explanation for this weak effect is that the effectiveness of social distancing varies across counties due to local population heterogeneity. To this end, we interact the encounter rate with county-level characteristics and find that several of these interaction terms are statistically significant. Furthermore, after controlling for these interaction terms, we find that the effect of social distancing is around 20 times larger than the effect size found in estimates without the interactions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: COVID-19; Social Distancing; County-Level Variation; Mask
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I12 - Health Behavior; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I18 - Government Policy ; Regulation ; Public Health; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology > Z18 - Public Policy

References

Allcott, Hunt, Levi Boxell, Jacob C Conway, Billy a Ferguson, Matthew Gentzkow, and Benny Goldman (2020a) `What Explains Temporal and Geographic Variation in the Early US Coronavirus Pandemic?’ Technical Report, National Bureau of Economic Research

Allcott, Hunt, Levi Boxell, Jacob Conway, Matthew Gentzkow, Michael Thaler, and David Y Yang (2020b) ‘Polarization and Public Health: Partisan Differences in Social Distancing During the Coronavirus Pandemic.’ Journal of Public Economics

Andersen, Martin (2020) ‘Early Evidence on Social Distancing in Response to COVID-19 in the United States.’ Available at SSRN 3569368

Banholzer, Nicolas, Eva van Weenen, Bernhard Kratzwald, Arne Seeliger, Daniel Tschernutter, Pierluigi Bottrighi, Alberto Cenedese, Joan Puig Salles, Stefan Feuerriegel, and Werner Vach (2020) ‘Estimating the Impact of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions on Documented Infections with COVID-19: a Cross-Country Analysis.’ medRxiv

Beraud, Guillaume, Steven Abrams, Philippe Beutels, Benoit Dervaux, and Niel Hens (2018) ‘Resurgence Risk for Measles, Mumps and Rubella in France in 2018 and 2020.’ Eurosurveillance 23(25), 1700796

Brenan, Megan (2020) ‘Americans Face Mask Usage Varies Greatly by Demographics.’ Gallup

Brzezinski, Adam, Valentin Kecht, David Van Dijcke, and Austin L Wright (2020) ‘Belief in Science Influences Physical Distancing in Response to Covid-19 Lockdown Policies.’ University of Chicago, Becker Friedman Institute for Economics Working Paper

Caley, Peter, David J Philp, and Kevin McCracken (2008) ‘Quantifying Social Distancing Arising From Pandemic Influenza.’ Journal of the Royal Society Interface 5(23), 631–639

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2019) ‘Underlying Cause of Death, 1999-2018’

Correia, Sergio, Paulo Guimaraes, and Thomas Zylkin (2019) ‘PPMLHDFE: Fast Poisson Estimation with High-Dimensional Fixed Effects.’ arXiv preprint arXiv:1903.01690

Courtemanche, Charles J, Joseph Garuccio, Anh Le, Joshua C Pinkston, and Aaron Yelowitz (2020) ‘Did Social-Distancing Measures in Kentucky Help to Flatten the COVID-19 Curve?’

Coxe, Stefany, Stephen G West, and Leona S Aiken (2009) ‘The Analysis of Count Data: a Gentle Introduction to Poisson Regression and Its Alternatives.’ Journal of Personality Assessment 91(2), 121–136

Dave, Dhaval M, Andrew I Friedson, Kyutaro Matsuzawa, and Joseph J Sabia (2020) ‘When Do Shelter-In-Place Orders Fight Covid-19 Best? Policy Heterogeneity Across States and Adoption Time.’ Technical Report, National Bureau of Economic Research

Dimke, Christine, Marissa C Lee, and Jude Bayham (2020) ‘Working From a Distance: Who Can Afford to Stay Home During COVID-19? Evidence From Mobile Device Data.’ medRxiv

Fan, Jingchun, Xiaodong Liu, Weimin Pan, Mark W Douglas, and Shisan Bao (2020) ‘Epidemiology of 2019 Novel Coronavirus Disease-19 in Gansu Province, China, 2020.’ Emerging Infectious Diseases

Fong, Min W, Huizhi Gao, Jessica Y Wong, Jingyi Xiao, Eunice YC Shiu, Sukhyun Ryu, and Benjamin J Cowling (2020) ‘Nonpharmaceutical Measures for Pandemic Influenza in Nonhealthcare Settings Social Distancing Measures’

Friedson, Andrew I, Drew McNichols, Joseph J Sabia, and Dhaval Dave (2020) ‘Did Californias Shelter-In-Place Order Work? Early Coronavirus-Related Public Health Effects.’ Technical Report, National Bureau of Economic Research

Frydman, Galit H, Edward W Boyer, Rosalynn M Nazarian, Elizabeth M Van Cott, and Gregory Piazza (2020) ‘Coagulation Status and Venous Thromboembolism Risk in African Americans: a Potential Risk Factor in COVID-19.’ Clinical and Applied Thrombosis/Hemostasis 26, 1076029620943671

Gao, Song, Jinmeng Rao, Yuhao Kang, Yunlei Liang, Jake Kruse, Doerte Doepfer, Ajay K Sethi, Juan Francisco Mandujano Reyes, Jonathan Patz, and Brian S Yandell (2020) ‘Mobile Phone Location Data Reveal the Effect and Geographic Variation of Social Distancing on the Spread of the COVID-19 Epidemic.’ arXiv preprint arXiv:2004.11430

Glaeser, Edward L, Caitlin S Gorback, and Stephen J Redding (2020) ‘How Much Does COVID-19 Increase with Mobility? Evidence From New York and Four Other US Cities.’ Technical Report, National Bureau of Economic Research

Gollwitzer, Anton, Cameron Martel, Julia Marshall, Johanna Marie Hohs, and John A Bargh (2020) ‘Connecting Self-Reported Social Distancing to Real-World Behavior At the Individual and US State Level’

Goolsbee, Austan, and Chad Syverson (2020) ‘Fear, Lockdown, and Diversion: Comparing Drivers of Pandemic Economic Decline 2020.’ Technical Report, National Bureau of Economic Research

Guzzetta, Giorgio, Flavia Riccardo, Valentina Marziano, Piero Poletti, Filippo Trentini, Antonino Bella, Xanthi Andrianou, Martina Del Manso, Massimo Fabiani, Stefania Bellino et al. (2020) ‘The Impact of a Nation-Wide Lockdown on COVID-19 Transmissibility in Italy.’ arXiv preprint arXiv:2004.12338

Hausman, Jerry a, Bronwyn H Hall, and Zvi Griliches (1984) ‘Econometric Models for Count Data with an Application to the Patents-R&D Relationship’

Holtgrave, David R (2010) ‘Is the Elimination of HIV Infection within Reach in the United States? Lessons from an Epidemiologic Transmission Model.’ Public Health Reports 125(3), 372–376

Homaira, N, N Briggs, J-L Oei, L Hilder, B Bajuk, T Snelling, and A Jaffe (2018) ‘High Impact of Influenza on Hospitalisation Rates in Children with a Range of Chronic Lung Diseases: a Population-Based Study.’ International Journal of Infectious Diseases 73, 36 20

Homaira, Nusrat, Stephen P Luby, William a Petri, Raija Vainionpaa, Mustafizur Rahman, Kamal Hossain, Cynthia B Snider, Mahmudur Rahman, ASM Alamgir, Farzina Zesmin et al. (2012) ‘Incidence of Respiratory Virus-Associated Pneumonia in Urban Poor Young Children of Dhaka, Bangladesh, 2009–2011.’ PloS one

Hutchinson, M Katherine, and Matthew C Holtman (2005) ‘Analysis of Count Data Using Poisson Regression.’ Research in nursing & health 28(5), 408–418

Kadambari, Seilesh, Paul Klenerman, and Andrew J Pollard (2020) ‘Why the Elderly Appear to Be More Severely Affected by COVID-19: the Potential Role of Immunosenescence and CMV.’ Reviews in medical virology 30(5), e2144

Kelso, Joel K, George J Milne, and Heath Kelly (2009) ‘Simulation Suggests That Rapid Activation of Social Distancing Can Arrest Epidemic Development Due to a Novel Strain of Influenza.’ BMC Public Health 9(1), 117

Khubchandani, Jagdish, Diana Saiki, and Jayanthi Kandiah (2020) ‘Masks, Gloves, and the COVID-19 Pandemic: Rapid Assessment of Public Behaviors in the United States.’ Epidemiologia 1(1), 16–22

Lehmann, Eliyahu Y, and Lisa Soleymani Lehmann (2020) ‘Responding to Patients Who Refuse to Wear Masks During the Covid-19 Pandemic.’ Journal of General Internal Medicine pp. 1–2

Lovett, Andrew, and Robin Flowerdew (1989) ‘Analysis of Count Data Using Poisson Regression.’ The Professional Geographer 41(2), 190–198

Ma, Junling (2020) ‘Estimating Epidemic Exponential Growth Rate and Basic Reproduction Number.’ Infectious Disease Modeling

Mandal, Manisha, and Shyamapada Mandal (2020) ‘COVID-19 Pandemic Scenario in India Compared to China and Rest of the World: a Data Driven and Model Analysis.’ medRxiv

Masters, Nina B, Shu-Fang Shih, Allen Bukoff, Kaitlyn B Akel, Lindsay C Kobayashi, Alison L Miller, Harapan Harapan, Yihan Lu, and Abram L Wagner (2020) ‘Social Distancing in Response to the Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) in the United States.’ PloS one 15(9), e0239025

MIT Election Data and Science Lab (2018) ‘County Presidential Election Returns 2000- 2016’

Nasreen, Sharifa, Stephen P Luby, W Abdullah Brooks, Nusrat Homaira, Abdullah Al Mamun, Mejbah Uddin Bhuiyan, Mustafizur Rahman, Dilruba Ahmed, Jaynal Abedin, Mahmudur Rahman et al. (2014) ‘Population-Based Incidence of Severe Acute Respiratory Virus Infections Among Children Aged Less Than 5 Years in Rural Bangladesh, June– October 2010.’ PloS one

Ngo, Madeline `Rounding Out the Social Distancing Scoreboard.’ https: //www.unacast.com/post/rounding-out-the-social-distancing-scoreboard. Accessed: 20-10-26 21

Painter, Marcus, and Tian Qiu (2020) ‘Political Beliefs Affect Compliance with Covid-19 Social Distancing Orders.’ Available at SSRN 3569098

Pan, an, Li Liu, Chaolong Wang, Huan Guo, Xingjie Hao, Qi Wang, Jiao Huang, Na He, Hongjie Yu, Xihong Lin et al. (2020) ‘Association of Public Health Interventions with the Epidemiology of the COVID-19 Outbreak in Wuhan, China.’ Journal of the American Medical Association

Peak, Corey M, Amy Wesolowski, Elisabeth Zu Erbach-Schoenberg, Andrew J Tatem, Erik Wetter, Xin Lu, Daniel Power, Elaine Weidman-Grunewald, Sergio Ramos, Simon Moritz et al. (2018) ‘Population Mobility Reductions Associated with Travel Restrictions During the Ebola Epidemic in Sierra Leone: Use of Mobile Phone Data.’ International Journal of Epidemiology 47(5), 1562–1570

Perrin, Andrew (2019) ‘Digital Gap between Rural and Nonrural America Persists.’ Accessed: 2020-11-17

Persico, Claudia, Kathryn R Johnson et al. (2020) ‘Deregulation in a Time of Pandemic: Does Pollution Increase Coronavirus Cases or Deaths?’ Technical Report, Institute of Labor Economics (IZA)

Pew Research Center (2019) ‘Mobile Fact Sheet.’ Accessed: 2020-05-13

SafeGraph INC (2020) ‘The Source of Truth for POI Data & Business Listings.’ https: //www.safegraph.com/. Accessed: 2020-05-13

Sprenger, Florian (2019) ‘The Network Is Not the Territory: on Capturing Mobile Media.’ New Media & Society 21(1), 77–96

Strickland, Ora L, Yolanda Powell-Young, Clara Reyes-Miranda, Omar Alzaghari, and Joyce Newman Giger (2020) ‘African-Americans Have a Higher Propensity for Death from COVID-19: Rationale and Causation.’ Journal of National Black Nurses’ Association: JNBNA 31(1), 1–12

The New York Time and Dynata (2020) ‘Mask-Wearing Survey Data’

Tillett, Richard L, Joel R Sevinsky, Paul D Hartley, Heather Kerwin, Natalie Crawford, Andrew Gorzalski, Chris Laverdure, Subhash C Verma, Cyprian C Rossetto, David Jackson et al. (2020) ‘Genomic Evidence for Reinfection with SARS-Cov-2: a Case Study.’ The Lancet Infectious Diseases

Unacast (2020) ‘Unacast Social Distancing Dataset.’ https://www.unacast.com/data-forgood. Accessed: 2020-04-029

United States Census Bureau (2019a) ‘County Business Patterns: 2018’ (2019b) ‘SAIPE State and County Estimates for 2018’ United States Department of Agriculture (2020) ‘County-level Data Sets’