Two-stage Budgeting with Bounded Rationality

Pretnar, Nick and Olivola, Christopher Y. and Montgomery, Alan (2021): Two-stage Budgeting with Bounded Rationality.

Abstract

We construct a unifying theory of two-stage budgeting and bounded rationality with mental accounting features. Mental accounting and rational inattention induce behavioral wedges between first-stage and second-stage expenditure budgets. Because reviewing one’s financial activities is cognitively costly, consumers might reassess only a subset of their spending budgets every period. Over- or under-spending affects future budgeting and expenditure decisions. We apply latent Bayesian inference to agent-level weekly expenditure data in order to structurally estimate the degree to which low-income consumers appear rationally constrained with respect to budgeting. Our findings provide insight into how consumers may respond to interventions that encourage more disciplined budgeting behavior, like push notifications in budgeting apps. If consumers are acutely aware of budget misses, they may adjust budgets upward to avoid the dis-utility of over-expenditure, driving savings rates and balances downward. In this manner, push notifications that warn consumers about budget thresholds could backfire and actually lead to budgeting behavior that reduces savings and wealth in the long-run.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: budgeting, mental accounting, bounded rationality, expenditure, savings
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D11 - Consumer Economics: Theory; D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; D - Microeconomics > D9 - Intertemporal Choice > D91 - Intertemporal Household Choice ; Life Cycle Models and Saving

References

Aiyagari, S. Rao. 1994. “Uninsured Idiosyncratic Risk and Aggregate Saving”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 109 (3): 659–684. (Cit. on p. 6).

Barnett, William, Douglas Fisher, and Apostolos Serletis. 1992. “Consumer Theory and the Demand for Money”. Journal of Economic Literature 30 (4): 2086–2119. (Cit. on p. 6).

Barten, Anton. 1964. “Consumer Demand Functions under Conditions of Almost Additive Preferences”. Econometrica 32 (1/2): 1–38. (Cit. on p. 3).

— . 1967. “Evidence on the Slutsky Conditions for Demand Equations”. The Review of Economics and Statistics 49 (1): 77–84. (Cit. on p. 3).

— . 1977. “The Systems of Consumer Demand Functions Approach: A Review”. Econo- metrica 45 (1): 23–50. (Cit. on p. 3).

Benjamin, Daniel J., Sebastian A. Brown, and Jesse M. Shapiro. 2013. “Who is ’behavioral’? Cognitive ability and anomalous preferences”. Journal of the European Economic Association 11 (6): 1231–1255. (Cit. on p. 45).

Bewley, Truman. 1986. “Stationary monetary equilibrium with a continuum of indepen- dently fluctuating consumers”. In Contributions to mathematical economics in honor of Gérard Debreu, ed. by Werner Hildenbrand. North Holland. (Cit. on p. 6).

Bordalo, Pedro, Nicola Gennaioli, and Andrei Shleifer. 2020. “Memory, Attention, and Choice”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, no. 135: 1399–1442. (Cit. on p. 4).

— . 2014. “Salience and Consumer Choice”. Journal of Political Economy 121 (5): 803–843. (Cit. on pp. 4, 11).

Brock, William. 1974. “Money and Growth: The Case of Long Run Perfect Foresight”. International Economic Review 15 (3): 750–777. (Cit. on p. 6).

Calvo, Guillermo. 1983. “Staggered Price in a Utility-Maximizing Framework”. Journal of Monetary Economics 12:383–398. (Cit. on p. 6).

Caplin, Andrew, and Mark Dean. 2015. “Revealed Preference, Rational Inattention, and Costly Information Acquisition”. American Economic Review 105 (7): 2183–2203. (Cit. on p. 4).

Chetty, Raj, Adam Looney, and Kory Kroft. 2009. “Salience and Taxation: Theory and Evidence”. American Economic Review 99 (4): 1145–1177. (Cit. on p. 4).

Chib, Siddhartha. 1998. “Estimation and comparison of multiple change-point models”. Journal of Econometrics 86:221–241. (Cit. on p. 25).

Cowan, Nelson. 2000. “The magical number 4 in short-term memory: A reconsidration of mental storage capacity”. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24:87–185. (Cit. on pp. 10, 11).

Deaton, Angus, and John Muellbauer. 1980a. “An Almost Ideal Demand System”. The American Economic Review 70 (3): 312–326. (Cit. on p. 3).

— . 1980b. “Economics and Consumer Behavior”. Chap. 5, 119–147. Cambridge University Press: New York. (Cit. on pp. 1, 3, 4, 8, 16).

Farhi, Emmanuel, and Xavier Gabaix. 2020. “Optimal Taxation with Behavioral Agents”. American Economic Review 110 (1): 298–336. (Cit. on pp. 5, 9).

Feenstra, Robert. 1986. “Functional Equivalence Between Liquidity Costs and the Utility of Money”. Journal of Monetary Economics 17:271–291. (Cit. on p. 6).

Feinberg, Richard. 1986. “Credit Cards as Spending Facilitating Stimuli: A Conditioning Interpretation”. Journal of Consumer Research 13 (3): 348–356. (Cit. on p. 5).

Felso ̋, Flóra, and Adriaan Soetevent. 2014. “Broad and Narrow Bracketing in Gift Certifi- cate Spending”. European Economic Review 66:284–302. (Cit. on p. 4).

Gabaix, Xavier. 2014. “A Sparsity-Based Model of Bounded Rationality”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 129 (4): 1661–1710. (Cit. on pp. 1, 4, 11).

Gathergood, John, et al. 2019. “How Do Individuals Repay Their Debt? The Balance- Matching Heuristic”. American Economic Review 109 (3): 844–875. (Cit. on p. 6).

Geary, Roy. 1950. “A Note on ‘A Constant-Utility Index of the Cost of Living’”. Review of Economic Studies 18 (2): 65–66. (Cit. on pp. 3, 7).

Gelman, Andrew, et al. 2013. Bayesian Data Analysis. Third. Chap. 7. Taylor & Francis, CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL. (Cit. on pp. 26, 27).

Gelman, Michael, et al. 2014. “Harnessing naturally occurring data to measure the response of spending to income”. Science 345:212–215. (Cit. on p. 5).

Geman, Stuart, and Donald Geman. 1984. “Stochastic Relaxation, Gibbs Distributions, and Bayesian Restoration of Images”. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 6 (6): 721–741. (Cit. on p. 25).

Gorman, William. 1959. “Separable Utility and Aggregation”. Econometrica 27 (3): 469– 481. (Cit. on p. 1).

Hastings, Justine, and Jesse Shapiro. 2013. “Fungibility and Consumer Choice: Evidence from Commodity Price Shocks”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 128 (4): 1449–1498. (Cit. on p. 10).

— . 2018. “How Are SNAP Benefits Spent? Evidence from a Retail Panel”. American Eco- nomic Review 108 (12): 3493–3540. (Cit. on pp. 5, 24).

Hastings, Wilfred. 1970. “Monte Carlo Sampling Methods Using Markov Chains and Their Applications”. Biometrika 57 (1): 97–109. (Cit. on p. 25).

Hicks, John. 1936. Value and Capital. Oxford: Oxford University Press. (Cit. on pp. 3, 4). Houthakker, Hendrik. 1960. “Additive Preferences”. Econometrica 28 (2): 244–257. (Cit. on p. 3).

Huggett, Mark. 1993. “The risk-free rate in heterogeneous-agent incomplete-insurance economies”. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 17:953–969. (Cit. on p. 6).

— . 1996. “Wealth distribution in life-cycle economies”. Journal of Monetary Economics 38:469–494. (Cit. on p. 6).

Kahneman, Daniel, and Dan Lovallo. 1993. “Timid Choices and Bold Forecasts: A Cognitive Perspective on Risk Taking”. Management Science 39 (1): 17–31. (Cit. on p. 4).

Ko ̋szegi, Botond, and Filip Mateˇjka. 2020. “Choice Simplification: A Theory of Mental Budgeting and Naive Diversification”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 135 (2): 1153– 1207. (Cit. on pp. 4, 5).

Ko ̋szegi, Botond, and Adam Szeidl. 2013. “A Model of Focusing in Economic Choice”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 128 (1): 53–104. (Cit. on pp. 4, 11).

Koch, Alexander, and Julia Nafziger. 2019. “Correlates of Narrow Bracketing”. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics 121 (4): 1441–1472. (Cit. on p. 4).

— . 2016. “Goals and bracketing under mental accounting”. Journal of Economic Theory 162 (C): 305–351. (Cit. on p. 4).

Koop, Gary, and Simon M. Potter. 2007. “Estimation and Forecasting in Models with Multiple Breaks”. The Review of Economic Studies 74 (3): 763–789. (Cit. on p. 25).

Leontief, Wassily. 1936. “Composite Commodities and the Problem of Index Numbers”. Econometrica 4 (1): 39–59. (Cit. on pp. 3, 4).

Leslie, Alan, Rochel Gelmand, and C.R. Gallistel. 2008. “The generative basis of natural number concepts”. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12 (6): 213–218. (Cit. on p. 11).

Malhotra, Naresh. 1982. “Information Load and Consumer Decision Making”. Journal of Consumer Research 8 (4): 419–430. (Cit. on p. 11).

Mani, Anandi, et al. 2013. “Poverty Impedes Cognitive Function”. Science 341:976–980. (Cit. on p. 5).

McCulloch, Robert, and Ruey Tsay. 1993. “Bayesian Inference and Prediction for Mean and Variance Shifts in Autoregressive Time Series”. Journal of the American Statistical Association 88 (423): 968–978. (Cit. on p. 25).

Miller, George A. 1956. “The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity for processing information”. Psychological Review 63 (2): 81–97. (Cit. on pp. 10, 11).

Mullainathan, Sendhil. 2002. “A Memory-Based Model of Bounded Rationality”. The Quar- terly Journal of Economics 107 (3): 735–774. (Cit. on p. 5).

Obstfeld, Maurice, and Kenneth Rogoff. 1983. “Speculative Hyperinflations in Maximizing Models: Can We Rule Them Out?” Journal of Political Economy 91 (4): 675–687. (Cit. on p. 6).

Olivola, Christopher Y., and Stephanie W. Wang. 2016. “Patience auctions: The impact of time vs. money bidding on elicited discount rates”. Experimental Economics 19 (4): 864– 885. (Cit. on p. 46).

Oprea, Ryan. 2020. “What Makes a Rule Complex?” American Economic Review 110 (12): 3913–3951. (Cit. on p. 11).

Prelec, Drazen, and George Loewenstein. 1998. “The Red and the Black: Mental Accounting of Savings and Debt”. Marketing Science 17 (1): 4–28. (Cit. on p. 5). Proctor, Bernadette, Jessica Semega, and Melissa Kollar. 2015. Income and Poverty in the United States: 2015. https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2016/demo/ p60-256.html. Accessed: 2019-05-06. (Cit. on p. 23).

Rabin, Matthew, and Georg Weizsäcker. 2009. “Narrow Bracketing and Dominated Choices”. American Economic Review 99 (4): 1508–1543. (Cit. on p. 4).

Read, Daniel, George Loewenstein, and Matthew Rabin. 1999. “Choice Bracketing”. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 19 (1): 171–197. (Cit. on p. 4).

Schilbach, Frank, Heather Schofield, and Sendhil Mullainathan. 2016. “The psychological lives of the poor”. American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings 106 (5): 435–440. (Cit. on p. 5).

Schwartzstein, Joshua. 2014. “Selective Attention and Learning”. Journal of the European Economic Association 12 (6): 1423–1452. (Cit. on pp. 4, 11).

Shefrin, Hersh, and Richard Thaler. 1981. “An Economic Theory of Self-Control”. Journal of Political Economy 89 (2): 392–406. (Cit. on pp. 1, 4, 10).

Silverman, Bernard. 1986. Density Estimation for Statistics and Data Analysis. 48. London: Chapman / Hall. (Cit. on p. 30).

Simon, Herbert. 1957. Models of Man. John Wiley & Sons: New York. (Cit. on pp. 10, 11). Sims, Christopher. 2003. “Implications of rational inattention”. Journal of Monetary Economics 50 (3): 665–690. (Cit. on p. 4).

Stone, Richard. 1954. “Linear Expenditure Systems and Demand Analysis: An Application to the Pattern of British Demand”. The Economic Journal 64 (255): 511–527. (Cit. on pp. 3, 7).

Strotz, Robert. 1957. “The Empirical Implications of a Utility Tree”. Econometrica 25 (1): 269–280. (Cit. on p. 1).

Thaler, Richard. 1985. “Mental Accounting and Consumer Choice”. Marketing Science 4 (3): 199–214. (Cit. on p. 5).

— . 1999. “Mental Accounting Matters”. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 12 (3): 183– 206. (Cit. on p. 1).

Thaler, Richard, et al. 1997. “The Effect of Myopia and Loss Aversion on Risk Taking: An Experimental Test”. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 112 (2): 647–661. (Cit. on p. 5).

Theil, Henri. 1965. “The Information Approach to Demand Analysis”. Econometrica 33 (1): 67–87. (Cit. on p. 3).

— . 1976. Theory and Measurement of Consumer Demand. Vol. 2. Elsevier: New York. (Cit. on p. 3).

Walsh, Carl. 2010. Monetary Theory and Policy. 3rd ed. MIT Press: Cambridge. (Cit. on p. 6).