Estimating the Economic Effects of US State and Local Fiscal Policy: A Synthetic Control Method Matched Regression Approach

Rickman, Dan S. and Wang, Hongbo (2022): Estimating the Economic Effects of US State and Local Fiscal Policy: A Synthetic Control Method Matched Regression Approach.

Abstract

In this paper, we attempt to address the limitations of previous research to provide further guidance on US state and local fiscal policymaking. We implement the synthetic control method to create pairwise matches for states in subsequent regression analysis. Several economic indicators and principal component analysis are used to construct broader narratives of state economic performance and we provide updated evidence. We compare the results with those obtained from using neighbors as matches and from standard unmatched growth regressions. The matched regressions produce more statistically significant relationships between state and local fiscal variables and economic outcomes than do the standard growth regressions. Although the findings provide additional guidance for state and local fiscal policymakers, a lack of robustness across alternative economic indicators and heterogeneity of results confirm the elusiveness of recommendations on specific policies that are applicable in all circumstances.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: State and local fiscal policy; Economic growth; Synthetic control method
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H71 - State and Local Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H72 - State and Local Budget and Expenditures; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R12 - Size and Spatial Distributions of Regional Economic Activity; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R3 - Real Estate Markets, Spatial Production Analysis, and Firm Location > R38 - Government Policy

References

Abadie, Alberto, 2021. “Using Synthetic Controls: Feasibility, Data Requirements, and Methodological Aspects,” Journal of Economic Literature 59(2), 391–425.

Abadie, Alberto, Alexis Diamond, and Jens Hainmueller, 2010. “Synthetic Control Methods for Comparative Case Studies: Estimating the Effect of California’s Tobacco Control Program,” Journal of the American Statistical Association 105, 493-505.

_____, 2015. “Comparative Politics and the Synthetic Control Method.” American Journal of Political Science 59(2), 495–510.

Abadie, Alberto, and Javier Gardeazabal, 2003. "The Economic Costs of Conflict: A Case-Control Study for the Basque Country," American Economic Review 93(1),113-132.

Agostini, Claudio and Soraphol Tulayasathien, 2007. “The Impact of State Corporate Taxes on FDI Location,” Public Finance Review 35(3), 335–360.

Alm, James, 2017. “Is Economics Useful for Policy,” Southern Economic Journal 83(4), 835–854.

Baltagi Badi H., Seuck Heun Song and Won Koh, 2003. “Testing Panel Data Regression Models with Spatial Error Correlation," Journal of Econometrics 117, 123-150.

Bartik, Timothy J., 1991. Who Benefits from State and Local Economic Development Policies? W. E. Upjohn Institute: Kalamazoo, MI.

Bartik, Timothy J., Stephen Biddle, Brad Hershbein, and Nathan D. Sotherland, 2018. WholeData: Unsuppressed County Business Patterns Data: Version 1.0 [dataset]. Kalamazoo, MI: W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

Bartik, Timothy J. and Nathan Sotherland, 2019. “Local Job Multipliers in the United States: Variation with Local Characteristics and with High-Tech Shocks,” W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research Working Paper 19-301, Kalamazoo, MI.

Brewer, Ben, Karen Smith Conway, and Jonathan C. Rork, 2021. “A Replication of the “Robust Relationship between Taxes and US Income,” Public Finance Review 49(3), 464-487.

Brown, Stephen P.A., Kathy J. Hayes and Lori L. Taylor, L.L., 2003. “State and Local Policy, Factor Markets and Regional Growth,” Review of Regional Studies 33: 40–60.

Conroy, Tessa, Steven Deller, and Alexandra Tsvetkova, 2016. “Regional Business Climate and Interstate Manufacturing Relocation Decisions,” Regional Science and Urban Economics 60, 155-168.

Conway, Karen Smith and Jonathan C. Rork, 2006. State Death Taxes and Elderly Migration: The Chicken or the Egg,” National Tax Journal 59(1), 97-128.

Fisher, Ronald C., 1997. “The Effects of State and Local Public Services on Economic Development,” New England Economic Review March-April, 53–67.

Gale, William G., Aaron Krupkin and Kim Reuben, 2015. “The Relationship between Taxes and Growth at the State Level: New Evidence,” National Tax Journal 68(4), 919–942.

Goff, Brian, Alex Lebedinsky and Stephen Lile, 2012. “A Matched Pair Analysis of State Growth Differences,” Contemporary Economic Policy 30(2), 293-305.

Goss, Ernie P., 1995. “The Effect of State and Local Taxes on Economic Development,” Southern Economic Journal 62, 320-333.

Greenaway-McGrevy, Ryan and Kyle Hood, 2019. “Aggregate Effects and Measuring Regional Dynamics,” Papers in Regional Science 98(5), 1955-1991.

Hammond George W. and Eric C. Thompson, 2008. “Determinants of Income Growth in Metropolitan and Nonmetropolitan Labour Markets,” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 90, 517–542.

Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, 2022. “State Rundown 1/26: States Offering Preview of Tax Themes and Trends for 2022,” https://itep.org/state-rundown-1-26-states-offering-preview-of-tax-themes-and-trends-for-2022/

Jonas, Jiri, 2012. “Great Recession and Fiscal Squeeze at US Subnational Government Level,” IMF Working Paper, July.

Komarek, Timothy M., 2020. “State-level Austerity, Education, and Large Urban Labor Markets: Evidence from Fiscal Policy Experiments in Kansas and Wisconsin,” Growth and Change 51, 556-583.

Leachman, Michael, 2019. “K-12 Funding Still Lagging in Many States,” Center of Budget and Policy Priorities, May 29. https://www.cbpp.org/blog/k-12-funding-still-lagging-in-many-states.

Leachman, Michael and Jennifer Sullivan, 2020. “Some States Much Better Prepared Than Others for Recession,” Center of Budget and Policy Priorities, March 20. https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/some-states-much-better-prepared-than-others-for-recession

Lusch, Stephen J. and James Stekelberg, 2020. “State Tax Haven Legislation and Corporate Income Tax Revenues,” Public Finance Review 48(3), 354 – 383.

Loveridge, Scott and Anne C. Selting, 1998. “A Review and Comparison of Shift-Share Identities,” International Regional Science Review 21: 37–58.

Mazerov, Michael. 2013. Academic Research Lacks Consensus on the Impact of State Tax Cuts on Economic Growth: A Reply to the Tax Foundation. Washington, DC: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

McBride, William. 2012. What is the Evidence on Taxes and Growth? Tax Foundation Special Report, Washington, DC: Tax Foundation.

McGuire, Teresa J., 1992. “Review: Who Benefits from State and Local Economic Development Policies? By Timothy J. Bartik” National Tax Journal 45(4), 457-459.

Millo, Giovanni and Gianfranco Piras, 2012. “splm: Spatial Panel Data Models in R,” Journal of Statistical Software 47(1), 1-38.

Mirrlees, James. 1971. "An Exploration in the Theory of Optimal Income Taxation," Review of Economic Studies 38, 178-208.

Mughan, Siân and Geoffrey Propheter, 2017. “Estimating the Manufacturing Employment Impact of Eliminating the Tangible Personal Property Tax: Evidence from Ohio,” Economic Development Quarterly 31(4), 299–311.

Partridge, Mark D. and Dan S. Rickman, 1998. “Regional Computable General Equilibrium Modeling: A Survey and Critical Appraisal,” International Regional Science Review 21(3), 205-248.

_____, 2006. “An SVAR Model of Fluctuations in US Migration Flows and State Labor Market Dynamics,” Southern Economic Journal 72(4), 958-980.

Peltzman, Sam, 2016. “State and Local Fiscal Policy and Growth at the Border,” Journal of Urban Economics 95, 1-15.

Poot, Jacques, 2000. “A Synthesis of Empirical Research on the Impact of Government on Long-Run Growth,” Growth and Change 31(Fall), 516-546.

Reed, W. Robert, 2008. “The Robust Relationship between Taxes and US State Income Growth,” National Tax Journal 61(1), 57–80.

_____, 2021. “Reply to Brewer, Conway, and Rork,” Public Finance Review 49(3), 488-491.

Rickman, Dan S., 2010. "Modern Macroeconomics and Regional Economic Modeling." Journal of Regional Science 50(1): 23-41.

Rickman, Dan S. and Hongbo Wang, 2018. “Two Tales of Two US States: Regional Fiscal Austerity and Economic Performance,” Regional Science and Urban Economics 68, 46-55.

_____, 2020. “US State and Local Fiscal Policy and Economic Activity: Do We Know More Now?” Journal of Economic Surveys 34(2) 424-465.

Siripurapu, Anshu and Jonathan Masters, 2021. “How COVID-19 Is Harming State and City Budgets,” Council on Foreign Relations, January 12. https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/how-covid-19-harming-state-and-city-budgets

Spreen, Thomas Luke, 2018. “The Effect of Flat Tax Rates on Taxable Income: Evidence from the Illinois Rate Increase,” National Tax Journal 71(2), 231–262.

Wang, Hongbo and Dan S. Rickman, 2018. “Regional Growth Differences in China for 1995–2013: An Empirical Integrative Analysis of their Sources,” Annals of Regional Science 60, 99–117.

Wasylenko, Michael, 1997. “Taxation and Economic Development: The State of the Economic Literature,” New England Economic Review March, 37–52.

Yu, Yihua and Dan S. Rickman, 2013. “US State and Local Fiscal Policies and Nonmetropolitan Area Economic Performance: A Spatial Equilibrium Analysis,” Papers in Regional Science 92(3): 579–597.

Zou, Ben, 2018. “The Local Economic Impacts of Military Personnel,” Journal of Labor Economics 36(3), 589-621.