Do Obese and Nonobese Consumers Respond Differently to Price Changes? Implications of Preference Heterogeneity for Using Food Taxes and Subsidies to Reduce Obesity

Zhen, Chen and Chen, Yu and Lin, Biing-Hwan and Karns, Shawn and Mancino, Lisa and Ver Ploeg, Michele (2021): Do Obese and Nonobese Consumers Respond Differently to Price Changes? Implications of Preference Heterogeneity for Using Food Taxes and Subsidies to Reduce Obesity.

Abstract

Preference heterogeneity in food demand has important health and equity implications for targeted taxes and subsidies intended to enhance diet quality and reduce obesity. We study the role of obesity in the purchases of food at home and food away from home using data from the nationally representative National Household Food Acquisition and Purchase Survey. We develop a method for incorporating the complex survey design and retail scanner data into the estimation of a 21-good Exact Affine Stone Index demand system with endogenous prices and truncated purchases. We find significant preference heterogeneity associated with the obesity status of household members. Counterfactual simulations find that 1) a sweetened beverage tax is effective in increasing the healthfulness of grocery purchases by lower-income obese consumers; 2) the nutritional benefits of a fruit and vegetable subsidy are concentrated on nonobese consumers with little improvement in obese consumers’ Healthy Eating Index and an increase in their total calories purchased; and 3) a fiscally neutral healthy food subsidy fully funded by an unhealthy food tax benefits nonobese consumers both financially and nutritionally more than it does obese consumers. These findings show that lowering healthy food prices without raising the cost of unhealthy foods is unlikely to reduce obesity. Policymakers in favor of a systems approach of simultaneously taxing unhealthy foods and subsidizing healthy foods should be mindful of the distributional effects of this policy on obese consumers and the lower-income population.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: soda tax, fruit and vegetable subsidy, FoodAPS, EASI demand, preference heterogeneity, nutrition inequality
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I14 - Health and Inequality; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I18 - Government Policy ; Regulation ; Public Health

References

Allcott, H., B.B. Lockwood, and D. Taubinsky. 2019a. Should we tax sugar-sweetened beverages? An overview of theory and evidence. Journal of Economic Perspectives 33(3):202–227.

Allcott, H., B.B. Lockwood, and D. Taubinsky. 2019b. Regressive sin taxes, with an application to the optimal soda tax. Quarterly Journal of Economics 134(3):1557–1626.

Allcott, H., R. Diamond, J-P. Dubé, J. Handbury, I. Rahkovsky, and M. Schnell. 2019c. Food deserts and the causes of nutritional inequality. Quarterly Journal of Economics 134(4):1793‒1844.

Amemiya, T. 1979. The estimation of a simultaneous-equation Tobit model. International Economic Review 20:169‒181.

Bartlett, S., J. Klerman, L. Olsho, et al. 2014. Evaluation of the Healthy Incentives Pilot (HIP): Final Report. Prepared by Abt Associates for the US Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service.

Baum, C.L., II and C.J. Ruhm. 2009. Age, socioeconomic status and obesity growth. Journal of Health Economics 28:635‒648.

Beatty, T.K.M. 2010. Do the poor pay more for food? Evidence from the United Kingdom. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 92(3), 608−621.

Berry, S., J. Levinsohn, and A. Pakes. 1995. Automobile prices in market equilibrium. Econometrica 63(4):841‒890.

Broda, C., E. Leibtag, and D.E. Weinstein. 2009. The role of prices in measuring the poor’s living standards. Journal of Economic Perspectives 23(2), 77−97.

Cameron, A.C. and D.L. Miller. 2015. A practitioner’s guide to cluster-robust inference. Journal of Human Resources 50(2):317‒372.

Cawley, J. and D.E. Frisvold. 2017. The pass-through of taxes on sugar-sweetened beverages to retail prices: the case of Berkeley, California. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 36(2):303–326.

Cawley, J., D.E. Frisvold, A. Hill, and D. Jones. 2019. The impact of the Philadelphia beverage tax on purchases and consumption by adults and children. Journal of Health Economics 67: Article 102225.

Cawley, J., D.E. Frisvold, A. Hill, and D. Jones. 2020a. Oakland’s sugar-sweetened beverage tax: Impacts on prices, purchases and consumption by adults and children. Economics and Human Biology 37: Article 100865.

Cawley, J., D. Frisvold, A. Hill, and D. Jones. 2020b. The impact of the Philadelphia beverage tax on prices and product availability. 39(3):605‒628.

Cawley, J. D. Frisvold, D. Jones, and C. Lensing. 2021. The pass-through of a tax on sugar-sweetened beverages in Boulder, Colorado. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 103(3):987‒1005.

Clay, M., M. Ver Ploeg, A. Coleman-Jensen, H. Elitzak, C. Gregory, D. Levin, C. Newman, and M.P. Rabbitt. 2016. Comparing National Household Food Acquisition and Purchase Survey (FoodAPS) Data With Other National Food Surveys’ Data, EIB-157, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service.

Courtemanche, C., R. Tchernis, and B. Ukert. 2018. The effect of smoking on obesity: Evidence from a randomized trial. Journal of Health Economics 57:31‒44.

Cox, T.L. and M.K. Wohlgenant. 1986. Prices and quality effects in cross-sectional demand analysis. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 68:908‒919.

Danaei, G., E.L. Ding, D. Mozaffarian, B. Taylor, J. Rehm, C.J.L. Murray, and M. Ezzati. 2009. The preventable causes of death in the United States: comparative risk assessment of dietary, lifestyle, and metabolic risk factors. PLOS Medicine 6(4):e1000058.

Deaton, A.S. and J. Muellbauer. 1980. An almost ideal demand system. American Economic Review 70:312–326.

Deaton, A.S. 1988. Quality, quantity, and spatial variation of price. American Economic Review 78:418‒430.

DellaVigna, S. and M. Gentzkow. 2019. Uniform pricing in U.S. retail chains. Quarterly Journal of Economics 134:2011–2084.

Dharmasena, S. and O. Capps, Jr. 2012. Intended and unintended consequences of a proposed national tax on sugar-sweetened beverages to combat the U.S. obesity problem. Health Economics 21(6):669–694.

Dong, D., B.W. Gould and H.M. Kaiser. 2004. Food demand in Mexico: An application of the Amemiya-Tobin approach to the estimation of a censored food system. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 86(4):1094–1107.

Dubois, P., R. Griffith, and A. Nevo. 2014. Do prices and attributes explain international differences in food purchases? American Economic Review 104(3):832‒867.

Ebbeling, C.B., H.A. Feldman, V.R. Chomitz, T.A. Antonelli, S.L. Gortmaker, S.K. Osganian, and D.S. Ludwig. 2012. A randomized trial of sugar-sweetened beverages and adolescent body weight. New England Journal of Medicine 367(15):1407–1416.

Epstein, L.H., K.K. Dearing, R.A. Paluch, J.N. Roemmich, and D. Cho. 2007. Price and maternal obesity influence purchasing of low- and high-energy-dense foods. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 86:914–922.

Epstein, L.H., R.A. Paluch, M.D. Beecher, and J.N. Roemmich. 2008. Increasing healthy eating versus reducing high energy-dense foods to treat pediatric obesity. Obesity 16(2):318‒326.

Epstein, L.H., K.K. Dearing, L.G. Roba, and E. Finkelstein. 2010. The influence of taxes and subsidies on energy purchased in an experimental purchasing study. Psychological Science 21(3):406–414.

Falbe, J., N. Rojas, A.H. Grummon, and K.A. Madsen. 2015. Higher retail prices of sugar-sweetened beverages 3 months after implementation of an excise tax in Berkeley, California. American Journal of Public Health 105(11):2194–2201.

Falbe, J., H.R. Thompson, C.M. Becker, N. Rojas, C.E. McCulloch, and K.A. Madsen. 2016. Impact of the Berkeley excise tax on sugar-sweetened beverage consumption. American Journal of Public Health 106(10):1865–1871.

Falbe, J., M.M. Lee, S. Kaplan, N.A. Rojas, A.M.O. Hinojosa, and K.A. Madsen. 2020. Higher sugar-sweetened beverage retail prices after excise taxes in Oakland and San Francisco. American Journal of Public Health 110(7):1017‒1023.

Finkelstein, E.A., J.G. Trogdon, J.W. Cohen, and W. Dietz. 2009. Annual medical spending attributable to obesity: Payer- and service-specific estimates. Health Affairs 28(5):w822–831.

Fischer, L.M., L.A. Sutherland, L.A. Kaley, T.A. Fox, C.M. Hasler, J. Nobel, M.A. Kantor, and J. Blumberg. 2011. Development and implementation of the guiding stars nutrition guidance program. American Journal of Health Promotion 26(2), e55-63.

Gandal, N. and A. Shabelansky. 2010. Obesity and price sensitivity at the supermarket. Forum for Health Economics & Policy 13(2):Article 9.

Gauri, D.K., K. Sudhir, and D. Talukdar. 2008. The temporal and spatial dimensions of price search: Insights from matching household survey and purchase data. Journal of Marketing Research 45(2):226-240.

Gibson, L.A., H.G. Lawman, S.N. Bleich, J. Yan, N. Mitra, M.T. LeVasseur, C.M. Lowery, and C.A. Roberto. 2021. No evidence of food or alcohol substitution in response to a sweetened beverage tax. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 60(2):e49–e57.

Gruber, J. and M. Frakes. 2006. Does falling smoking lead to rising obesity? Journal of Health Economics 25:183‒197.

Guenther, P.M., K.O. Casavale, S.I. Kirkpatrick, J. Reedy, H.A.B. Hiza, K.J. Kuczynski, L.L. Kahle, and S.M. Krebs-Smith. 2013. Update of the Healthy Eating Index: HEI-2010. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics 113(4):569–580.

Guenther, P.M., S.I. Kirkpatrick, J. Reedy, S.M. Krebs-Smith, D.W. Buckman, K.W. Dodd, K.O. Casavale, and R.J. Carroll. 2014. The Healthy Eating Index-2010 is a valid and reliable measure of diet quality according to the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans. Journal of Nutrition 144(3):399‒407.

Harberger, A.C. 1964. The measurement of waste. American Economic Review 54:58‒76.

Harding, M. and M. Lovenheim. 2017. The effect of prices on nutrition: Comparing the impact of product- and nutrient-specific taxes. Journal of Health Economics 53:53–71.

Harnack, L., J.M. Oakes, B. Elbel, T. Beatty, S. Rydell, and S. French. 2016. Effects of subsidies and prohibitions on nutrition in a food benefit program. JAMA Internal Medicine 176(11):1610‒1618.

Hausman, J. 1997. Valuation of New Goods under Perfect and Imperfect Competition. In The Economics of New Goods, Studies in Income and Wealth, ed. T.F. Bresnahan and R.J. Gordon, Vol. 58, 209–247. Chicago, IL: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Huang, K.S. 1996. Nutrient elasticities in a complete food demand system. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 78(1):21‒29.

Lancaster, K.J. 1966. A new approach to consumer theory. Journal of Political Economy 74(2):132‒157.

Léger, P.T. and L.M. Powell. 2021. The impact of the Oakland SSB tax on prices and volume sold: A study of intended and unintended consequences. Health Economics 30:1745‒1771.

Lewbel, A. and K. Pendakur. 2009. Tricks with Hicks: The EASI demand system. American Economic Review 99:827‒863.

Lin, B-H., T.A. Smith, J-Y. Lee, and K.D. Hall. 2011. Measuring weight outcomes for obesity intervention strategies: The case of a sugar-sweetened beverage tax. Economics and Human Biology 9(4):329–341.

Lozano-Rojas, F. and P. Carlin. 2021. Getting sugar back? Soda taxes beyond sodas. Available at SSRN: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3712719

McFadden, D. 1974. Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior. In P. Zarembka, ed., Frontiers in Econometrics. New York: Academic Press.

Meyerhoefer, C.D., C.K. Ranney and D.E. Sahn. 2005. Consistent estimation of censored demand systems using panel data. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 87(3):660–672.

Mineur, Y.S., A. Abizaid, Y. Rao, R. Salas, R.J. DiLeone, D. Gündisch, S. Diano, M. De Biasi, T.L. Horvath, X-B. Gao, and M.R. Picciotto. 2011. Nicotine decreases food intake through activation of POMC neurons. Science 332:1330‒1332.

Murphy, K.M. and R.H. Topel. 1985. Estimation and inference in two-step econometric models. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 3(4):370‒379.

Newey, W.K. 1987. Efficient estimation of limited dependent variable models with endogenous explanatory variables. Journal of Econometrics 36:231‒250.

Nonnemaker, J., E. Finkelstein, M. Engelen, T. Hoerger, and M. Farrelly. 2009. Have efforts to reduce smoking really contributed to the obesity epidemic? Economic Inquiry 47(2):366‒376.

Oddo, V.M., J. Leider, and L.M. Powell. 2021. The impact of Seattle’s sugar-sweetened beverage tax on substitution to sweets and salty snacks. Journal of Nutrition 151(10):3232–3239.

Ogden, C.L., C.D. Fryar, C.B. Martin, D.S. Freedman, M.D. Carroll, Q. Gu, and C.M. Hales. 2020. Trends in obesity prevalence by race and Hispanic origin—1999‒2000 to 2017‒2018. JAMA 324(12):1208–1210.

Okrent, A.M. and J.M. Alston. 2012. The Demand for Disaggregated Food-Away-From-Home and Food-at-Home Products in the United States, ERR-139, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service.

Okrent, A.M. and M. Sweitzer. 2016. Obesity as a modifier of price sensitivity in the United States. Selected paper presentation at the AAEA Annual Meetings, Boston, MA.

Olsho, L.EW, J.A. Klerman, P.E. Wilde, and S. Bartlett. 2016. Financial incentives increase fruit and vegetable intake among Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program participants: a randomized controlled trial of the USDA Healthy Incentives Pilot. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 104:423‒435.

Perali, F. and J-P. Chavas. 2000. Estimation of censored demand equations from large cross-section data. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 82(4):1022–1037.

Powell, L.M. and J. Leider. 2020. The impact of Seattle’s sweetened beverage tax on beverage prices and volume sold. Economics and Human Biology 37: Article 100856.

Rao, D.S.P. 1990. A system of log-change index numbers for multilateral comparisons. In Comparisons of Prices and Real Products in Latin America, ed. J. Salazar-Carillo and D.S. Prasada Rao, 127‒139. New York: Elsevier Science.

Roberto, C.A., H.G. Lawman, M.T. LeVasseur, N. Mitra, A. Peterhans, B. Herring, and S.N. Bleich. 2019. Association of a beverage tax on sugar-sweetened and artificially sweetened beverages with changes in beverage prices and sales at chain retailers in a large urban setting. JAMA 321(18):1799–1810.

Rojas, C. and E. Wang. 2021. Do taxes on soda and sugary drinks work? Scanner data evidence from Berkeley and Washington State. Economic Inquiry 59(1): 95–118.

Seiler, S., A. Tuchman, and S. Yao. 2021. The impact of soda taxes: Pass-through, tax avoidance, and nutritional effects. Journal of Marketing Research 58(1):22‒49.

Silberberg, E. 1985. Nutrition and the demand for tastes. Journal of Political Economy 93(5), 881−900.

Silver, L.D., S.W. Ng, S. Ryan-Ibarra, L.S. Taillie, M. Induni, D.R. Miles, J.M. Poti, and B.M. Popkin. 2017. Changes in prices, sales, consumer spending, and beverage consumption one year after a tax on sugar-sweetened beverages in Berkeley, California, US: A before-and-after study. PLoS Medicine 14(4): e1002283.

Subar, A.F., V. Kipnis, R.P. Troiano, D. Midthune, D.A. Schoeller, S. Bingham, C.O. Sharbaugh, J. Trabulsi, S. Runswick, R. Ballard-Barbash, J. Sunshine, and A. Schatzkin. 2003. Using intake biomarkers to evaluate the extent of dietary misreporting in a large sample of adults: the OPEN study. American Journal of Epidemiology 158(1):1–13.

Summers, R. 1973. International price comparisons based upon incomplete data. Review of Income and Wealth 19(1):1-16.

Taylor, R.L.C., S. Kaplan, S.B. Villas-Boas, and K. Jung. 2019. Soda wars: the effect of a soda tax election on university beverage sales. Economic Inquiry 57(3):1480–1496.

Terza, J.V., A. Basu and P.J. Rathouz. 2008. Two-stage residual inclusion estimation: Addressing endogeneity in health econometric modeling. Journal of Health Economics 27(3):531‒543.

USDA/US HHS (US Department of Agriculture and US Department of Health and Human Services). 2010. Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2010. 7th Edition, Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

USDA ERS (US Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service). 2016. National Household Food Acquisition and Purchase Survey (FoodAPS): Nutrient Coding Overview.

Valizadeh, P., B.M. Popkin, and S.W. Ng. 2021. Linking a sugar-sweetened beverage tax with fruit and vegetable subsidies: A simulation analysis of the impact on the poor. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition forthcoming.

Wang, E., C. Rojas, and F. Colantuoni. 2017. Heterogenous behavior, obesity, and storability in the demand for soft drinks. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 99(1):18–33.

West, S.E. and R.C. Williams III. 2004. Estimates from a consumer demand system: implications for the incidence of environmental taxes. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 47:535–558.

Williams, R.L. 2000. A note on robust variance estimation for cluster-correlated data. Biometrics 56:645−646.

Wooldridge, J.M. 2002. Econometric Analysis of Cross-Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Yu, Y. and E.C. Jaenicke. 2020. Estimating food waste as household production inefficiency. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 102(2):525‒547.

Zhen, C., J.L. Taylor, M.K. Muth, and E. Leibtag. 2009. Understanding Differences in Self-Reported Expenditures between Household Scanner Data and Diary Survey Data: A Comparison of Homescan and Consumer Expenditure Survey. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy 31(3):470–92.

Zhen, C., M.K. Wohlgenant, S. Karns, and P. Kaufman. 2011. Habit formation and demand for sugar-sweetened beverages. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 93(1):175–193.

Zhen, C., E.A. Finkelstein, J.M. Nonnemaker, S.A. Karns, and J.E. Todd. 2014. Predicting the effects of sugar-sweetened beverage taxes on food and beverage demand in a large demand system. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 96(1):1–25.

Zhen, C., I.F. Brissette, and R.R. Ruff. 2014. By ounce or by calorie: The differential effects of alternative sugar-sweetened beverage tax strategies. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 96(4):1070–1083.

Zhen, C., M. Muth, A. Okrent, S. Karns, D. Brown, and P. Siegel. 2019. Do differences in reported expenditures between household scanner data and expenditure surveys matter in health policy research? Health Economics 28:782‒800.