Revenue Decentralization and the Probability of a Fiscal Crisis: Is There a Tipping Point for Adverse Effects?

Nakatani, Ryota (2023): Revenue Decentralization and the Probability of a Fiscal Crisis: Is There a Tipping Point for Adverse Effects?

Abstract

Does government revenue decentralization affect the probability of a fiscal crisis? Is there a tipping point where revenue decentralization worsens the probability of a fiscal crisis? To answer these questions, we use cross-country panel data on 66 countries from 1982 to 2019. The binary choice models show that revenue decentralization is positively associated with crisis probability when countries exceed a certain threshold of decentralization. When more than 16-17 percent of general government revenue is decentralized to local governments, this adverse effect of revenue decentralization occurs. This is consistent with the recent theoretical prediction that tax revenue collection efforts weaken as the government decentralizes revenue more. The adverse effects of revenue decentralization are large in low-income countries. Our finding implies the benefits of revenue centralization, such as economies of scale for revenue agencies, eliminating externalities due to tax competition, and the intergovernmental insurance role of federal transfers against local shocks.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Revenue Decentralization; Fiscal Crisis; Binary Choice Model; Federalism; Local Government
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H71 - State and Local Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H74 - State and Local Borrowing; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession

References

Alm, James, and Steven Sheffrin. 2013. Can Tax Reform Solve the “Fiscal Trilemma”? Public Finance Review 41 (6): 711-720.

Aray, Henry, and Luis Pedauga. 2022. The Relationship between Decentralization and Economic Growth across Regimes. Annals of Regional Science, forthcoming.

Argimón, Isabel, and Pablo Hernández de Cos. 2012. Fiscal Rules and Federalism as Determinants of Budget Performance: An Empirical Investigation for the Spanish Case. Public Finance Review 40 (1): 30-65.

Asatryan, Zareh, Lars P. Feld, and Benny Geys. 2015. Partial Fiscal Decentralization and Sub-national Government Fiscal Discipline: Empirical Evidence from OECD Countries. Public Choice 163: 307-320.

Badia, Marialuz Moreno, Paulo Medas, Pranav Gupta, and Yuan Xiang. Debt Is Not Free. 2022. Journal of International Money and Finance 127: 102654.

Bahl, Roy, and Johannes Linn. 1994. Fiscal Decentralization and Intergovernmental Transfers in Less Developed Countries. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 24 (1): 1-20.

Baskaran, Thushyanthan. 2012. Tax Decentralization and Public Deficits in OECD Countries. Publius: The Journal of Federalism. 42 (4): 688-707.

Baskaran, Thushyanthan, and Lars P. Feld. 2013. Fiscal Decentralization and Economic Growth in OECD Countries: Is There a Relationship? Public Finance Review 41(4): 421-445.

Besley, Timothy, and Stephen Coate. 2003. Centralized versus Decentralized Provision of Local Public Goods: A Political Economy Approach. Journal of Public Economics 87: 2611-2637.

Boadway, Robin., and Jean-François Tremblay. 2012. Reassessment of the Tiebout Model. Journal of Public Economics 96: 1063-1078.

Carbonnier, Clément. 2013. Decentralization and Tax Competition between Asymmetrical Local Governments: Theoretical and Empirical Evidence. Public Finance Review 41 (4): 391-420.

Coen-Pirani, Daniele, and Michael Wooley. 2018. Fiscal Centralization: Theory and Evidence from the Great Depression. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 10 (2): 39-61.

De Mello, Luiz R. 2001. Fiscal Decentralization and Borrowing Costs: The Case of Local Governments. Public Finance Review 29 (2): 108-138.

Dincecco, Mark. 2009. Fiscal Centralization, Limited Government, and Public Revenues in Europe, 1650–1913. The Journal of Economic History 69 (1): 48-103.

Facchini, Giovanni, and Cecila Testa. 2008. Fiscal Decentralization, Regional Inequality and Bail-outs: Lessons from Brazil’s Debt Crisis. The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 48: 333-344.

Feld, Lars P., Gebhard Kirchgässner, and Christoph A. Schaltegger. 2010. Decentralized Taxation and the Size of Government: Evidence from Swiss State and Local Governments. Southern Economic Journal 77 (1), 27-48.

Foremny, Dirk. 2014. Sub-national Deficits in European Countries: The Impact of Fiscal Rules and Tax Autonomy. European Journal of Political Economy 34: 86-110.

Gordon, Roger. 1983. An Optimal Tax Approach to Fiscal Federalism. Quarterly Journal of Economics 97: 567-586.

Honohan, Patrick, and Daniela Klingebiel. 2003. The Fiscal Cost Implications of an Accommodating Approach to Banking Crises. Journal of Banking and Finance 27: 1539-1560.

Inman, Robert P. and Daniel L. Rubinfeld. 1996. Designing Tax Policy in Federalist Economies: An Overview. Journal of Public Economics 60: 307-334.

Jacobsen, Rasmus Højbjerg, Nielsen, Søren Bo, and Anders Sørensen. 2013. The Fiscal Trilemma in a Danish Perspective. Public Finance Review 41 (6): 791-823.

Krugman, Paul. 1979. A Model of Balance-of-Payments Crises. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 11: 311-325.

Lalvani, Mala. 2002. Can Decentralization Limit Government Growth? A Test of the Leviathan Hypothesis for the Indian Federation. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 32 (3): 25-46.

Lockwood, Ben. 1999. Inter-Regional Insurance. Journal of Public Economics 72: 1-37.

Lohse, Tim, and Julio R. Robledo. 2013. Public Self-Insurance and the Samaritan’s Dilemma in a Federation. Public Finance Review 41 (1): 92-120.

McAndrew, William P. 2018. National versus Local Production: Finding the Balance between Fiscal Federalism and Economies of Scale. Public Finance Review 46 (6): 926-948.

McLure, Jr., Charles. E. 1967. The Interstate Exporting of State and Local Taxes: Estimates for 1962. National Tax Journal 20: 49-77.

Nakatani, Ryota. 2019. A Possible Approach to Fiscal Rules in Small Islands — Incorporating Natural Disasters and Climate Change. IMF Working Paper 19/186.

Nakatani, Ryota. 2023a. Fiscal Crises, Decentralization, and Indiscipline. Scottish Journal of Political Economy 70 (5): 459-478.

Nakatani, Ryota. 2023b. Productivity Drivers of Infrastructure Companies: Network Industries Utilizing Economies of Scale in the Digital Era. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, forthcoming.

Nakatani, Ryota, Qianqian Zhang, and Isaura Garcia Valdes. 2023a. Fiscal Decentralization Improves Social Outcomes When Countries Have Good Governance. IMF Working Paper 22/111.

Nakatani, Ryota, Qianqian Zhang, and Isaura Garcia Valdes. 2023b. Health Expenditure Decentralization and Health Outcomes: The Importance of Governance. Publius: The Journal of Federalism, forthcoming.

Neyapti, Bilin. 2006. Revenue Decentralization and Income Distribution. Economics Letters 92: 409-416.

Nguyen, Thanh Cong, Vítor Castro, and Justine Wood. 2022. A New Comprehensive Database of Financial Crises: Identification, Frequency, and Duration. Economic Modelling 108: 105770.

Oates, Wallace E. 2005. Toward A Second-Generation Theory of Fiscal Federalism. International Tax and Public Finance 12: 349-373.

Persson, Torsten, and Guido Tabellini. 1996. Federal Fiscal Constitutions: Risk Sharing and Moral Hazard. Econometrica 64: 623-646.

Rattsø, Jørn, and Per Tovmo. 2002. Fiscal Discipline and Asymmetric Adjustment of Revenues and Expenditures: Local Government Responses to Shocks in Denmark. Public Finance Review 30 (3): 208-234.

Reiter, Michael, and Alfons Weichenrieder. 1997. Are Public Goods Public? A Critical Survey of the Demand Estimates for Local Public Services. FinanzArchiv 54: 374-408.

Rodríguez-Pose, Andrés, and Roberto Ezcurra. 2011. Is Fiscal Decentralization Harmful for Economic Growth? Evidence from the OECD Countries. Journal of Economic Geography 11 (4): 619-643.

Sanguinetti, Pablo, and Mariano Tommasi. 2004. Intergovernmental Transfers and Fiscal Behavior Insurance versus Aggregate Discipline. Journal of International Economics 62: 149-170.

Saptono, Prianto Budi, and Gustofan Mahmud. 2023. Stimulus or Enforcement? How Intergovernmental Transfers Crowd-in Local Taxes in Indonesia. Public Finance Review 51 (6): 782-837.

Schwager, Robert. 1999. The Theory of Administrative Federalism: An Alternative to Fiscal Centralization and Decentralization. Public Finance Review 27 (3): 282-309.

Shadbegian, Ronald J. 1999. Fiscal Federalism, Collusion, and Government Size: Evidence from the States. Public Finance Review 27 (3): 262-281.

Widmer, Philippe, and Peter Zweifel. 2012. Fiscal Equalization, Tiebout Competition, and Incentives for Efficiency in a Federalist Country. Public Finance Review 40 (1): 3-29.