Factors of social tension in the provinces of the Russian Empire in the late 19th and early 20th centuries

Popov, Vladimir and Konchakov, Roman and Didenko, Dmitry (2023): Factors of social tension in the provinces of the Russian Empire in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Abstract

The key question of the economic and social post-reform history of Russia (after the agrarian reform of 1861) is what exactly led to the revolutions of the early 20th century. Were these revolutions a natural result of the growth of social tensions due to the flawed “Prussian path” of the development of capitalism in agriculture (a combination of large landlords’ estates and small land ownership of the bulk of the peasants) or did Russian capitalism develop successfully on the whole, and the revolutions were by no means inevitable, but rather caused by random, transient factors (war, political mistakes of the authorities and the opposition, etc.) – brief overview of these discussions is in Nefedov and Ellman (2016).

This paper aims to contribute to this discussion by analyzing the patterns and causes of social protest (peasants’ unrests, strikes at industrial enterprises, crimes against persons). We compute the index of inequality of land distribution for the Russian provinces, and find that the dynamics of social protest before the First Russian Revolution of 1905-07, from the 1890s to the early 1900s, occurred in provinces with the most uneven land distribution. These were mostly regions in the periphery of the empire (Lithuania, Poland, Belarus’, Ukraine, Novorossiya, Volga, Urals, Siberia, Far East, Caucuses, Central Asia) that were colonized in the 16th-19th centuries and did not have many serfs to begin with, and where the crown gave huge land areas to the nobility usually as a reward for service.

We speculate that this could have constituted one of the unique features of Russian development – it was the only state that experienced such a rapid territorial expansion in the era of serfdom with the result of developing extremely high land distribution inequalities in the new provinces, higher than in other European countries at the same time. These unique inequalities in land distribution could help explain the greater revolutionary activity in Russia even though the income (not land) inequalities seem to have been lower than in other countries in the early 20th century and lower than in Russia today (Lindert, Nafziger, 2014).

We also show that the increase in domestic violence was positively affected by illiteracy and alcohol consumption, whereas for social unrest alcohol consumption did not matter (insignificant) and literacy had either significant positive impact (increase in strikes) or was insignificant (increase in peasants’ unrest). Success rate of strikes, though, was linked positively with education (literacy rate and the average number of years of schooling) in 1895-99, but in 1900-04 the relationship was negative. In the late 19th century strikes were successful mostly in educated regions, whereas in 1900-04 less educated regions became successful in their strikes’ activity as well.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Inequality, land distribution, Russian revolutions, human capital
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D63 - Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D74 - Conflict ; Conflict Resolution ; Alliances ; Revolutions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I24 - Education and Inequality; N - Economic History > N1 - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics ; Industrial Structure ; Growth ; Fluctuations > N13 - Europe: Pre-1913; N - Economic History > N5 - Agriculture, Natural Resources, Environment, and Extractive Industries > N53 - Europe: Pre-1913; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies > O52 - Europe; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q15 - Land Ownership and Tenure ; Land Reform ; Land Use ; Irrigation ; Agriculture and Environment

References

Afonina G.M. (comp.) (1995). Краткие сведения о развитии отечественных железных дорог с 1838 г. по 1990 г. [Brief information on the development of domestic railways from 1838 to 1990]. Moscow: Центральная научно-техническая библиотека железнодорожного транспорта России [Publishing House of the Central Scientific and Technical Library of Railway Transport of Russia].

Anfimov A.M. (ed.) (1998). Крестьянское движение в России в 1901-1904 гг. Сборник документов [The Peasant Movement in Russia in 1901-1904. A Collection of documents]. Moscow: Наука [Science].

Baten J., Hippe R. (2018). Geography, land inequality and regional numeracy in Europe in historical perspective. Journal of Economic Growth. Vol. 23. No. 1. P. 79-109.

Bogdanov, S.V. (2013). Богданов С.В. Смертность от убийств в России во второй половине XIX в.: масштабы, тенденции, территориальные особенности [Mortality from homicide in Russia in the second half of the 19th century: scale, trends, territorial patterns]. - Криминология [Criminology], № 3, 2013.

Borodkin, Leonid, Brigitte Granville and Carol Scott Leonard (2008). The rural/urban wage gap in the industrialisation of Russia, 1884-1910. - European Review of Economic History, Vol. 12, No. 1 (APRIL 2008), pp. 67-95. https://www.jstor.org/stable/41378476.

Borodkin L., Shilnikova I. (2020). Labour Conflicts: Russia 1895-1904. Version 1. https://datasets.iisg.amsterdam/dataset.xhtml?persistentId=hdl:10622/LSCGBO.

Borodkin et al. (2011). Бородкин Л.И., Глазунов С.В., Новиков А.В., Потолов С.И., Пушкарева И.М., Шильникова И.М. Трудовые конфликты и рабочее движение в России на рубеже XIX – XX в. [Labor conflicts and the labor movement in Russia at the turn of the 19th - 20th centuries] СПб.: Алетейя [Aletheia], 2011.

Bovykin (1986). Бовыкин В. И. Статистика стачек в России и в других индустриальных странах Европы, и в США [Statistics of strikes in Russia and in other industrial countries of Europe, and in the USA]. – М.: Институт истории СССР [Institute of History of the USSR], 1986. – 150 с.

Cheremukhin A., Golosov M., Guriev S., Tsyvinski A. (2017). The Industrialization and Economic Development of Russia through the Lens of a Neoclassical Growth Model. The Review of Economic Studies. Vol. 84. No. 2. P. 613–649. + Online Appendix. https://doi.org/10.1093/restud/rdw026.

Davydov M.A. (2016). Двадцать лет до Великой воины: Российская модернизация Витте-Столыпина. [Twenty Years before the Great War: Russian Modernization by Witte-Stolypin]. 2nd ed. St. Petersburg: Алетейя [Aletheia].

Gerschenkron A. (1962). Economic backwardness in historical perspective, a book of essays. Cambridge: Belknap Press.

Gerschenkron A. (1970). Europe in the Russian Mirror. Four Lectures in Economic History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Goldstone J.A. (1991). Revolution and rebellion in the early modern world. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Goldstone, Jack, et al. (2015). Политическая демография России. Политика и государственное управление. [Political Demography of Russia. Politics and State Government]. Российская академия народного хозяйства и государственной службы при Президенте Российской Федерации [Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration], 2015. https://repec.ranepa.ru/rnp/ppaper/mn44.pdf.

Goldstone J.A., Grinin L., Korotayev A. (Eds). (2022). Handbook of Revolutions in the 21st Century: The New Waves of Revolutions, and the Causes and Effects of Disruptive Political Change. Cham: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-86468-2.

Gregory, Paul R. (1980). Grain Marketings and Peasant Consumption, Russia, 1885–1913. Explorations in Economic History (17), no. 2 (1980): 135–64.

Gregory P. (1982). Russian National Income, 1885-1913. London: Cambridge University Press.

Gregory P. (1994). Before Command: An economic history of Russia from Emancipation to the first five-year plan. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

GSh (1884). Военно-топографический отдел Главного штаба [Military Topographic Department of the General Staff]. Карта Азиатской России с прилегающими к ней владениями [Map of Asian Russia with adjacent possessions]. St. Petersburg.

GSh (1921). Военно-топографический отдел Главного штаба [Military Topographic Department of the General Staff]. Военно-дорожная карта Азиатской России. Составлена в 1895 г. Исправлена в 1908-19 гг. [Military road map of Asian Russia. Compiled in 1895, corrected in 1908-19]. Moscow.

Kessler H., Markevich A. (2020). Electronic archive of Russian Historical Statistics, 18th – 21st centuries. Version 1. [Topic 1-Population]. http://ristat.org.

Konchakov R.B., Didenko D.V. (2022). База данных «Данные исторической статистики по человеческому капиталу, экономическому развитию и урбанизации за 1904 г. в Россииской империи (включая количество учебных заведении и количество учащихся за указанные периоды)» [Database "Data of historical statistics on human capital, economic development and urbanization for 1904 in the Russian Empire (including the number of educational institutions and the number of students for the indicated periods)"]. Certificate No. 2022620024. https://elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=47779072.

Kumon, Yuzuru (2021). The Deep Roots of Inequality. Institute for the Advanced Studies in Toulouse. Working Paper No. 125. November 2021. https://www.iast.fr/sites/default/files/IAST/wp/wp_iast_125.pdf.

Kuznets, S. (1966). Modern Economic Growth: Rate, Structure, and Spread. New Haven; London: Yale University Press.

Kuznetsov I.A. (2012) Русская урожайная статистика 1883-1915 гг.: источник в контексте историографии [Russian crop statistics 1883-1915: source in the context of historiography]. In: Borodkin L.I., Petrov Yu.A., Salomatina S.A. (Eds). Экономическая история [Russian Economic History Yearbook]. 2011/2012. Moscow: Российская политическая энциклопедия (РОССПЭН) [Russian Political Encyclopedia (ROSSPEN)]. P. 190-228.

Lenin, V.I. (1977 [1899]). The development of capitalism in Russia. – Collected works. Vol. 3. Moscow: Progress Publishers.

Lenin, V.I. (1974 [1917]). New data on the laws governing the development of capitalism in agriculture. Part one. Capitalism and agriculture in the United States of America. Collected works. Vol. 22. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 13-102.

Lenin, V.I. (1977 [1908]). Agrarian program of social-democracy in the Russian revolution. Collected works. Vol. 15. Moscow: Progress Publishers, pp. 158-181.

Lenin, V. I. (1906). The Proletariat and its Ally in the Russian Revolution. Published December 20, 1906 in Proletary, No. 10. Published according to the newspaper text. Source: Lenin Collected Works, Progress Publishers, 1965, Moscow, Volume 11, pp. 365-375. Https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1906/dec/20.htm

Lenin, V. I. (1912). The Essence of “The Agrarian Problem in Russia” Nevskaya Zvezda No. 6, May 22, 1912. Signed: R.S. Published according to the text in Nevskaya Zvezda. Source: Lenin Collected Works, Progress Publishers, [1975], Moscow, Volume 18, pp. 73-77.

Lindert, Peter H. and Steven Nafziger (2014). Russian Inequality on the Eve of Revolution. - The Journal of Economic History. Vol. 74, No. 3 (SEPTEMBER 2014), pp. 767-98.

Markevich A., Zhuravskaya E. (2018). The Economic Effects of the Abolition of Serfdom: Evidence from the Russian Empire. American Economic Review. Vol. 108. No. 4-5. P. 1074-1117. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20160144.

Minfin (1903). Департамент окладных сборов Министерства финансов [Department of Direct Taxes of the Ministry of Finance]. Материалы высочайше учрежденной 16 ноября 1901 г. Комиссии по исследованию вопроса о движении с 1861 г. по 1900 г. благосостояния сельского населения среднеземледельческих губерний, сравнительно с другими местностями Европейской России [Materials of the High Commission established on November 16, 1901 to investigate the welfare of the rural population of the central agricultural provinces from 1861 to 1900, compared with other areas of European Russia]. Part 1. St. Petersburg.

Miniust (1900). Министерство юстиции [Ministry of Justice]. Свод статистических сведений по делам уголовным, проводившимся в 1896 году в судебных учреждениях, действующих на основании уставов Императора Александра II [A summary of statistical information on criminal cases conducted in 1896 in judicial institutions operating on the basis of the statutes by Emperor Alexander II]. St. Petersburg.

Miniust (1915). Министерство юстиции [Ministry of Justice]. Свод статистических сведений о подсудимых, оправданных и осужденных по приговорам общих судебных мест, судебно-мировых установлений и учреждений, образованных по законоположениям 12 июля 1889 года за 1912 год [A set of statistical information about the accused, acquitted and convicted by the verdicts of the common courts, peace-making judicial institutions and institutions formed according to the provisions of the law as of July 12, 1889 for 1912]. Petrograd.

Minzeml (1907, 1916). Министерство земледелия. Отдел сельской экономии и сельскохозяиственной статистики [Ministry of Agriculture and State Property. Department of Rural Economy and Agricultural Statistics]. Сборник статистико-экономических сведений по сельскому хозяйству России и иностранных государств [Collection of statistical and economic data on agriculture in Russia and foreign countries]. St. Petersburg – Petrograd.

Mironov B.N. (2018). Российская империя: от традиции к модерну. [The Russian Empire: from Tradition to Modernity]. 3 vols. 2nd ed. St. Petersburg: Дм. Буланин.

Mironov B.N. (2019). Крестьянское движение в России накануне эмансипации как момент истины [The Peasant Movement in Russia on the Eve of Emancipation as a Moment of Truth]. Вестник Санкт-Петербургского университета. История [Herald of Saint Petersburg University. History], 2019, vol. 64, iss. 3, рp. 817–842. https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu02.2019.301 (In Russian).

Nefedov S.A. (2011) История России. Факторный анализ. Т. II. [History of Russia. Factor analysis]. Vol. II. От окончания Смуты до Февральской революции [From the end of the Times of Trouble to the February Revolution]. Moscow: Территория будущего [Territory of the Future].

Nefedov S., Ellman M. (2016). The Development of Living Standards in Russia before the First World War: An Examination of the Anthropometric Data. Revolutionary Russia. Vol. 29. No. 2. P. 149-168. https://doi.org/10.1080/09546545.2016.1243618.

Novoselsky, S. (1916), Новосельский С.Л. Обзор главнейших данных по демографии и санитарной статистике России [Review of the principal data on demography and sanitary statistics in Russia]. Petrograd, 1916, P. 6-37. Проект «Динамика экономического и социального развития России в XIX - начале ХХ вв.» Демография. [Project "Dynamics of economic and social development of Russia in the 19th - early 20th centuries." Demography]. http://hist.msu.ru/Dynamics/data/01_019.xls).

Nureev R.M., Latov Yu.V. (2013). От «восточного деспотизма» к «среднеслабому капитализму»: оборванный путь институционального развития императорской России [From “Oriental Despotism” to “Average – Weak Capitalism”: The Ragged Path of Institutional Development of Imperial Russia]. Мир России [Universe of Russia]. Vol. 22. No. 4. P. 3-39.

Novokmet, Filip, Thomas Piketty and Gabriel Zucman (2017). From Soviets to Oligarchs: Inequality and Property in Russia, 1905-2016. Journal of Economic Inequality 16 (2): 189–223. DOI: 10.1007/s10888-018-9383-0.

Obukhov V.M. (1927). Движение урожаев в Европейской России в период 1883 - 1915 гг. [The movement of crops in European Russia in the period 1883 – 1915]. In Groman V.G. (ed.). Влияние неурожаев на народное хозяйство России. [The impact of crop failures on Russia’s national economy]. Part 1. Moscow. Prilozhenie 1 [Appendix 1], pp. 59-108.

Oleinikova,Ye. I. (2021). Олейникова Е. И. Магистерская диссертация «Динамика преступности в губерниях Европейской России в 1896-1913 годы по региональным данным о количестве осужденных: статистический и геоинформационный анализ» [Master's thesis "The dynamics of crime in the provinces of European Russia in 1896-1913 based on regional data on the number of convicts: statistical and geoinformation analysis."]. Московский государственный университет имени М.В. Ломоносова. Исторический факультет. Кафедра исторической информатики [Moscow Lomonosov State University. Faculty of History. Department of Historical Information Science], Moscow, 2021.

Petrov, Yu. A. (2018). The Great Russian Revolution: Problems of Historical Memory. Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Vol. 88. P. 163–165.

Petrov Yu. A. (2020). Государство и экономический рост в позднеимперской России [The State and Economic Growth in Late Imperial Russia]. Уральский исторический вестник [Ural Historical Journal]. No. 1(66). Р. 18-26.

Popov V. (2014). Mixed Fortunes: An Economic History of China, Russia, and the West. New York: Oxford University Press.

Prokopovich S.N., ed. (1918). Опыт исчисления народного дохода 50 губерний Европейской России в 1900-1913 гг. [Calculation national income of the 50 provinces of European Russia in 1900-1913]. Moscow: Совет Всероссийских кооперативных съездов [Council of All-Russian Cooperative Congresses].

Shelokhaev V.V., Solov'ev K.A. (2019). Кризис Россииской империи как историографическая проблема [Crisis of Russian Empire as a historiographical problem]. Российская история [Russian history]. No 2. P. 142-157.

Shmelev, Nikolai, and Popov, Vladimir (1989). The Turning Point: Revitalizing the Soviet Economy. New York, Doubleday, 1989.

Stickley, Andrew (2006). On Interpersonal Violence in Russia in the Present and the Past: A Sociological Study. Ph.D. thesis: Stockholm University.

Strel’bitskii I.A. (1915). Специальная карта Европейской России [Special map of European Russia] (1:420,000). 1865-1871. Petrograd: Литография картографического заведения Военно-топографического отдела [Lithography of the Cartographic Establishment of the Military Topographic Department of the General Staff].

Strumilin S.G. (1966 [1930]). Оплата труда в России [Labor remuneration in Russia]. In: Очерки экономической истории России и СССР [Essays on the economic history of Russia and the USSR]. Moscow: Наука [Science], pp. 23-99.

Troinitskii N.A., ed. (1898-1905). Первая всеобщая перепись населения Российской империи 1897 г. [The First General Census of the Population of the Russian Empire in 1897. Vols. 1-50, 65, 67, 68, 70, 72-80 [in Russian] St. Petersburg: Центральный статистический комитет Министерства внутренних дел [Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs].

TsSK MVD (1880-1885). Центральный статистический комитет Министерства внутренних дел [Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. Статистика поземельной собственности и населенных мест Европейской России: по данным обследования, произведенного статистическими учреждениями Министерства внутренних дел, по поручению Статистического совета [Statistics on land ownership and settlements in European Russia: according to a survey conducted by the statistical offices of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, commissioned by the Statistical Council]. St. Petersburg.

TsSk (1894). Vremennik Tsentral'nogo statisticheskogo komiteta Ministerstva vnutrennikh del. No 35. Umershie nasil'stvenno i vnezapno v Evropeiskoi Rossii v 1875-1887 gg. [Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Abstract No. 35. Those who died violently and suddenly in European Russia in 1875-1887]. Saint Petersburg.

TsSK MVD (1894). Центральный статистический комитет Министерства внутренних дел [Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. Средний сбор хлебов и картофеля за десятилетие 1883–92 гг. в 60 губерниях Европейской России по отношению к народному продовольствию [Average harvest of bread and potatoes for the decade 1883–92 in 60 provinces of European Russia in relation to national food]. In: Временник Центрального статистического комитета Министерства внутренних дел [Annals of the Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. № 34. St. Petersburg.

TsSK MVD (1897). Центральный статистический комитет Министерства внутренних дел [Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. Умершие насильственно и внезапно в Российской империи в 1888-1893 гг. [Those who died violently and suddenly in the Russian Empire in 1888-1893]. In: Временник Центрального статистического комитета Министерства внутренних дел [Annals of the Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. № 41. St. Petersburg.

TsSK MVD (1907). Центральный статистический комитет Министерства внутренних дел [Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. Статистика землевладения 1905 г. Свод данных по 50 губерниям Европейской России [Land ownership statistics in 1905. Compilation of data on 50 provinces of European Russia]. St. Petersburg.

TsSK MVD (1915, 1916). Центральный статистический комитет Министерства внутренних дел [Central Statistical Committee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs]. Статистический ежегодник России за 1914 г., 1915 г. [Statistical Yearbook of Russia]. Petrograd.

Turchin P., Nefedov S.A. (2009). Secular cycles. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.

Ustyuzhanin, V., & Korotayev, A. (2023). Education and Revolutions: Why do Revolutionary Uprisings Take Violent or Nonviolent Forms? Cross-Cultural Research, 0(0). Https://doi.org/10.1177/10693971231162231

Vainshtein A.L. (1960). Народное богатство и народнохозяйственное накопление предреволюционной России (Статистическое исследование) [National wealth and accumulation in the national economic of pre-revolutionary Russia (A Statistical study)]. Moscow: Gosstatizdat TsSU SSSR.

Volkov V.V. (2016). «Дешево и сердито». Рынок труда в Европейской России в конце XIX – начале XX в. 2 vols. [“Cheap and well done.” The labor market in European Russia in the late XIX-early XX centuries]. 2 vols. St. Petersburg: Polytechnic-print.

Zhukov D.S., Kanishchev V.V., Lyamin S.K. (2017). Исследование интенсивности крестьянских волнений в Европейской России во второй половине XIX в. средствами теории самоорганизованной критичности [A study of the intensity of peasant unrest in European Russia in the second half of the 19th century, by means of the theory of self-organized criticality]. Историческая информатика [Historical Informatics]. No. 1. Р. 38-51. https://doi.org/10.7256/2306-0891.2017.1.22145.