The Impact of Delay: Evidence from Formal Out-of-Court Restructuring

Srhoj, Stjepan and Kovač, Dejan and Shapiro, Jacob N. and Filer, Randall K. (2021): The Impact of Delay: Evidence from Formal Out-of-Court Restructuring.

Abstract

Bankruptcy restructuring procedures are used in most legal systems to decide the fate of businesses facing financial hardship. We study how bargaining failures in such procedures impact the economic performance of participating firms in the context of Croatia, which introduced a "pre-bankruptcy settlement" (PBS) process in the wake of the Great Recession of 2007 - 2009. Local institutions left over from the communist era provide annual financial statements for both sides of more than 180,000 debtor-creditor pairs, enabling us to address selection into failed negotiations by matching a rich set of creditor and debtor characteristics. Failures to settle at the PBS stage due to idiosyncratic bargaining problems, which effectively delays entry into the standard bankruptcy procedure, leads to a lower rate of survival among debtors as well as reduced employment, revenue, and profits. We also track how bargaining failures diffuse through the network of creditors, finding a significant negative effect on small creditors, but not others. Our results highlight the impact of delay and the importance of structuring bankruptcy procedures to rapidly resolve uncertainty about firms' future prospects.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: bankruptcy, insolvency, liquidation, restructuring
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D02 - Institutions: Design, Formation, Operations, and Impact; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G33 - Bankruptcy ; Liquidation; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G34 - Mergers ; Acquisitions ; Restructuring ; Corporate Governance; L - Industrial Organization > L3 - Nonprofit Organizations and Public Enterprise > L38 - Public Policy; P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P37 - Legal Institutions ; Illegal Behavior

References

Aghion, P., Antonin, C. and Bunel, S. (2021), The Power of Creative Destruction, The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge.

Agrawal, A., Gonzalez-Uribe, J. and Martinez-Correa, J. (2020), `Measuring the ex-ante incentive effects of bankruptcy reorganization procedures'.

Altman, E. (1983), Corporate Financial Distress: a complete guide to predicting, avoiding, and dealing with bankruptcy, Wiley, New York.

Altman, E. I. (1984), `A further empirical investigation of the bankruptcy cost question', The Journal of Finance 39(4), 1067-1089.

Altman, E. I. and Hotchkiss, E. (2010), Corporate Financial distress and bankruptcy: Predict and avoid bankruptcy, analyze and invest in distressed debt, Vol. 289, John Wiley & Sons.

Altman, E. I., Iwanicz-Drozdowska, M., Laitinen, E. K. and Suvas, A. (2017), `Financial Distress Prediction in an International Context: A Review and Empirical Analysis of Altman's Z-Score Model', Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting.

Antill, S. and Grenadier, S. R. (2019), `Optimal capital structure and bankruptcy choice: Dynamic bargaining versus liquidation', Journal of Financial Economics 133(1), 198-224.

Araujo, A., Ferreira, R., Lagaras, S., Moraes, F., Ponticelli, J. and Tsoutsoura, M. (2021), The Labor Effects of Pro-Labor Bias in Bankruptcy.

Armour, J. and Cumming, D. (2008), `Bankruptcy law and entrepreneurship', American Law and Economics Review 10(2), 303-350.

Battiston, S., Gatti, D. D., Gallegati, M., Greenwald, B. and Stiglitz, J. E. (2007), `Credit chains and bankruptcy propagation in production networks', Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 31(6), 2061-2084.

Benmelech, E., Bergman, N., Milanez, A. and Mukharlyamov, V. (2019), `The agglomeration of bankruptcy', The Review of Financial Studies 32(7), 2541-2586.

Bernstein, S., Colonnelli, E., Giroud, X. and Iverson, B. (2019), `Bankruptcy spillovers', Journal of Financial Economics 133(3), 608-633.

Bernstein, S., Colonnelli, E. and Iverson, B. (2019), `Asset allocation in bankruptcy', The Journal of Finance 74(1), 5-53.

Bloom, N. (2007), `Uncertainty and the dynamics of r&d', American Economic Review 97(2), 250-255.

Bolton, P. and Scharfstein, D. S. (1996), `Optimal debt structure and the number of creditors', Journal of Political Economy 104(1), 1-25.

Bradley, M. and Rosenzweig, M. (1992), `The untenable case for chapter 11', Yale Law Journal pp. 1043-1095.

Branch, B. (2002), `The costs of bankruptcy: A review', International Review of Financial Analysis 11(1), 39-57.

Bris, A., Welch, I. and Zhu, N. (2006), `The costs of bankruptcy: Chapter 7 liquidation versus chapter 11 reorganization', The Journal of Finance 61(3), 1253-1303.

Broadie, M., Chernov, M. and Sundaresan, S. (2007), `Optimal debt and equity values in the presence of chapter 7 and chapter 11', The Journal of Finance 62(3), 1341-1377.

Brouwer, M. (2006), `Reorganization in us and european bankruptcy law', European Journal of Law and Economics 22(1), 5-20.

Cefis, E., Bettinelli, C., Coad, A. and Marsili, O. (2021), `Understanding firm exit: a systematic literature review', Small Business Economics pp. 1-24.

Cepec, J. and Grajzl, P. (2019), `Measuring the effectiveness of bankruptcy institutions: filtering failures in slovenian financial reorganizations', Journal of Institutional Economics 15(3), 553-567.

Chabe-Ferret, S. (2017), `Should we combine difference in differences with conditioning on pre-treatment outcomes?'.

Coad, A. (2018), `Firm age: a survey', Journal of Evolutionary Economics 28(1), 13-43.

Damaraju, N. L., Barney, J. B. and Dess, G. G. (2020), `Do stringent bankruptcy laws always deter entrepreneurial activities? a study of cultural influences', Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice pp. 1-22.

Davydenko, S. A. and Franks, J. R. (2008), `Do bankruptcy codes matter? a study of defaults in france, germany, and the uk', The Journal of Finance 63(2), 565-608.

Fackler, D., Mueller, S. and Stegmaier, J. (2021), `Explaining wage losses after job displacement: Employer size and lost firm wage premiums', Journal of the European Economic Association.

Filer, R. K. and Golbe, D. L. (2003), `Debt, operating margin, and investment in workplace safety', The Journal of Industrial Economics 51(3), 359-381.

Franks, J. R. and Torous, W. N. (1989), `An empirical investigation of us firms in reorganization', The Journal of Finance 44(3), 747-769.

Gilson, S. C., John, K. and Lang, L. H. (1990), `Troubled debt restructurings: An empirical study of private reorganization of firms in default', Journal of Financial Economics 27(2), 315-353.

Hotchkiss, E. S. (1995), `Postbankruptcy performance and management turnover', The Journal of Finance 50(1), 3-21.

Iverson, B. (2018), `Get in line: Chapter 11 restructuring in crowded bankruptcy courts', Management Science 64(11), 5370-5394.

Janda, K. and Rakicova, A. (2014), Corporate Bankruptcies in Czech Republic, Slovakia, Croatia and Serbia, MPRA Paper 54109, University Library of Munich, Germany. URL: https://ideas.repec.org/p/pra/mprapa/54109.html

Kalay, A., Singhal, R. and Tashjian, E. (2007), `Is chapter 11 costly?', Journal of Financial Economics 84(3), 772-796.

Kovac, D., Vukovic, V., Kleut, N. and Podobnik, B. (2016), `To Invest or Not to Invest, That Is the Question: Analysis of Firm Behavior under Anticipated Shocks', PLOS ONE 11(8).

Lang, L. H. and Stulz, R. (1992), `Contagion and competitive intra-industry effects of bankruptcy announcements: An empirical analysis', Journal of Financial Economics 32(1), 45-60.

Lee, S.-H., Yamakawa, Y., Peng, M. W. and Barney, J. B. (2011), `How do bankruptcy laws affect entrepreneurship development around the world?', Journal of Business Venturing 26(5), 505-520.

LoPucki, L. M. and Doherty, J. W. (2004), `The determinants of professional fees in large bankruptcy reorganization cases', Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 1(1), 111-141.

LoPucki, L. M. and Whitford, W. C. (1992), `Patterns in the bankruptcy reorganization of large publicly held companies', Cornell L. Rev. 78, 597.

Ma, S., Tong, J. T. and Wang, W. (2021), Bankrupt innovative firms, Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research.

McKenzie, D. (2017), `Identifying and spurring high-growth entrepreneurship: Experimental evidence from a business plan competition', American Economic Review.

Muge, A. M., Andrews, D. and Millot, V. (2017), Insolvency regimes, zombie firms and capital reallocation, Working Papers No 1399 54109, OECD Economics Department. URL: https://dx.doi.org/10.1787/5a16beda-en

Napoli Coordes, L. (2015), `The Geography of Bankruptcy', Vanderbilt Law Review.

Parikh, S. D. (2013), `Modern Forum Shopping in Bankruptcy', Connecticut Law Review . Peric, M. and Vitezic, V. (2016), `Impact of global economic crisis on rm growth', Small Business Economics 46(1), 1-12.

Ponticelli, J. and Alencar, L. S. (2016), `Court enforcement, bank loans, and rm investment: evidence from a bankruptcy reform in brazil', The Quarterly Journal of Economics 131(3), 1365-1413.

Puga, D. (2010), `The magnitude and causes of agglomeration economies', Journal of Regional Science 50(1), 203-219.

Rubin, D. B. (1973), `The Use of Matched Sampling and Regression Adjustment to Remove Bias in Observational Studies', Biometrics 29(1), 185-203.

Sajter, D. (2008), `Ekonomski aspekti stecaja i restrukturiranja u stecaju', Ekonomski fakultet Osijek, raspolozivo na: https://bib.irb.hr/datoteka/377526.Sajter_Disertacija.pdf (02.07. 2017.).

Sajter, D. (2014), `Effciency of croatian commercial courts in processing bankruptcy cases', Ekonomski pregled: mjesecnik Hrvatskog drustva ekonomista Zagreb 65(2), 155.

Senbet, L. W. and Wang, T. Y. (2010), `Corporate financial distress and bankruptcy: A survey', Foundations and trends in finance 5(4).

Silva, V. A. B. and Saito, R. (2018), `Corporate restructuring: empirical evidence on the approval of the reorganization plan', RAUSP Management Journal 53(1), 49-62.

Silva, V. A. B. and Saito, R. (2020), `Corporate financial distress and reorganization: A survey of theoretical and empirical contributions', Revista Brasileira de Gest~ao de Negocios 22, 401-420.

Srhoj, S., Lapinski, M. and Walde, J. (2020), `Impact evaluation of business development grants on sme performance', Small Business Economics pp. 1-17.

Srhoj, S., Skrinjaric, B. and Radas, S. (2021), `Bidding against the odds? the impact evaluation of grants for young micro and small firms during the recession', Small Business Economics p. 83-103.

Srhoj, S. and Zilic, I. (2021), `Fine... i'll do it myself: Lessons from self-employment grants in a long recession period', IZA Journal of Labor Policy 10(6), 1-31.

Stiglitz, J. E. (2001), `Bankruptcy laws: Basic economic principles', Resolution of Financial Distress: An International Perspective on the Design of Bankruptcy Laws, ed. by Stijn Claessens, Simeon Djankov, and Ashoka Mody, WBI Development Studies (Washington: World Bank) pp. 1-23.

Stojcic, N., Srhoj, S. and Coad, A. (2020), `Innovation procurement as capabilitybuilding: Evaluating innovation policies in eight central and eastern european countries', European Economic Review 121, 103330.

Thorburn, K. S. (2000), `Bankruptcy auctions: costs, debt recovery, and firm survival', Journal of Financial Economics 58(3), 337-368.

Vukovic, V. (2020), `Corruption and re-election: how much can politicians steal before getting punished?', Journal of Comparative Economics 48(1), 124-143.

Wagner, J. (2007), `Exports and productivity: A survey of the evidence from firm-level data', World Economy 30(1), 60-82.

White, M. J. (1984), `Reorganization."', Handbook of Modern Finance edited by Dennis Logue, Boston: Warren, Gorhman & Lamont pp. 477-487.

White, M. J. (1989), `The corporate bankruptcy decision', Journal of Economic Perspectives 3(2), 129-151.

White, M. J. (1994), `The costs of corporate bankruptcy: A us-european comparison', In Corporate Bankruptcy: Economic and Legal Perspectives, J. Bhandari and L. Weiss (eds). Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press .

Yi, M., Mueller, S. and Stegmaier, J. (2017), `Transferability of skills across sectors and heterogeneous displacement costs', American Economic Review 107(5), 332-36.